Old Norse religion(Redirected from Norse paganism)
This article may need to be rewritten entirely to comply with Wikipedia's quality standards. (August 2017)
Old Norse religion developed from early Germanic religion during the Proto-Norse period, when the North Germanic people separated into a distinct branch of the Germanic peoples. It was displaced by Christianization of the North Germanic peoples. Scholars reconstruct aspects of North Germanic religion by historical linguistics, archaeology, toponymy, and records left by North Germanic peoples, such as runic inscriptions in the Younger Futhark, a distinctly North Germanic extension of the runic alphabet. Numerous Old Norse works dated to the 13th century record Norse mythology, a component of North Germanic religion.
Old Norse religion was polytheistic, entailing a belief in various gods and goddesses. Norse mythology divided these deities into two groups, the Æsir and the Vanir, who engaged in an ancient war until realising that they were equally powerful. Among the most widespread deities were the gods Oðinn and Thor. This world was inhabited also by various other mythological races, including giants, dwarfs, elves, and land-spirits. Norse cosmology revolved around a world tree known as Yggdrasil, with various realms existing alongside that of humans, named Midgard. These include multiple afterlife realms, several of which are controlled by a particular deity.
Transmitted through oral culture rather than through codified texts, Old Norse religion focused heavily on ritual practice, with kings and chiefs playing a central role in carrying out public acts of sacrifice. Various cultic spaces were used; initially, outdoor spaces such as groves and lakes were typically selected, but by the third century CE cult houses were also purpose built for ritual activity. Norse society also contained practitioners of Seiðr, a form of sorcery which some scholars describe as shamanistic. Various forms of burial were conducted, including both inhumation and cremation, typically accompanied by a variety of grave goods.
Throughout its history, varying levels of trans-cultural diffusion occurred among neighbouring peoples, such as the Sami and Finns. By the twelfth century Old Norse religion had succumbed to Christianity, with elements continuing into Scandinavian folklore. A revival of interest in Old Norse religion occurred amid the romanticist movement of the nineteenth century, during which it inspired a range of artworks. It also attracted the interest of political figures, and was used by a range of right-wing and nationalist groups. Academic research into the subject began in the early nineteenth century, initially influenced by the pervasive romanticist sentiment.
The archaeologist Anders Andrén noted that "Old Norse religion" is "the conventional name" applied to the pre-Christian religions of Scandinavia. See for instance  Other terms used by scholarly sources include "pre-Christian Norse religion", "Norse religion", "Norse paganism", "Nordic paganism", "Scandinavian paganism", "Scandinavian heathenism", "Scandinavian religion", "Northern paganism", and "Northern heathenism". This Old Norse religion can be seen as part of a broader Germanic religion found across linguistically Germanic Europe; of the different forms of this Germanic religion, that of the Old Norse is the best-documented.
Rooted in ritual practice and oral tradition, Old Norse religion was fully integrated with other aspects of Norse life, including subsistence, warfare, and social interactions. Open codifications of Old Norse beliefs were either rare or non-existent. The practitioners of this belief system themselves had no term meaning "religion", which was only introduced with Christianity. Following Christianity's arrival, Old Norse terms that were used for the pre-Christian systems were forn sið ("old custom") or heiðinn sið ("heathen custom"), terms which suggest an emphasis on rituals, actions, and behaviours rather than belief itself. The earliest known usage of the Old Norse term heiðinn is in the poem Hákonarmál; its uses here indicates that the arrival of Christianity has generated consciousness of Old Norse religion as a distinct religion.
Old Norse religion has been classed as an ethnic religion, and as a "non-doctrinal community religion". It varied across time, in different regions and locales, and according to social differences. This variation is partly due to its transmission through oral culture rather than codified texts. For this reason, the archaeologists Andrén, Kristina Jennbert, and Catharina Raudvere stated that "pre-Christian Norse religion is not a uniform or stable category", while the scholar Karen Bek-Pedersen noted that the "Old Norse belief system should probably be conceived of in the plural, as several systems". The historian of religion Hilda Ellis Davidson stated that it would have ranged from manifestations of "complex symbolism" to "the simple folk-beliefs of the less sophisticated".
During the Viking Age, the Norse likely regarded themselves as a more or less unified entity through their shared Germanic language, Old Norse. The scholar of Scandinavian studies Thomas A. DuBois said Old Norse religion and other pre-Christian belief systems in Northern Europe must be viewed as "not as isolated, mutually exclusive language-bound entities, but as broad concepts shared across cultural and linguistic lines, conditioned by similar ecological factors and protracted economic and cultural ties". During this period, the Norse interacted closely with other ethno-cultural and linguistic groups, such as the Sámi, Balto-Finns, Anglo-Saxons, Greenlandic Inuit, and various speakers of Celtic and Slavic languages. Economic, marital, and religious exchange occurred between the Norse and many of these other groups. Enslaved individuals from the British Isles were common throughout the Nordic world during the Viking Age. Different elements of Old Norse religion had different origins and histories; some aspects may derive from deep into prehistory, others only emerging following the encounter with Christianity.
Old Norse textual sourcesEdit
A few runic inscriptions with religious content survive from pagan Scandinavia, particularly asking Thor to hallow or protect a memorial stone; carving his hammer on the stone also served this function.
In contrast to the few runic fragments, a considerable body of literary and historical sources survive in Old Norse manuscripts using the Latin script, all of which were created after the conversion of Scandinavia, the majority in Iceland. Some of the poetic sources in particular, the Poetic Edda and skaldic poetry, may have been originally composed by heathens, and Hávamál contains both information on heathen mysticism and what Ursula Dronke referred to as "a round-up of ritual obligations". In addition there is information about pagan beliefs and practices in the sagas, which include both historical sagas such as Snorri Sturluson's Heimskringla and the Landnámabók, recounting the settlement and early history of Iceland, and the so-called sagas of Icelanders concerning Icelandic individuals and groups; there are also more or less fantastical legendary sagas. Many skaldic verses are preserved in sagas. Of the originally heathen works, we cannot know what changes took place either during oral transmission or as a result of their being recorded by Christians; the sagas of Icelanders, in particular, are now regarded by most scholars as more or less historical fiction rather than as detailed historical records. A large amount of mythological poetry has undoubtedly been lost.
One important written source is Snorri's Prose Edda, which incorporates a manual of Norse mythology for the use of poets in constructing kennings; it also includes numerous citations, some of them the only record of lost poems, such as Þjóðólfr of Hvinir's Haustlǫng. Snorri's Prologue eumerises the Æsir as Trojans, deriving Æsir from Asia, and some scholars have suspected that many of the stories that we only have from him are also derived from Christian medieval culture.
Other textual sourcesEdit
Additional sources remain by non-Scandinavians writing in languages other than Old Norse. The earliest of these, Tacitus' Germania, dates to around 100 CE and describes religious practices of several Germanic peoples, but has little coverage of Scandinavia. In the Middle Ages, several Christian commentators also wrote about Scandinavian paganism, mostly from a hostile perspective. The best known of these are Adam of Bremen's Gesta Hammaburgensis ecclesiae pontificum (History of the Bishops of Hamburg), written between 1066 and 1072, which includes an account of the temple at Uppsala, and Saxo Grammaticus' 12th-century Gesta Danorum (History of the Danes), which includes versions of Norse myths and some material on pagan religious practices. In addition, Muslim Arabs wrote accounts of Norse people they encountered, the best known of which is Ibn Fadlan's 10th-century Risala, an account of Volga Viking traders that includes a detailed description of a ship burial.
Archaeological and toponymic evidenceEdit
Since the literary evidence that represents Old Norse sources was recorded by Christians, archaeological evidence especially of cultic sites and burials is of great importance particularly as a source of information on Norse religion before the conversion. Many aspects of material culture—including settlement locations, artefacts and buildings—may cast light on beliefs, and archaeological evidence regarding cult practices indicates chronological, geographic and class differences far greater than are suggested by the surviving texts.
Place-names are an additional source of evidence. Theophoric place-names, including instances where a pair of deity names occur in close proximity, provide an indication of the importance of the cult of those deities in different areas, dating back to before our earliest written sources. The toponymic evidence shows considerable regional variation, and some deities, such as Ullr and Hǫrn, occur more frequently than the surviving myths would lead us to expect, whereas comparatively few Odin place-names occur.
Some place-names contain elements indicating that they were sites of religious activity: those formed with -vé, -hörgr, and -hof, words for cult sites of various kinds, and also likely those formed with -akr or -vin, words for "field", when coupled with the name of a deity. Magnus Olsen developed a typology of such place-names in Norway, from which he posited a development in pagan worship from groves and fields toward the use of temple buildings.
Personal names are also a source of information on the popularity of certain deities; for example Thor's name was an element in the names of both men and women, particularly in Iceland.
Iron Age originsEdit
Andrén described Old Norse religion as a "cultural patchwork" which emerged under a wide range of influences, both from earlier Scandinavian religions and elements introduced from elsewhere. It may have had links to Nordic Bronze Age: while the putatively solar-oriented belief system of Bronze Age Scandinavia is believed to have died out around 500 BCE, a number of Bronze Age motifs—such as the wheel cross—reappear in later Iron Age contexts. It is often regarded as having developed from earlier religious belief systems found among the Germanic Iron Age peoples. The Germanic languages likely emerged in the first millennium BCE in present-day northern Germany or Denmark, after which they spread; several of the deities in Old Norse religion have parallels among other Germanic societies. The Scandinavian Iron Age began around 500 to 400 BCE.
