Theodor Schwann (German pronunciation: [ˈteːodoːɐ̯ ˈʃvan]; 7 December 1810 – 11 January 1882) was a German physician and physiologist. His most significant contribution to biology is considered to be the extension of cell theory to animals. Other contributions include the discovery of Schwann cells in the peripheral nervous system, the discovery and study of pepsin, the discovery of the organic nature of yeast, and the invention of the term metabolism.
|Died||11 January 1882 (aged 71)|
|Awards||Copley Medal (1845)|
|Influences||Johannes Peter Müller|
Early life and education
Theodor Schwann was born in Neuss on 7 December 1810 to Leonard Schwann and Elisabeth Rottels. Leonard Schwann was a goldsmith and later a printer. Theodor Schwann studied at the Dreikönigsgymnasium (also known as the Tricoronatum or Three Kings School), a Jesuit school in Cologne. Schwann was a devout Roman Catholic. In Cologne his religious instructor Wilhelm Smets, a priest and novelist, emphasized the individuality of the human soul and the importance of free will.:643
In 1829 Schwann enrolled at the University of Bonn in the premedical curriculum. He received a bachelor of philosophy in 1831. While at Bonn, Schwann met and worked with physiologist Johannes Peter Müller. Müller is considered to have founded scientific medicine in Germany, publishing his Handbuch der Physiologie des Menschen für Vorlesungen in 1837–1840.:387 It was translated into English as Elements of Physiology in 1837–1843 and became the leading physiology textbook of the 1800s.
In 1831, Schwann moved to the University of Würzburg for clinical training in medicine. In 1833, he went to the University of Berlin, where Müller was now Professor of Anatomy and Physiology. Schwann graduated with an M.D. degree in medicine from the University of Berlin in 1834. He did his thesis work in 1833-1834, with Müller as his advisor. Schwann's thesis involved a careful study of the necessity for oxygen during the embryonic development of the chicken. To carry it out, he designed and built an apparatus that enabled him to pump the gases oxygen and hydrogen out of the incubation chamber at specific times. This enabled him to establish the critical period in which the eggs needed oxygen.:60
Schwann passed the state examination to practice medicine in the summer of 1834, but he chose to continue to work with Müller, doing research rather than practicing medicine. He could afford to do so, at least in the short term, because of a family inheritance.:60 His salary as an assistant was only 120 taler. For the next five years, Schwann would pay the other three-quarters of his expenses out of his inheritance. As a long-term strategy, it was not sustainable.:86
From 1834-1839, Schwann worked as an assistant to Müller in at the Anatomisch-zootomische Museum at the University of Berlin. Schwann carried out a series of microscopic and physiological experiments focused on studying the structure and function of nerves, muscles and blood vessels. In addition to performing experiments in preparation for Müller's book on physiology, Schwann did research of his own. Many of his important contributions were made during the time that he worked with Müller in Berlin.
Schwann used newly powerful microscopes to examine animal tissues. This enabled him to observe animal cells and note their different properties. His work complemented that of Matthias Jakob Schleiden in plants and was informed by it; the two were close friends.:60
Described as quiet and serious, Schwann was particularly gifted in the construction and use of apparatus for his experiments. He was also able to identify important scientific questions and design experiments to systematically test them. His writing has been described as accessible, and his logic as a "clear progression".:60 He identified the question that he wanted to answer and communicated the importance of his findings effectively to others. His co-worker Jakob Henle spoke of him as having an "inborn drive" to experiment.:60
By 1838, Schwann needed a position with a more substantial salary. He hoped to return to Bonn, a Catholic city. He attempted to gain a professorship there in 1838 and again in 1846, but was disappointed.:85–86 Instead, in 1839, Schwann accepted the chair of anatomy at the Université Catholique de Louvain in Leuven, Belgium, another Catholic city.:85–86
Schwann proved to be a dedicated and conscientious professor. With his new teaching duties, he had less time for new scientific work. He spent considerable time perfecting experimental techniques and instruments for use in experiments. He produced few papers. One exception was a paper in 1844 that reported on a series of experiments on dogs and established the importance of bile in digestion.:87
In examining processes such as muscle contraction, fermentation, digestion, and putrefaction, Schwann sought to show that living phenomena were the result of physical causes rather than "some immaterial vital force".:643 Nonetheless, he still sought to reconcile "an organic nature" with "a divine plan.":645 Some writers have suggested that Schwann's move in 1838, and his decreased scientific productivity after that, reflect religious concerns and perhaps even a crisis relating to the theoretical implications of his work on cell theory.:85–86 However, other authors regard this as misrepresenting his thinking, and reject the idea that Schwann went through an existential crisis or a mystical phase.:85–86 Ohad Parnes uses Schwann's laboratory notebooks and other unpublished sources along with his publications to reconstruct his research as a unified progression.:126 Florence Vienne draws on unpublished writings to discuss the ways in which cell theory, as a "unifying principle of organic development", related to the philosophical, religious, and political ideas of various proponents including Schwann.
