Brexit divorce bill
The Brexit financial settlement ('divorce bill') is a sum of money due to the European Union (EU) from the United Kingdom (UK) when it leaves the EU (a process commonly referred to as Brexit) to settle the UK's share of the financing of all the obligations undertaken while it was a member of the EU. In the Withdrawal Agreement negotiations, it is officially referred to as the "financial settlement".
The UK Office for Budget Responsibility's estimate of the financial settlement as at 31 October 2019, after payment of normal contributions of £5 billion from 30 March to 31 October, is £32.8 billion (€36.3 billion).
The UK and EU began negotiations with differing perspectives on the basis for the bill. The UK side saw it as payment for preferential access to the European Single Market whereas the EU saw it as obligations previously agreed to funding the budget round ending 2020 and for share of longer-range commitments. In December 2017, the negotiators reached agreement on the scope of these commitments and the methods for their valuation.
History of the negotiationsEdit
During the 2016 United Kingdom European Union membership referendum, Vote Leave claimed that the UK was sending £350 million to the EU every week (the Institute for Fiscal Studies estimated the true net figure as being about half this.). Following the referendum, the UK signalled that it may consider paying the EU to attain preferential access to the European Single Market and may offer to pay liabilities on a moral and co-operative basis, even if not legally obliged to do so, to secure a preferential working relationship with the EU. In Prime Minister Theresa May's speech on 17 January 2017 setting out the UK's plans to negotiate Brexit, she stated:
"And because we will no longer be members of the single market, we will not be required to contribute huge sums to the EU budget. There may be some specific European programmes in which we might want to participate. If so, and this will be for us to decide, it is reasonable that we should make an appropriate contribution. But the principle is clear: the days of Britain making vast contributions to the European Union every year will end."
Despite the claim, ministers and officials, including Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union David Davis, had already indicated that some kind of payment to the EU might have to be part of a future trade deal and the House of Lords were told in January 2017 that the UK may have to contribute to the EU's budget after Brexit because of previous obligations entered into, unless a deal is done.
The leaders of France and Germany both stated that the UK would need to agree to terms regarding departure, including in relation to a divorce bill, before discussing future relationships. This was reinforced by EU27 guidelines issued to the remaining 27 countries.
Estimates of over £50 billion appeared for a divorce bill and there were concerns raised about whether, and how much, the UK would owe the EU and that such a dispute could lead to an early end to negotiations, with the UK leaving the EU without a deal. Secretary of State for International Trade Liam Fox claimed it would be “absurd” for the UK to pay a large sum and Conservative Party MP John Redwood said there was no legal basis to the demands.
House of Lords reportEdit
HL Paper 125, 4 March 2017, European Union Committee 15th sessional report, Brexit and the EU budget , Chapter 3, Potential demands.
A 4 March 2017 report of the European Union Committee of the House of Lords acknowledged that the EU may claim for (1) part of the current budget (which runs from 2014 to 2020) post March 2019, because it was approved by the UK (2) part of the EU future commitments which amount to €200 billion and (3) a contribution if the UK is to continue with access to some EU programmes. The report concluded that the UK had no legal obligation to make "exit" payments to the EU if there was no post-Brexit deal.
Trigger of Article 50Edit
Theresa May's letter of 29 March 2017 to President of the European Council Donald Tusk triggering Article 50 noted that she wanted "fair settlement of the UK’s rights and obligations as a departing member state, in accordance with the law and in the spirit of the United Kingdom’s continuing partnership with the EU".
On 29 April 2017, the EU27 heads of state unanimously accepted negotiating guidelines prepared by Donald Tusk. The guidelines take the view that Article 50 permits a two-phased negotiation, whereby the UK first needs to agree to a financial commitment and to lifelong benefits for EU citizens in Britain, before the EU27 will entertain negotiations on a future relationship. In the requested first phase of the withdrawal negotiation, the UK must pay a "divorce bill", initially estimated as amounting up to £52bn and then, after additional financial demands from Germany, France, and Poland, amounting to £92bn.
The Prime Minister insisted to President of the European Commission Jean-Claude Juncker that talks about the future UK-EU relationship should start early and that Britain did not owe any money to the EU under the current treaties. Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs Boris Johnson claimed that the amounts being discussed were extortionate and said that European leaders can 'go whistle' over the EU divorce bill.