Archaeological evidence is particularly important for understanding these early periods. Accounts from this time were produced by Tacitus; according to the scholar Gabriel Turville-Petre, Tacitus' observations "help to explain" later Old Norse religion. Tacitus described the Germanic peoples as having a priestly caste, open-air sacred sites, and an emphasis on sacrifice (including human), augury, and fortune telling. Tacitus notes that the Germanic peoples were polytheistic and mentions some of their deities through perceived Roman equivalents.
Viking Age expansionEdit
During the Viking Age, Norse people left Scandinavia and settled elsewhere throughout Northwestern Europe. Some of these areas, such as Iceland, the Orkneys, Shetland, and the Faroe Island, were hardly populated, whereas other areas, such as England, Scotland, the Western Isles, Isle of Man, and Ireland, were already heavily populated.
In the 870s, Norwegian settlers left their homeland and colonised Iceland, bringing their belief system with them. Place-name evidence suggests that Thor was the most popular god on the island, although there are also saga accounts of devotés of Freyr in Iceland, including a "priest of Freyr" in the later Hrafnkels saga. There are no place-names connected to Odin on the island. Unlike other Nordic societies, Iceland lacked a monarchy and thus a centralising authority which could enforce religious adherence; there were both pagan and Christian communities from the time of its first settlement.
Scandinavian settlers brought Old Norse religion to Britain in the latter decades of the ninth century. Several British place-names indicate possible cultic sites; for instance, Roseberry Topping in North Yorkshire was known as Othensberg in the twelfth century, a name deriving from the Old Norse Óðinsberg ("Hill of Óðin"). Several place-names also contain Old Norse references to mythological entities, such as alfr, skratii, and troll. The English church found itself in need of conducting a new conversion process to Christianise this incoming population.
Christianisation and declineEdit
The Nordic world first encountered Christianity through its settlements in the (already Christian) British Isles and through trade contacts with the eastern Christians in Novgorod and Byzantium. By the time Christianity arrived in Scandinavia it was already the accepted religion across most of Europe. It is not well understood how the Christian institutions converted these Scandinavian settlers, in part due to a lack of textual descriptions of this conversion process equivalent to Bede's description of the earlier Anglo-Saxon conversion. However, it appears that the Scandinavian migrants had converted to Christianity within the first few decades of their arrival.[further explanation needed] After Christian missionaries from the British Isles—including figures like St Willibrord, St Boniface, and Willehad—had travelled to parts of northern Europe in the eighth century, Charlemagne pushed for Christianisation in Denmark, with Ebbo of Rheims, Halitgar of Cambrai, and Willeric of Bremen proselytizing in the kingdom during the ninth century. The Danish king Harald Klak converted (826), likely to secure his political alliance with Louis the Pious against his rivals for the throne. The Danish monarchy reverted to Old Norse religion under Horik II (854 – c. 867).
The Norwegian king Hákon the Good had converted to Christianity while in England. On returning to Norway, he kept his faith largely private but encouraged Christian priests to preach among the population; some pagans were angered and—according to Heimskringla—three churches built near Trondheim were burned down. His successor, Harald Greycloak, was also a Christian but similarly had little success in converting the Norwegian population to his religion. Haakon Sigurdsson later became the de facto ruler of Norway, and although he agreed to be baptised under pressure from the Danish king and allowed Christians to preach in the kingdom, he enthusiastically supported pagan sacrificial customs, asserting the superiority of the traditional deities and encouraging Christians to return to their veneration. His reign (975–995) saw the emergence of a "state paganism", an official ideology which bound together Norwegian identity with pagan identity and rallied support behind Haakon's leadership. Haakon was killed in 995 and Olaf Tryggvason, the next king, took power and enthusiastically promoted Christianity; he forced high-status Norwegians to convert, destroyed temples, and killed those he called 'sorcerers'. Sweden was the last Scandinavian country to officially convert; although little is known about the process of Christianisation, it is known that the Swedish kings had converted by the early 11th century and that the country was fully Christian by the early 12th.
Olaf Tryggvason sent a Saxon missionary, Þangbrandr, to Iceland. Many Icelanders were angered by Þangbrandr's proselytising, and he was outlawed after killing several poets who insulted him. Animosity between Christians and pagans on the island grew, and at the Althing in 998 both sides blasphemed each other's gods. In an attempt to preserve unity, at the Althing in 999, an agreement was reached that the Icelandic law would be based on Christian principles, albeit with concessions to the pagan community. Private, albeit not public, pagan sacrifices and rites were to remain legal.
Across Germanic Europe, conversion to Christianity was closely connected to social ties; mass conversion was the norm, rather than individual conversion. A primary motivation for kings converting was the desire for support from Christian rulers, whether as money, imperial sanction, or military support. Christian missionaries found it difficult convincing Norse people that the two belief systems were mutually exclusive; the polytheistic nature of Old Norse religion allowed its practitioners to accept Jesus Christ as one god among many. The encounter with Christianity could also stimulate new and innovative expressions of pagan culture, for instance through influencing various pagan myths. As with other Germanic societies, syncretisation between incoming and traditional belief systems took place. For those living in isolated areas, pre-Christian beliefs likely survived longer, while others continued as survivals in folklore.
By the 12th century, Christianity was firmly established across Northwestern Europe. For two centuries, Scandinavian ecclesiastics continued to condemn paganism, although it is unclear whether it still constituted a viable alternative to Christian dominance. These writers often presented paganism as being based on deceit or delusion; some stated that the Old Norse gods had been humans falsely euhemerised as deities.
Old Norse mythological stories survived in oral culture for at least two centuries, to be recorded in the 13th century. How this mythology was passed down is unclear; it is possible that pockets of pagans retained their belief system throughout the 11th and 12th centuries, or that it had survived as a cultural artefact passed down by Christians who retained the stories while rejecting any literal belief in them. The historian Judith Jesch suggested that following Christianisation, there remained a "cultural paganism", the re-use of pre-Christian myth "in certain cultural and social contexts" that are officially Christian. For instance, Old Norse mythological themes and motifs appear in poetry composed for the court of Cnut the Great, an eleventh-century Christian Anglo-Scandinavian king. Saxo is the earliest medieval figure to take a revived interest in the pre-Christian beliefs of his ancestors, doing so not out of a desire to revive their faith but out of historical interest. Snorri was also part of this revived interest, examining pagan myths from his perspective as a cultural historian and mythographer. As a result, Norse mythology "long outlasted any worship of or belief in the gods it depicts".
Norse mythology, stories of the Norse deities, is preserved in Eddic poetry and in Snorri Sturluson's guide for skalds, the Poetic Edda. We also have depictions of some of these stories on picture stones in Gotland and in other visual records including some early Christian crosses, which attests to how widely known they were. The myths were transmitted purely orally until the end of the period, and were subject to variation; one key poem, "Vǫluspá", is preserved in two variant versions in different manuscripts, and Snorri's retelling of the myths sometimes varies from the other textual sources that are preserved. There was no single authoritative version of a particular myth, and we must presume variation over time and from place to place, rather than "a single unified body of thought". In particular, there may have been influences from interactions with other peoples, including northern Slavs, Finns, and Anglo-Saxons, and Christian mythology exerted an increasing influence.
Old Norse religion was polytheistic, with many anthropomorphic gods and goddesses, who express human emotions and in some cases are married and have children. One god, Baldr, is said in the myths to have died. Archaeological evidence on worship of particular gods is sparse, although placenames may also indicate locations where they were venerated. For some gods, particularly Loki, there is no evidence of worship; however, this may be changed by new archaeological discoveries. Regions, communities, and social classes likely varied in the gods they venerated more or at all. There are also accounts in sagas of individuals who devoted themselves to a single deity, described as a fulltrúi or vinr (confidant, friend); this has been seen as a view of the heathen past influenced by the Christian cult of the saints, but can also be seen in Egill Skallagrímsson's reference to his relationship with Odin in his "Sonatorrek", a tenth-century skaldic poem. Although our literary sources are all relatively late, there are also indications of change over time.
Norse mythological sources, particularly Snorri and "Vǫluspá", differentiate between two groups of deities, the Æsir and the Vanir, who fought a war during which the Vanir broke down the walls of the Æsir's stronghold, Asgard, and eventually made peace by means of a truce and the exchange of hostages. Some mythographers have suggested that this myth was based on recollection of a conflict in Scandinavia between adherents of different belief systems; in Georges Dumézil's tripartite theory both the war and the division of the pantheon into two groups are related to Indo-European parallels, with the Vanir exemplifying the second "function", that of fertility and the cycle of life and death.
Major deities among the Æsir include Thor (who is often referred to in literary texts as Asa-Thor, "Thor the Áss"), Odin and Týr. Very few Vanir are named in the sources: Njǫrðr, his son Freyr, and his daughter Freyja; according to Snorri all of these could be called Vanaguð (Vanir-god), and Freyja also Vanadís (Vanir-dís). The status of Loki within the pantheon is problematic, and according to "Lokasenna" and "Vǫluspá" and Snorri's explanation, he is imprisoned beneath the earth until Ragnarok, when he will fight against the gods. As far back as 1889 Sophus Bugge suggested this was a version of the myth of Lucifer.
The general Old Norse word for the goddesses is Ásynjur, which is properly the feminine of Æsir. An old word for goddess may be dís, which is preserved as the name of a group of female supernatural beings.
