Private browsing is a privacy feature in some web browsers. When operating in such a mode, the browser creates a temporary session that is isolated from the browser's main session and user data. Browsing history is not saved, and local data associated with the session, such as cookies, are cleared when the session is closed.
These modes are designed primarily to prevent data and history associated with a particular browsing session from persisting on the device, or being discovered by another user of the same device. Private browsing modes do not necessarily protect users from being tracked by other websites or their internet service provider (ISP). Furthermore, there is a possibility that identifiable traces of activity could be leaked from private browsing sessions by means of the operating system, security flaws in the browser, or via malicious browser extensions, and it has been found that certain HTML5 APIs can be used to detect the presence of private browsing modes due to differences in behaviour.
Apple's Safari browser was one of the first major web browsers to include this feature. The feature has since been adopted in other browsers, and led to popularization of the term in 2008 by mainstream news outlets and computing websites when discussing beta versions of Internet Explorer 8. Adobe Flash Player 10.1 began honoring browser settings and private browsing status in regards to the storage of local shared objects.
Noted uses of private browsing modes include hiding undesirable content from the browsing history (such as visits to adult-oriented websites, or more benign scenarios such as concealing online shopping for surprise gifts), performing web searches that are not algorithmically influenced by prior browsing habits or the user's recorded interests, providing a "clean" temporary session for a guest user (such as when using a public computer), and using websites with multiple accounts simultaneously. Private browsing has also been used as a means to circumvent metered paywalls on some websites. In a survey by search engine DuckDuckGo, 48% of participants declined to respond (leading researcher Elie Bursztein to note that "surveys are clearly not the best approach to understand why people are using the private browsing mode because of the embarrassment factor"), and 18% listed shopping as their primary use of private browsing modes.
A study the Mozilla Foundation found that most sessions lasted only about 10 minutes, but that there were periods where activation increased, usually around 11 a.m. to 2 p.m., 5 p.m., between 9 p.m. and 10 p.m., and a minor peak about an hour or two after midnight.
Support in popular browsersEdit
Private browsing is known by different names in different browsers.
|April 29, 2005||Safari 4.4||Private Browsing (Command⌘+Shift+n)|
|December 11, 2008||Google Chrome 4.4||Incognito (Ctrl+Shift+n or ⌘+Shift+n for Mac)|
|March 19, 2009||Internet Explorer||InPrivate Browsing (Ctrl+Shift+p or ⌘+Shift+p for Mac)|
|June 30, 2009||Mozilla Firefox 3.5||Private Browsing (Ctrl+Shift+p or ⌘+Shift+p for Mac)|
|March 2, 2010||Opera 10.50||Private Tab / Private Window (Ctrl+Shift+n or ⌘+Shift+n for Mac)|
|November 18, 2014||Amazon Silk||Private Browsing (Swipe from the left edge of the screen, and then tap Settings and select Enter Private Browsing)|
|July 29, 2015||Microsoft Edge||InPrivate Browsing (Ctrl+Shift+p or ⌘+Shift+p for Mac)|
It is a common misconception that private browsing modes can protect users from being tracked by other websites or their internet service provider (ISP). Such entities can still use information such as IP addresses and user accounts to uniquely identify users. Some browsers have partly addressed this shortcoming by offering additional privacy features that can be automatically enabled when using private browsing mode, such as Firefox's "Tracking Protection" feature to control use of web trackers (which has since been rolled into a larger "content blocking" function extended outside of private browsing mode), and Opera offering an in-house VPN service embedded within the browser.
In 2012, Brazilian researchers published the results of a project where they applied forensic techniques (namely the Foremost data carving tool and Strings program) to extract information about the users browsing activities on Internet Explorer and Firefox browsers with their private mode enabled. They were able to collect enough data to identify pages visited and even partially reconstruct them. This research was later extended to include the Chrome and Safari browsers. The gathered data proved that the browsers' private mode implementations are not able to fully hide users' browsing activities and that browsers in private mode leave traces of activities in caching structures and files related to the paging process of the operating system.
Another independent security analysis, performed by a group of researchers at Newcastle University in 2014, reported a range of potential security vulnerabilities in the implementation of the private modes across Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer, and Safari, including that;
- Browser extensions could still record history if they were active in private mode. Although Chrome and Firefox have since required extensions to be enabled on an opt-in basis for their private browsing modes, an installed extension in the normal mode could learn the user's activities in the private mode by measuring the usage of shared computing resources.
- Data erasure by the browser alone is found to be insufficient. For example, the records of visited websites during the private session can be retained in memory for a long time even after the private session is closed. In addition, the visited website records are usually kept by the operating system in the local DNS cache. Furthermore, the modified timestamps of certain profile files saved on the disk may reveal if the private mode was previously turned on and when it was turned on.
- Software bugs present in some browsers were found to seriously degrade the security of the private mode. For example, in some earlier versions of Safari, the browser retained private browsing history records if the browser program was not closed normally (e.g., as a result of program crash), or if the user acted to add a bookmark within the private mode.
- Depending on whether the session is in the private or the normal mode, web browsers typically exhibit different user interfaces and traffic characteristics. This allows a remote website to tell if the user is currently in the private mode, for example, by checking the color of the hyperlinks or measuring the time of writing cookies. (The fact that the user is using the private mode should be considered protected information as well.)
