Talk:The Last Mountain

Latest comment: 12 years ago by 184.57.8.102 in topic Eric Mathis

Netflix streaming edit

At present, WP policies regarding pay services prevent the mention of streaming availability through Netflix. But it does seem this info would have value to users of the Wiki, just as dvd availability has. As thee are multiple streaming services available legally, would it not be prudent to offer streanming availability info in film articles? Bustter (talk) 15:54, 21 February 2012 (UTC)Reply

Eric Mathis edit

Are Eric Mathis's criticisms of the film notable enough to be cited? I find the citation rather misleading. I followed the link and it seems the two criticsms--that the film "paradoxically maintains.." whatever/mumble-jumbo, something about destructive paradigms that doesnt make sense to me; and in particular his calling the CRMW wind study misleading--are just tossed out, with no explanation whatsoever. Unless I'm blind. Can anyone expand (or rather, show where Mr. Mathis expands) on either of his criticisms? If not, it just seems rather unworthy of mention IMO

I'm not trying to purge criticism of the film. I would have less objection even if, say, a coal industry insider was cited, so long as the criticism had some meat to it. Even if I personally though the "meat" was rotten, self-serving, and completely unfounded; as long as it's noteworthy and substantial criticism. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 184.57.8.102 (talk) 00:34, 22 April 2012 (UTC)Reply