Localised and ancestral deitiesEdit
Ancestral deities were common among Finno-Ugric peoples, and remained a strong presence among the Finns and Sámi after Christianisation. Ancestor veneration may have played a part in the private religious practices of Norse people in their farmsteads and villages; in the 10th century, Norwegian pagans attempted to encourage the Christian king Haakon to take part in an offering to the gods by inviting him to drink a toast to the ancestors alongside a number of named deities.
The norns are female figures who determine individuals' fate. Snorri describes them as a group of three, but he and other sources also allude to larger groups of norns who decide the fate of newborns. It is uncertain whether they were worshipped.
The vættir, spirits of the land, were thought to inhabit certain rocks, waterfalls, and trees, and offerings were made to them. For many, they may have been more important in daily life than the gods. Texts also mention various kinds of elves and dwarfs. Fylgjur, guardian spirits, generally female, were associated with individuals and families. Hamingjur, dísir and swanmaidens are female supernatural figures of uncertain stature within the belief system; the dísir may have functioned as tutelary goddesses. Valkyries were associated with the myths concerning Odin, and also occur in heroic poetry such as the Helgi lays, where they are depicted as princesses who assist and marry heroes.
Conflict with the jǫtnar, or giants, is a frequent motif in the mythology. They are described as both the ancestors and sworn enemies of the gods. Gods marry giantesses but giants' attempts to couple with goddesses are repulsed. Most scholars believe the jǫtnar were not worshipped, although this has been questioned. The Eddic jǫtnar have parallels with their later folkloric counterparts, although unlike them they have much wisdom.
Several accounts of the Old Norse cosmogony, or creation myth, appear in surviving textual sources, but there is no evidence that these were certainly produced in the pre-Christian period. It is possible that they were developed during the encounter with Christianity, as pagans sought to establish a creation myth complex enough to rival that of Christianity. According to the account in Völuspá, the universe was initially a void known as Ginnungagap. There then appeared a giant, Ymir, and after him the gods, who lifted the earth out of the sea. A different account is provided in Vafþrúðnismál, which describes the world being made from the components of Ymir's body: the earth from his flesh, the mountains from his bones, the sky from his skull, and the sea from his blood. Grímnismál also describes the world being fashioned from Ymir's corpse, although adds the detail that the giants emerged from a spring known as Élivágar.
In Snorri's Gylfaginning, it is again stated that the Old Norse cosmogony began with a belief in Ginnungagap, the void. From this emerged two realms, the icy, misty Niflheim and the fire-filled Muspell, the latter ruled over by fire-giant, Surtr. A river produced by these realms coagulated to form Ymir, while a cow known as Audumbla then appeared to provide him with milk. Audumbla licked a block of ice to free Buri, whose son Bor married a giantess named Bestla. Some of the features of this myth, such as the cow Audumbla, are of unclear provenance; Snorri does not specify where he obtained these details as he did for other parts of the myths, and it may be that these were his own personal inventions.
Völuspá portrays Yggdrasil as a giant ash tree. Grímnismál claims that the deities meet beneath Yggdrasil daily to pass judgement. It also claims that a serpent gnaws at its roots while a deer grazes from its higher branches; a squirrel runs between the two animals, exchanging messages. Grímnismál also claims that Yggdrasil has three roots; under one resides the goddess Hel, under another the frost-giants, and under the third humanity. Snorri also relates that Hel and the frost-giants live under two of the roots but places the gods, rather than humanity, under the third root. The term Yggr means "the terrifier" and is a synonym for Oðinn, while drasill was a poetic word for a horse; "Yggdrasil" thereby means "Oðinn's Steed". This idea of a cosmic tree has parallels with those from various other societies, and may reflect part of a common Indo-European heritage.
The Ragnarok story survives in its fullest exposition in Völuspá, although elements can also be seen in earlier poetry. The Ragnarok story suggests that the idea of an inescapable fate pervaded Norse world-views. There is much evidence that Völuspá was influenced by Christian belief, and it is also possible that the theme of conflict being followed by a better future—as reflected in the Ragnarok story—perhaps reflected the period of conflict between paganism and Christianity.
Norse religion had several fully developed ideas about death and the afterlife. Snorri refers to four realms which welcome the dead; although his descriptions reflect a likely Christian influence, the idea of multiple otherworlds is likely pre-Christian. Unlike Christianity, Old Norse religion does not appear to have adhered to the belief that moral concerns impacted an individual's afterlife destination.
Warriors who died in battle became the Einherjar and were taken to Oðinn's hall, Valhalla. There they waited until Ragnarok, when they would fight alongside the Æsir. According to the poem Grímnismál, Valhalla had 540 doors and that a wolf stood outside its western door, while an eagle flew overhead. In that poem, it is also claimed that a pig named Sæhrímnir is eaten every day and that a goat named Heiðrún stands atop the hall's roof producing an endless supply of mead. It is unclear how widespread a belief in Valhalla was in Norse society; it may have been a literary creation designed to meet the ruling class' aspirations, since the idea of deceased warriors owing military service to Oðinn parallels the social structure of which warriors and their lord. There is no archaeological evidence clearly alluding to a belief in Valhalla.
According to Snorri, while one half of the slain go to Valhalla, the other go to Frejya's hall, Fólkvangr, and that those who die from disease or old age go to a realm known as Hel; it was here that Baldr went after his death. The concept of Hel as an afterlife location never appears in pagan-era skaldic poetry, where "Hel" always references to the eponymous goddess. Snorri also mentions the possibility of the dead reaching the hall of Brimir in Gimlé, or the hall of Sindri in the Niðafjöll Mountains.
Various sagas and the Eddaic poem Helgakviða Hjörvarðssonar refer to the dead residing in their graves, where they remain conscious. In these thirteenth century sources, ghosts (Draugr) are capable of haunting the living. In both Laxdæla Saga and Eyrbyggja Saga, connections are drawn between pagan burials and hauntings.
In mythological accounts, the deity most closely associated with death is Oðinn. In particular, he is connected with death by hanging; this is apparent in Hávamál, a poem found in the Poetic Edda. In stanza 138 of Hávamál, Oðinn describes his "auto-sacrifice", in which he hangs himself on Yggdrasill, the world tree, for nine nights, in order to attain wisdom and magical powers. In the late Gautreks Saga, King Víkarr is hanged and then punctured by a spear; his executioner says "Now I give you to Oðinn".
Textual accounts suggest a spectrum of rituals, from large public events to more frequent private and family rites, which would have been interwoven with daily life. However, written sources are vague about Norse rituals, and many are invisible to us now even with the assistance of archaeology. Sources mention some rituals addressed to particular deities, but understanding of the relationship between Old Norse ritual and myth remains speculative.
The primary religious ritual in Norse religion appears to have been sacrifice, or blót. Many texts, both Old Norse and other, refer to sacrifices. The Saga of Hákon the Good in Heimskringla states that there were obligatory blóts, at which animals were slaughtered and their blood, called hlaut, sprinkled on the altars and the inside and outside walls of the temple, and ritual toasts were drunk during the ensuing sacrificial feast; the cups were passed over the fire and they and the food were consecrated with a ritual gesture by the chieftain; King Hákon, a Christian, was forced to participate but made the sign of the cross. The description of the temple at Uppsala in Adam of Bremen's History includes an account of a festival every nine years at which nine males of every kind of animal were sacrificed and the bodies hung in the temple grove. There may have been many methods of sacrifice: a number of textual accounts refer to the body or head of the slaughtered animal being hung on a pole or tree. In addition to seasonal festivals, an animal blót could take place, for example, before duels, after the conclusion of business between traders, before sailing to ensure favourable winds, and at funerals. Remains of animals from many species have been found in graves from the Old Norse period, and Ibn Fadlan's account of a ship burial includes the sacrifice of a dog, draft animals, cows, a rooster and a hen as well as that of a servant girl.
In the Eddic poem "Hyndluljóð", Freyja expresses appreciation for the many sacrifices of oxen made to her by her acolyte, Óttar. In Hrafnkels saga, Hrafnkell is called Freysgoði for his many sacrifices to Freyr. There may also be markers by which we can distinguish sacrifices to Odin, who was associated with hanging, and some texts particularly associate the ritual killing of a boar with sacrifices to Freyr; but in general, archaeology is unable to identify the deity to whom a sacrifice was made.
The texts frequently allude to human sacrifice. Temple wells in which people were sacrificially drowned are mentioned in Adam of Bremen's account of Uppsala and in Icelandic sagas, where they are called blótkelda or blótgrǫf, and Adam of Bremen also states that human victims were included among those hanging in the trees at Uppsala. In Gautreks saga, people sacrifice themselves during a famine by jumping off cliffs, and both the Historia Norwegiæ and Heimskringla refer to the willing death of King Dómaldi as a sacrifice after bad harvests. Mentions of people being "sentenced to sacrifice" and of the "wrath of the gods" against criminals suggest a sacral meaning for the death penalty; in Landnamabók the method of execution is given as having the back broken on a rock. It is possible that some of the bog bodies recovered from peat bogs in northern Germany and Denmark and dated to the Iron Age were human sacrifices. Such a practice may have been connected to the execution of criminals or of prisoners of war; on the other hand, some textual mentions of a person being "offered" to a deity, such as a king offering his son, may refer to a non-sacrificial "dedication".
Archaeological evidence supports Ibn Fadlan's report of funerary human sacrifice: in various cases, the burial of someone who died of natural causes is accompanied by another who died a violent death. For example, at Birka a decapitated young man was placed atop an older man buried with weapons, and at Gerdrup, near Roskilde, a woman was buried alongside a man whose neck had been broken. Many of the details of Ibn Fadlan's account are borne out by archaeology; and it is possible that those elements which are not visible in the archaeological evidence—such as the sexual encounters—are also accurate.
