Women in Refrigerators
Type of site
|Created by||Daniel Merlin Goodbrey
Women in Refrigerators (or WiR) is a website created in 1999 by a group of feminists and comic book fans, and more broadly a common comic book trope from which the website took its name. The website features a list of female comic book characters who have been injured, killed, or depowered as a plot device within various superhero comic books, and seeks to analyze why these plot devices are used disproportionately on female characters.
The term "Women in Refrigerators" was coined by writer Gail Simone as a name for the website in early 1999 during online discussions about comic books with friends. It refers to an incident in Green Lantern #54 (1994), written by Ron Marz, in which Kyle Rayner, the title hero, comes home to his apartment to find that his girlfriend, Alexandra DeWitt, had been killed by the villain Major Force and stuffed into a refrigerator. Simone and her colleagues then developed a list of fictional female characters who had been "killed, maimed or depowered", in particular in ways that treated the female character as merely a device to move a male character's story arc forward, rather than as a fully developed character in her own right. The list was then circulated via the Internet over Usenet, Bulletin Board System, e-mail and electronic mailing lists. Simone also e-mailed many comic book creators directly for their responses to the list.
The list is considered "infamous" in certain comic book fan circles. Respondents often found different meanings to the list itself, though Simone maintained that her simple point had always been: "If you demolish most of the characters girls like, then girls won't read comics. That's it!"
Simone received numerous e-mail responses from comic book fans and professionals. Some correspondents reacted with hostility at the creation of the list and assumed a radical feminist agenda on the part of Simone. Some responses were neutral and others were positive. Additionally, arguments on the merits of the list were published on comic-book fan sites in early 1999. Discussions developed regarding the use of gruesome injury, death or depowerment of friends and acquaintances of heroic comic book characters as a plot device.
Simone published many of the responses she received on the website. Journalist Beau Yarbrough created the initial design and coding on the original site. Technology consultant John Bartol edited the content. Robert Harris, a librarian and comic-book fan, contributed to site maintenance and updates along with fan John Norris. The idea for placing the list online originated with software developer Jason Yu, who also served as the original site host.
Several comic book creators indicated that the list caused them to pause and think about the stories they were creating. Often these responses contained arguments for or against the use of death or injury of female characters as a plot device. A list of some responses from comic book professionals is included at the site. Marz's reply stated (in part) "To me the real difference is less male-female than main character-supporting character. In most cases, main characters, "title" characters who support their own books, are male. [...] the supporting characters are the ones who suffer the more permanent and shattering tragedies. And a lot of supporting characters are female."
Dead Men DefrostingEdit
Some fans argued that many characters, regardless of gender, eventually return given sufficient importance in a storyline or fandom popularity. Thus, second and third-string characters (and not first-grade leads) are more likely to be killed off permanently regardless of gender. Sidekicks in general also tend to be singled out frequently. The deaths of Robin II and Captain America supporting character Bucky Barnes were often cited as an example of this trend in online discussions on the message boards of Comic Book Resources at the time of the original development of WiR. In response to that line of reasoning, content editor John Bartol wrote an article, "Dead Men Defrosting", in which he argued that when male heroes are killed or altered, they are more typically returned to their status quo. According to Bartol, after most female characters are altered they are "never allowed, as male heroes usually are, the chance to return to their original heroic states. And that's where we begin to see the difference."
In popular cultureEdit
References in mass cultureEdit
In 2000, several national newspapers ran articles that referenced the site, generating discussion on the topic of sexism in pop culture and the comic-book industry. Some universities also list the content of Women in Refrigerators as related to analysis and critique of pop culture.
Women in Refrigerators SyndromeEdit
Women in Refrigerators Syndrome was coined in various forms via online discussions and articles. The term describes the use of the death or injury of a female comic book character as a plot device in a story starring a male comic book character. It is also used to note the depowerment or elimination of a female comic-book character. Cases of it deal with a gruesome injury or murder of a female character at the hands of a supervillain, usually as a motivating personal tragedy for a male superhero, to whom the victim is connected. The death or injury of the female character, then helps cement the hatred between the hero and the villain responsible. Kyle Rayner is a particularly cited example, due to the common tragedies that befall women in his life.