In 1848, Schwann's compatriot Antoine Frédéric Spring convinced him to transfer to the University of Liège, also in Belgium. At Liège, Schwann continued to follow the latest advances in anatomy and physiology but did not himself make major new discoveries. He became something of an inventor. One of his projects was a portable respirator, designed as a closed system to support human life in environments where the surroundings cannot be breathed. By 1858 he was serving as professor of physiology, general anatomy and embryology. As of 1872, he ceased to teach general anatomy, and as of 1877, embryology. He retired fully in 1879.
Schwann was deeply respected by his peers. In 1878, a festival was held to celebrate his years of teaching and his many contributions. He was presented with a unique gift: a book containing 263 autographed photographic portraits of scientists from various countries, each of them sent by the scientist to be part of the gift for Schwann. The volume was dedicated "To the creator of the cell theory, the contemporary biologists."
When viewed in the context of his unpublished writings and laboratory notes, Schwann's research can be seen as "a coherent and systematic research programmme" in which biological processes are described in terms of material objects or "agents", and the causal dependencies between the forces that they exert, and their measurable effects. Schwann's idea of the cell as a fundamental, active unit then can be seen as foundational to the development of microbiology as "a rigorously lawful science".:121–122
Some of Schwann's earliest work in 1835 involved muscle contraction, which he saw as a starting point for "the introduction of calculation to physiology".:122 He developed and described an experimental method to calculate the contraction force of the muscle, by controlling and measuring the other variables involved. His measurement technique was developed and used later by Emil du Bois-Reymond and others. Schwann's notes suggest that he hoped to discover regularities and laws of physiological processes.
In 1835, relatively little was known about digestive processes. William Prout had reportd in 1824 that the digestive juices of animals contained hydrochloric acid. Schwann realized that other substances in digestive juices might also help to break down food. At the beginning of 1836, Schwann began to study digestive processes. He conceptualized digestion as the action of a physiological agent, which, though not immediately visible or measurable, could be characterized experimentally as a "peculiar specific substance".:124–125
Eventually Schwann found the enzyme pepsin, which he successfully isolated from the stomach lining and named in 1836. Schwann coined its name from the Greek word πέψις pepsis, meaning "digestion" (from πέπτειν peptein "to digest"). Pepsin was the first enzyme to be isolated from animal tissue. He demonstrated that it could break down the albumin from egg-white into peptones.
Even more importantly, Schwann wrote, by carrying through such analyses one could eventually "explain the whole developmental process of life in all organized bodies.":126 During the next year, he studied both decomposition and respiration, constructing apparatus that he would later adapt for the study of yeast.:128
Yeast, fermentation, and spontaneous generation
Next Schwann studied yeast and fermentation. His work on yeast was independent of work done by Charles Cagniard de la Tour and Friedrich Traugott Kützing, all of whom published work in 1837. By 1836, Schwann had carried out numerous experiments on alcohol fermentation. Powerful microscopes made it possible for him to observe yeast cells in detail and recognize that they were tiny organisms whose structures resembled those of plants.
Schwann went beyond others who simply had noted the multiplication of yeast during alcoholic fermentation, first by assigning yeast the role of a primary causal factor, and then by claiming it was alive. Schwann used the microscope to carry out a carefully planned series of experiments that contraindicated two popular theories of fermentation in yeast. First he controlled the temperature of fluid from fermenting beer in a closed vessel in the presence of oxygen. Once heated, the liquid could no longer ferment. This disproved Joseph Louis Gay-Lussac's speculation that oxygen caused fermentation. It suggested that some sort of microorganism was necessary for the process to happen. Next, Schwann tested the effects of purified air and unpurified air. He sterilized the air by passing it through heated glass bulbs. Fermentation did not occur in the presence of purified air. It did occur in the presence of unpurified air, suggesting that something in the air started the process. This was strong evidence against the theory of spontaneous generation, the idea that living organisms could develop out of nonliving matter.