In 2015, researchers from Pennsylvania State University found that a considerable amount of extensions on Firefox violated the private browsing policy[how?] based on an investigation of the top 2,000 extensions. Many extensions maintain their own profile folders on the local machine, and most of them will not wipe the browsing data after the private browsing session ends. This violation even happens on some most popular extensions with millions of users on Firefox.
Private Browsing DetectionEdit
Implementations of the FileSystem API can be used to detect users in private mode. Prior to Chrome 76, the FileSystem API was not available in Incognito mode. Sites including The New York Times and The Boston Globe used these techniques to detect and block Chrome users to prevent circumvention of their paywall policies by visiting their sites in the mode. Citing the ability to detect Incognito as being a privacy violation, Chrome 76 implements the API in Incognito mode, thus countering the tactic. However, it was later discovered that the disk space quotas for the API differed between normal and Incognito modes, which have once again been used to detect Incognito users.
- Trapani, Gina (May 4, 2005). "Safari's private (porn) browsing mode". Lifehacker. Retrieved 2010-04-11.
- Foley, Mary Jo. "Microsoft to roll out more granular 'porn mode' with IE 8". ZDNet. Retrieved 2008-10-04.
- Sadighi, Lalee. "Microsoft's Internet Explorer 8 Goes 'Porn Mode'". Red Herring. Archived from the original on 2008-09-12. Retrieved 2008-10-04.
- Kidman, Angus. "Microsoft releases IE8 beta 2: MS porn mode included". APC. Retrieved 2008-10-04.
- "Adobe Flash 10.1 supports "private browsing"". The H. Retrieved 2019-08-14.
- "Adobe Flash Player Private Browsing May Force Change in Fraud Fight". eWEEK. Retrieved 2019-08-14.
- Paul, Ian; hassles, PCWorld | PT About | Smart fixes for your PC (2014-03-11). "Three practical reasons to use your browser's private mode". PCWorld. Retrieved 2019-08-14. Missing
- Brownlee, Chip (2019-07-31). "Google's Chrome Update Just Unlocked Lots of Newspapers' Metered Paywalls". Slate Magazine. Retrieved 2019-08-14.
- Bursztein, Elie. "Understanding how people use private browsing". Retrieved 2019-08-14.
- Espiner, Tom. "Private browsing tools still leave data trail". ZDNet. Retrieved 2019-08-14.
- "Private browsing: 16 good reasons to use incognito mode". ZDNet. Retrieved 2019-08-14.
- Ulmer, Hamilton (23 August 2010). "Understanding Private Browsing". Blog of Metrics. Mozilla Foundation. Retrieved 24 August 2010.
- Parchisanu, Daniel (November 9, 2018). "How to go incognito in all web browsers: Chrome, Firefox, Opera, Edge, and Internet Explorer". Digital Citizen. Retrieved January 9, 2019.
- "Microsoft Announces Availability of Internet Explorer 8" (Press release). Microsoft. 19 March 2009. Archived from the original on 22 March 2009. Retrieved 16 December 2011.
- "Mozilla Cross-Reference mozilla1.9.1". Mozilla Foundation. Retrieved 2009-05-26.
- Mateu, Roberto. "Opera 10.5 pre-alpha for Labs". Opera Software. Archived from the original on 2011-08-26. Retrieved 2009-12-22.
- "Private Browsing for Amazon Silk". Amazon Inc. Archived from the original on 2014-12-22. Retrieved 2014-11-18.
- Grothaus, Michael (2019-04-12). "Incognito mode won't keep your browsing private. Do this instead". Fast Company. Retrieved 2019-08-14.
- Cimpanu, Catalin. "Firefox 63 released with 'always-on' tracking protection". ZDNet. Retrieved 2019-08-14.
- R. Ruiz, F. P. Amatte, K. J. B. Park, Tornando Pública a Navegação “In Private”. Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Forensic Computer Science – ICoFCS 2012, Available online Sep 2012.
- R. Ruiz, F. P. Amatte, K. J. B. Park, Opening the “Private Browsing” Data – Acquiring Evidence of Browsing Activities. Proceedings of the International Conference on Information Security and Cyber Forensics (InfoSec2014), Available online Oct 2014.
- Satvat, Kiavash; Forshaw, Matthew; Hao, Feng; Toreini, Ehsan (2014). "On the privacy of private browsing – A forensic approach". Journal of Information Security and Applications. 19: 88–100. doi:10.1016/j.jisa.2014.02.002.
- Keizer, Gregg (2019-03-08). "How to go incognito in Chrome, Firefox, Safari and Edge". Computerworld. Retrieved 2019-08-14.
- B. Zhao, P. Liu, Private Browsing Mode Not Really That Private: Dealing with Privacy Breaches Caused by Browser Extensions. In Proceedings of the 45th Annual IEEE/IFIP International Conference on Dependable Systems and Networks (DSN 2015), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Available online June 2015.
- Brodkin, Jon (2019-07-19). "Chrome 76 prevents NYT and other news sites from detecting Incognito Mode". Ars Technica. Retrieved 2019-08-21.
- Tung, Liam. "Chrome's 'more private' Incognito mode: Websites can still detect you're using it". ZDNet. Retrieved 2019-08-14.
- Duckett, Chris. "Google to clamp down on Incognito Mode detection". ZDNet. Retrieved 2019-08-14.
- "How to Turn On Private or Incognito Browsing". wikiHow. Retrieved Jul 31, 2018.