Talk:G Girls

Latest comment: 7 years ago by Aoba47 in topic Reclassification/Assessment

Reclassification/Assessment

edit
  • I am reclassifying this from a "Start" to a "Stub" as there are several issues with this article. The actual content of this article is extremely short and a superficial overview of the band. As someone completely unfamiliar with the band and all of its singers, I could not really get that much from the article. There should be an expansion on how the band was formed and more information on the songs outside of just their commercial performance. I agree that "Call the Police" is notable enough for its own page and I think a page could even be possibly made for "Milk & Honey" if enough coverage from third-party, reliable sources can be found, but this article does not give me a lot of context or information to support this group being notable enough to have its own page. It is pretty bad that a single cover has to be used for the infobox image if there are not any images of these singers together from a live show or promotional interview. I just wanted to explain my reclassification/assessment, and state that more work needs to be put into this. Aoba47 (talk) 16:45, 9 April 2017 (UTC)Reply