History of English grammars
The history of English grammars begins late in the sixteenth century with the Pamphlet for Grammar by William Bullokar. In the early works, the structure and rules of English grammar were contrasted with those of Latin. A more modern approach, incorporating phonology, was introduced in the nineteenth century.
Sixteenth to eighteenth centuriesEdit
The first English grammar, Pamphlet for Grammar by William Bullokar, written with the seeming goal of demonstrating that English was quite as rule-bound as Latin, was published in 1586. Bullokar's grammar was faithfully modeled on William Lily's Latin grammar, Rudimenta Grammatices (1534). Lily's grammar was being used in schools in England at that time, having been "prescribed" for them in 1542 by Henry VIII. Although Bullokar wrote his grammar in English and used a "reformed spelling system" of his own invention, many English grammars, for much of the century after Bullokar's effort, were to be written in Latin; this was especially so for books whose authors were aiming to be scholarly. Christopher Cooper's Grammatica Linguæ Anglicanæ (1685) was the last English grammar written in Latin.
The yoke of Latin grammar writing bore down oppressively on much of the early history of English grammars. Any attempt by one author to assert an independent grammatical rule for English was quickly followed by equal avowals by others of truth of the corresponding Latin-based equivalent. Even as late as the early nineteenth century, Lindley Murray, the author of one of the most widely used grammars of the day, was having to cite "grammatical authorities" to bolster the claim that grammatical cases in English are different from those in Ancient Greek or Latin.
The focus on tradition, however, belied the role that other social forces had already begun to play in the early seventeenth century. In particular, increasing commerce, and the social changes it wrought, created new impetus for grammar writing. On the one hand, greater British role in international trade created demand for English grammars for speakers of other languages. Many such grammars were published in various European languages in the second half of the seventeenth century. On the other hand, English grammars began to reach a wider audience within Britain itself. They spread beyond their erstwhile readership of "learned," privileged, adult males to other groups of native speakers such as women, merchants, tradesmen, and even schoolboys. Consequently, by the early eighteenth century, many grammars, such as John Brightland's A Grammar of the English tongue (1711) and James Greenwood's Essay towards a practical English grammar, were targeting people without "Latin background," including the "fair sex" and children.
If by the end of the seventeenth century English grammar writing had made a modest start, totaling 16 new grammars since Bullokar's Pamphlet of 115 years before, by the end of the eighteenth, the pace was positively brisk; 270 new titles were added during that century. Both publishing and demand, moreover, would continue to mushroom. The first half of the nineteenth century would see the appearance of almost 900 new books on English grammar. Showing little originality, most new books took the tack of claiming—as justification for their appearance—that the needs of their particular target audience were still unmet or that a particular "grammatical point" had not been treated adequately in the preexisting texts, or oftentimes both. Texts that were both utilitarian and egalitarian were proliferating everywhere. Edward Shelley's The people's grammar; or English grammar without difficulties for 'the million' (1848), for example, was written for "the mechanic and hard-working youth, in their solitary struggles for the acquirement of knowledge." Similarly, William Cobbett's popular mid-century book was titled, A Grammar of the English Language, In a Series of Letters: Intended for the Use of Schools and of Young Persons in General, but more especially for the use of Soldiers, Sailors, Apprentices, and Plough-Boys.
Eighteenth-century prescriptive grammarsEdit
Robert Lowth, Bishop of Oxford and thereafter of London, scholar of Hebrew poetry, and for a short time Oxford Professor of Poetry, was the first and the best known of the widely emulated grammarians of the 18th century. A self-effacing clergyman, he published A Short Introduction to English Grammar, with critical notes (1762), his only work on the subject, without the author's name on the title page. His influence extended, through the works of his students Lindley Murray and William Cobbett, well into the late 19th century. He would also become, among prescriptive grammarians, the target of choice for the criticism meted out by later descriptivist linguists. Lowth wrote against preposition stranding, using "whose" as the possessive case of "which", and using "who" instead of "whom" in certain cases.
