Talk:PowerBook 5300

Latest comment: 17 years ago by Neale Monks in topic 5300 vs. 3400 in the Problems section

5300 vs. 3400 in the Problems section

edit

The PowerBook 3400 series introduced in the February of 1997 had a slot that could use modules built for the 5300, but apart from DMA and slightly faster processors it still had few new features. That makes the PowerBook 5300 an example for the damage introduction problems can do to the reputation of a remarkable product (and of the whole company), even long after they have been resolved

While I agree with the conclusion, I think saying that the 3400 was merely a slightly tweaked version of the 3400 is a bit of an understatement. The 3400 had, among other things:

  • CD drive
  • PCI architecture
  • 64-bit wide internal bus
  • Accelerated graphics
  • Built-in Ethernet
  • Li-Ion battery
  • Four loudspeakers
  • A better, higher-resolution screen

So even if superficially they look quite alike, under the skin they are very different machines. It's perhaps better to say that the 3400 is the machine the 5300 should have been, and perhaps would have been, had the technology been slightly more mature and the time of manufacture.

Cheers, Neale Neale Monks 23:23, 7 November 2006 (UTC)Reply