Schwann had demonstrated that fermentation required the presence of yeasts to start, and stopped when the yeasts stopped growing. He concluded that sugar was converted to alcohol as part of an organic biological process based on the action of a living substance, the yeast. He demonstrated that fermentation was not an inorganic chemical process like sugar oxidation. Living yeast was necessary for the reaction that would produce more yeast.
Although Schwann was correct, his ideas were ahead of most of his peers. They were strongly opposed by Justus von Liebig and Friedrich Wöhler, both of whom saw his emphasis on the importance of a living organism as supporting vitalism. Liebig, in contrast, saw fermentation as a series of purely chemical events, without involving living matter. Ironically, Schwann's work was later seen as being a first step away from vitalism.:56–57 Schwann was the first of Müller's pupils to work towards a physico-chemical explanation of life. Schwann's view furthered a conceptualization of living things in terms of the biological reactions of organic chemistry, while Liebig sought to reduce biological reactions to purely inorganic chemistry.
The value of Schwann's work on fermentation eventually would be recognized by Louis Pasteur, ten years later. Pasteur would begin his fermentation research in 1857 by repeating and confirming Schwann's work, accepting that yeast were alive, and then taking fermentation research further. Pasteur, not Schwann, would challenge Liebig's views in the Liebig–Pasteur dispute. In retrospect, the germ theory of Pasteur, as well as its antiseptic applications by Lister, can be traced to Schwann's influence.
In 1837, Matthias Jakob Schleiden viewed and stated that new plant cells formed from the nuclei of old plant cells. Dining with Schwann one day, their conversation turned on the nuclei of plant and animal cells. Schwann remembered seeing similar structures in the cells of the notochord (as had been shown by Müller) and instantly realized the importance of connecting the two phenomena. The resemblance was confirmed without delay by both observers. In further experiments, Schwann examined notochordal tissue and cartilage from toad larvae, as well as tissues from pig embryos, establishing that animal tissues are composed of cells, each of which has a nucleus.
Schwann published his observations in 1838 in the Neue notisen geb. nat.-heilk. This was followed in 1839 by the publication of his book Mikroskopische Untersuchungen über die Uebereinstimmung in der Struktur und dem Wachsthum der Thiere und Pflanzen (Microscopic investigations on the similarity of structure and growth of animals and plants). It is considered a landmark work, foundational to modern biology.
In it Schwann declared that "All living things are composed of cells and cell products". He drew three further conclusions about cells, which formed his cell theory or cell doctrine. The first two were correct:
- The cell is the unit of structure, physiology, and organization in living things.
- The cell retains a dual existence as a distinct entity and a building block in the construction of organisms.
By the 1860s, these tenets were the accepted basis of cell theory, used to describe the elementary anatomical composition of plants and animals.
Schwann's theory and observations created a foundation for modern histology. Schwann claimed that "there is one universal principle of development for the elementary parts of organisms, however different, and this principle is the formation of cells." Schwann supported this claim by examining adult animal tissues and showing that all tissues could be classified in terms of five types of highly differentiated cellular tissues.
- cells that are independent and separate, e.g. blood cells
- cells that are independent but compacted together in layers, e.g. skin, fingernails, feathers
- cells whose connecting walls have coalesced, e.g. cartilage, bones, and tooth enamel
- elongated cells forming fibers, e.g. tendons and ligaments
- cells formed by the fusion of walls and cavities, e.g. muscles, tendons and nerves
Schwann's third tenet, speculating on the formation of cells, was later disproven. Schwann hypothesized that living cells formed in ways similar to the formation of crystals. Biologists would eventually accept the view of pathologist Rudolf Virchow, who popularized the maxim Omnis cellula e cellula—that every cell arises from another cell—in 1857. The epigram was originally put forth by François-Vincent Raspail in 1825, but Raspail's writings were unpopular, partly due to his republican sentiments. There is no evidence to suggest that Schwann and Raspail were aware of each other's work.:630–631
Schwann was particularly interested in nervous and muscular tissues. As part of his efforts to classify bodily tissues in terms of their cellular nature, he discovered the cells that envelope the nerve fibers, which are now called Schwann cells in his honor. How the fatty myelin sheaths of peripheral nerves were formed was a matter of debate that could not be answered until the electron microscope was invented. All axons in the peripheral nervous system are now known to be wrapped in Schwann cells. Their mechanisms continue to be studied.