In 2003, scholar Karen Cajka described nine Englishwomen who published grammars in the late eighteenth century: Ellin Devis, Dorothea Du Bois, Mrs. M. C. Edwards, Mrs. Eves, Ellenor Fenn (aka Mrs. Teachwell and Mrs. Lovechild), Ann Fisher, Jane Gardiner née Arden, Blanche Mercy, and Mrs. Taylor. They "together published a total of twelve discrete grammars, with over one hundred documented editions appearing well into the nineteenth century". The study of English grammar was seen as important in learning how to write English well, and in learning other languages later.
Nineteenth century to presentEdit
It was during the nineteenth century that modern-language studies became systematized. In the case of English, this happened first in continental Europe, where it was studied by historical and comparative linguists. In 1832, Danish philologist Rasmus Rask published an English grammar, Engelsk Formlære, part of his extensive comparative studies in the grammars of Indo-European languages. German philologist Jacob Grimm, the elder of the Brothers Grimm, included English grammar in his monumental grammar of Germanic languages, Deutsche Grammatik (1822–1837). German historical linguist Eduard Adolf Maetzner published his 1,700 page Englische Grammatik between 1860 and 1865; an English translation, An English grammar: methodical, analytical and historical appeared in 1874. Contributing little new to the intrinsic scientific study of English grammar, these works nonetheless showed that English was being studied seriously by the first professional linguists.
As phonology became a full-fledged field, spoken English began to be studied scientifically as well, generating by the end of the nineteenth century an international enterprise investigating the structure of the language. This enterprise comprised scholars at various universities, their students who were training to be teachers of English, and journals publishing new research. All the pieces were in place for new "large-scale English grammars" which combined the disparate approaches of the previous decades. The first work to lay claim to the new scholarship was British linguist Henry Sweet's A new English grammar: logical and historical, published in two parts, Phonology and Accidence (1892) and Syntax (1896), its title suggesting not only continuity and contrast with Maetzner's earlier work, but also kinship with the contemporary A New English Dictionary on Historical Principles (begun 1884), later the Oxford English Dictionary (1895). Two other contemporary English grammars were also influential. English Grammar: Past and Present, by John Collinson Nesfield, was originally written for the market in colonial India. It was later expanded to appeal to students in Britain as well, from young men preparing for various professional examinations to students in "Ladies' Colleges." Other books by Nesfield include A Junior Course In English Composition, A Senior Course In English Composition, but it was his A Manual Of English Grammar and Composition that proved really successful both in Britain and her colonies—so much so that it formed the basis for many other grammar and composition primers including but not limited to Warriner's English Grammar and Composition, and High School English Grammar and Composition, casually called Wren & Martin, by P.C. Wren and H. Martin. Grammar of spoken English (1924), by H. E. Palmer, written for the teaching and study of English as a foreign language, included a full description of the intonation patterns of English.
The next set of wide-ranging English grammars were written by Danish and Dutch linguists. Danish linguist Otto Jespersen, who had coauthored a few books with Henry Sweet, began work on his seven-volume Modern English grammar on historical principles in the first decade of the twentieth century. The first volume, Sounds and Spellings, was published in 1909; it then took forty years for the remaining volumes on syntax (volumes 2 through 5), morphology (volume 6), and syntax again (volume 7), to be completed. Jespersen's original contribution was in analyzing the various parts of a sentence in terms of categories that he named, rank, junction, and nexus, forgoing the usual word classes. His ideas would inspire the later work of Noam Chomsky and Randolph Quirk.
The Dutch tradition of writing English grammars, which began with Thomas Basson's The Conjugations in Englische and Netherdutche in the same year—1586—as William Bullokar's first English grammar (written in English), gained renewed strength in the early 20th century in the work of three grammarians: Hendrik Poutsma, Etsko Kruisinga, and Reinard Zandvoort. Poutsma's Grammar of late modern English, published between 1904 and 1929 and written for "continental, especially Dutch students," selected all its examples from English literature.
