Begotten is a 1989 American experimental dark fantasy horror film written, produced, edited and directed by Edmund Elias Merhige. It stars Brian Salsburg, Donna Dempsy, Stephen Charles Barry, and members of Merhige's theatre company Theatre of Material. The film contains no dialogue, being designed to mimic the style of aged black-and-white films. Incorporating events and themes from various creation myths, Begotten centers on the death of God, and the subsequent birth of Mother Earth and Son of Earth, following their journey of death and rebirth through a barren landscape. Author Scott MacDonald noted that the plot is intentionally left ambiguous to invite multiple interpretations of the film.
Theatrical release poster
|Directed by||E. Elias Merhige|
|Produced by||E. Elias Merhige|
|Written by||E. Elias Merhige|
|Music by||Evan Albam|
|Cinematography||E. Elias Merhige|
|Edited by||Noëlle Penraat|
Theatre Of Material
William Markle Associates (Sound)
|Distributed by||World Artists Home Video (All media)|
Begotten was influenced by the theories and ideas of Antonin Artaud and Friedrich Nietzsche, which in Merhige's opinion had not been developed on film to the fullest extent. Inspiration for the film's visual style came from Georges Franju's documentary short Blood of the Beasts, as well as Akira Kurosawa's Seven Samurai, Stan Brakhage's The Act of Seeing with One's Own Eyes, and the German Expressionist film The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari. Begotten was originally intended to be a theatre production but was later opted as a film production after Merhige learned that it would be too expensive to produce through the medium of theatre. It was filmed on location in New York and New Jersey, over a period of three and a half years (although in one interview, Merhige stated that filming lasted for five and a half months).
Begotten did not gain distribution until approximately two years after editing was completed. It was briefly screened at the San Francisco International Film Festival, where it was seen by film critics Tom Luddy and Peter Scarlet, who brought it to the attention of fellow critic Susan Sontag, who wrote the film's most publicized review that was instrumental to its eventual release. In spite of Sontag's highly publicized review, the film was largely ignored by mainstream critics and is currently banned in Singapore due to its violence. It eventually attained a cult following referred to as a "copy-cult" by authors Ernest Mathijs and Xavier Mendik, given the film's rarity. It has been included in multiple lists belonging to a number of media outlets, and was followed by a short film sequel in 2006, titled Din of Celestial Birds, which deals with the theory of evolution. Begotten has become influential on several avant-garde works, experimental films, and has been cited by several artists as inspiration for some of their works.
- 1 Plot
- 2 Cast
- 3 Themes
- 4 Influences
- 5 Production
- 6 Release
- 7 Reception
- 8 Legacy
- 9 See also
- 10 References
- 11 Sources
- 12 Further reading
- 13 External links
Inside a small shack, a robed figure, God Killing Himself, proceeds to disembowel himself with a straight razor. After removing some of His internal organs, God dies and a woman, Mother Earth, emerges from the mutilated remains. Bringing the corpse to arousal, she uses His semen to impregnate herself. Time passes and Mother, now visibly pregnant, stands beside a coffin containing God's corpse. Wandering off into a vast and barren landscape, Mother later gives birth to Son of Earth, a malformed convulsing man. The man is soon abandoned by his mother, who leaves him to his own devices.
After an untold period of time wandering across the barren landscape, the Son of Earth later encounters a group of faceless nomads who seize him by his umbilical cord. Upon being captured, the Son of Earth begins vomiting up organic pieces that the nomads excitedly accept as gifts. The nomads then throw the man into a fire pit where he burns to death. Son of Earth is then resurrected by Mother Earth, who comforts her newly reborn offspring before they both continue across the barren landscape. The nomads soon return and proceed to attack the Son of Earth as Mother Earth stands in a trance-like state. The nomads soon turn their attention to her, knocking her to the ground before raping, then murdering her, as her son watches helplessly nearby.
Once the nomads have left, a group of robed figures arrives to carry away Mother Earth's mutilated remains, which are disemboweled. Afterwards, the group then returns to murder and disembowel her son, burying the pieces of both mother and son into the crust of the earth. As time passes, the burial site soon becomes lush with flowers as grainy photographs of God Killing Himself are shown. In the final scene, "Mother Earth" and "Son of Earth" are seen again in a flashback, this time wandering through a forest.
- Brian Salzburg as God Killing Himself:
- A mysterious, robed entity who disembowels himself with a straight razor. He is also the father of Mother Earth and Son of Earth, the latter of which was born through artificial insemination.
- Donna Dempsey as Mother Earth:
- A female entity based on the earth deity of the same name. She is the mother of Son of Earth, whom she conceived via artificial insemination.
- Stephen Charles Barry as Son of Earth (Flesh on Bone):
- The deformed, convulsing son of Mother Earth and God Killing Himself. Barry would later reprise his role in the film's sequel, Din of Celestial Birds, which was also written and directed by Merhige.
Members of Merhige's theatre company Theatre of Material – which included Adolpho Vargas, Arthur Streeter, Daniel Harkins, Erik Slavin, James Gandia, Michael Phillips, and Terry Andersen – provided additional credits for other characters in the film such as the Nomads and Robed Figures.
Critics have identified several major themes in Begotten. In interviews, Merhige himself has acknowledged that he intentionally incorporated these themes into the film, while also inviting viewers to form their own interpretations of the film.
Death and rebirthEdit
You with your memory are dead, frozen
Lost in a present that never stops passing
Here lives the incantation of matter
A language forever.
Like a flame burning away the darkness
Life is flesh on bone convulsing above the ground.
— The opening intertitle for the film, suggesting the film's themes of life and death.
Several critics have noted that Begotten contains an underlying theme of death and rebirth, recurring throughout most of the director's works. In an interview with Marty Mapes of Movie Habit.com, Merhige stated, "I've always believed in the continuity of consciousness. I don't think the body dying means it's over. It just means that there's a transformation taking place. So what we call physical death is not something that I think is some sorrowful loss. I just think that the entire universe is in a constant state of change and in its movement we’re kind of moving with it."