EU position paperEdit
Two different legal approaches arose in determining the financial element of the Brexit withdrawal agreement and (at least initially) the UK and EU negotiators differed on which would be the more appropriate. David Davis said that the "UK wants to go through the Brexit bill line-by-line to work out what it owes the EU." In September 2017, the European negotiator Michel Barnier, in an address to the Italian parliament noted that despite progress in each topic of the Withdrawal Agreement negotiations, major issues were remaining in each topic, including for the financial settlement, for which his goal was that:
- « All that is necessary in this negotiation is that everyone honors the commitments that they have made to each other. To settle the accounts. No more, no less.»
- « To settle the accounts in an objective manner, on the basis of all commitments made at 28.»
- « (...) to provide – and (...) must provide – certainty for project managers working in Europe, such as in Italy and its regions, and in other continents, such as Africa, on the basis of the commitment of the 28.»
- «But beyond money, this is a question of trust between the 27 and the United Kingdom, based on the respect of one's signature. And everyone knows that we will need this trust to create a solid relationship in the future.».
In 2017, the UK had a 16% share in the European Investment Bank (EIB) worth £8.8bn based on data submitted by Lawyers for Britain. As part of the financial settlement, the UK's liability resulting from the guarantee for the financing made by the EIB while the UK was a Member State is to be maintained and its level decreased in line with the amortisation of the EIB portfolio outstanding at the time of UK's withdrawal, at the end of which the paid-in capital of the United Kingdom in the EIB will be reimbursed to the UK. In March 2018, the OBR estimated the net asset to offset the overall financial settlement at €3.5bn.
The Bank of England (BoE) has invested in the European Central Bank (ECB) amounting to 14.3374% of its paid up capital, equating to €58.2 million at 1 January 2019. The BoE does not participate in any profits (or losses) of the ECB. The BoE has also made loans to the ECB. The ECB set up the European Financial Stability Facility in 2010, which has a borrowing facility of €440bn and in addition used a guarantee from the European Commission and the EU Budget as collateral to borrow a further €60bn. The paid-in capital of the UK in the ECB will be reimbursed to the BoE.
The UK benefits from a rebate which reduces its contribution to the EU budget. The rebate is paid a year in arrears, accordingly the 2019 rebate would be payable in 2020.
The EU has considerable assets including buildings, equipment and financial instruments, and there is a potential claim by the UK for a portion of these assets. Boris Johnson, the UK's Foreign Secretary, commenting on the Brexit "divorce bill" in May 2017 stated that the valuable EU assets the UK has paid for over the years should be properly valued, and that there were good arguments for including them in the negotiations.
Agreement on scope of commitments and methods for valuationEdit
On 11 December 2017, Theresa May confirmed that the UK and the EU had agreed “the scope of commitments, and methods for valuations and adjustments to those values.”
The UK's obligation is to be fixed as a percentage of the EU's obligations calculated at the date of withdrawal in accordance with a methodology agreed in the first phase of the negotiations. The amount due is complex to be calculated and includes various liabilities apart from just the core EU budget. The UK is also entitled to a portion of EU assets.
In March 2018, the UK's Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) published the UK's economic and fiscal outlook including details of the financial settlement which it estimated at £37.1 billion (€41.4 billion). The estimated settlement was made up of:
- £16.4bn (€18.5bn) towards the UK’s contribution to the EU budget to December 2020 (after offsetting for the UK rebate);
- £18.2bn (€20.2bn) towards outstanding commitments for projects that have been signed off but not yet paid for by 2020 (The Reste à Liquider ("RAL") from successive Multiannual Financial Frameworks) to be paid up to 2028; and
- £2.5bn (€2.7bn) for other financial liabilities, being an estimate for pension liabilities of €9.5bn offset by other assets totalling €6.8bn. The payments towards the pension liabilities are estimated to be made until 2064.
The OBR's updated estimate of the financial settlement in March 2019 was £37.8 billion (€41.8 billion).
The UK would continue to benefit from all programmes as before the withdrawal until their closure under the condition that it respects the applicable EU legal rules.
Article 50 extensionsEdit
As the UK did not leave the EU on 29 March 2019, the UK continues to contribute to the EU as a member. Its contributions for the period from 30 March to 31 October 2019, the current end of the Article 50 period, are £5 billion, leaving £32.8 billion (€36.3 billion) remaining to be settled at 31 October 2019.
On 7 September 2018 it was announced that Barnier had made a concession to British MPs and that the EU will allow a future trade agreement to be linked to the payment of the divorce bill. The EU Commission had long insisted that any trade agreement between the EU and Britain could not be linked to payment of financial settlements.
The financial settlement is not binding until the UK Parliament approves the Withdrawal Agreement.