Timeline of English grammarsEdit
- 1551. John Hart The opening of the unreasonable writing of our English toung
- 1586. William Bullokar: Brief Grammar of English.
- 1594. Paul Greaves: Grammatica Anglicana.
- 1617. Alexander Hume: Orthographie and Congruitie of the Britan Tongue.
- 1619/1621. Alexander Gill: Logonomia Anglica.
- 1634. Charles Butler: English Grammar.
- 1640. Ben Jonson: The English Grammar.
- 1646. Joshua Poole: The English Accidence.
- 1653. John Wallis: Grammatica Linguæ Anglicanæ.
- 1654. Jeremiah Wharton: The English Grammar.
- 1662. James Howell: A New English Grammar.
- 1669. John Newton: School Pastime for Young Children: or the Rudiments of Grammar.
- 1671. Thomas Lye: The Child's Delight.
- 1685. Christopher Cooper: Grammatica Linguæ Anglicanæ.
- 1688. Guy Miège: The English Grammar.
- 1693. Joseph Aickin: The English grammar.
- 1700. A. Lane: A Key to the Art of Letters.
- 1745. Ann Fisher (grammarian) A New Grammar.
- 1761. Joseph Priestley: The Rudiments of English Grammar:Adapted to the Use of Schools.
- 1762. Robert Lowth: A short introduction to English grammar: with critical notes.
- 1763. John Ash: Grammatical institutes: or, An easy introduction to Dr. Lowth's English grammar.
- 1765. William Ward: An Essay on English Grammar.
- 1766. Samuel Johnson: A dictionary of the English Language...: to which is prefixed, a Grammar of the English Language.
- 1772. Joseph Priestley: The Rudiments of English Grammar: Adapted to the Use of Schools.
- 1775. Ellin Devis: The Accidence
- 1772. Dorothea Du Bois: Short English Grammar
- 1795. Lindley Murray: English grammar: adapted to the different classes of learners.
- 1799. Jane Gardiner: Young Ladies’ Grammar
- 1804. Noah Webster: A Grammatical Institute of the English Language.
- 1809. William Hazlitt: A New and Improved Grammar of the English Tongue
- 1818. William Cobbett: A Grammar of the English Language, In a Series of Letters.
- 1850. William Chauncey Fowler: English grammar: The English language in its elements and forms.
- 1874 Eduard Adolf Maetzner, An English grammar: methodical, analytical, and historical. With a treatise on the orthography, prosody, inflections and syntax of the English tongue, and numerous authorities cited in order of historical development. (English translation of Englische Grammatik (1860–65)).
- 1892/98. Henry Sweet: A New English Grammar, Logical and Historical (Part 1: Introduction, Phonology, and Accidence; Part 2: Syntax).
- 1904–1929. Hendrik Poutsma: A Grammar of Modern English (5 volumes).
- 1909–1932. Etsko Kruisinga: A Handbook of Present-day English
- 1909–1949. Otto Jespersen: A Modern English Grammar on Historical Principles.
- 1931/1935. George O. Curme: A Grammar of the English Language.
- 1945. R. W. Zandvoort: A Handbook of English Grammar.
- 1952. Charles C. Fries: The Structure of English: An Introduction to the Construction of English Sentences.
- 1984. M. A. K. Halliday: An Introduction to Functional Grammar.
- 1985. Randolph Quirk, Sidney Greenbaum, Geoffrey Leech, and Jan Svartvik: A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language.
- 1999. Douglas Biber, Stig Johansson, Geoffrey Leech, Susan Conrad, and Edward Finegan: Longman Grammar of Spoken and Written English.
- 2002. Rodney Huddleston and Geoffrey Pullum: The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language.
- 2006. Ronald Carter and Michael McCarthy: The Cambridge Grammar of English.
- 2011. Bas Aarts: Oxford Modern English Grammar.