Reviewing the film, Episent.com noted that the film's recurring theme of death and rebirth might have been inspired by a near-death experience Merhige had suffered during his youth at age nineteen. Author and independent filmmaker John Kenneth Muir pointed out the film's ideas of suffering, death, and rebirth: "Watching this pageant of suffering, our minds jump to the idea of man assiduously, painfully re-shaping the hard soil of Earth to gain a foothold and grow crops; to bring life from unforgiving terra firma. Is this how the Earth "feels" to be under our yoke? To be shaped to our purposes?" Muir also pointed out that the initial scenes of brutality, and suffering, were followed by "cathartic" scenes of cleansing, and renewal of the Earth exemplified by the passing of the seasons. Author William E.B. Verrone also noted this depiction of violence, birth, and death: "if indeed we are to mourn the death and destruction of God/Mother/Son, then we can because of the immense mistreatment and suffering. And when flowers wilt and then bloom, we are offered salvation."
Religion, mythology, and the occultEdit
Many critics have pointed out the film's incorporation of various religious and mythological themes and events from Christianity, Celtic mythology, and Slavic mythology including Creation, Mother Earth, and various other religious themes, on which the events that take place in the film are loosely based. Merhige himself has acknowledged that the film was deliberately arranged to appear as part of a mythology. Author William E.B. Verrone observes, "Begotten offers a (non) story—about primitive myths, divine birth, and punishment, a cryptic passion play about Earth’s birth and torture, told quite literally—but meant to evoke a more metaphoric, symbolic realm of experience and understanding.” Author Scott MacDonald pointed out that the film's highly allegorical plot, "suggest[s] a historical overview of attitudes popular in North America and Europe during the past few centuries." MacDonald also interpreted the film's plot as The death of God, and the birth and rape of Nature, or God-as-Nature. In their book Cult Cinema: An Introduction, authors Ernest Mathijs and Jamie Sexton noted that the film "makes perhaps the most serious attempt to visualize elements of Dionysian orgiastic cultism in combination with Gnostic and pagan myths".
The film's opening sequence shares many similarities with various creation myths, specifically ones where life is generated from the corpse or dismemberment of an originator deity. Author Herbert S. Lindenberger felt that Merhige was "redoing old fertility myths that Sir James Frazer pulled together to shock late Victorians about the savagery of their ancestors." Lindenberger also noted the film's inclusion of themes taken from Christianity such as the "buried god", his resurrection, and the inclusion of god's mother. In his article 10 Horror Movies Too Intense Even for Halloween, ScreenRant's Jason Wojnar stated that the film's unconventional storyline was, "an abstract interpretation of the death and rebirth of God, Earth, and Man".
Janet Maslin of The New York Times categorized the film as being a "re-envision[ing] of primitive myths in visceral, monstrously immediate terms." Film critic Richard Corliss from Time pointed out that the film contained multiple references to Druidism. Corliss also noted the film's mixture of druidism with several biblical stories such as the Creation (Genesis), the Nativity, and Christ's torture/death.
Several critics have pointed out possible influences for the film's visual style. Merhige himself has cited the theories and ideas of Antonin Artaud and Friedrich Nietzsche, which in his opinion had not been developed on film to the fullest extent, as well as the works of Bosch, Goya, Munk, Eisenstein, and Buñuel. In a 1993 interview with author Scott MacDonald, Merhige also listed Georges Franju's documentary short Blood of the Beasts as an inspiration for the visual style of the film, as well as Akira Kurosawa's Seven Samurai, Stan Brakhage's The Act of Seeing with One's Own Eyes, and the German expressionist film The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari. Film critic Eric D. Snider has pointed out that David Lynch's Eraserhead might also have influenced the film's visual style.
Development and pre-productionEdit
Writer/director E. Elias Merhige on the development of the film's script
Begotten was written, produced, and directed by Merhige, with development for the film beginning in the mid-to-late 1980s, although some sources list the date as 1984. Merhige had studied New York State University, and soon developed an interest in the theatre after attending several performances while in Manhattan. Merhige was particularly fascinated by a Japanese dance troupe called Sankai Juku which, the director later learned, consisted of a core group that did everything together and knew each other thoroughly on both a professional and personal level. Wanting to achieve something similar, Merhige founded Theatre of Material, a small theatre production company based in New York City. After working on several different experimental theatre productions, Merhige began developing his next project. The film was originally intended to be a theatre production, and Mehige later recalled: "I originally thought of it as a dance theatre with live music piece that we would do at Lincoln Center." It was only after discovering that it would cost a quarter of a million dollars to produce that the decision was made to adapt the script for a motion picture instead of a theatre production. Also, as members of the company started moving on to other projects, Merhige had wanted to keep a permanent record of the company's work.
Merhige, who was nineteen at the time, wrote the film's script in six months. Before working on Begotten, he had previously made several short films such as Implosion (1983), Spring Rain (1984), and A Taste of Youth (1985). These were well-received, and gave the director the experience and insight he needed while working on Begotten. For the development of the film's script, Merhige and members of Theatre of Material wanted the film to be silent, instead focusing on what the director called “emotions on the fringes” and emotions which they felt that most directors and artists would avoid. In preparation for writing the film's script, Merhige and members from Theatre of Material would perform breathing exercises as a group, then examine the experience afterwards. As Merhige explained, "We would breathe to the point of hysteria and create these moments of panic. Afterwards, we would analyze what the experience was all about. It was an intimate science." The group would then write down ideas and scenes based on their experiences, with Merhige incorporating segments that scared him, as well as others that he was not able to understand but had stuck with him. The initial draft for the film's screenplay was then brought to the members of the group, who also worked as both cast and crew for the film, where they would rehearse excerpts from the script, followed by a discussion about what they had just read prior to breaking it down into its physical elements. A period of four-and-a-half months was dedicated to rehearsing the film, as Merhige wanted the cast "in tune with one another" before shooting.
Principal photography took place in the mid-to-late 1980s, over a period of three-and-a-half months[Note 2] in several different locations. Merhige filled multiple roles in the film's production, including work on cinematography, and special effects, the latter using a 16mm Arriflex camera on black and white reversal film. Merhige had previously worked on several short film subjects before developing Begotten. The opening sequence depicting the robed figure (listed in the credits as "God Killing Himself") disemboweling himself and Mother Earth emerging from his remains was shot first. The sequence was then edited together and shown to the cast and crew, whose reactions to the footage was very enthusiastic, with Merhige stating: "I think it proved to everyone that this was an important film, that there really was nothing else like it, and we were actually going to make it happen." Most of the film's cast and crew were paid little to nothing, with their forms of payment being free room and board, and Merhige himself paying for all of their expenses. In his book Film Out of Bounds: Essays and Interviews on Non-Mainstream Cinema Worldwide, author Matthew Edwards cited the film as an example of low-budget films outside of Hollywood that were both "unique and distinct despite minuscule budgets, and display[ed] more flair, invention, style, and substance than your average Hollywood popcorn flick."
