Butter (2011 film)
Butter is a 2011 comedy film directed by Jim Field Smith, from a screenplay by Jason Micallef, starring Yara Shahidi, Jennifer Garner, Ty Burrell, Olivia Wilde, Rob Corddry, Ashley Greene, Alicia Silverstone, and Hugh Jackman. It was released on October 5, 2012 in the United States and Canada by The Weinstein Company. The film is said to be a satire of the 2008 Democratic presidential primary. Butter received mixed reviews from critics who questioned Smith's direction of the film's script in terms of humor and satire and the performances from the ensemble cast.
Theatrical release poster
|Directed by||Jim Field Smith|
|Written by||Jason Micallef|
|Music by||Mateo Messina|
The film takes place in and around Johnson County, Iowa. Destiny (Yara Shahidi) is a ten-year-old foster child in Iowa who gets placed with Ethan (Rob Corddry) and Jill Emmet (Alicia Silverstone). While visiting the Iowa State Fair by herself, she wanders into the exhibit of the winning butter sculpture, a life-sized Last Supper, and skillfully finishes the Holy Grail cup, which impresses the sculpture's creator, Bob Pickler (Ty Burrell).
Bob has won fair's butter-sculpture contest for the past 15 years straight; because of his dominance, he is asked to abstain from future competitions to give others a chance. Bob's wife Laura (Jennifer Garner), overly competitive and socially ambitious, goes to the home of the competition's organizer to protest. Bob goes to a strip club and solicits stripper Brooke (Olivia Wilde) for sex in his minivan. Laura discovers them and T-bones the van with her SUV.
Laura decides to enter the county's preliminary sculpture competition herself because of the social status that comes with winning. Destiny decides to enter as well, as does Brooke, who just wants to harass the Picklers because Bob owes her $600. Despite practice, Laura comes in second to Destiny.
When Brooke appears at the Picklers' seeking her money, Bob's daughter Kaitlin (Ashley Greene) admits her and takes her up to her room. After talking a bit, Kaitlin challenges Brooke to a game of truth-or-dare which escalates to them having sex. Kaitlin is drawn to Brooke's alternative style and attitude; Brooke just wants the money (she ups the amount to $1200) and Kaitlin says she can get it. Meanwhile, Kaitlin's stepmom Laura is hooking up with Boyd Bolton (Hugh Jackman), an old high-school boyfriend who is now a used-car salesman. She's seducing him to get him to falsely testify to county officials that Ethan paid him to help Destiny in the competition. Laura suggests a rematch at the state fair. Destiny agrees; everyone else is disgruntled.
Brooke gets her money from an infatuated Kaitlin, meets Destiny after school, and takes her to the mall to buy her a $1,200 set of chef's knives to help her in the rematch with Laura. When Destiny gets home, a social worker informs her that her biological mother has died.
At the state fair, Laura carves a replica of John F. Kennedy's car immediately after his assassination complete with the president's blown-up skull and Jackie Kennedy and Clint Hill crawling onto the trunk; Destiny creates her biological mother holding her infant self in a rocking chair. That night before the judging, Boyd sneaks into the butter-sculpture room and defaces Destiny's sculpture with a blowtorch. Destiny, disappointed and expecting to lose now, encounters Laura in the restroom and offers the forgiveness of her handshake. Laura tells Destiny that winning the butter-sculpting contest means more to her than the little girl can comprehend. Laura feels she has little opportunity to distinguish herself otherwise, while Destiny has talent and her entire life to realize her own potential. Despite the damage, Destiny's sculpture wins. The sabotage of the piece is recognized as "higher art" as the judges believe the melted face lends the butter sculpture a greater depth. Destiny goes on to win in the state competition, where judges give a positive critique on her piece, deeming it an "angst-ridden exploration of post-natal abandonment."
Upon her victory, Destiny assures Laura that the butter-carving contest is "not all that you have." Laura kneels down to Destiny and hugs her, understanding that she must move on to greater triumphs that are her own.
Later, Destiny is officially adopted by the Emmets and Laura is running for Governor of Iowa, claiming that God appeared to her and advised her to run.
- Jennifer Garner as Laura Pickler
- Yara Shahidi as Destiny
- Ty Burrell as Bob Pickler
- Olivia Wilde as Brooke
- Rob Corddry as Ethan Emmet
- Ashley Greene as Kaitlin Pickler
- Alicia Silverstone as Jill Emmet
- Hugh Jackman as Boyd Bolton
- Kristen Schaal as Carol-Ann Stevenson
- Phyllis Smith as Nancy
- Corena Chase as Mrs. Schram
- Brett Hill as Hayden
The screenplay is the debut of Jason Micallef. He submitted a draft of the script for a Nicholl Fellowship with the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences in 2008 and won. This was the first film produced by Jennifer Garner's production company, Vandalia Films. The script came third on Leonard Franklin's 2008 Blacklist of Hollywood's most popular unproduced screenplays. The film premiered at the 2011 Toronto International Film Festival.