Schwann also discovered that muscle tissue in the upper esophagus was striated. He speculated that the muscular nature of the esophagus enabled it to act as a pipe, moving food between the mouth and the stomach.
In examining teeth, Schwann was the first to notice "cylindrical cells" connected to both the inner surface of the enamel and the pulp. He also identified fibrils in the dentinal tubes, which later became known as "Tomes's fibers". He speculated on the possible structural and functional significance of the tubes and fibrils.
In his Microscopical researches, Schwann introduced the term "metabolism", which he first used in the German adjectival form "metabolische" to describe the chemical action of cells. French texts in the 1860s began to use le métabolisme. Metabolism was introduced into English by Michael Foster in his Textbook of Physiology in 1878.
- Dudenredaktion; Kleiner, Stefan; Knöbl, Ralf (2015) [First published 1962]. Das Aussprachewörterbuch [The Pronunciation Dictionary] (in German) (7th ed.). Berlin: Dudenverlag. pp. 771, 834. ISBN 978-3-411-04067-4.
- Krech, Eva-Maria; Stock, Eberhard; Hirschfeld, Ursula; Anders, Lutz Christian (2009). Deutsches Aussprachewörterbuch [German Pronunciation Dictionary] (in German). Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. pp. 914, 987. ISBN 978-3-11-018202-6.
- Chisholm, Hugh (1911). "Schwann, Theodor". Encyclopædia Britannica (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press.
- "Theodor Schwann German physiologist". Encyclopaedia Britannica. Retrieved 31 October 2018.
- Price, Catherine (2018). "Probing the Mysteries of Human Digestion". Distillations. 4 (2): 27–35. Retrieved 30 October 2018.
- "Theodor Schwann". Famous Scientists. Retrieved 1 November 2018.
- Thomas, Tony Abraham (2017). "Theodor Schwann: A founding father of biology and medicine". Current Medical Issues. 15 (4): 299. doi:10.4103/cmi.cmi_81_17. Retrieved 1 November 2018.
- Vienne, Florence (28 November 2017). "Worlds Conflicting". Historical Studies in the Natural Sciences. 47 (5): 629–652. doi:10.1525/hsns.2017.47.5.629. Retrieved 5 November 2018.
- Oppenheimer, Jane (1963). "Review: LIVES AND LETTERS OF THEODOR SCHWANN A REVIEW Reviewed Work: Lettres de Théodore Schwann by Marcel Florkin". Bulletin of the History of Medicine. 37 (1): 78–83. JSTOR 44446900.
- Garrison, Fielding Hudson (8 December 2013). An Introduction to the History of Medicine, with Medical Chronology, Bibliographic Data and Test Questions - Primary Source Edition. Nabu Press. pp. 387–404, 416. ISBN 978-1295393169. Retrieved 31 October 2018.
- "Schwann, Theodor Ambrose Hubert". Max Planck Institute for the History of Science. Retrieved 31 October 2018.
- Otis, Laura (5 April 2007). Müller's lab. Oxford University Press. pp. 60–76. ISBN 9780195306972. Retrieved 31 October 2018.
- Aubert, Genviève (2003). "Theodor Schwann" (PDF). In Aminoff, Michael; Daroff, Robert (eds.). Encyclopedia of the Neurological Sciences. San Diego: Academic Press. pp. 215–217. Retrieved 3 March 2015.
- Hajdu, Steven I. (2002). "A note from history: Introduction of the cell theory". Annals of Clinical and Laboratory Science. 32 (1): 98–100. PMID 11848625. Retrieved 31 October 2018.
