Talk:Metropolitan Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital

Latest comment: 1 year ago by Brunton in topic Refs are useless in this article

Refs are useless in this article

edit

None of the references are actually functional or support notability for this school. If nobody helps in this regard, in a couple of days I will have to sort out the problem! - Roxy the dog 12:22, 1 April 2023 (UTC)Reply

Tracked down the refs to the college's own website on the Wayback Machine, found that much of content was copied from them so removed it. Another dead link didn't mention the college in the only archived version I found (a list of affiliated institutions). The only other source used apart from the college's own site is a similar list. Brunton (talk) 10:50, 2 April 2023 (UTC)Reply
Archived sources: About, Admission, Anti-ragging. Brunton (talk) 11:35, 2 April 2023 (UTC)Reply
Good work Brunton - I didn't know what an Anti ragging cell is!
Also, Do we need a list of hospital deptartments and facilities? That sort of thing belongs on the hospital guide on the hospital noticeboard, not an encyclopeadia article.
Regarding the images, The College building has been heavily photoshopped to add the greeen logo twice, and the writin' above the door. The disco pics (all three) show nothing special I have no idea what is special about an indore[sic] patient, and it really looks like a group of mourners are wailing about the death in the "Cadaveric oath" pic. What on earth is a Cadaveric oath, fgs.
I think the whole lot should be stubbed to just the first sentence. Anybody? Roxy the dog 13:56, 2 April 2023 (UTC)Reply
I'd noticed that about the photo as well, it seems to be the building the college is in - the photo on the college website has a photo of the same building with one of the logos but not the text above the door, for example. Not sure that there isn't some sort of COI here, the editor who added the photo is claiming the photos (some apparently taken inside the college) and the logo as their own work, and says in edsums that they're editing "as per organization request".
I suppose I'd better ask for the copyvios to be revdeled.
Is it even notable? I can't find much about the college apart from mentions in lists and directory sites, its Facebook page, and its own website (which seems to be down at the moment). Brunton (talk) 15:42, 2 April 2023 (UTC)Reply