Butter received mixed reviews from critics. Review aggregation website Rotten Tomatoes gave the film a 35% approval rating, based on 60 reviews, with an average score of 4.6 out of 10. Metacritic gave the film has a 40 out of 100 rating, based on 23 reviews.
Peter Debruge of Variety gave high praise to director Jim Field Smith for his moments of upbeat comedy and honest dramatics, and Jennifer Garner's comedic performance, saying that "In another helmer’s hands, Butter might have been a dark comedy; here, the humor is twisted but the world is bright as can be." Sean O'Connell of The Washington Post gave the film 3 out of 4 stars, similarly praising Garner for showing great humorous timing and Smith's direction of biting satire that falls just shy of the works of Christopher Guest and Alexander Payne, concluding that "But with Garner’s triumphant turn as a buttoned-down manipulator and Smith’s broad, scatological punch lines, Butter often proves it’s sharp enough to . . . okay, I’ll say it, to slice through butter." Joel Arnold of NPR found the film's satire a bit obvious in its message but said that it gets by with its cast of characters delivering strong humor, saying that "this is a movie centrally about a competition, and there Butter finds its comedic footing."
The majority of critics were more mixed on the film's script in terms of humor, performances and political leanings. Christian Shoard of The Guardian said that despite the minor roles of Schaal and Wilde, the film's confused parody of the 2012 Republican election elicits few laughs and a message that amounts to nothing, concluding that "there's something about this film's churn of goo and grit that lingers ambivalently, difficult to digest." Peter Travers of Rolling Stone gave the film 2 out of 4 stars, finding it too broad and lacking sharpness in its political satire and Garner's absurdly humorous performance barely getting any laughs, concluding that "she's stuck in a movie that wishes it were a Christopher Guest sendup but comes off like a cheap imitation."
Scott Bowles of USA Today felt the cast was wasted with cheap humor and underwritten characters, calling it "a film more enamored of its premise than interested in making it work." He gave it 1 and-a-half out of 4 stars. Sam Adams of The A.V. Club gave the film a D+ for using its premise as a failed satire mouthpiece to make lackluster jokes about the Midwest, saying that "Mostly, Butter is a venue for writer [Jason] Micallef and director [Jim Field] Smith to lob spitballs at people about whom they seem to know nothing, and care less." Ty Burr of The Boston Globe also felt the film lacked focus with its off-target satire and cartoonish characters, singling out Garner's performance as a "one-note caricature" that makes pot-shots at Michele Bachmann and Sarah Palin, concluding that, "It may play to audiences who like their satire cynical and safe, but the aftertaste of Butter is rancid."
- "Butter (2010)". Box Office Mojo. Retrieved December 31, 2014.
- Saito, Stephen. "'Butter' Churns a Political Fable Out of Race, Age and Iowa Butter Sculptors". Take Part. Retrieved March 9, 2013.
- 2008 Nicholl Fellows. .
- Billington, Alex (December 10, 2008). "The 2008 Black List - Most Popular Unproduced Screenplays". FirstShowing.net. Retrieved August 28, 2012.
- Brevet, Brad (September 14, 2011). "Harvey Weinstein Turns Toronto 'Butter' Premiere into a Political Statement". Rope of Silicon. Retrieved August 29, 2012.
- "Butter". Rotten Tomatoes. Flixster. Retrieved January 7, 2013.
- "Butter Reviews". Metacritic. CBS Interactive. Retrieved November 2, 2015.
- Debruge, Peter (September 5, 2011). "Review: 'Butter'". Variety. Penske Media Corporation. Retrieved November 2, 2015.
- O'Connell, Sean (October 5, 2012). "Busting guts and genres". The Washington Post. Nash Holdings LLC. Retrieved November 2, 2015.
- Arnold, Joel (October 4, 2012). "No Contest: Everything Is Better With 'Butter'". NPR. Retrieved November 3, 2015.
- Shoard, Christian (September 15, 2011). "Toronto film festival 2011: Butter – review". The Guardian. London: Guardian Media Group. Retrieved November 3, 2015.
- Travers, Peter (October 4, 2012). "Butter". Rolling Stone. Wenner Media. Retrieved November 3, 2015.
- Bowles, Scott (October 5, 2012). "'Butter': A recipe for stale laughs". USA Today. Gannett Company. Retrieved November 2, 2015.
- Adams, Sam (October 4, 2012). "Butter". The A.V. Club. The Onion. Retrieved November 2, 2015.
- Burr, Ty (October 4, 2012). "'Butter' too pat to work as satire". The Boston Globe. Boston.com. Retrieved November 3, 2015.