- Linn 2008, p. 74
- Lily 1709, original 1534
- Linn 2008, p. 74, Dons 2004, pp. 16–17
- Linn, p. 75
- Linn, p. 76
- Cajka, Karen (2003). The forgotten women grammarians of eighteenth-century England (Doctoral Dissertations. Paper AAI3118940. ed.). University of Connecticut. Retrieved 11 December 2015.
- Hilton, Mary; Shefrin, Jill (2009). Educating the Child in Enlightenment Britain: Beliefs, Cultures, Practices. Ashgate Publishing, Ltd. p. 83.
- Linn, pp. 78–79
- Linn 2008, p. 80
- Linn 2008, p. 81
- Linn 2008, p. 82
- Bullokar 1586a, Bullokar 1586b, Dons 2004, p. 7
- Dons 2004, pp. 8–9
- Dons 2004, pp. 10–12
- Dons 2004, pp. 10–12, Jonson 1756, original 1640
- Dons 2004, pp. 13–15
- Dons 2004, pp. 16–17
- Fisher 1750, original 1745
- Lowth 1775, original 1762
- Ash 1810, original 1763
- Ward 1765, Ward 1767
- Johnson 1766
- Priestley 1772, Hodson 2008
- Percy, Carol (1994). "Paradigms for their Sex? Women's Grammars in Late Eighteenth-Century England". Histoire Epistemologie Langage. 16: 123.
- DNB 00
- Murray 1809, original 1795, Murray 1838, original 1797
- Michael, Ian (1970). English Grammatical Categories and the Tradition to 1800. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Webster 1804, Webster 1822
- Cobbett 1883, original 1818
- Fowler 1881, original 1850
- Maetzner & Grece 1874a, Maetzner & Grece 1874c, Linn 2008, p. 79
- Sweet 1900, original 1892, Sweet 1898, Linn 2008, p. 79
- Poutsma 1904–1929, Linn 2008, p. 81
- Kruisinga 1909–1932, Linn 2008, p. 82
- Jespersen 1909–1940
- Curme 1931, Curme 1935
- Zandvoort 1945, Linn 2008, p. 82
- Fries 1952, Linn 2008, p. 83
- Halliday 1984
- Quirk et al. 1985
- Biber et al. Finegan
- Huddleston & Pullum 2002
- Carter & McCarthy 2006
- Aarts 2011
- Aarts, Bas (2011), Oxford Modern English Grammar, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Ash, John (1810, original 1763), Grammatical institutes: or, An easy introduction to Dr. Lowth's English grammar Check date values in:
- Auer, Anita (2008), "Eighteenth-century grammars and book catalogues", in Tieken-Boon van Ostade, Ingrid, Grammars, Grammarians and Grammar-Writing in Eighteenth-Century England, Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter, pp. 57–78, ISBN 978-3-11-019627-6
- Bullokar, William (1586a), Bref Grammar for English, London:Edmund Bollifant
- Biber, Douglas; Johansson, Stig; Leech, Geoffrey; Conrad, Susan; Finegan, Edward (1999), Longman grammar of spoken and written English, Pearson Education Limited. Pp. 1203, ISBN 0-582-23725-4
- Brown, Goold (1851, original 1836), The grammar of English grammars: with an introduction, historical and critical, New York: Samuel S. & William Wood. Pp. 1028 Check date values in:
- Bullokar, William (1586b), William Bullokarz Pamphlet for Grammar, London:Edmund Bollifant
- Carter, Ronald.; McCarthy, Michael., eds. (2006), The Cambridge Grammar of English Language, Cambridge University Press. Pp. 973, ISBN 0-521-58846-4
- Cobbett, William (1883, original 1818), A Grammar of the English Language, In a Series of Letters: Intended for the Use of Schools and of Young Persons in General, but more especially for the use of Soldiers, Sailors, Apprentices, and Plough-Boys, New York and Chicago: A. S. Barnes and Company Check date values in:
- Curme, George O. (1931), A Grammar of the English Language, Volume 3: Syntax, Boston: D. C. Heath
- Curme, George O. (1935), A Grammar of the English Language, Volume 2: Parts of Speech and Accidence, Boston: D. C. Heath
- Dons, Ute (2004), Descriptive adequacy of early modern English grammars, Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. Pp. 304, ISBN 3-11-018193-2
