Talk:Lisa Specht

Latest comment: 4 years ago by Huon in topic Revert to better-sourced version

Revert to better-sourced version edit

Tjla12 turned the draft written by Ritchie333 into a copy of the version that had previously been deleted as promotional. I have reverted the page back to Ritchie333's version. The problems with the other version include unreliable and non-independent sources, promotional statements without context (e.g. "is recognized for her work in women's rights" - by people who at the same opportunity say they "greatly enjoyed [their] friendship with this charming and accomplished woman"; it's somewhat less impressive if the recognition comes from her friends and when there's no independent secondary source reporting on it), and promotional statements not supported by the cited sources at all (e.g. "philanthropist"). Huon (talk) 23:31, 10 August 2019 (UTC)Reply