- Parnes, Ohad (11 April 2006). "From agents to cells: Theodor Schwann's research notes of the years 1835 to 1838". In Holmes, F. L.; Renn, J.; Rheinberger, Hans-Jörg (eds.). Reworking the bench : research notebooks in the history of science. Kluwer Academic Publishers. pp. 123–. ISBN 978-0-306-48152-9. Retrieved 6 November 2018.
- Karenberg, Axel (26 October 2000). "Chapter 7. The Schwann cell". In Koehler, Peter J.; Bruyn, George W.; Pearce, John M. S. (eds.). Neurological eponyms. Oxford University Press. pp. 44–50. ISBN 9780195133660. Retrieved 8 November 2018.
- Finkelstein, Gabriel (2013). Emil du Bois-Reymond : neuroscience, self, and society in nineteenth-century Germany. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. pp. 51–52. ISBN 9780262019507.
- Miller, David; Millar, Ian; Millar, John; Millar, Margaret (25 July 2002). The Cambridge Dictionary of Scientists (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press. pp. 320–321. ISBN 9780511074141. Retrieved 2 November 2018.
- Florkin M (March 1957). "[Discovery of pepsin by Theodor Schwann]". Revue Médicale de Liège (in French). 12 (5): 139–44. PMID 13432398.
- Asimov, Isaac (1980). A short history of biology. Westport, Conn: Greenwood Press. p. 95. ISBN 978-0-313-22583-3.
- Modlin, Irvin M.; Sachs, George (2004). Acid related diseases : biology and treatment (2nd ed.). Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. p. 195. ISBN 978-0781741231. Retrieved 8 November 2018.
- Meulders, Michel (2010). Helmholtz : from enlightenment to neuroscience (PDF). MIT Press. pp. 56–60. Retrieved 31 October 2018.
- Schlenk, Fritz (1997). "Early Research on Fermentation — a Story of Missed Opportunities" (PDF). In Cornish-Bowden, A. (ed.). New Beer in an Old Bottle: Eduard Buchner and the Growth of Biochemical Knowledge. Valencia, Spain: Universitat de València. pp. 43–50. Retrieved 2 November 2018.
- Schwann, Th. (1837). "Vorläufige Mittheilung, betreffend Versuche über die Weingährung und Fäulniss". Annalen der Physik und Chemie. 117 (5): 184–193. doi:10.1002/andp.18371170517. ISSN 0003-3804.
- "Schwann, Theodor (1810-1882)". Eric Weisstein's World of Biography. Retrieved 2 November 2018.
- Springer, Alfred (13 October 1892). "The Micro-organisms of the Soil". Nature. 46 (1198): 576–579. Bibcode:1892Natur..46R.576.. doi:10.1038/046576b0. ISSN 0028-0836.
- Berche, P. (October 2012). "Louis Pasteur, from crystals of life to vaccination". Clinical Microbiology and Infection. 18: 1–6. doi:10.1111/j.1469-0691.2012.03945.x. PMID 22882766. Retrieved 3 November 2018.
- Lafar, Franz; Salter, T. C. (1898). Technical Mycology: Schizomycetic fermentation. C. Griffin and company, limited. pp. 18–19. Retrieved 3 November 2018.
- Geisler, Eliezer; Heller, Ori (1998). Management of medical technology : theory, practice, and cases. Kluwer Academic Publishers. pp. 267–268. ISBN 9780792380542. Retrieved 3 November 2018.
- Schwann T. Ueber die Analogie in der Structur und dem Wachsthum der Thiere und Pflanzen. Neue Not Geb Nat Heil, 1838;Jan:33–36; 1838;Feb:25–29; 1838;Apr:21–23.
- Rhoads, Dan (5 November 2007). "History of Cell Biology". Bite Size Bio. Retrieved 31 October 2018.
- Schwann, Theodor (1839). Microscopical Researches into the Accordance in the Structure and Growth of Animals and Plants. Berlin: Printed for the Sydenham Society. (English translation by Henry Smith, for the Sydenham Society, 1847)
- Williams, Henry Smith (1900). The Story of Nineteenth-century Science. Harper & Brothers. ISBN 978-1145376991. Retrieved 6 November 2018.
- Rogers, Kara (15 January 2011). Medicine and healers through history (1st ed.). Britannica Educational Pub. p. 132. ISBN 9781615303670. Retrieved 5 November 2018.