- Finegan, Edward (1999), "English grammar and usage", in Romaine, Suzanne, The Cambridge history of the English language, volume IV, 1776–1997, Cambridge University Press. Pp. 783, pp. 536–588, ISBN 0-521-26477-4
- Fowler, William Chauncey (1881, original 1850), English grammar: The English language in its elements and forms. With a history of its origin and development. Designed for use in colleges and schools, New York: Harper & Brothers, Publishers Check date values in:
- Fries, Charles Carpenter (1952), The Structure of English: An Introduction to the Construction of English Sentences, New York: Harcourt, Brace, and Company
- Glau, Gregory R. (1993), "Mirroring Ourselves? The Pedagogy of Early Grammar Texts", Rhetoric Review, 11 (2): 418–435, doi:10.1080/07350199309389015, JSTOR 465811
- Görlach, Manfred (1999), English in nineteenth-century England: an introduction, Cambridge University Press. Pp. 338, ISBN 0-521-47684-4
- Halliday, M. A. K. (1984), Introduction to Functional Grammar, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, ISBN 0-674-46120-7
- Harry, Philip (1907), "Reviewed work(s): Geschichte der Fabeldichtung in England bis zu John Gay (1726). by Max Plessow", Modern Language Notes, 22 (5): 157–158, JSTOR 2916967
- Hodson, Jane (2008), "Joseph Priestley's two Rudiments of English Grammar: 1761 and 1768", in Tieken-Boon van Ostade, Ingrid, Grammars, Grammarians and Grammar-Writing in Eighteenth-Century England, Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter, pp. 177–190, ISBN 978-3-11-019627-6
- Howatt, Philip Reid; Widdowson, H. G. (2004), A History of English Language Teaching, Oxford University Press. Pp. 417, ISBN 0-19-442185-6
- Huddleston, Rodney D.; Pullum, Geoffrey K., eds. (2002). The Cambridge grammar of the English language. Cambridge University Press. Pp. 1860. ISBN 0-521-43146-8.
- Jespersen, Otto (1909–1940), A modern English grammar on historical principles (volumes 1–7), Heidelberg: C. Winter
- Jonson, Ben (1756, original 1640), "The English grammar: Made by Ben Jonson for the benefit of all strangers, out of his observation of the English language now spoken and in use", The Works of Ben Jonson: Volume 7, London: D. Midwinter et al Check date values in:
- Johnson, Samuel (1766), A dictionary of the English Language...: to which is prefixed, a Grammar of the English Language, London: A. Millar et al
- Kruisinga, Etsko (1909–1932), A Handbook of Present-day English, 4 volumes, Utrecht: Kemink en zoon
- Linn, Andrew (2006), "English grammar writing", in Aarts, Bas; McMahon, April, Handbook of English Linguistics, Wiley-Blackwell. Pp. 824, pp. 72–92, ISBN 1-4051-8787-5
- Fisher, Ann (1750, original 1745), A New Grammar of the English Language with Exercises of Bad English, Newcastle: I. Thompson Check date values in:
- Lowth, Robert (1775, original 1762), A short introduction to English grammar: with critical notes, London: J. Dodsley and T. Cadell Check date values in:
- Maetzner, Eduard Adolf Ferdinand Maetzner; Grece, (Translator) Clair James (1874a), An English grammar: methodical, analytical, and historical. With a treatise on the orthography, prosody, inflections and syntax of the English tongue, and numerous authorities cited in order of historical development. Volume I, London: J. Murray; Boston: Robert Brothers
- Maetzner, Eduard Adolf Ferdinand Maetzner; Grece, (Translator) Clair James (1874c), An English grammar: methodical, analytical, and historical. With a treatise on the orthography, prosody, inflections and syntax of the English tongue, and numerous authorities cited in order of historical development. Volume III, London: J. Murray; Boston: Robert Brothers
