Tokenism is the practice of making only a perfunctory or symbolic effort to be inclusive to members of minority groups, especially by recruiting people from underrepresented groups in order to give the appearance of racial or gender equality within a workplace or educational context.[1][2][3] The effort of including a token individual in work or school is usually intended to create the impression of social inclusiveness and diversity (racial, religious, sexual, etc.) in order to deflect accusations of discrimination.[4]

HistoryEdit

The social concept and the employment practice of tokenism became understood in the popular culture of the United States in the late 1950s.[5] In the face of racial segregation, tokenism emerged as a solution that though earnest in effort, only acknowledged an issue without actually solving it.[6] In the book Why We Can't Wait (1964), civil rights activist Martin Luther King Jr. discussed the subject of tokenism, and how it constitutes a minimal acceptance of black people to the mainstream of U.S. society.[7]

When asked about the gains of the Civil Rights Movement in 1963, human rights activist Malcolm X answered, “What gains? All you have gotten is tokenism — one or two Negroes in a job, or at a lunch counter, so the rest of you will be quiet.”[8][9]

In the field of psychology, the broader definition of tokenism is a situation in which a member of a distinctive category is treated differently from other people. The characteristics that make the person of interest a token can be perceived as either a handicap or an advantage, as supported by Václav Linkov. In a positive light, these distinct people can be seen as experts in their racial/cultural category, valued skills, or a different perspective on a project. In contrast, tokenism is most often seen as a handicap due to the ostracism of a selected sample of a minority group.[10] Linkov also attributes drawbacks in psychology to Cultural and Numerical Tokenism, instances that have shifted where value of expertise is placed and its effect on proliferating information that is not representative of all the possible facts.[10]

Black characters being the first characters to die was first identified in Hollywood horror movies of the 1930s, notes writer Renee Cozier. The Oscars ceremonies have received criticism over a lack of representation of people of color, as critics have pointed towards a lack of minorities nominated for awards, particularly in 2015 and 2016, when not a single actor of color was nominated. Around this time, minorities accounted for 12.9% of lead roles in 163 films surveyed in 2014, according to the 2016 Hollywood Diversity Report.[11]

In televisionEdit

Tokenism, in a television setting, can be any act of putting a minority into the mix to create some sort of publicly viewed diversity. A racial divide in TV has been present since the first television show that hired minorities, Amos 'n' Andy (1928–1960) in 1943. Regardless of whether a token character may be stereotypical or not, tokenism can initiate a whole biased perception that may conflict with how people see a specific race, culture, gender, or ethnicity.[12] From the Huffington Post, America Ferrera states, “Tokenism is about inserting diverse characters because you feel you have to; true diversity means writing characters that aren’t just defined by the color of their skin, and casting the right actor for the role."[13]

Ethnic and racial representation in television has been proven as an educational basis to inform mass audiences. However, tokenism leads to a narrow representation of minority groups, and this trend often leads to minority characters being exposed in negative or stereotypical fashions.[14] Research done as early as the 1970s suggests an early recognition and disapproval of tokenism and its effects on perceptions of minority groups—specifically, perceptions of African Americans. Tokenism seemed to be used as a quick fix for the complete void of major/recurring minority roles in television, but its skewed representation lacked room for thoroughly independent and positive roles. Throughout that decade, major broadcast networks including NBC and ABC held a collective 10:1 ratio of white characters to black characters, a much smaller margin of which had recurring African American characters. At that, the representation of African American women was much slimmer. The use of these token characters often portrayed African American people to stand in sidekick positions to their white counterparts.[15] Research completed on token ethnic characters into the new millennium has found that the representation of males has grown in numbers, but has not improved in negative portrayal. Statistics on token ethnic characters still suggest toxic masculinity in African American males; threateningly powerful stereotypes of African American women; hyper-sexuality of African American and Asian women; and effeminate characteristics in Asian men and men of other racial minorities.[16]