A majority of the film was shot at a construction site on the border between New York City and New Jersey, where Merhige had been given permission to shoot for a period of twenty days when construction crews were not working. Members of the construction site would occasionally lend the film crew a hand by constructing landscapes when certain shots of mountains were needed during a scene. Scenes involving time-lapses of sunrises and sunsets were shot by the director, who spent a couple of days alone in the mountains near Santa Fe or Albuquerque. Funding for the film came from Merhige's grandfather, who had set Merhige up with a trust fund for medical school.[Note 3] Additional costs for the film were paid by Merhige from income he received while working multiple jobs as a special effects artist. Merhige described working on the film as being powerful and one that was both transformative, and ritualistic that changed the lives of all those involved with the project.
Begotten had been envisioned by Merhige as a silent film depicting "a time that predated spoken language and communication being made on a sensory level." Merhige had previously worked as a special effects designer for various different companies, including a brief job where he performed rotoscoping for a Disney television show, and knew how to create the visual effects needed for the film. In order to create the desired look and feel for the film, Merhige would experiment with the film reel during filming to give it an old, withered look. This included running the unshot negative through sandpaper in order to scratch it up before shooting. Still unsatisfied with the overall effect, Merhige decided to use an optical printer but was unable to find one within the film's budget. The optical printer was constructed over a period of eight months by Merhige himself, who would use old spare parts acquired from camera stores and special effects houses that he had worked on and off at. Merhige would later use this technique of what he called "rephotography" in his following film Shadow of the Vampire. The editing process proved to be the most time consuming, as each minute of footage generated by the optical printer took on average between eight and ten hours to complete. This process also involved analyzing and testing each resulting shot before sending the tests off to the lab. If a particular shot appeared to be off, it was changed and often involved reshooting the footage that had been completed beforehand. Most of the film was developed in a small developing studio located on 48th Street called Kin-O-Lux Labs, run by German immigrant Fred Schreck (no relation to famed German actor Max Schreck) who had immigrated from Germany after the end of World War II. Merhige had met the elderly Schreck while he was developing test footage for the film. Merhige had been turned down by various studios where he tried to have the footage developed before going to Kin-O-Lux. Schreck immediately took a liking to the director and allowed Merhige to use the lab to develop the footage, while also teaching him how to hand-develop the footage. Schreck is credited under "special thanks" in the film's credits. At one point during the editing process, Merhige enlisted his father's input on certain scenes. As later recalled during an interview with MovieMaker Magazine: "I would bring my father, who loves John Ford westerns, into the editing room to see this silent, black and white, extremely bizarre film, and I would ask him whether the scene made sense and if it worked. And he said: 'None of it makes sense to me but if I had a choice of what made better sense within the edit I would use this edit over that edit.' He was very open-minded."
The sound mix used in the film was composed and arranged by Evan Albam. Merhige hired Albam after Tim McCann, a close friend of Merhige and assistant director for the film, recommended him for constructing the film's music and sound effects. Albam had a job painting houses at the time, composing music in his spare time before being hired to compose the soundtrack for the film. Merhige would work closely with Albam on developing the film's music and sound effects in order to find the right balance of visual and audio cues for the film, a process that took a year to complete.
Begotten did not gain distribution until approximately two years after editing for the film had been completed. During this time, Merhige would show it to possible distributors but most refused to release the film as it did not fit into a specific genre, making it difficult to bring the film to market. Merhige then took it to a number of museums in hopes of eventually finding a distributor. In the end, only two showed any interest, but both were turned down by Merhige who felt that they would not have been the right choice. As a result, Merhige became very protective of the film, only showing it to people he felt he could trust. It was briefly screened at the San Francisco International Film Festival, where it was seen by film critics Tom Luddy and Peter Scarlet. Both were fascinated by the film's distinct visual style and brought it to the attention of fellow critic Susan Sontag. Sontag, who set up a private screening at her home for some of her closest friends. Her praise of the film became one of the Begotten's most publicized reviews and instrumental for its eventual release. Sontag later brought the film to the Berlin Film Festival where it was viewed by director Werner Herzog. Merhige later recalled that Herzog was "very supportive of the film".
Begotten was shown for the first time at the Montreal World Film Festival on October 26, 1989. The film would later have screenings at the San Francisco International Film Festival, and the Berlin Film Festival in the early to mid 1990s. Its first official premiere took place at the New York City's Film Forum in the fall of 1990. It was exhibited several years later at the Stadtkino Theater in Vienna in 1992, as a part of a retrospective of American independent cinema titled "Unknown Territories".
On October 20, 2014, it was screened at Brooklyn's Spectacle Theater, as a part of its fourth annual "Spectober" film event. The film was later screened at the third annual horror film festival SpectreFest on October 28, 2015 along with its spiritual sequel Din of Celestial Birds followed by an onstage discussion with Merhige. The film was shown at the Music Box Theatre in Midtown Manhattan on September 25, 2016, during its 25th Anniversary celebration, where it was screened from Merhige's personal 16mm print. It was viewed as a double-feature alongside the director's other film Shadow of the Vampire, and was followed by a Q&A with Merhige. The film was later screened at the Short Film Festival in London on January 8, 2017, where it was shown again in its original 16mm format, accompanied by a live music score from the film. It was screened on October 17, 2019 at the Rice Media Center, as part of a celebration of "Low-Fi" Analog film series.
