Talk:Clara Morgane

Latest comment: 18 days ago by Anatole-berthe in topic Reference asked about music made by Clara Morgane

Mid or High

edit

If I read the criterion for High importance, I think she should be rated as High. She has achieved nationwide notability in France. If you look for instance at the French language wikipedia, she is the 37th most visited entry on that Wikipedia, ahead of any other actress entry (French or international), mainstream or not ! Hektor 18:20, 8 August 2007 (UTC)Reply

OK, "often appears on national TV" would be High, but it would be nice if there were a few verifiable references added to the article that said that. --AnonEMouse (squeak) 18:28, 8 August 2007 (UTC)Reply
37th most visited entry on French language wikipedia seems verifiable to me. Hektor 19:08, 8 August 2007 (UTC)Reply
No, that's a self-reference, and not really relevant. We don't know if the article was visited because she is popular, or only because of something with the article itself: perhaps it was involved in an edit war or arbitration case (do they have those on FR?) or was written up in a newspaper article on "look how silly FR Wikipedia is, having articles on complete nobodies" or something else that doesn't really have to do with her own notability. We need something like a newspaper article saying she is a regular fixture on national TV. Well, "need" is overstating the case a little, since I am taking your word for it, the importance rating is really only an internal marking on a talk page, it doesn't directly affect the real article. Make that "want", "would like", "would appreciate". :-) --AnonEMouse (squeak) 19:18, 8 August 2007 (UTC)Reply
I cannot help there, I don't know any web site which lists guests of past French TV programs. All I can say, living in France, is that she is everywhere, mostly in evening or late night talk shows, especially now she has started a singing career. Regarding the French wikipedia thing, I think this is relevant since she is every month in the top 100, so this is not a special event or something. We are talking 5000 hits a day, that makes a lot of French-speaking people every month looking for information about her ! Hektor 19:31, 8 August 2007 (UTC)Reply
I can also say that her latest single Sexy Girl is rated 32nd this week in France. Her album reached 46th rank as best rank but has now dropped to 188th.

Reference asked about music made by Clara Morgane

edit

I'd like to understand something. For example , when I read on the article than a reference is asked after the next sentence "In 2007, she started a singing career. Rudy Lansard and Abdel Maalikoom produced her first song J'Aime.[citation needed] "

The citation needed is about the fact it's her first song released , the fact "Rudy Lansard" and "Abdel Maalikoom" produced this , or the song itself ?


I hope my English is understandable. Anatole-berthe (talk) 03:34, 30 October 2024 (UTC)Reply