Deposition of artefacts in wetlands was a practice in Scandinavia during many periods of prehistory. In the early centuries of the Common Era, huge numbers of destroyed weapons were placed in wetlands: mostly spears and swords, but also shields, tools, and other equipment. Beginning in the 5th century, the nature of the wetland deposits changed; in Scandinavia, fibulae and bracteates were placed in or beside wetlands from the 5th to the mid-6th centuries, and again beginning in the late 8th century, when weapons as well as jewellery, coins and tools again began to be deposited, the practice lasting until the early 11th century. This practice extended to non-Scandinavian areas inhabited by Norse people; for example in Britain, a sword, tools, and the bones of cattle, horses and dogs were deposited under a jetty or bridge over the River Hull. The precise purposes of such depositions are unclear.
It is harder to find ritualised deposits on dry land. However, at Lunda (meaning "grove") near Strängnäs in Södermanland, archaeological evidence has been found at a hill of presumably ritual activity from the 2nd century BCE until the 10th century CE, including deposition of unburnt beads, knives and arrowheads from the 7th to the 9th century. Also during excavations at the church in Frösö, bones of bear, elk, red deer, pigs, cattle, and either sheep or goats were found surrounding a birch tree, having been deposited in the 9th or 10th century; the tree likely had sacrificial associations and perhaps represented the world tree.
Rites of passageEdit
A child was accepted into the family via a ritual of sprinkling with water (Old Norse ausa vatni) which is mentioned in two Eddic poems, "Rígsþula" and "Hávamál", and was afterwards given a name. The child was frequently named after a dead relative, since there was a traditional belief in rebirth, particularly in the family.
Old Norse sources also describe rituals for adoption (the Norwegian Gulaþing Law directs the adoptive father, followed by the adoptive child, then all other relatives, to step in turn into a specially made leather shoe) and blood brotherhood (a ritual standing on the bare earth under a specially cut strip of grass, called a jarðarmen).
Weddings occur in Icelandic family sagas. The Old Norse word brúðhlaup has cognates in many other Germanic languages and means "bride run"; it has been suggested that this indicates a tradition of bride-stealing, but other scholars including Jan de Vries interpreted it as indicating a rite of passage conveying the bride from her birth family to that of her new husband. The bride wore a linen veil or headdress; this is mentioned in the Eddic poem "Rígsþula". Freyr and Thor are each associated with weddings in some literary sources. In Adam of Bremen's account of the pagan temple at Uppsala, offerings are said to be made to Fricco (presumably Freyr) on the occasion of marriages, and in the Eddic poem "Þrymskviða", Thor recovers his hammer when it is laid in his disguised lap in a ritual consecration of the marriage. "Þrymskviða" also mentions the goddess Vár as consecrating marriages; Snorri Sturluson states in Gylfaginning that she hears the vows men and women make to each other, but her name probably means "beloved" rather than being etymologically connected to Old Norse várar, "vows".
Burial of the dead is the Norse rite of passage about which we have most archaeological evidence. There is considerable variation in burial practices, both spatially and chronologically, which suggests a lack of dogma about funerary rites. Both cremations and inhumations are found throughout Scandinavia, but in Viking Age Iceland there were inhumations but, with one possible exception, no cremations. The dead are found buried in pits, wooden coffins or chambers, boats, or stone cists; cremated remains have been found next to the funeral pyre, buried in a pit, in a pot or keg, and scattered across the ground. Most burials have been found in cemeteries, but solitary graves are not unknown. Some grave sites were left unmarked, others memorialised with standing stones or burial mounds.
Grave goods feature in both inhumation and cremation burials. These often consist of animal remains; for instance, in Icelandic pagan graves, the remains of dogs and horses are the most common grave goods. In many cases, the grave goods and other features of the grave reflect social stratification, particularly in the cemeteries at market towns such as Hedeby and Kaupang. In other cases, such as in Iceland, cemeteries show very little evidence of it.
Ship burial is a form of elite inhumation attested both in the archaeological record and in Ibn Fadlan's written account. Excavated examples include the Oseberg ship burial near Tønsberg in Norway, another at Klinta on Öland, and the Sutton Hoo ship burial in England. A boat burial at Kaupang in Norway contained a man, woman, and baby lying adjacent to each other alongside the remains of a horse and dismembered dog. The body of a second woman in the stern was decked out with weapons, jewellery, a bronze cauldron, and a metal staff; archaeologists have suggested that she may have been a sorceress. In certain areas of the Nordic world, namely coastal Norway and the Atlantic colonies, smaller boat burials are sufficiently common to indicate it was no longer only an elite custom.
Ship burial is also mentioned twice in the Old Norse literary-mythic corpus. A passage in Snorri Sturluson's Ynglinga Saga states that Odin—whom he presents as a human king later mistaken for a deity—instituted laws that the dead would be burned on a pyre with their possessions, and burial mounds or memorial stones erected for the most notable men. Also in his Prose Edda, the god Baldr is burned on a pyre on his ship, Hringhorni, which is launched out to sea with the aid of the giantess Hyrrokkin; Snorri wrote after the Christianisation of Iceland, but drew on Úlfr Uggason's skaldic poem "Húsdrápa".
Mysticism, magic and shamanismEdit
The myth preserved in the Eddic poem "Hávamál" of Odin hanging for nine nights on Yggdrasill, sacrificed to himself and dying in order to secure knowledge of the runes and other wisdom in what resembles an initiatory rite, is evidence of mysticism in Old Norse religion.
The gods were associated with two distinct forms of magic. In "Hávamál" and elsewhere, Odin is particularly associated with the runes and with galdr. Charms, often associated with the runes, were a central part of the treatment of disease in both humans and livestock in Old Norse society. In contrast seiðr and the related spæ, which could involve both magic and divination, were practised mostly by women, known as vǫlur and spæ-wives, often in a communal gathering at a client's request. 9th- and 10th-century female graves containing iron staffs and grave goods have been identified on this basis as those of seiðr practitioners. Seiðr was associated with the Vanic goddess Freyja; according to a euhemerized account in Ynglinga saga, she taught seiðr to the Æsir, but it involved so much ergi ("unmanliness, effeminacy") that other than Odin himself, its use was reserved to priestesses. There are, however, mentions of male seiðr workers, including elsewhere in Heimskringla, where they are condemned for their perversion.
In Old Norse literature, practitioners of seiðr are often described as foreigners, particularly Sami or Finns or in rarer cases from the British Isles. Practitioners such as Þorbjörg Lítilvölva in the Saga of Erik the Red appealed to spirit helpers for assistance. Many scholars have pointed to this and other similarities between what is reported of seiðr and spæ ceremonies and shamanism. The historian of religion Dag Strömbäck regarded it as a borrowing from Sami or Balto-Finnic shamanic traditions, but there are also differences from the recorded practices of Sami noaidi. Since the 19th century, some scholars have sought to interpret other aspects of Old Norse religion itself by comparison with shamanism; for example, Odin's self-sacrifice on the World Tree has been compared to Finno-Ugric shamanic practices. However, the scholar Jan de Vries regarded seiðr as an indigenous shamanic development among the Norse, and the applicability of shamanism as a framework for interpreting Old Norse practices, even seiðr, is disputed by some scholars.
Cult practices often took place outdoors. For example, at Hove in Trøndelag, Norway, offerings were placed at a row of posts bearing images of gods. Terms particularly associated with outdoor worship are vé (shrine) and hörgr (cairn or stone altar). Many place-names contain these elements in association with the name of a deity, and for example at Lilla Ullevi (compounded with the name of the god Ullr) in Bro parish, Uppland, Sweden, archaeologists have found a stone-covered ritual area at which offerings including silver objects, rings, and a meat fork had been deposited. Place-name evidence suggests that cultic practices might also take place at many different kinds of sites, including fields and meadows (vangr, vin), rivers and lakes, bogs, groves (lundr) and individual trees, and rocks.
Some Icelandic sagas mention sacred places. In both Landnámabók and Eyrbyggja saga, members of a family who particularly worshipped Thor are said to have passed after death into the mountain Helgafell (holy mountain), which was not to be defiled by bloodshed or excrement, or even to be looked at without washing first. Mountain worship is also mentioned in Landnámabók as an old Norwegian tradition to which Auðr the Deepminded's family reverted after she died; the scholar Hilda Ellis Davidson regarded it as associated particularly with the worship of Thor. In Víga-Glúms saga, the field Vitazgjafi (certain giver) is associated with Freyr and similarly not to be defiled. The scholar Stefan Brink has argued that one can speak of a "mythical and sacral geography" in pre-Christian Scandinavia.
Several of the sagas refer to cult houses or temples, generally called in Old Norse by the term hof. There are detailed descriptions of large temples, including a separate area with images of gods and the sprinkling of sacrificial blood using twigs in a manner similar to the Christian use of the aspergillum, in Kjalnesinga saga and Eyrbyggja saga; Snorri's description of blót in Heimskringla adds more details about the blood sprinkling. Adam of Bremen's 11th-century Latin history describes at length a great temple at Uppsala at which human sacrifices regularly took place, and containing statues of Thor, Wotan and Frikko (presumably Freyr; a scholion adds the detail that a golden chain hung from the eaves.