Tokenism in television has been spoken about under a different umbrella in recent decades. For example, tokenism was analyzed in an article that examined actions in the television show Scandal (2012–2018). Though today there are many black main characters in many popular television shows, Stephanie L. Gomez's article speaks about Kerry Washington as Olivia Pope. Gomez compares the character of Olivia Pope to three tropes of black women, "the slave mistress," "the help," and "the jezebel."[17]

In 2012, Acura put out a casting call for their commercial where they stated that the main actor must be a “nice looking, friendly, not too dark” African American.[18][19]

In the mediaEdit

Just like television, tokenism in the media has changed over time to coincide with real life events. During the years of 1946-87 the weekly magazine, The New Yorker was analyzed to determine how often and in what situations blacks were being portrayed in the magazine's cartoon section. Over the 42 years of research, there was only one U.S. black main character in a cartoon where race was not the main theme, race was actually completely irrelevant. All cartoons from the earliest times depicted U.S. blacks in stereotypical roles. In the late 1960s and early 1970s, cartoons were mostly racially themed, and depicted blacks in "token" roles where they are only there to create a sense of inclusion.[20]

Tokenism appears in advertising as well as other subdivisions of major media. Tokenism is interpreted as reinforcing subtle representations of minorities in commercials. Studies have shown that, among other racial minorities, Asian Americans are targeted by advertising companies to fulfill casting diversity, but are the most likely ethnic minority to be placed in the backgrounds of advertisements.[21][22]

In the workplaceEdit

A Harvard Business School professor, Rosabeth Moss Kanter, asserted back in 1977[23] that a token employee is usually part of a "socially-skewed group" of employees who belong to a minority group that constitutes less than 15% of the total employee population of the workplace. [24]

By definition, token employees in a workplace are known to be few; hence, their alleged high visibility among the staff subjects them to greater pressure to perform their work at higher production standards of quality and volume and to behave in the expected, stereotypical manner. [24] Given the smallness of the group of token employees in a workplace, the individual identity of each token person is usually disrespected by the dominant group, who apply a stereotype role to them as a means of social control in the workplace. [24]

Research comparing the effects of gender and race tokenism on individuals indicates that the practice of tokenism can accurately predict conditions in the workplace for members of racial minorities.[25]

According to one study, racial minorities also experience heightened performance pressures related to their race and gender; however, many reported that racial problems were more common than gender problems.[26]

In her work on tokenism and gender, professor Kanter said that the problems experienced by women in a typically male-dominated occupations were due solely to the skewed proportions of men and women in these occupations. [24]

In politicsEdit

In politics, allegations of tokenism may occur when a political party puts forward candidates from under-represented groups, such as women or racial minorities, in races that the party has little or no chance of winning, while making limited or no effort to ensure that such candidates have similar opportunity to win the nomination in races where the party is safe or favoured.[27] The "token" candidates are frequently submitted as paper candidates, while nominations in competitive or safe seats continue to favor members of the majority group.[28]

The end result of such an approach is that the party's slate of candidates maintains the appearance of diversity, but members of the majority group remain overrepresented in the party's caucus after the election — and thus little to no substantive progress toward greater inclusion of underrepresented groups has actually occurred.[28]

In fictionEdit

In fiction, a token character exists only to achieve minimal compliance with the normality presumed for the society described in the story. Writers also use the token character to pay lip service to the rules and the standards that they do not abide, such as by obeying anti-racism policies, by including a token ethnic-minority character who has no true, narrative function in the plot and is usually a stereotype character.

In fiction, token characters represent groups which vary from the norm (usually defined as a white, heterosexual male) and are otherwise excluded from the story. The token character can be based on ethnicity (i.e. black, Hispanic, Asian), religion (i.e. Jewish, Muslim), sexual orientation (i.e., gay), or gender (typically a female character in a predominantly male cast). Token characters are usually background characters, and, as such, are usually disposable, and are eliminated from the narrative early in the story, in order to enhance the drama, while conserving the main characters.[29][30]

In much contemporary cinema and television, the inclusion of token characters is usually and implausibly seen in historical settings where such a person's race would be immediately noticed.[31] Typically, other characters tend to treat the token characters as though they are not concerned with their race or ethnicity. Notable exceptions to this practice include stories based in history and stories that address racism directly.[32][33] The South Park character Token Black is a reference to this.[34]

Social and media commentator Eric July defines tokenism as the purposeful "gender, race, or sexuality change of a pre-established character."[35] July's primary criticism of tokenism is that it is lazy. He finds 'tokenizations' in comic books to be in the main politically motivated and at the expense of creative character development and of quality story-telling.