- Bunge, R P; Bunge, M B; Eldridge, C F (March 1986). "Linkage Between Axonal Ensheathment and Basal Lamina Production by Schwann Cells". Annual Review of Neuroscience. 9 (1): 305–328. doi:10.1146/annurev.ne.09.030186.001513. PMID 3518587.
- "Schwann cell". Encyclopaedia Britannica. Retrieved 31 October 2018.
- Jacobson, Marcus (14 March 2013). Developmental neurobiology (3rd ed.). Plenum Press. ISBN 978-0306437977. Retrieved 6 November 2018.
- Rosso, Gonzalo; Young, Peter; Shahin, Victor (25 October 2017). "Implications of Schwann Cells Biomechanics and Mechanosensitivity for Peripheral Nervous System Physiology and Pathophysiology". Frontiers in Molecular Neuroscience. 10: 345. doi:10.3389/fnmol.2017.00345. PMC 5660964. PMID 29118694.
- Schlager, Neil; Lauer, Josh (2000). Science and its times : understanding the social significance of scientific discovery. Gale Group. p. 287. ISBN 978-0787639372.
- Baume, Louis J. (1980). The biology of pulp and dentine : a historic, terminologic-taxonomic, histologic-biochemical, embryonic and clinical survey. S. Karger. ISBN 9783805530323.
- Heilbron, John L. (2003). The Oxford companion to the history of modern science. Oxford University Press. p. 513. ISBN 9780195112290. Retrieved 8 November 2018.
- Aszmann, O. C. (2000). "The life and work of Theodore Schwann". Journal of Reconstructive Microsurgery. 16 (4): 291–5. doi:10.1055/s-2000-7336. PMID 10871087.
- Florkin, M. (1958). "Episodes in medicine of the people from Liège: Schwann & the stigmatized". Revue Médicale de Liège. 13 (18): 627–38. PMID 13591909.
- Florkin, M. (1957). "1838; Year of crisis in the life of Théodore Schwann". Revue Médicale de Liège. 12 (18): 503–10. PMID 13466730.
- Florkin, M. (1957). "Discovery of pepsin by Theodor Schwann". Revue Médicale de Liège. 12 (5): 139–44. PMID 13432398.
- Florkin, M. (1951). "Schwann as medical student". Revue Médicale de Liège. 6 (22): 771–7.
- Florkin, M. (October 1951). "Schwann at the Tricoronatum". Revue Médicale de Liège. 6 (20): 696–703. PMID 14883601.
- Florkin, M. (1951). "The family and childhood of Schwann". Revue Médicale de Liège. 6 (9): 231–8. PMID 14845235.
- Haas, L. F. (1999). "Neurological stamp. Theodore Schwann (1810–82)". J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry. 66 (1): 103. doi:10.1136/jnnp.66.1.103. PMC 1736145. PMID 9886465.
- Hayashi, M. (1992). "Theodor Schwann and reductionism". Kagakushi Kenkyu. 31 (184): 209–14. PMID 11639601.
- Kiszely, G. (1983). "Theodor Schwann". Orvosi Hetilap. 124 (16): 959–62. PMID 6343953.
- Kosinski, C. M. (2004). "Theodor Schwann". Der Nervenarzt. 75 (12): 1248. doi:10.1007/s00115-004-1805-5. PMID 15368056.
- Kruta, V. (1987). "The idea of the primary unity of elements in the microscopic structure of animals and plants. J. E. Purkynĕ and Th. Schwann". Folia Mendeliana. 22: 35–50. PMID 11621603.
- Lukács, D. (April 1982). "Centenary of the death of Theodor Schwann". Orvosi Hetilap. 123 (14): 864–6. PMID 7043357.
- Watermann, R. (1973). "Theodor Schwann accepted the honorable appointment abroad". Medizinische Monatsschrift. 27 (1): 28–31. PMID 4576700.
- Watermann, R. (1960). "Theodor Schwann as a maker of lifesaving apparatus". Die Medizinische Welt. 50: 2682–7. PMID 13783359.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Theodor Schwann.|
- Works by or about Theodor Schwann at Internet Archive
- Schwann, Theodor and Schleyden, M. J. 1847. Microscopical researches into the accordance in the structure and growth of animals and plants. London: Printed for the Sydenham Society
- Herbermann, Charles, ed. (1913). . Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company.