These details appear exaggerated and probably indebted to Christian churches, and in the case of Uppsala to the Biblical description of Solomon's temple. Based on the dearth of archaeological evidence for dedicated cult houses, particularly under early church buildings in Scandinavia, where they were expected to be found, and additionally on Tacitus' statement in Germania that the Germanic tribes did not confine their deities to buildings, many scholars have believed hofs to be largely a Christian idea of pre-Christian practice. In 1966, based on the results of a comprehensive archaeological survey of most of Scandinavia, the Danish archaeologist Olaf Olsen proposed the model of the "temple farm": that rather than the hof being a dedicated building, a large longhouse, especially that of the most prominent farmer in the district, served as the location for community cultic celebrations when required.
Since Olsen's survey, however, archaeological evidence of temple buildings has come to light in Scandinavia. Although Sune Lindqvist's interpretation of post holes which he found under the church at Gamla Uppsala as the remains of an almost square building with a high roof was wishful thinking, excavations nearby in the 1990s uncovered both a settlement and a long building which may have been either a longhouse used seasonally as a cult house or a dedicated hof. The building site at Hofstaðir, near Mývatn in Iceland, which was a particular focus of Olsen's work, has since been re-excavated and the layout of the building and further discoveries of the remains of ritually slaughtered animals now suggest that it was a cult house until ritually abandoned. Other buildings that have been interpreted as cult houses have been found at Borg in Östergötland, Lunda in Södermanland, and Uppakra in Scania, Remains of one pagan temple have so far been found under a medieval church, at Mære in Nord-Trøndelag, Norway.
In Norway, the word hof appears to have replaced older terms referring to outdoor cult sites during the Viking Age; it has been suggested that the use of cult buildings was introduced into Scandinavia starting in the 3rd century based on the Christian churches then proliferating in the Roman Empire, as part of a range of political and religious changes that Nordic society was then experiencing. Some of the cult houses which have been found are located within what archaeologists call "central places": settlements with various religious, political, judicial, and mercantile functions. A number of these central places have place-names with cultic associations, such as Gudme (home of gods), Vä (vé), and Helgö (holy island). Some archaeologists have argued that they were designed to mirror Old Norse cosmology, thus connecting ritual practices with wider world-views.
Priests and kingsEdit
There is no evidence of a professional priesthood among the Norse, and rather cultic activities were carried out by members of the community who also had other social functions and positions. In Old Norse society, religious authority was harnessed to secular authority; there was no separation between economic, political, and symbolic institutions. Both the Norwegian kings' sagas and Adam of Bremen's account claim that kings and chieftains played a prominent role in cultic sacrifices. In medieval Iceland, the goði was a social role that combined religious, political, and judicial functions, responsible for serving as a chieftain in the district, negotiating legal disputes, and maintaining order among his þingmenn. Most evidence suggests that public cultic activity was largely the preserve of high-status males in Old Norse society. However, there are exceptions. The Landnámabók refers to two women holding the position of gyðja, both of whom were members of local chiefly families. In Ibn Fadlan's account of the Rus, he describes an elder woman known as the "Angel of Death" who oversaw a funerary ritual.
Among scholars, there has been much debate as to whether sacral kingship was practiced among Old Norse communities, in which the monarch was endowed with a divine status and thus being responsible for ensuring that a community's needs were met through supernatural means. Evidence for this has been cited from the Ynglingatal poem in which the Swedes kill their king, Domalde, following a famine. However, interpretations of this event other than sacral kingship are possible; for instance, Domalde may have been killed in a political coup.
Iconography and imageryEdit
The most widespread religious symbol in Viking Age Old Norse religion was Mjöllnir, the hammer of Thor. This symbol first appears in the ninth century and may be a conscious response to the symbolism of the Christian cross. Although found across the Viking world, Mjöllnir pendants are most commonly found in graves from modern Denmark, south-eastern Sweden, and southern Norway; their wide distribution suggests the particular popularity of Thor. When found in inhumation graves, Mjöllnir pendants are more likely to be found in women's graves then men's. Earlier examples were made from iron, bronze, or amber, although silver pendants became fashionable in the tenth century. This may have been a response to the growing popularity of Christian cross amulets.
The two religious symbols may have co-existed closely; one piece of archaeological evidence suggesting that this is the case is a soapstone mould for casting pendants discovered from Trengården in Denmark. This mould had space for a Mjöllnir and a crucifix pendant side by side, suggesting that the artisan who produced these pendants catered for both religious communities. These have typically been interpreted as a protective symbol, although may also have had associations with fertility, being worn as amulets, good-luck charms, or sources of protection. However, around 10 percent of those discovered during excavation had been placed on top of cremation urns, suggesting that they had a place in certain funerary rituals.
Gods and goddesses were depicted through figurines, pendants, fibulas, and as images on weapons. Thor is usually recognised in depictions by his carrying of Mjöllnir. Iconographic material suggesting other deities are less common that those connected to Thor. Some pictorial evidence, most notably that of the picture stones, intersect with the mythologies recorded in later texts. These picture stones, produced in mainland Scandinavia during the Viking Age, are the earliest known visual depictions of Norse mythological scenes. It is nevertheless unclear what function these picture-stones had or what they meant to the communities who produced them.
Oðinn has been identified on various gold bracteates produced from the fifth and sixth centuries. Some figurines have been interpreted as depictions of deities. The Lindby image from Skåne, Sweden is often interpreted as Oðinn because of its missing eye;  the bronze figurine from Eyrarland in Iceland as Thor because it holds a hammer. A bronze figurine from Rällinge in Södermanland has been attributed to Freyr because it has a big phallus, and a silver pendant from Aska in Östergötland has been seen as Freya because it wears a necklace that could be Brisingamen.
Another image that recurs in Norse artwork from this period is the valknut (the term is modern, not Old Norse). These symbols may have a specific association with Oðinn, because they often accompany images of warriors on picture stones.
Romanticism, aesthetics, and politicsEdit
During the romanticist movement of the nineteenth century, various northern Europeans took an increasing interest in Old Norse religion, seeing in it an ancient pre-Christian mythology that provided an alternative to the dominant Classical mythology. As a result, artists featured Norse gods and goddesses in their paintings and sculptures, and their names were applied to streets, squares, journals, and companies throughout parts of northern Europe.
The mythological stories derived from Old Norse and other Germanic sources provided inspiration for various artists, including Richard Wagner, who used these narratives as the basis for his Der Ring des Nibelungen. Also inspired by these Old Norse and Germanic tales was J. R. R. Tolkien, who used them in creating his legendarium, the fictional universe in which he set novels like The Lord of the Rings. During the 1930s and 1940s, elements of Old Norse and other Germanic religions were adopted by Nazi Germany. Since the fall of the Nazis, various right-wing groups continue to use elements of Old Norse and Germanic religion in their symbols, names, and references; some Neo-Nazi groups, for instance, use Mjöllnir as a symbol.
Theories about a shamanic component of Old Norse religion have been adopted by forms of Nordic neoshamanism; groups practicing what they called seiðr were established in Europe and the United States by the 1990s.
Research into Old Norse religion has been interdisciplinary, involving historians, archaeologists, philologists, place-name scholars, literary scholars, and historians of religion. Scholars from different disciplines have tended to take different approaches to the material; for instance, many literary scholars have been highly sceptical about how accurately Old Norse text portrays pre-Christian religion, whereas historians of religion have tended to regard these portrayals as highly accurate.
Interest in Norse mythology was revived in the eighteenth century, and scholars turned their attention to it in the early nineteenth century. Since this research appeared from the background of European romanticism, many of the scholars operating in the nineteenth and twentieth century framed their approach through nationalism, and were strongly influenced in their interpretations by romantic notions about nationhood, conquest, and religion. Their understandings of cultural interaction was also coloured by nineteenth-century European colonialism and imperialism. Many regarded pre-Christian religion as singular and unchanging, directly equated religion with nation, and projected modern national borders onto the Viking Age past.
Due to the use of Old Norse and Germanic iconography by the Nazis, academic research into Old Norse religion reduced heavily following the Second World War. Scholarly interest in the subject then revived in the late 20th century. By the 21st century, Old Norse religion was regarded as one of the best known non-Christian religions from Europe, alongside that of Greece and Rome.
- Andrén 2011, p. 846; Andrén 2014, p. 14.
- Nordland 1969, p. 66; Turville-Petre 1975, p. 3; Näsström 1999, p. 12; Näsström 2003, p. 1; Hedeager 2011, p. 104; Jennbert 2011, p. 12.
- Andrén 2005, p. 106; Andrén, Jennbert & Raudvere 2006, p. 12.
- Turville-Petre 1975, p. 1; Steinsland 1986, p. 212.
- Abram 2011, p. 16.
- DuBois 1999, p. 8.
- DuBois 1999, p. 52; Jesch 2004, p. 55; O'Donoghue 2008, p. 8.
- Simpson 1967, p. 190.
- Clunies Ross 1994, p. 41; Hultgård 2008, p. 212.
- Andrén 2011, p. 856.
- Davidson 1990, p. 14.
- Andrén 2011, p. 846.
- Hultgård 2008, p. 212.
- DuBois 1999, p. 42.
- Andrén, Jennbert & Raudvere 2006, p. 12.
- Andrén, Jennbert & Raudvere 2006, p. 12; Andrén 2011, p. 853.
- Abram 2011, p. 105.
- DuBois 1999, p. 41; Brink 2001, p. 88.
- Davidson 1990, p. 14: DuBois 1999, pp. 44, 206; Andrén, Jennbert & Raudvere 2006, p. 13.