In filmEdit

Since the release of the original six Star Wars films, there has been much discussion, on Twitter and Reddit especially, of this use of tokenism.[36][37][38] The character of Lando Calrissian (portrayed by Billy Dee Williams) and Mace Windu (portrayed by Samuel L. Jackson) have been cited as two human characters of racial minority that appear on screen. Lando was one of the first developed black characters in a science-fiction film at the time. Loyola Marymount University Professor of African American Studies, Adilifu Nama, has stated that this character is "a form of tokenism that placed one of the most optimistic faces on racial inclusion in a genre that had historically excluded Black representation."[37]

When the first film of the newest installment of the franchise, The Force Awakens, was released in 2015, the conversation shifted.[39] Where in the past two trilogies the main three characters were two White men and a White woman, in the new trilogy the main trio consists of a black man (John Boyega), a Hispanic man (Oscar Isaac), and a white woman (Daisy Ridley).[39] Although the canon racial representation was more prominent, there was fan backlash at the cast of a main black storm-trooper.[39]

Directed by Ryan Coogler, the film Black Panther portrays the heroes of the fictional African kingdom of Wakanda as godlike. They possess otherworldly sophistication by virtue of their blackness, in contrast to longstanding tendencies in mainstream film toward tokenism, stereotyping, and victimhood in depictions of people of African descent. The superhero the Black Panther, a.k.a. King T’Challa, learns to stand in solidarity with the oppressed, even those in whose oppression he has been unwittingly complicit, such as the children of the African diaspora. As a result, the film can function as catalyst for reflection on the part of viewers in terms of how they might perceive more clearly the complexity, variety, and ambiguity represented by blackness, whether others’ or their own, and how they, too, might identify with the Other.[40]

The Walt Disney Company has attempted to enlarge the diversity of the "Disney Princess" franchise through the inclusion of female characters with multiple ethnicities. At this time, there are five princesses representing different ethnicities. From Aladdin (1992), Princess Jasmine is Arabian; from Pocahontas (1995), Pocahontas is Native American; from Mulan (1998), Mulan is Chinese; from Princess and the Frog (2009), Princess Tiana is African-American; from Moana (2016), Moana is Polynesian. [41] However, these characters are the sole providers for their representation, as opposed to the other nine caucasian princesses. [42]

The Harry Potter series, written by author J.K. Rowling, has displayed tokenism through race and sexuality. Potter’s first love interest, Cho Chang, was named after two Asian surnames. NBC Asian America reporter Kimberly Yam tweeted that the one use of Asian representation in the series had a name equivalent to “ching chong”. [43] Rowling also revealed Albus Dumbledore to be homosexual weeks after the final book was released, though his sexuality is not mentioned in the books or films. [44] Fans displayed disappointment against this representation, as Dumbledore would be the only gay character in the series, and his supposed love interest was Gellert Grindelwald, an immoral teen fascist.[45]