Begotten had received very limited home media distribution after its theatrical release, with current copies of the film being out of print and difficult to acquire. Initially, Merhige did not intend for the film to be released on home video, stating in an interview with Scott MacDonald that he had previously been repulsed by home video as a medium. Merhige eventually changed his mind and felt that the original soundtrack mix, with which he had not been completely satisfied, could be enhanced through the medium. The film was briefly released on VHS by World Artists Home Video on March 10, 1995. It was later given a very limited DVD release by World Artists on February 20, 2001 and included a souvenir booklet, the original theatrical trailer, rare and never-before-seen movie stills, and production photos. This edition of the film has long been out of print, which has led to the circulation and distribution of illegal, bootlegged and pirated digital copies.
On July 29, 2016, Merhige announced via Instagram that the film would be released for the first time on Blu-ray in the Fall of that year. However, the distribution deal fell through and a second announcement, during its 25th-anniversary screening alongside Shadow of the Vampire at Music Box Theatre in Midtown Manhattan, did not provide a release date either.
Begotten has received little to no attention from film critics, with many mainstream reviewers ignoring the film entirely. Merhige was initially afraid that audiences would misunderstand parts, or the entire film altogether, "When I finished the film, I felt sure it would be misunderstood and consigned to the underground again. I see it as a very serious, very beautiful work of art, but when it was first finished, I was always thinking, 'What if everybody just laughs? What if they don't see anything in it?' There is always that possibility." Reactions to the film upon its release were extremely polarized, but Merhige has stated that he remains grateful for starting his career with the film. The limited reviews on the film have been mixed to positive, with some critics calling it a masterpiece, praising the film's unique visual style, and resonating themes; others have criticized these same merits along with its brutal violence and running time.
Susan Sontag—one of the leading advocates for the film—praised it, referring to it as "a metaphysical splatter film" and "one of the 10 most important films of modern times". Marc Savlov from the Austin Chronicle called the film "Experimental, haunting, dreamlike, and intentionally confounding", also writing, "Merhige's stylized nightmare/dreamscape is a calculatedly misbegotten travelogue through Hell, accompanied by a jittery, muffled soundtrack of caterwauling crickets, doomed souls and worse." Adrian Halen from Horror News.net gave the film a positive review, stating, "Begotten is hard to consume on many levels. Though in that consumption is also a smattering of brilliance".Jonathan Rosenbaum from the Chicago Reader called it "a remarkable if not extremely upsetting and gory black-and-white experimental feature", further stating: "If you're squeamish you should avoid this like the plague; others may find it hard to shake off the artistry and originality of this visionary effort. And if you're looking to be freaked out you shouldn't pass it up." David Sterritt from Christian Science Monitor offered the film similar praise, stating that the film 'strongly recalls the work of Samuel Beckett's stark novel How It Is'. Sterritt also noted the film's claustrophobic feelings and dark narrative, writing, "Shot in grainy black-and-white on 16mm film, and then put through a multiple solarization process to bring out astonishing new relationships between shades of black, white, and grey, Begotten is entrancing, obsessive, disturbing, and probably indelible." Angelo from BloodyGoodHorror.com gave the film a positive review; he stated in his review, "In a way, it inspires so much emotion on such a deep and raw level, it's a moving and poignant film." However, the message it makes is not pretty... But if you're like me, and wondering if you've been desensitized after years of horror flicks, it'll show you whether you can still feel or not". Dennis Schwartz from Ozus' World Movie Reviews awarded the film a grade B+, praising the film's visual aesthetic, and comparing the film's graphic imagery to paintings by Francis Bacon.Mexican film critic Marco González Ambriz called the film "magnificent" and a must-see "for anyone interested in the cinematic avant-garde", although he also noted that many viewers would likely find the film unbearable.
The film was not without its detractors. Author and independent filmmaker John Kenneth Muir awarded the film a mixed rating of two and a half out of a possible four stars, calling it "an experimental, one-of-a-kind cinematic experience". In his review, Muir praised the film's originality and powerful imagery, while criticizing the running time as being too long.Janet Maslin from the New York Times criticized the film for being too grotesque, writing "Mr. Merhige's concentration, while impressive in its way, seems almost entirely self-contained, with little effort to engage an audience on even the level of myth." Rob Gonsalves from eFilmCritic.com panned the film, awarding it one out of five stars. In the review, Gonsalves, who referred to Merhige as "[a] bullshit artist (as opposed to a true artist)", criticized the film's running time as being overlong and its visual style as being empty and repetitive while also negatively comparing it to David Lynch's Eraserhead. Concluding his review, Gonsalves wrote, "If you enjoy projecting meaning onto stylish nothingness, Begotten is your movie. The rest of us may consider it the sort of art movie that gives art movies a bad name."
Begotten has gradually developed a cult following over the years and is considered by some to be the director's masterpiece. In their analytical book on cult cinema, authors Ernest Mathijs and Xavier Mendik cited the reasons for the film's cult status were due to its severely limited availability, with much of its exposure being through the distribution of bootleg copies which they called a "copy-cult". The film is currently banned in Singapore due to its graphic and disturbing content.
Begotten has been included in multiple lists at various media outlets. In 2012, Complex included the film on its list of 50 Most Disturbing Movies. Sarah Gibson from Highsnobiety listed it in her 10 of the Most Damaged and Disturbing Movies Ever Made. It was placed at #10 on AskMen's 10 Hard-To-Stomach Horror Movies, stating that the film was "so miserable that it likely wouldn't have seen the light of day were it not for Susan Sontag". Taste of Cinema.com listed it at #13 in its 20 Most Disturbing Movies of All Time, summarizing, "Begotten possesses a haunting, atmospherically visceral quality that has yet to be surpassed... Combine Merhige's avant-garde film style with sequences of torture and unsettling imagery, and you get one of the most shocking experimental pictures of all time." It was placed at #4 on Nylon's "8 Most Disturbing Horror Films Ever Made". Entertainment Weekly included the film in its "13 of the Most Disturbing — and Critically Acclaimed — Movies to Ever Hit Theaters", describing it as "kind of like if Alejandro Jodorowsky told the story of creation filtered through the lens of Eraserhead." In his book Disorders of Magnitude: A Survey of Dark Fantasy, author Jason V. Brock listed the film at #7, and as one of his favorite Radio, Film, and/or Television Productions.
The film's critical success also proved to be a starting point for Merhige's filmmaking career, who would go on to make the much praised Shadow of the Vampire and Suspect Zero, although the latter was released to negative reviews. Actor Nicolas Cage, the producer of Shadow of the Vampire, had pushed for the director's hiring after viewing a copy of Begotten.