- Andrén 2014, p. 16.
- Andrén, Jennbert & Raudvere 2006, p. 13.
- Bek-Pedersen 2011, p. 10.
- Davidson 1990, p. 16.
- DuBois 1999, p. 18.
- DuBois 1999, p. 7.
- DuBois 1999, p. 10.
- DuBois 1999, p. 22.
- Andrén, Jennbert & Raudvere 2006, p. 14.
- Davidson, Lost Beliefs, pp. 1, 18.
- Abram, p. 9.
- Turville-Petre, pp. 82–83.
- Turville-Petre, p. 11.
- Ursula Dronke, ed. and trans., The Poetic Edda, Volume 3: Mythological Poems II, Oxford: Oxford University, 2011, ISBN 978-0-19-811182-5, p. 63, note to "Hávamál", Verse 144.
- Näsström, "Fragments", p. 12.
- Abram, p. 10.
- Davidson, Gods and Myths, p. 15.
- Turville Petre, p. 13.
- Turville-Petre, pp. 22–23.
- Turville-Petre, p. 24.
- Abram, p. 27.
- Davidson, "Human Sacrifice", p. 337.
- Abram, p. 28.
- Abram, pp. 28–29.
- Andrén, Religion, p. 846; Cosmology, p. 14.
- Turville-Petre, p. 8.
- Abram, pp. 2, 4.
- Andrén, "Behind 'Heathendom'", p. 106.
- Andrén, Jennbert and Raudvere, p. 13.
- Turville-Petre, pp. 2–3.
- Abram, p. 61.
- De Vries, Volume 1, p. 46.
- Abram, p. 60.
- De Vries, Volume 1, p. 60.
- DuBois, p. 5.
- Abram 2011, pp. 53, 79.
- Turville-Petre 1975, p. 6.
- Lindow 2002, p. 3.
- Abram 2011, p. 54.
- Turville-Petre 1975, p. 7.
- Abram 2011, p. 58.
- Abram 2011, pp. 54–55.
- DuBois 1999, pp. 20–21.
- Cusack 1998, p. 160; Abram 2011, p. 108.
- Abram 2011, p. 108.
- Sundqvist, An Arena for Higher Powers, pp. 87–88.
- O'Donoghue 2008, pp. 60–61; Abram 2011, p. 108.
- Cusack 1998, p. 161; O'Donoghue 2008, p. 64.
- Abram 2011, p. 182.
- Cusack 1998, p. 161; O'Donoghue 2008, p. 4; Abram 2011, p. 182.
- Jolly 1996, p. 36; Pluskowski 2011, p. 774.
- Jesch 2011, pp. 19–20.
- Gelling 1961, p. 13; Meaney 1970, p. 120; Jesch 2011, p. 15.
- Meaney 1970, p. 120.
- Jolly 1996, p. 36.
- DuBois 1999, p. 154.
- Cusack 1998, p. 151.
- Jolly 1996, pp. 41–43; Jesch 2004, p. 56.
- Pluskowski 2011, p. 774.
- Cusack 1998, pp. 119–27; DuBois 1999, p. 154.
- Cusack 1998, p. 135.
- Cusack 1998, pp. 135–36.
- Cusack 1998, p. 140.
- Abram 2011, pp. 99–100.
- Abram 2011, pp. 123–24.
- Abram 2011, pp. 128–30.
- Abram 2011, p. 141.
- Davidson 1990, p. 12; Cusack 1998, pp. 146–47; Abram 2011, pp. 172–74.
- Lindow 2002, pp. 7, 9.
- Cusack 1998, p. 163; Abram 2011, p. 187.
- Abram 2011, p. 188.
- Cusack 1998, pp. 164–68; Abram 2011, pp. 189–90.
- Cusack 1998, p. 176.
- Cusack 1998, p. 145; Abram 2011, p. 176.
- Davidson 1990, pp. 219–20; Abram 2011, p. 156.
- Abram 2011, p. 171; Andrén 2011, p. 856.
- Cusack 1998, p. 168.
- Cusack 1998, p. 179.
- Davidson 1990, p. 23.
- Abram 2011, p. 193.
- Abram 2011, p. 178.
- Abram 2011, pp. 201, 208.
- Abram 2011, p. 191.
- Jesch 2004, p. 57.
- Jesch 2004, pp. 57–59.
- Abram 2011, p. 207.
- Abram 2011, pp. 208, 219.
- O'Donoghue 2008, p. 6.
- Abram, p. 81.
- In addition to the verses cited in the Prose Edda, which are for the most part close to one of the two. Dronke, The Poetic Edda, Volume 2: Mythological Poems, Oxford: Oxford University, 1997, repr. 2001, ISBN 978-0-19-811181-8, pp. 61–62, 68–79.
- Turville-Petre, pp. 24–25; p. 79 regarding his changes to the story in "Þórsdrápa" of Thor's journey to the home of the giant Geirrǫðr.
- O'Donoghue, p. 19.
- Abram, p. 207.
- O'Donoghue, p. 8.
- Abram, p. 171.
- Abram, pp. 79, 228.
- O'Donoghue, pp. 23–24.
- O'Donoghue, p. 67.
- Abram, p. 151.
- De Vries, volume 1, p. 265.
- Abram, pp. 62–63.
- DuBois, p. 59.
- Davidson, Gods and Myths, p. 219.
- Sundqvist, An Arena for Higher Powers, pp. 87–90.
- O'Donoghue p. 27.
- Nordland, p. 67.
- Turville-Petre, pp. 161–62.
- Näsström, "Fragments", p. 180.
- DuBois, p. 56.
- De Vries, Volume 2, p. 150.
- Skáldskaparmál, ch. 14, 15, 29; Edda Snorra Sturlusonar: udgivet efter handskrifterne, ed. Finnur Jónsson, Copenhagen: Gyldendal, 1931, pp. 97–98, 110.
- Anna Birgitta Rooth, Loki in Scandinavian Mythology, Acta Regiae Societatis humaniorum litterarum Lundensis 61, Lund: Gleerup, 1961, OCLC 902409942, pp. 162–65.
- Lotte Motz, "Sister in the Cave; the stature and the function of the female figures of the Eddas", Arkiv för nordisk filologi 95 (1980) 168–82.
- DuBois, p. 46.
- DuBois, p. 47
- Jónas Gíslason "Acceptance of Christianity in Iceland in the Year 1000 (999)", in: Old Norse and Finnish Religions and Cultic Place-Names, ed. Tore Ahlbäck, Turku: Donner Institute for Research in Religious and Cultural History, 1991, OCLC 474369969, pp. 223–55.
- Simek, "Þorgerðr Hǫlgabrúðr", pp. 326–27.
- De Vries, Volume 2, p. 284.
- Turville-Petre, pp. 256–57.
- Lindow, "Norns", pp. 244–45.
- De Vries, p. 272.
- Dubois, p. 50
- Davidson, Gods and Myths, p. 214.
- Turville-Petre, p. 221.
- Davidson, Gods and Myths, p. 61.
- De Vries, Volume 1, pp. 273–74.
- Simek, "Giants", p. 107.
- Motz, "Giants in Folklore and Mythology: A New Approach", Folklore (1982) 70–84, p. 70.
- O'Donoghue, p. 232.
- Steinsland, pp. 212–13.
- Motz, "Giants", p. 72.
- O'Donoghue 2008, p. 116.
- O'Donoghue 2008, p. 16.
- O'Donoghue 2008, p. 13.
- O'Donoghue 2008, p. 14.
- O'Donoghue 2008, pp. 114–15.
- O'Donoghue 2008, p. 15.
- O'Donoghue 2008, pp. 17–18.
- O'Donoghue 2008, p. 18.
- O'Donoghue 2008, p. 17.
- Hultgård 2008, p. 215.
- Abram 2011, pp. 157–58.
- Abram 2011, p. 163.
- Abram 2011, p. 165.
- Abram 2011, p. 164.
- Abram 2011, p. 4.
- DuBois 1999, p. 79.
- DuBois 1999, p. 81.
- Abram 2011, p. 212.
- DuBois 1999, p. 89.
- Abram 2011, p. 107.
- Abram 2011, pp. 105–06.
- Abram 2011, p. 78.
- DuBois 1999, p. 79Abram 2011, p. 116
- Abram 2011, p. 119.
- Abram 2011, p. 80.
- DuBois 1999, p. 77.
- DuBois 1999, p. 85.
- DuBois 1999, pp. 87–88.
- Abram 2011, p. 75.
- Abram 2011, p. 76.
- Andrén, "Old Norse and Germanic Religion", pp. 848–49.
- Andrén, "Behind 'Heathendom'", p. 108.
- Jacqueline Simpson, "Some Scandinavian Sacrifices", Folklore 78.3 (1967) 190–202, p. 190.
- Andrén, "Old Norse and Germanic Religion", pp. 853, 855.
- Clunies Ross, p. 13.
- Abram, p. 70.
- Turville-Petre, p. 251.
- Turville-Petre, p. 244.
- Simpson, p. 193.
- Magnell, p. 195.
- Magnell, p. 196.
- Davidson, "Human Sacrifice".
- Turville-Petre, p. 273.
- Turville-Petre, p. 239.
- "Hrafnkel's Saga", tr. Hermann Pálsson, in Hrafnkel's Saga and Other Icelandic Stories, Harmondsworth, Middlesex: Penguin, 1985, ISBN 9780140442380, ch. 1: "He loved Frey above all the other gods and gave him a half-share in all his best treasures. ... He became their priest and chieftain, so he was given the nickname Frey's-Priest."