Discussing the site in his book Dangerous Curves: Action Heroes, Gender, Fetishism and Popular Culture, Bowling Green State University professor Jeffrey A. Brown noted that while male comic book heroes have tended to die heroically and be magically brought back from the dead afterwards, female characters have been likelier to be casually but irreparably wounded or killed, often in a sexualized fashion. To support his claim, he cited the Joker shattering the original Batgirl's spine just for fun, resulting in her being restricted to a wheelchair for over a decade, and the villain Black Mask binding, torturing and killing the first female Robin from DC Universe, Stephanie Brown.
The frequent violence against female characters has led many people[who?] to ask for a change in the way female characters are written and portrayed. These people[who?] have expressed the desire for female characters to serve in a more active role in stories, as well as not be subject to such displays of violence.
Several contributors to the site and the original list later became comic book creators and entertainment industry professionals. These writers were also all members of the early Internet group of comic book fans and aspiring writers known collectively as "The Pantheon." This group includes:[not in citation given]
- Stephen Cmelak – creator of the webcomic Avatars.
- Daniel Merlin Goodbrey – digital designer and underground comicbook author, creator of the hypercomic Six-Gun: Tales from an Unfolded Earth, and the iPod comic Brain Fist.
- Brian Joines – writer of the independent comic The 7 Guys of Justice and as of 2006 publishing new comics through Platinum Studios.
- Greg Dean Schmitz – creator of UpcomingMovies.com, AKA Greg's Previews, and columnist for Fandango and Rotten Tomatoes.
- Gail Simone - author of several comic books including Birds of Prey for DC Comics and Marvel's Deadpool.
- Simone, Gail (March 1999). "Women in Refrigerators". LBY3. Retrieved August 24, 2013.
- Condon, Michael (October 2002). "The Fanzig Challenge". Fanzing. Retrieved January 11, 2006.
- Prowse-Gany, Brian (August 12, 2015). "Rise of the Female Superhero". Yahoo! News.
- Simone, Gail (March 1999). "The List". lb3.com. Retrieved August 24, 2013.
- Simone, Gail (March 28, 1999). "Email as of 4/28/99". LBY3. Retrieved January 11, 2006.
- Simone, Gail; Bartol, John (Editors). "Fan Reactions". "Women in Refigerators". Retrieved August 24, 2013.
- "Who's Who: The Scarlet Rob". Gay League. Retrieved 2010-11-08.
- "Women in Refrigerators". lby3.com. Retrieved 2012-12-21.
- Simone, Gail; Harris Rob (Editors). "Responding Creators". Women in Refrigerators. LBY3. Retrieved August 24, 2013.
- "Ron Marz responds". Women in Refrigerators. LBY3. Retrieved August 24, 2013.
- Bartol, John (March 1999). "Dead Men Defrosting". Women in Refrigerators. LBY3. Retrieved August 24, 2013.
- "Letters Wonder women; Cool Kidd; Give it a rest" by various authors, 25 May 2000, published in the Dallas Observer. Retrieved 15 January 2006.
- "Popular Culture". Washington State University. Retrieved August 24, 2013.
- Moore, Perry. "Who cares about the death of a gay superhero anyway?". perrymoorestories.com. Retrieved August 24, 2013.
- Voulieris, John. "What Women Want". comicsbulletin.com. Archived from the original on 19 May 2005.
And then every now and then you get the girlfriend in the refrigerator syndrome and it probably turns potential female readers off.
- Krause, Melissa (July 6, 2007). "Point/Counterpoint in the Blogosphere..." Newsarama. July 6, 2007.
- Brown, Jeffrey A. Dangerous curves: action heroines, gender, fetishism, and popular culture. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi. pp. 175–6. ISBN 160473714X.
- Lynskey, Dorian (March 25, 2015). "Kapow! Attack of the feminist superheroes". The Guardian.
- "Avatars' official website". Avatarsonline.net. Retrieved 2010-11-08.
- "Sixgun: Tales From An Unfolded Earth". Comic Book Resources. Retrieved 2010-11-08.
- "Brain Fist". E-merl.com. 2007-08-07. Retrieved 2010-11-08.
- "Fan Reactions". Women in Refrigerators. Retrieved September 9, 2013.
- Weiland, Jonah (December 27, 2002). "'7 Guys of Justice' return this July in special giant-sized issue". Comic Book Resources.
- "Yahoo! Movies: About Greg's Previews". Movies.yahoo.com. Retrieved 2010-11-08.
- "Yahoo! Movies - Greg's Previews". Movies.yahoo.com. Retrieved 2010-11-08.