- "The EU "divorce bill"". Full Fact. Retrieved 2019-03-24.
- "Position paper "Essential Principles on Financial Settlement"" (PDF). 12 June 2017. Retrieved 23 March 2019.
- "Fiscal risks report" (PDF). Office for Budget Responsibility. July 2019. p. 166. Retrieved 19 July 2019.
- "Let's give our National Health Service the £350 million the EU takes every week | LSE Digital Library". digital.library.lse.ac.uk. Retrieved 30 March 2017.
- "FactCheck: do we really send £350m a week to Brussels?". blogs.channel4.com. Archived from the original on 8 July 2016. Retrieved 31 July 2016.
- "David Davis suggests UK could pay for single market access". The Guardian. 1 December 2016. Retrieved 2 April 2017.
- "The government's negotiating objectives for exiting the EU: PM speech". 17 January 2017. Retrieved 24 March 2019.
- Henley, Jon (17 January 2017). "Key points from May's Brexit speech: what have we learned?". The Guardian. Retrieved 24 March 2019.
- "Brexit: UK contributions to EU 'could continue' after exit". BBC. 11 January 2017. Retrieved 24 March 2019.
- "Brexit EU guidelines: UK told settle divorce bill before talking trade deals". Sky News. 31 March 2017.
- Boffey, Daniel (17 March 2017). "EU sources: May must mention UK's financial settlement in article 50 notice". Retrieved 23 March 2019.
- Keep, Matthew (16 March 2017). "The UK's contribution to the EU budget". House of Lords.
- "Brexit and the EU Budget" (PDF). House of Lords. 4 March 2017. Retrieved 2 April 2017.
- "Brexit: UK 'not obliged' to pay divorce bill say peers". BBC News. 4 March 2017. Retrieved 30 August 2018.
- "Prime Minister's letter to Donald Tusk triggering Article 50". 29 March 2017. Retrieved 23 March 2019.
- Boffey, Daniel (29 April 2017). "EU leaders agree on tough stance at special Brexit summit". The Guardian. Retrieved 14 May 2017.
- "European Council (Art. 50) guidelines for Brexit negotiations". Council of the European Union. 29 April 2017. Retrieved 14 April 2017.
- Foster, Peter (29 April 2017). "EU Brexit guidelines: What's in the document, and what it really means". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 14 May 2017.
- Worstall, Tim (3 May 2017). "It Is To Laugh At Their Mistake – EU's Brexit Bill Claim Now At €100 Billion". Forbes. Retrieved 15 May 2017.
- Roberts, Dan (1 May 2017). "May dismisses reports of frosty dinner with EU chief as 'Brussels gossip'". The Guardian. Retrieved 15 May 2017.
- Mason, Rowena (11 July 2017). "European leaders can 'go whistle' over EU divorce bill, says Boris Johnson". the Guardian.
- Rankin, Jennifer (30 May 2017). "Painstaking detail of Brexit process revealed in EU documents". The Guardian. Retrieved 23 June 2017.
- "Britain is 'backtracking' on its Brexit divorce bill commitments, EU's chief negotiator warns". The Independent. 7 September 2017. Retrieved 22 September 2017.
- "European Commission - PRESS RELEASES - Press release - Speech by Michel Barnier in front of the Committees of Foreign Affairs and the Committees of European Affairs of the Italian Parliament". europa.eu.
- Niamh McIntyre (2017-03-12). "Brexit: UK could demand £9bn back from EU instead of paying divorce bill". The Independent. Retrieved 2017-05-03.
- "Economic and fiscal outlook – March 2018". 13 March 2018. Retrieved 23 March 2019.
- "Capital subscription". European Central Bank. 1 January 2019.
- "UK's Brexit bill likely to be well under €60bn, says think tank". The Irish Times. 30 March 2017.
- "Boris Johnson says Brussels should [not] pay 'preposterous' Brexit bill". Sky News. 13 May 2017. Retrieved 13 May 2017.
- "The EU "divorce bill"". Full Fact. 15 November 2018. Retrieved 23 March 2019.
- McTague, Tom (13 March 2018). "Britain's Brexit Bill Revealed £37.1B Over 45 years". Politico. Retrieved 23 March 2019.
- Crisp, James (7 September 2018). "Michel Barnier concedes that payment of £39 billion Brexit bill could guarantee UK-EU trade deal" – via www.telegraph.co.uk.
- "PM to discuss no-deal Brexit plans". BBC News. 13 September 2018.