- Abram, p. 71.
- Turville-Petre, p. 255.
- Turville-Petre, pp. 245–46
- Kjalnesinga saga, Vatnsdæla saga; De Vries Volume 1, p. 410, Turville-Petre, p. 254.
- Davidson, "Human Sacrifice", p. 337.
- Turville-Petre, p. 254.
- Turville-Petre, p. 253.
- De Vries, Volume 1, p. 414.
- Davidson, "Human Sacrifice", p. 333.
- Andrén, "Old Norse and Germanic Religion", p. 849.
- De Vries, Volume 1, p. 415.
- Davidson, "Human Sacrifice", p. 334.
- Abram, p. 72.
- Ellis Davidson, "Human Sacrifice", p. 336.
- Abram, p. 73.
- Brink, p. 96.
- Andrén, "Behind 'Heathendom'", pp. 108–09.
- Andrén, "Old Norse and Germanic Religion", p. 853.
- Julie Lund, (2010). "At the Water's Edge", in Martin Carver, Alex Sanmark, and Sarah Semple, eds., Signals of Belief in Early England: Anglo-Saxon Paganism Revisited, ISBN 978-1-84217-395-4, Oxford: Oxbow, pp. 49–66. p. 51.
- Hutton, p. 328.
- Andrén, "Behind "Heathendom'", p. 110.
- Andrén, "Old Norse and Germanic Religion", pp. 853–54.
- De Vries, Volume 1, pp. 178–80. Before the water rite, a child could be rejected; infanticide was still permitted under the earliest Christian laws of Norway, p. 179.
- De Vries, Volume 1, pp. 181–83.
- De Vries, Volume 1, pp. 184, 208, 294–95; De Vries suggests the jarðarmen ritual is a symbolic death and rebirth.
- De Vries, Volume 1, pp. 185–86. Brúðkaup, "bride-purchase", also occurs in Old Norse, but according to de Vries probably refers to the bride price and hence to gift-giving rather than "purchase" in the modern sense.
- gekk hón und líni; De Vries, Volume 1, p. 187.
- De Vries, Volume 1, p. 187.
- Turville-Petre, p. 81.
- Margaret Clunies Ross, "Reading Þrymskviða", in The Poetic Edda: Essays on Old Norse Mythology, ed. Paul Acker and Carolyne Larrington, Routledge medieval casebooks, New York / London: Routledge, 2002, ISBN 9780815316602, pp. 177–94, p. 181.
- De Vries, Volume 2, p. 327.
- Andrén, "Old Norse and Germanic Religion", p. 855.
- DuBois, p. 71.
- Rúnar Leifsson, (2012). "Evolving Traditions: Horse Slaughter as Part of Viking Burial Customs in Iceland", in The Ritual Killing and Burial of Animals: European Perspectives, ed. Aleksander Pluskowski, Oxford: Oxbow, 2012, ISBN 978-1-84217-444-9, pp. 184–94, p. 185.
- DuBois, p. 72.
- Rúnar Leifsson, p. 184.
- Abram, p. 74.
- DuBois, p. 73.
- DuBois, p. 80.
- Abram, pp. 74–75.
- Gylfaginning, ch. 48; Simek, "Hringhorni", pp. 159–60; "Hyrrokkin", p. 170.
- Davidson, Gods and Myths, pp. 143–44.
- Simek, "Odin's (self-)sacrifice", p. 249.
- Turville-Petre, pp. 11, 48–50.
- Simek, "Runes", p. 269: "Odin is the god of runic knowledge and of runic magic."
- Turville-Petre, pp. 64–65.
- DuBois, p. 104.
- DuBois, p. 123.
- Andrén, "Old Norse and Germanic Religion", p. 855.
- Davidson, Gods and Myths, p. 117.
- Turville-Petre, p. 65.
- DuBois, p. 136.
- De Vries, Volume 1, p. 332.
- Davidson, Gods and Myths, p. 121.
- DuBois, p. 128.
- Davidson, "Gods and Myths", p. 119.
- DuBois, p. 129.
- Schnurbein, pp. 117–18.
- DuBois, p. 130.
- Schnurbein, p. 117.
- Turville-Petre, p. 50.
- Schnurbein, p. 119.
- De Vries, Volume 1, pp. 330–33.
- Schnurbein, p. 123.
- Berend, Nora (2007). Christianization and the Rise of Christian Monarchy: Scandinavia, Central Europe and Rus' c. 900–1200. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. p. 124. ISBN 978-0-521-87616-2.
- Sundqvist, An Arena for Higher Powers, pp. 131, 394.
- Turville-Petre, pp. 237–38.
- DuBois, p. 76.
- Brink, p. 100.
- Ellis, Road to Hel, p. 90.
- Turville-Petre, pp. 69, 165–66.
- Ellis Davidson, Gods and Myths, pp. 101–02.
- Brink, p. 77.
- De Vries, Volume 1, pp. 382, 389, 409–10.
- Turville-Petre, pp. 244–45.
- Simek, "Uppsala temple", pp. 341–42.
- Abram, p. 69.
- Olsen, English summary p. 285: "[I] suggest that the building of the pagan hof in Iceland was in fact identical with the veizluskáli [feasthall] of the large farm: a building in everyday use which on special occasions became the setting for the ritual gatherings of a large number of people."
- Davidson, Myths and Symbols in Pagan Europe, p. 32: "the hall of a farmhouse used for communal religious feasts, perhaps that of the goði or leading man of the district who would preside over such gatherings."
- Olsen, pp. 127–42, English summary pp. 282–83.
- Richard Bradley, Ritual and Domestic Life in Prehistoric Europe, London/New York: Routledge, 2005, ISBN 0-415-34550-2, pp. 43–44, citing Neil S. Price, The Viking Way: Religion and War in Late Iron Age Scandinavia, Doctoral thesis, Aun 31, Uppsala: Department of Archaeology and Ancient History, 2002, ISBN 9789150616262, p. 61.
- Lucas, Gavin; McGovern, Thomas (2007). "Bloody Slaughter: Ritual Decapitation and Display at the Viking Settlement of Hofstaðir, Iceland". European Journal of Archaeology. 10 (1): 7–30. doi:10.1177/1461957108091480.
- Andrén, "Old Norse and Germanic Religion", p. 854.
- Magnell, p. 199.
- Davidson, Myths and Symbols in Pagan Europe, pp. 31–32.
- Turville-Petre, p. 243.
- Hedeager, "Scandinavian 'Central Places'", p. 7.
- Hedeager, "Scandinavian 'Central Places'", pp. 5, 11–12.
- Hultgård 2008, p. 217.
- Hedeager 2002, p. 5 Abram 2011, p. 100.
- DuBois 1999, p. 66.
- DuBois 1999, p. 66; Abram 2011, p. 74.
- Abram 2011, p. 74.
- Abram 2011, p. 92 Price & Mortimer 2014, pp. 517–18.
- Abram 2011, p. 92.
- Abram 2011, p. 65.
- Abram 2011, p. 5.
- Abram 2011, p. 66.
- DuBois 1999, p. 159; Abram 2011, p. 66.
- DuBois 1999, p. 159; O'Donoghue 2008, p. 60; Abram 2011, p. 66.
- Abram 2011, pp. 5, 65–66.
- Andrén 2011, p. 851.
- Abram 2011, p. 9.
- Abram 2011, p. 7.
- Abram 2011, p. 6.
- Abram 2011, p. 77.
- Davidson 1990, p. 147; Abram 2011, pp. 77–78.
- Andrén 2011, p. 847.
- Staecker 1999, p. 89.
- Schnurbein 2003, pp. 133–34.
- Näsström 1999, pp. 177–79.
- Davidson 1990, p. 17.
- DuBois 1999, p. 11; Andrén 2011, p. 846.
- DuBois 1999, p. 11.
- Andrén 2005, p. 105.
- Abram, Christopher (2011). Myths of the Pagan North: The Gods of the Norsemen. New York and London: Continuum. ISBN 978-1847252470.
- Andrén, Anders (2005). "Behind "Heathendom": Archaeological Studies of Old Norse Religion". Scottish Archaeological Journal. 27 (2): 105–38. JSTOR 27917543.
- Andrén, Anders (2011). "Old Norse and Germanic Religion". In Timothy Insoll (ed.). The Oxford Handbook of the Archaeology of Ritual and Religion. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. pp. 846–62. ISBN 978-0-19-923244-4.
- Andrén, Anders (2014). Tracing Old Norse Cosmology: The World Tree, Middle Earth, and the Sun in Archaeological Perspectives. Lund: Nordic Academic Press. ISBN 978-91-85509-38-6.
- Andrén, Anders; Jennbert, Kristina; Raudvere, Catharina (2006). "Old Norse Religion: Some Problems and Prospects". In Anders Andrén, Kristina Jennbert, and Catharina Raudvere. Old Norse Religion in Long-Term Perspectives. Lund: Nordic Academic Press. pp. 11–14. ISBN 978-9189116818.
- Bek-Pedersen, Karen (2011). The Norns in Old Norse Mythology. Edinburgh: Dunedin Academic Press. ISBN 978-1-906716-18-9.
- Brink, Stefan (2001). "Mythologizing Landscape: Place and Space of Cult and Myth". In Michael Stausberg (ed.). Kontinuitäten und Bruche in der Religionsgeschichte. Berlin: De Gruyter. pp. 76–112. ISBN 9783110172645.