Merhige was later hired by singer Marilyn Manson to direct music videos for his songs "Antichrist Superstar" and "Cryptorchid", the latter utilizing imagery that was heavily incorporated from Begotten. Manson was a huge admirer of Begotten, which he called "one of the strangest and scariest films I've seen", and had personally contacted Merhige to ask him if he would be willing to direct the music video for his song "Cryptorchid". The latter video premiered at the San Francisco International Film Festival in 1997 where it won a Golden Gate Certificate of Merit Award. It was subsequently barred from release by Interscope Records, whom Manson claimed were "appalled by it", due to its fascist iconography, namely the Nuremberg rallies, along with U.S. military footage and images of a Ku Klux Klan lynching. "Cryptorchid" was also beset with troubles and remained unreleased until it was leaked on YouTube in 2010. Merhige has since become a prominent member of the theatre, directing numerous stage plays which include A Dream Play, an adaption of William Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream, and Waiting for Godot.
Din of Celestial BirdsEdit
Begotten is considered by Merhige as the start of an unofficial trilogy. The second film in the trilogy, a 14-minute short titled Din of Celestial Birds, was shot in a similar visual fashion as Begotten. As with the film's predecessor, Merhige fulfilled multiple roles during its production, functioning as the writer, director, and producer. Funding for Din of Celestial Birds came through the cooperation of the Q6 production group, a collective of philosophers and artists. According to Merhige, inspiration for Din of Celestial Birds came from silent films, such as Jean Cocteau's Blood of a Poet (1930), Fritz Lang's Metropolis (1927), and the works of the Lumiere brothers. As he stated in an interview with Turner Classic Movies, "[...] I stripped my idea down to its simplest form and peeled my crew back to people I trust—my friends, a computational visual neuroscientist, a visual philosopher/painter, a multi-media performance artist, a gifted musician-composer, and a sculptor/painter. I then took off to search for creation in its simplest and purest form."
Focusing on the theory of evolution instead of religion and mythology, the film opens with the text that reads: "hello and welcome ... do not be afraid ... be comforted ... remember ... our origin...", followed by images depicting The Big Bang. Then, after a hyper-accelerated trip through the evolution of life and the Earth, it culminates in the birth of an embryonic pseudo-humanoid called the Son of Light (Stephen Charles Barry) that reaches to some unknown source.
Michael Pope's acclaimed 2001 experimental film Neovoxer has been compared to Begotten, featuring a similar visual style and "impressionistic mythology". The flashback sequences in Panos Cosmatos's 2010 film Beyond the Black Rainbow were said to be openly inspired by Begotten. Kyle Turner from Mubi.com compared the 2015 experimental film Ville Marie as being very similar to Merhige's film in terms of cinematic style, and use of reverse-exposure.
Certain scenes in Can Evrenol's 2015 surrealist horror film Baskin were compared to Begotten. In an interview with Muzzeland Press, visual artist and musician Rob Stanley cited the film's dark imagery as one of the influences for his artwork. James Quinn's 2017 experimental horror film Flesh of the Void was noted by several critics as being similar to Merhige's film in style and narrative. However, Quinn himself stated, in an interview with Nightmare on Film Street, that he felt his film did not fall into the same category. Certain scenes from Blake Williams' 2018 avant-garde science fiction film Prototype were compared to Begotten by Glenn Kenny of The New York Times. Jimmy Joe Roche's 2018 experimental short film, Skin of Man, was also said to have been influenced by Begotten.
The film's reach has also extended into the music world. American music artist Zola Jesus listed the film as a major inspiration for her 2017 music album Okovi, writing: "for months on end I had E. Elias Merhige’s 1990 film Begotten on loop. I’d sit in my dark room being lit by nothing but the screen’s caustic frames. It was my closest friend during my darkest moments and a scream I couldn’t let out on my own. I’ve never felt so directly inspired by a piece of art before." For their experimental musical composition Frankenstein Bemshi! at the 2018 Rochester Fringe Festival, performers Dave Esposito and G. E. Schwartz mixed portions of Begotten with the 1910 film Frankenstein, accompanied by live guitar music, electronic soundscapes, spoken narration, and with poetry added as text to the movie's image. Lead singer Dimitri Giannopoulos, from the American rock band Horse Jumper Of Love, revealed that the single "Airport", from their 2019 album So Divine, was partially inspired by Begotten.
- Various media outlets have mistakenly reported that the film's screening at the San Francisco Film Festival in 1990 was its first release.
- In an interview with Scott MacDonald, Merhige alternately stated that filming spanned over a period of five-and-a-half months.
- A total of approximately $20,000.
- MacDonald 1998, p. 284.
- SFFSa 2018.
- Dutka 2004.
- Merhige 1991.
- TCM 2006.
- MacDonald 1998, p. 289.
- FilmmakerMagazine 2000.
- Mapes 2004.
- SouthernEyes 2011a.
- Muir 2010.
- Verrone 2011, p. 157.
- Maslin 1991a.
- MovieMakerMagazine 2007.
- MacDonald 1998, p. 286.
- Verrone 2011, p. 154.
- MacDonald 1998, p. 290.
- Mathijs & Sexton 2012, p. 140.
- Leonard & McClure 2004, pp. 32–33.
- Savlov 2009.
- Aldama & Lindenberger 2016, p. 165.
- Wojnar 2019.
- Mathijs & Mendik 2011, p. 20.
- Essman 2010.
- MacDonald 1998, p. 292.
- Snyder 2011.
- Rosenbaum 1995a.
- Rosenbaum 1995b.
- MacDonald 1998, p. 285.
- Seibold 2016.
- Allon, Cullen & Patterson 2002, p. 374.
- MacDonald 1998, p. 287.
- Edwards 2018, p. 20.
- LAWeekly 1994, p. 43.
- Mathijs & Sexton 2012, p. 163.
- Hoberman 2003, p. 91.
- Kaufman 2001.
- MacDonald 1998, p. 291.
- Nicolay 2016.
- Griffin 1989a, p. 64.
- Griffin 1989b, p. 16.
- Hoberman 2003, p. 90.
- Prince 2002, p. 437.
- SpectacleTheater 2014.
- Disser 2014.