- Michael, Ian (1970), English Grammatical Categories and the Tradition to 1800, Cambridge University Press. Pp. 622, ISBN 0-521-07634-X
- Michael, Ian (1987), The teaching of English: from the sixteenth century to 1870, Cambridge University Press. Pp. 634, ISBN 0-521-24196-0
- Murray, Lindley (1809, original 1795), English grammar: adapted to the different classes of learners, 17th edition, Philadelphia: Benjamin Johnson et al. Pp. 308 Check date values in:
- Murray, Lindley (1838, original 1797), Abridgment of Murray's English Grammar: With an Appendix, Containing Exercises in Orthography, in Parsing, in Syntax, and in Punctuation: Designed for the Younger Classes of Learners, Philadelphia: J. and W. Paul Check date values in:
- Plessow, Max (1906), Geschichte der Fabeldichtung in England bis zu John Gay (1726). Nebat Neudruck von Bullokars "Fables of Æsop," 1585, "Booke at Large" 1580, "Bref Grammar for English" 1586, und "Pamphlet for Grammar" 1586, Berlin: Mayer und Müller. Pp. 392
- Poutsma, Hendrik (1904–1929), A Grammar of Modern English: for the use of continental, especially Dutch, students. Five Volumes, volume 1: The Sentence, Section 1: The Elements of the Sentence (1904), Groningen: P. Noordhoff. Pp. 348
- Poutsma, Hendrik (1904–1929), A Grammar of Modern English: for the use of continental, especially Dutch, students. Five Volumes, volume 1: The Sentence, Section 2: The Composite Sentence (1905), Groningen: P. Noordhoff. Pp. 461
- Priestley, Joseph (1772), The Rudiments of English Grammar: Adapted to the Use of Schools, London: J. and F. Rivington, T. Lowndes, S. Crowder, T. Becket, and J. Johnson. Pp. 202
- Quirk, Randolph; Greenbaum, Sidney; Leech, Geoffrey; Svartvik, Jan (1985), A comprehensive grammar of the English language, Harlow: Longman. Pp. 1779, ISBN 0-582-51734-6
- Storm, Johan Frederik Breda (1892), Englische Philologie, volume 1, part 1, Leipzig: O. R. Reisland. Pp. 484
- Storm, Johan Frederik Breda (1896), Englische Philologie, volume 1, part 2, Leipzig: O. R. Reisland. Pp. 614
- Sweet, Henry (1900, original 1892), A New English Grammar, Logical and Historical, Part 1, Introduction, Phonology, and Accidence, Oxford: Clarendon Press Check date values in:
- Sweet, Henry (1898), A New English Grammar, Logical and Historical, Part 2, Syntax, Oxford: Clarendon Press
- Tieken-Boon van Ostade, Ingrid (2006), "English at the onset of the normative tradition", in Mugglestone, Lynda, The Oxford history of English, Oxford University Press. Pp. 485, pp. 240–273, ISBN 0-19-924931-8
- Tieken-Boon van Ostade, Ingrid, ed. (2008), Grammars, Grammarians and Grammar-Writing in Eighteenth-Century England, Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter, ISBN 978-3-11-019627-6
- Ward, William (1765), An essay on grammar as it may be applied to the English language, London: Horsfield
- Ward, William (1767), A grammar of the English language, in two treatises: The first, containing rules for every part of its construction, The second, shewing the nature of the several parts of speech, York: A. Ward, for C. Etherington. Pp. 271
- Webster, Noah (1804), A grammatical institute of the English language: comprising an easy, concise, and systematic method of education designed for the use of English schools in America. Part second, containing a plain and comprehensive grammar grounded on the true principles and idioms of the language, New York: E. Duyckinck. Pp. 116
- Webster, Noah (1822), A Philosophical and Practical Grammar of the English Language, New Haven: Howe & Spalding. Pp. 223
- Zandvoort, Reinard Willem (1945), A handbook of English grammar, Groningen: Wolters-Noordhoff. Pp. 349