- Clunies Ross, Margaret (1994). Prolonged Echoes: Old Norse Myths in Medieval Northern Society: Volume 1: The Myths. Odense: Odense University Press. ISBN 978-8778380081.
- Cusack, Carole M. (1998). Conversion Among the Germanic Peoples. London and New York: Cassell. ISBN 978-0304701551.
- Davidson, H. R. Ellis (1990) . Gods and Myths of Northern Europe. London: Penguin. ISBN 978-0-14-013627-2.
- Davidson, Hilda Roderick Ellis (1988). Myths and Symbols in Pagan Europe: Early Scandinavian and Celtic Religions. Manchester: Manchester University Press. ISBN 9780719022074.
- Davidson, Hilda Ellis (1992). "Human Sacrifice in the Late Pagan Period in North Western Europe". In Martin Carver (ed.). The Age of Sutton Hoo: The Seventh Century in North-Western Europe. Woodbridge: Boydell Press. pp. 331–40. ISBN 9780851153308.
- Davidson, H. R. Ellis (1993). The Lost Beliefs of Northern Europe. London and New York: Routledge. ISBN 9780415049375.
- De Vries, Jan (1970) [1956, 1957]. Altgermanische Religionsgeschichte (2 vols.). Grundriss der germanischen Philologie 12 (3rd, reprint of 2nd, ed.). Berlin: De Gruyter. OCLC 799742942.
- DuBois, Thomas A. (1999). Nordic Religions in the Viking Age. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press. ISBN 9780812217148.
- Ellis, Hilda Roderick (1943). The Road to Hel: A Study of the Conception of the Dead in the Old Norse Literature. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. OCLC 1001026528.
- Gelling, Margaret (1961). "Place-Names and Anglo-Saxon Paganism". University of Birmingham Historical Journal. 8: 7–25.
- Hedeager, Lotte (2002). "Scandinavian 'Central Places' in a Cosmological Setting". In Birgitta Hårdh and Lars Larsson (eds.). Central Places in the Migration and the Merovingian Periods. Lund: Acta Archaeologica Lundensia. pp. 3–18.
- Hedeager, Lotte (2011). Iron Age Myth and Materiality: An Archaeology of Scandinavia AD 400–1000. London and New York: Routledge. ISBN 9781136817250.
- Hultgård, Anders (2008). "The Religion of the Vikings". In Stefan Brink and Neil Price (eds.). The Viking World. London and New York: Routledge. pp. 212–18. ISBN 9781134318261.
- Hutton, Ronald (2013). Pagan Britain. New Haven and London: Yale University Press. ISBN 978-0-300-197716.
- Jennbert, Kristina (2011). Animals and Humans: Recurrent Symbiosis in Archaeology and Old Norse Religion. Nordic Academic Press. ISBN 978-9185509379.
- Jesch, Judith (2004). "Scandinavians and 'Cultural Paganism' in Late Anglo-Saxon England". In Paul Cavill (ed.). The Christian Tradition in Anglo-Saxon England: Approaches to Current Scholarship and Teaching. Cambridge: D. S. Brewer. pp. 55–68. ISBN 978-0859918411.
- Jesch, Judith (2011). "The Norse Gods in England and the Isle of Man". In Daniel Anlezark (ed.). Myths, Legends, and Heroes: Essays on Old Norse and Old English Literature. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. pp. 11–24. ISBN 978-0802099471.
- Jolly, Karen Louise (1996). Popular Religion in Late Saxon England: Elf Charms in Context. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press. ISBN 978-0807845653.
- Leifsson, Rùnar (2012). "Evolving Traditions: Horse Slaughter as Part of Viking Burial Customs in Iceland". In Aleksander Pluskowski (ed.). The Ritual Killing and Burial of Animals: European Perspectives. Oxford and Oakville: Oxbow Books. pp. 184–94. ISBN 978-1-84217-444-9.
- Lindow, John (2002). Norse Mythology: A Guide to Gods, Heroes, Rituals, and Beliefs. New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780199839698.
- Lindow, John (2006). "Narrative Worlds, Human Environments, and Poets". In Anders Andrén, Kristina Jennbert, and Catharina Raudvere (eds.). Old Norse Religion in Long-Term Perspectives. Lund: Nordic Academic Press. pp. 21–25. ISBN 978-9189116818.
- Lund, Julie (2010). "At the Water's Edge". In Martin Carver, Alex Sanmark, and Sarah Semple (eds.). Signals of Belief in Early England: Anglo-Saxon Paganism Revisited. Oxford and Oakville: Oxbow Books. pp. 49–66. ISBN 978-1-84217-395-4.
- Magnell, Ola (2012). "Sacred Cows or Old Beasts? A Taphonomic Approach to Studying Ritual Killing with an Example from Iron Age Uppåkra, Sweden". In Aleksander Pluskowski (ed.). The Ritual Killing and Burial of Animals: European Perspectives. Oxford and Oakville: Oxbow Books. pp. 195–207. ISBN 978-1-84217-444-9.
- Meaney, Audrey (1970). "Æthelweard, Ælfric, the Norse Gods and Northumbria". Journal of Religious History. 6 (2): 105–32. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9809.1970.tb00557.x.
- Motz, Lotte (1982). "Giants in Folklore and Mythology: A New Approach". Folklore. 93 (1): 70–84. JSTOR 1260141.
- Näsström, Britt-Mari (1999). "Fragments of the Past: How to Study Old Norse Religion". Scripta Instituti Donneriani Aboensis. 17 (2): 177–85.
- Näsström, Britt-Mari (2003) . Freya: The Great Goddess of the North. Harwich Port: Clock and Rose Press. ISBN 978-1-593-86019-6.
- Nordland, Odd (1969). "Valhall and Helgafell: Syncretistic Traits of the Old Norse Religion". Scripta Instituti Donneriani Aboensis. 3: 66–99.
- O'Donoghue, Heather (2008). From Asgard to Valhalla: The Remarkable History of the Norse Myths. London and New York: I. B. Tauris. ISBN 978-1845113575.
- Olsen, Olaf (1966). Hørg, Hov og Kirke: Historiske og Arkæologiske Vikingetidsstudier. Copenhagen: Gad. OCLC 6819543.
- Pluskowski, Aleks (2011). "The Archaeology of Paganism". In Helena Hamerow, David A. Hinton, and Sally Crawford (eds.). The Oxford Handbook of Anglo-Saxon Archaeology. Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp. 764–78. ISBN 978-0199212149.
- Price, Neil; Mortimer, Paul (2014). "An Eye for Odin? Divine Role-Playing in the Age of Sutton Hoo". European Journal of Archaeology. 17 (3). pp. 517–38.
- Rooth, Anna Birgitta (1961). Loki in Scandinavian Mythology. Lund: C. W. K. Gleerup.
- Schnurbein, Stefanie von (2003). "Shamanism in the Old Norse Tradition: A Theory between Ideological Camps". History of Religions. 43 (2). pp. 116–38. doi:10.1086/423007.
- Simek, Rudolf (2008). Dictionary of Northern Mythology (new ed.). Boydell & Brewer. ISBN 978-0859915137.
- Simpson, Jacqueline (1967). "Some Scandinavian Sacrifices". Folklore. 78 (3). pp. 190–202.
- Staecker, Jörn (1999). "Thor's Hammer: Symbol of Christianization and Political Delusion". Lund Archaeological Review. 5. pp. 89–104.
- Steinsland, Gro (1986). "Giants as Recipients of Cult in the Viking Age?". In Gro Steinsland (ed.). Words and Objects: Towards a Dialogue between Archaeology and History of Religion. Oslo: Norwegian University Press. pp. 212–22. ISBN 9788200077510.
- Sundqvist, Olof (2016). An Arena for Higher Powers: Ceremonial Buildings and Religious Strategies for Rulership in Late Iron Age Scandinavia. Studies in the History of Religions. 150. Leiden/Boston: Brill. ISBN 9789004292703.
- Turville-Petre, E. O. G. (1975) . Myth and Religion of the North: The Religion of Ancient Scandinavia. Westport: Greenwood Press.
- Price, Neil (2002). The Viking Way: Religion and War in Late Iron Age Scandinavia. Uppsala: Department of Archaeology and Ancient History, Uppsala University. ISBN 91-506-1626-9.
- Price, Neil (2010). "Passing into Poetry: Viking-Age Mortuary Drama and the Origins of Norse Mythology". Medieval Archaeology. 54 (1): 123–56. doi:10.1179/174581710X12790370815779.
- Price, Neil (2014). "Nine Paces from Hel: Time and Motion in Old Norse Ritual Performance". World Archaeology. 46 (2): 178–91. doi:10.1080/00438243.2014.883938.
- Staecker, J. (1999). "Thor's Hammer: Symbol of Christianization and Political Delusion". Lund Archaeological Review: 89–104.
- Sundqvist, O. (2002). Freyr's Offspring: Rulers and Religion in Ancient Svea Society. Uppsala: Acta Universitatis Uppsaliensis.
- Sundqvist, O. (2012). "'Religious Ruler Ideology' in Pre-Christian Scandinavia: A Contextual Approach". In C. Raudevere and J. P. Schjødt. More Than Mythology: Narratives, Ritual Practices and Regional Distribution in Pre-Christian Scandinavian Religion. Lund: Nordic Academic Press. pp. 225–61.
- The Norse Gods, BBC Radio 4 discussion with Carolyne Larrington, Heather O'Donoghue & John Hines (In Our Time, Mar. 11, 2004)