- Busch 2015.
- Moore 2015.
- DO312 2016.
- MothClub 2017.
- Rouner 2019.
- TLAVideo 2003, p. 50.
- Hall 1995.
- Hartl 1995, p. 80.
- Allmovie 2001a.
- Henkel 2000.
- Willmore 2014.
- FilmThreat 2009.
- Mathijs & Mendik 2011, p. 21.
- Merhige 2016.
- Chaw 2015.
- Muir 2011, pp. 140-142.
- Allmovie 2001b.
- Halen 2018.
- Sterritt 1990, p. 11.
- Angelo 2010.
- Schwartz 2016.
- Ambriz 2004.
- Maslin 1991b.
- Gonsalves 2006.
- JamesRiverFilmFestival 2015.
- Mathijs & Mendik 2011, pp. 20-21.
- Mathijs & Sexton 2012, pp. 34-35.
- ComplexMagazine 2018.
- Gibson 2016.
- Hurcomb 2015.
- Blicq 2015.
- Manders 2017.
- Heigl 2017.
- Brock 2014, p. 300.
- FandangoMedia1a 2000.
- FandangoMedia1b 2004.
- Mottram 2014.
- Massaccesi 2015, p. 113.
- Blackwelder 2000.
- Preira 2011.
- Bennett 2019.
- Celebritarian 2005, p. 5.
- SFFSb 2017.
- Barkan 2015.
- FilmAffinity 2006.
- ThirdEye 2016.
- Traces d'Images 2017, p. 194.
- SouthernEyes 2011b.
- Day 2012.
- Turner 2015.
- FilmStage 2016.
- Raab 2016.
- Millican 2017.
- Romero 2018.
- Derington 2017.
- Kenny 2018.
- CEFilmFestival 2019.
- Jesus 2016.
- Lubitow 2018.
- BWWNewsDesk 2019.
- Aldama, Frederick L; Lindenberger, Herbert S (2 February 2016). Aesthetics of Discomfort: Conversations on Disquieting Art. University of Michigan Press. ISBN 978-0-472-05300-1.
- "Begotten (1991) - E. Elias Merhige". AllMovie. RhythmOne. Retrieved 13 May 2017.
- "Allmovie – Begotten". RhythmOne.
- Allon, Yoram; Cullen, Del; Patterson, Hannah (2002). Contemporary North American Film Directors: A Wallflower Critical Guide. Wallflower Press. ISBN 978-1-903364-52-9.
- Ambriz, Marco (20 March 2004). "Begotten". RevistaCinefagia.com (in Spanish). Retrieved 21 July 2019.
- Angelo (1 December 2010). "Begotten (Movie Review)". BloodyGoodHorror.com. Retrieved 31 July 2015.
- Barkan, Jonathan (15 May 2015). "[From Best To Worst] The Music Videos Of Marilyn Manson: "Antichrist Superstar"". Bloody Disgusting. Archived from the original on April 25, 2017. Retrieved March 27, 2017.
- Barone, Matt; Serafino, Jason; Pimentel, Julia (10 October 2018). "The Most Disturbing Movies of All Time". Complex.com. Retrieved 23 July 2019.
- E. Elias Merhige (Director) (1991). Begotten (DVD). United States: Theatre of Material.
- Bennett, J (5 January 2019). "Marilyn Manson's 'Antichrist Superstar': The Story Behind the Album Cover Art". RevolverMag.com. J. Bennett. Retrieved 12 July 2019.
- Blackwelder, Rob (16 October 2000). "E. Elias Merhige interview for "Shadow of the Vampire" (2001)". SplicedWire.com. Rob Blackwelder. Retrieved 10 December 2018.
- Blicq, Tom (1 January 2015). "The 20 Most Disturbing Movies of All Time". TasteofCinema.com. Tom Blicq. Retrieved 23 July 2019.
- Brock, Jason V. (17 July 2014). Disorders of Magnitude: A Survey of Dark Fantasy. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. ISBN 978-1-4422-3525-0.
- Busch, Anita (21 August 2015). "SpectreVision Unveils Lineup For 3rd Annual Genre Film Festival". Deadline.com. Anita Busch. Retrieved 12 January 2017.
- "Horse Jumper Of Love Share AIRPORT Track On Stereogum". BroadwayWorld.com. BWW News Desk. 28 May 2019. Retrieved 10 September 2019.
- "Dramatic New Scenes For Celebritarian Needs: An Exclusive Interview With Marilyn Manson". MansonUSA. 3 November 2005. Archived from the original on June 4, 2006. Retrieved March 27, 2017.
- Chaw, Walter (20 July 2015). "Film Freak Central - The Expressionist: FFC Interviews E. Elias Merhige". FilmFreakCentral.net. Walter Chaw. Retrieved 15 July 2017.
- "Champs-Élysées Film Festival - 18 au 25 juin 2019". ChampsElseesFilmFestival.com. Champs-Élysées Film Festival. 18 June 2019. Retrieved 5 August 2019.
- Day, Nick (22 June 2012). "BEYOND THE BLACK RAINBOW - The Review - We Are Movie Geeks". WeAreMovieGeeks.com. Nick Day. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
- Derington, Anthony (1 September 2017). "Interview: FLESH OF THE VOID'S James Quinn - Nightmare on Film Street". NOFSPodcast.com. Nightmare on Film Street. Retrieved 14 October 2019.
- Disser, Nicole (10 October 2014). "Bank Robber's Tell-All, Copycat Horror, And A Terrifying Take on Genesis". BedfordandBowery.com. Nicole Disser. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
- Dutka, Eleaine (26 August 2004). "When evil is on the prowl - Los Angeles Times". LATimes.com. Archived from the original on 13 August 2019. Retrieved 13 August 2019.
- Edwards, Matthew (24 July 2018). Film Out of Bounds: Essays and Interviews on Non-Mainstream Cinema Worldwide. McFarland. ISBN 978-1-4766-0780-1.
- "Shadow of the Vampire (2000)". Rotten Tomatoes. Fandango Media. Retrieved 18 November 2016.
- "Suspect Zero (2004) - Rotten Tomatoes". Rotten Tomatoes.com. Fandango Media. Retrieved 3 July 2017.