See alsoEdit

ReferencesEdit

NotesEdit

  1. ^ "tokenism: definition of tokenism in Oxford dictionary". Oxford Dictionaries Online.
  2. ^ "tokenism, n." Oxford English Dictionary.
  3. ^ "Tokenism". Reference.com.
  4. ^ Hogg, Michael A.; Vaughan, Graham M. (2008). Social Psychology. Harlow: Prentice Hall. pp. 368–369. ISBN 978-0-13-206931-1.
  5. ^ Nesbitt, Paula D. (1997). "Gender, Tokenism, and the Construction of Elite Clergy Careers". Review of Religious Research. 38 (3): 193–210. doi:10.2307/3512083. ISSN 0034-673X. JSTOR 3512083.
  6. ^ Wallis, Victor (12 May 2014). "The Plague of Tokenism". Retrieved August 6, 2017.
  7. ^ King, Martin Luther (1964). Why We Can't Wait. Harper & Row. ISBN 978-0451527530.
  8. ^ Lomax, Louis (1963). "A Summing Up: Louis Lomax interviews Malcolm X". Teaching American History. Retrieved September 4, 2016.
  9. ^ Frost, Bryan-Paul; Sikkenga, Jeffrey (2003). History of American Political Thought. Lexington Books. p. 689. ISBN 978-0739106242.
  10. ^ a b Linkov, Václav. "Tokenism In Psychology: Standing On The Shoulders Of Small Boys." Integrative Psychological & Behavioral Science 48.2 (2014): 143-160. Academic Search Complete. Web. 10 Mar. 2016.
  11. ^ Greene, Eric. "Hollywood Diversity Report: Mounting evidence that more diverse casts help the bottom line". UCLA Newsroom. Retrieved 2018-11-26.
  12. ^ Rada, James A. (1 December 2000). "A New Piece to the Puzzle: Examining Effects of Television Portrayals of African Americans". Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media. 44 (4): 704–715. doi:10.1207/s15506878jobem4404_11. S2CID 144441607.
  13. ^ Editor, Carolina Moreno; Post, The Huffington (20 May 2016). "America Ferrera Breaks Down The Difference Between Tokenism And 'True Diversity'". HuffPost. Retrieved 23 January 2017.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)
  14. ^ Williamson, Andy; DeSouza, Ruth (June 2006). "Representing Ethnic Communities in the Media". Aotearoa Ethnic Network Journal. 1 (1): 20–23. CiteSeerX 10.1.1.515.6283.
  15. ^ Hinton, James L.; Seggar, John F.; Northcott, Herbert C.; Fontes, Brian F. (1974). "Tokenism and improving imagery of blacks in TV drama and comedy: 1973". Journal of Broadcasting. 18 (4): 423–432. doi:10.1080/08838157409363756.
  16. ^ Brooks, Dwight E.; Hebert, Lisa P. "Gender, Race, and Media Representation" (PDF).
  17. ^ Gomez, Stephanie L.; McFarlane, Megan D. (2017-05-04). ""It's (not) handled": race, gender, and refraction in Scandal". Feminist Media Studies. 17 (3): 362–376. doi:10.1080/14680777.2016.1218352. ISSN 1468-0777. S2CID 152023635.
  18. ^ Staff, The Root. "Acura Casting Call: 'Not Too Dark' Blacks". The Root. Retrieved 2018-11-23.
  19. ^ "Acura NSX Super Bowl Commercial -- Only Light-Skinned Blacks Need Apply". TMZ. Retrieved 2018-11-23.
  20. ^ Thibodeau, Ruth (1989-01-01). "From Racism to Tokenism: The Changing Face of Blacks in New Yorker Cartoons". Public Opinion Quarterly. 53 (4): 482. doi:10.1086/269168. ISSN 0033-362X.
  21. ^ Taylor, Charles R.; Stern, Barbara B. (1997). "Asian-Americans: Television Advertising and the "Model Minority" Stereotype". Journal of Advertising. 26 (2): 47–61. doi:10.1080/00913367.1997.10673522. JSTOR 4189033.
  22. ^ Link to external site, this link will open in a new window; Link to external site, this link will open in a new window (September 28, 2020). "Learning an Inclusive Blue Humanities: Oceania and Academia through the Lens of Cinema". Humanities. 9 (3): 67. doi:10.3390/h9030067. ProQuest 2427371686.
  23. ^ Kanter, Rosabeth M. (1977). Men and Women of the Corporation. Basic Books. ISBN 9780465044528.
