User:Gerda Arendt/ACE 2020

Question from Gerda

2. In 2013, we had WP:ARBINFOBOX. In 2018, Voceditenore commented this. Would you agree?

Answers

As of 18 November, all candidates answered to my liking, more or less detailed. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 08:37, 18 November 2020 (UTC)

Almost as soon as all had answered, we had a new situation. I asked the candidates about that on 5 December. Good answers linked. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 21:27, 5 December 2020 (UTC)

... and changed my mind --Gerda Arendt (talk) 23:20, 7 December 2020 (UTC)

Candidate	nom day	answer day	answers	Precious no.	Precious reason	experience	sup	elected
Bradv	10 Nov	11 Nov	I haven't yet had cause to wade into that dispute	2263	"help improve the encyclopedia and achieve its vision"	arb	Y	Y
Primefac	15 Nov	15 Nov	on the whole I would agree + action	1556	astronomical spectroscopy cleanup	arb	Y	Y
Scottywong	15 Nov	15 Nov	from my admittedly limited perspective, I would agree + design preferred	2479	bot tasks and tools	admin	Y
Maxim	15 Nov	16 Nov	if we're to look at the situation now, nothing appears be bubbling	1196	ice hockey players	arb		Y
BDD	16 Nov	16 Nov	I haven't encountered such disputes recently + good answer	2480	people in education and music	admin	Y	Y
Barkeep49	17 Nov	17 Nov	the strength of feelings about them still runs deep + 7 Dec response	2109	radiant child	admin	Y	Y
TonyBallioni (withdrawn)	17 Nov	17 Nov	I'd agree in part that they’re being used more frequently without controversy as compared to 2013	1682	papal conclaves	admin
L235	17 Nov	18 Nov	there haven't been widespread infobox conduct issues since the Civility case + 9 Dec apology	1977	supreme court	admin, arb clark		Y
Hawkeye7	17 Nov	17 Nov	Sure. As far as I know, things are calm now.	171	people in sports and battles	former admin
CaptainEek	17 Nov	17 Nov	editors have been using civil discussion to solve infobox issues for some years + good question "why removed"	2440	birds of the Southwestern U.S.	admin	Y	Y
Guerillero	17 Nov	17 Nov	Broadly, yes.	761	Toil, tools, tradition and trust	arb
‎SMcCandlish	17 Nov	17 Nov	debates I've seen semi-recently have been more appropriately focused on whether an infobox is helpful + 7 Dec infobox expected	1786	four dimensions player		Y

The most detailed answer, telling me of carefully looking at this field, so hopefully others as well, came from ‎SMcCandlish. None of the candidates would break the wiki, but those saying - in other words -- that arbcom helped to peace in the matter might want to look closer. Related thoughts can be found on my talk: vision 2020 and Gerda's dream. Today's decoration is for BB's music. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 13:00, 23 November 2020 (UTC)

Voted 2 December --Gerda Arendt (talk) 20:04, 2 December 2020 (UTC)

Results