- "Din of Celestial Birds (S) (2006) - FilmAffinity". Film Affinity.com. 2006. Retrieved 5 December 2018.
- "SUNRISE, SUNSET". Filmmaker Magazine.com. 1 July 2000. Retrieved 27 December 2016.
- "New to Streaming: 'The Revenant,' 'James White,' 'A Brighter Summer Day,' 'The Pearl Button,' and More". TheFilmStage.com. 25 March 2016. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
- "THE BOOTLEG FILES: BEGOTTEN – Film Threat". Film Threat.com. 29 May 2009. Retrieved 18 October 2018.
- Gibson, Sarah (8 November 2016). "10 of the Most Damaged and Disturbing Movies Ever Made". HighSnobiety.com. Retrieved 23 July 2019.
- Gonsalves, Rob (29 November 2006). "Begotten". eFilmCritic.com. Retrieved 20 April 2017.
- Griffin, John (26 October 1989). "High definition is becoming horror show for organizers". Montreal, Quebec: Postmedia Network. The Gazette. p. 64. Retrieved 22 October 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
- Griffin, John (30 October 1989). "New Film Festival Sets Attendance Record". Montreal, Quebec: Postmedia Network. The Gazette. p. 16. Retrieved 22 October 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
- Essman, Scott (20 September 2010). "Interview: Elias Merhige (Begotten)". HorrorNews.net. Retrieved 27 July 2015.
- Halen, Adrian (4 January 2018). "Film Review: Begotten (1990)". HorrorNews.net. HorrorNews. Retrieved 11 October 2019.
- Hall, Phil (1 December 1995). "Begotten Not Forgotten". Wired.com. Retrieved 2 August 2019.
- Heigl, Alex (10 March 2017). "13 of the Most Disturbing — and Critically Acclaimed — Movies to Ever Hit Theaters". EntertainmentWeekly.com. Retrieved 23 July 2019.
- Halen, Adrian (4 January 2018). "Film Review: Begotten (1990)". HorrorNews.net. Adrian Helen. Retrieved 20 July 2019.
- Henkel, Guido (30 October 2000). "For adventurous film lovers: Begotten comes to DVD - DVD Review & High Definition". DVDReview.com. Retrieved 2 August 2019.
- Hartl, John (10 March 1995). "Several movies bypass theaters in March". Akron, Ohio: The Akron Beacon Journal. p. 80. Retrieved 24 October 2019.
- Hoberman, J. (2003). The Magic Hour: Film at Fin de Siècle. Temple University Press. ISBN 978-1-56639-995-1.
- Hurcomb, Kelly (24 October 2015). "10 Hard to Stomach Horror Movies". AskMen.com. Kelly Hurcomb. Retrieved 23 July 2019.
- "22nd James River Film Festival: NEOVOXER featuring Michael Pope". JamesRiverFilm.com. James River Film Society. 9 April 2015. Archived from the original on March 12, 2019. Retrieved 22 July 2019.
- Kaufman, Anthony (5 January 2001). "INTERVIEW: The Vampiric Arts of Merhige and Dafoe in "Shadow"". IndieWire.com. IndieWire. Retrieved 14 October 2019.
- Jesus, Zola (11 September 2016). "Zola Jesus on Artists From Different Disciplines Who Inspired Her New Album, 'Okovi'ARTnews". ARTNews.com. Zola Jesus. Retrieved 18 October 2018.
- Kenny, Glenn (30 August 2018). "Review: In 'Prototype,' Multiple Screens Tell an Apocalyptic Story - The New York Times". New York Times.com. Glenn Kenny. Retrieved 8 September 2018.
- "Begotten". Los Angeles, California: LA Weekly. 11 August 1994. p. 43. Retrieved 15 October 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
- Leonard, Scott A.; McClure, Michael (2004). Myth and knowing: an introduction to world mythology. McGraw-Hill. ISBN 978-0-7674-1957-4.
- Lubitow, Adam (23 September 2018). "Adam reviews 'Frankenstein Bemshi!' and 'One Frogless Evening: A Tribute to Amphibian Artiste Michigan J. Frog'". RochesterCity Newspaper.com. Adam Lubitow. Retrieved 26 October 2018.
- MacDonald, Scott (1998). A Critical Cinema 3: Interviews with Independent Filmmakers. University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-20943-5.
- Manders, Hayden (30 October 2017). "Ranking the 8 Most Disturbing Horror Films Ever Made". Nylon.com. Hayden Manders. Retrieved 23 July 2019.
- Mapes, Marty (26 August 2004). "Interview with E. Elias Merhige - Movie Habit". Movie Habit.com. Retrieved 13 September 2018.
- Maslin, Janet (5 June 1991a). "Begotten - Trailer - Cast - Showtimes - NYTimes.net". NYTimes.com. Janet Maslin. Archived from the original on 7 March 2016. Retrieved 22 July 2019.
- Maslin, Janet (1991b). "Movie Review - - Breaking New Ground And Finding the Grotesque - NYTimes.com". NYTimes.com. Janet Maslin. Archived from the original on 10 March 2016. Retrieved 22 July 2019.
- Massaccesi, Cristina (1 December 2015). Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror. Columbia University Press. ISBN 978-0-9932384-6-8.
- Mathijs, Ernest; Sexton, Jamie (30 March 2012). Cult Cinema: An Introduction. John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1-4443-9643-0.
- Mathijs, Ernest; Mendik, Xavier (20 December 2011). 100 Cult Films. Bloomsbury Academic. ISBN 978-1-84457-408-7.
- Merhige, Edmund (8 August 2016). "E. Elias Merhige on Instagram: "CHICAGO and DENVER announced!". Instagram.com. E. Elias Merhige. Retrieved 11 May 2019.
- Millican, Joshua (20 April 2017). "NSFW Trailer for "Flesh of the Void" is Extremely Disturbing with Echoes of "Begotten"". HorrorFreakNews.com. Joshua Millican. Retrieved 6 June 2018.
- Moore, Debi (22 August 2015). "SpectreFest 2015 Lineup Includes Cooties, Sun Choke, Goodnight Mommy, Deathgasm, and More! - Dread Central". Dread Central.com. Debi Moore. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
- Mottram, James (28 October 2014). "BBC - Films - interview - E Elias Merhige - Shadow of the Vampire". BBC.co.uk. James Mottram. Retrieved 23 July 2019.