  24. ^ a b c d Kanter 1993.
  25. ^ Jackson, Pamela Braboy; Thoits, Peggy A.; Taylor, Howard F. (1995). "Composition of the Workplace and Psychological Well-Being: The Effects of Tokenism on America's Black Elite". Social Forces. 74 (2): 543–557. doi:10.1093/sf/74.2.543.
  26. ^ Turner, Caroline Sotello Viernes (2002). "Women of Color in Academe: Living with Multiple Marginality". The Journal of Higher Education. 73 (1): 74–93. JSTOR 1558448.
  27. ^ Duffy, Andrew (9 April 2011). "More women, fewer chances". p. B3. Retrieved 16 July 2018.[failed verification].
  28. ^ a b Kanthak, Kristin; Krause, George A. (2012). The Diversity Paradox: Political Parties, Legislatures, and the Organizational Foundations of Representation in America. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0199891740.
  29. ^ Gray, Sadie (2008-07-17). "Ethnic minorities accuse TV programmers of tokenism". The Independent. London. Retrieved 2010-03-27.
  30. ^ Carter, Helen (2002-11-13). "Minorities accuse TV and radio of tokenism". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 2010-03-27.
  31. ^ "Response The new Wuthering Heights does not ignore racism; it tackles it full on | Comment is free". The Guardian. 2011-01-25. Retrieved 2012-02-13.
  32. ^ "Why Wuthering Heights gives me hope". The Guardian. 2011-01-25. Retrieved 2012-02-13.
  33. ^ French, Philip (2011-11-13). "Wuthering Heights – review | Film | The Observer". Guardian. Retrieved 2012-02-13.
  34. ^ "South Park Studios". Retrieved January 27, 2013.
  35. ^ "Tokenism & Tokenization Explained". YoungRippa59. 2021-08-14. Retrieved 2021-08-15.
  36. ^ Neighbors, R. C.; Rankin, Sandy (2011-07-27). The Galaxy Is Rated G: Essays on Children's Science Fiction Film and Television. McFarland. ISBN 978-0-7864-5875-2.
  37. ^ a b Nama, Adilifu (2010-01-01). Black Space: Imagining Race in Science Fiction Film. University of Texas Press. ISBN 978-0-292-77876-4.
  38. ^ Brode, Douglas; Deyneka, Leah (2012-07-02). Sex, Politics, and Religion in Star Wars: An Anthology. Scarecrow Press. ISBN 978-0-8108-8514-1.
  39. ^ a b c Harrison, Rebecca (June 2019). "Gender, Race and Representation in the Star Wars franchise: an Introduction". University of Glasgow: Media Education Journal. Issue 65: 16–19 – via AMES GoogleScholar.
  40. ^ Faithful, George (October 28, 2018). "Dark of the World, Shine on Us: The Redemption of Blackness in Ryan Coogler's Black Panther". Religions. 9 (10): 304. doi:10.3390/rel9100304. ProQuest 2125033129.
  41. ^ [1], Disney. Disney Princess, Disney Entertainment, https://princess.disney.com/.
  42. ^ [2], Vargas, Alani. “What Country Does Each Disney Princess Come from?” Showbiz Cheat Sheet, 14 May 2020, https://www.cheatsheet.com/entertainment/what-country-does-each-disney-princess-come-from.html/. .
  43. ^ [3],Yam, Kimberly [@KimmyThePooh] Twitter, 7 June 2020, https://twitter.com/kimmythepooh/status/1269428961391652864?lang=en.
  44. ^ [4], Elliott, Gina. “Rowling Reveals Harry Potter Secrets.” Time, Time Inc., 20 Oct. 2007, http://content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,1675622,00.html .
  45. ^ [5], Carmody, Broede. “J.K. Rowling Says Dumbledore and Grindelwald Had 'Passionate' Sexual Relationship.” The Sydney Morning Herald, The Sydney Morning Herald, 18 Mar. 2019, https://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/movies/jk-rowling-says-dumbledore-and-grindelwald-had-passionate-sexual-relationship-20190318-p5159p.html.

BibliographyEdit

External linksEdit

  •   The dictionary definition of tokenism at Wiktionary