Talk:Kate Garbers

Latest comment: 5 years ago by Bradv in topic Source review

Untitled

edit

This article was started by user:Whatkatydid1976 in a sandbox during an editathon at Amnesty International's London office on 20 May 2018, and was moved to a draft article so that later participants might also work on it. Paul W (talk) 13:46, 20 May 2018 (UTC)Reply

Source review

edit

As of this version, there are 7 sources in the article:

  1. Is an author's bio on the Guardian. Brief, possibly self-published. Not in-depth.
  2. Award page which doesn't mention the subject at all (perhaps an old version did, but that doesn't appear to be available).
  3. Corporation page, listing legal directors. Garbers is listed as resigned.
  4. Mentions the subject in passing, as "Unseen's managing director"
  5. Article written by the subject (self-published source, not suitable for notability).
  6. Mentions the subject in passing, as "director of modern slavery charity Unseen".
  7. Brief biography on the "most influential women" page, out of 100. No in-depth coverage.

I initially thought this subject was notable, but a more thorough review shows that almost none of the information in this article has a proper source. A Google search turns up little more than additional mentions in passing, and does not provide the significant coverage in reliable sources required to satisfy WP:BASIC. Bradv🍁 03:08, 7 December 2018 (UTC)Reply