- "SPECIAL EVENT: Begotten + Live Score by The Begotten". ShortFilms.org.uk. MothClub. 2017. Retrieved 20 July 2019.
- "E. Elias Merhige's Power of Unflinching Belief - MovieMaker Magazine". MovieMaker.com. MovieMaker Magazine. 3 February 2007. Retrieved 13 September 2018.
- Muir, John (29 March 2010). "John Kenneth Muir's Reflections on Cult Movies and Classic TV: CULT MOVIE REVIEW: Begotten (1991)". Reflectionsonfilmandtelevision.blogspot.com. Retrieved 22 December 2016.
- Muir, John Kenneth (6 October 2011). Horror Films of the 1990s. McFarland, Incorporated, Publishers. ISBN 978-0-7864-8480-5.
- Nicolay, Scott (28 January 2016). "E. Elias Merhige: The Greatest Apple You'll Ever Eat". ScottNicolay.com. Scott Nicolay. Retrieved 15 July 2017.
- "Begotten & Shadow of the Vampire Double Feature with Director E. Elias Merhige in Person!". DO312.com. DO312.com. 25 September 2016. Retrieved 15 July 2017.
- Raab, Johnathan (11 January 2016). "An Interview with dark artist Rob Stanley". MuzzelandPress.com. Johnathan Raab. Retrieved 31 July 2019.
- Preira, Matt (4 October 2011). "Marilyn Manson's Antichrist Superstar Is 15: A Video History". Broward Palm Beach.com. Matt Preira. Retrieved 19 July 2017.
- Prince, Stephen (15 March 2002). A New Pot of Gold: Hollywood Under the Electronic Rainbow, 1980 1989 (2nd ed.). University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-23266-2.
- Romero, Evan (14 March 2018). "'Flesh of the Void' (2018) Movie Review - PopHorror". PopHorror.com. Retrieved 6 June 2018.
- Rosenbaum, Jonathan (1 March 1995a). "Begotten". Chicago Reader. Jonathan Rosenbaum. Retrieved 27 July 2015.
- Rosenbaum, Jonathan (1995b). "Begotten". JonathanRosenbaum.net. Jonathan Rosenbaum. Retrieved 24 July 2019.
- Rouner, Jef (20 October 2019). "Analog film fans are high on Rice's Low-Fi supply - HoustonChronicle.com". HustonChronicle.com. The Huston Chronicle. Retrieved 26 October 2019.
- "Begotten: film explores Christian and pagan myths of fertility in cycle of birth, death and rebirth". UnderSouthernEyes.Epinsent.com. Episent.com. 15 November 2011a. Retrieved 13 September 2017.
- "Din of Celestial Birds: exploration of evolution and development of consciousness in short film – Under Southern Eyes". UnderSouthernEyes.Episent.com. nausika. 2011b. Retrieved 5 December 2018.
- Savlov, Marc (18 May 2009). ""Jane! Stop This Crazy Thing!" (The Downside to Galaxy Highland Theater's New Robotic Seats) Five Films We Don't Want to See in D-Box". Austin Chronicle.com. Marc Savlov. Retrieved 22 December 2016.
- Sauve qui peut le court métrage; Traces d'Images (20 February 2017). Catalogue Clermont FilmFest09 (in French). Sauve qui peut le court métrage. GGKEY:UWGZ61YKB1U. Retrieved 3 August 2019.
- Schwartz, Dennis (23 May 2016). "shadowofthevampire". Sover.net. Ozus' World Movie Reviews. Archived from the original on 11 June 2016. Retrieved 10 October 2019.
- Seibold, Witney (29 April 2016). "The Beautiful Horror of BEGOTTEN – The 13th Floor". The13thFloor.tv. The 13th Floor. Retrieved 13 September 2018.
- Geritz, Kathy. "Begotten". History.sfs.org. San Francisco Film Festival. Retrieved 26 October 2018.
- "Marilyn Manson: Anti-Christ Superstar". San Francisco International Film Festival. Archived from the original on March 27, 2017. Retrieved March 27, 2017.
- Snyder, Eric (13 April 2011). "What's the Big Deal?: Eraserhead (1977)". Film.com. Eric Snyder. Archived from the original on April 18, 2011. Retrieved 20 July 2019.
- "SPECTOBER IV". SpectacleTheater.com. Spectacle Theater. October 2014. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
- Sterritt, David (November 27, 1990). "The Best of Independent Films Are There If You Look for Them". Christian Science Monitor. p. 11.
- "Din of Celestial Birds by E. Elias Merhige". The Third Eye.co.uk. The Third Eye. 11 January 2016. Retrieved 5 December 2018.
- (Firm), TLA Video (24 October 2003). TLA Video & DVD Guide 2004: The Discerning Film Lover's Guide. St. Martin's Press. ISBN 978-0-312-31686-0.
- "DIN OF CELESTIAL BIRDS FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 15 AT 8 & 11 PM ET AND AN ADDITIONAL SHOWING AT 4 AM ET". Turner Classic Movies.com. Turner Classic Movies. 15 September 2006. Retrieved 22 June 2017.
- Turner, Kyle (6 January 2015). "First Look 2015 on Notebook". Mubi.com. Mubi. Retrieved 11 December 2018.
- Verrone, William (8 November 2011). The Avant-Garde Feature Film: A Critical History. McFarland & Company, Inc. ISBN 978-0-7864-8881-0. Retrieved 6 August 2019.
- Willmore, Alison (20 August 2014). "26 Hard-To-Find Movies That Remind Us Why VHS, DVD, and LaserDisc Still Matter". BuzzFeed.com. Alison Willmore. Retrieved 3 July 2017.
- Wojnar, Jason (12 October 2019). "10 Horror Movies Too Intense Even For Halloween". ScreenRant.com. Screen Rant. Retrieved 2 December 2019.
- Jason Louv (17 April 2018). John Dee and the Empire of Angels: Enochian Magick and the Occult Roots of the Modern World. Inner Traditions/Bear. ISBN 978-1-62055-590-3.
- Armond White (1995). The Resistance: Ten Years of Pop Culture that Shook the World. Overlook Press. ISBN 978-0-87951-586-7.