Talk:Hungarian folk music

Active discussions

hungarian or roma/gypsy music?Edit

this article leaves the impression that, in the end, hungarian folk music is indeed gypsy music. this is incorrect. by the nineteenth century, many of the wandering musicians who played at weddings, village festivals, and even for the rural elite and wealthier peasants in hungarian speaking territory, were gypsies--and also jews. roma and jews were two groups that were largely denied regular means for making a living in society. playing music was one means open to them, and so in time they developed a tradition and reputation of excellency in music. but they by far and wide were not the only musicians playing this music. as many ethnic hungarians played this music as well, but a stereotype nonetheless developed that this was exlcusively or particularly gypsy music being played in transylvania and hungary proper. just as jews were wrongly believed to be, in a negative stereotype, the masters of a parasitic capitalism, the music of hungary that is the cultural heritage of all hungarian-speaking musicians--be they roma, jewish, or hungarian--became known as gypsy music, even in the hungarian language. and this stereotype is, unfortunately, quite alive and well in the us and europe today.

hungarians, gypsies, jews and even other ethnic minorities over centuries created this music together. it is a unique musical tradition with a lot of variation of style (depending on village and region) but which also has a great deal of uniformity across hungarian-speaking territory. it is by far hungarian music. roma in others countries play different music--this should be the most obvious reason why this is not a specifically gypsy or roma music, even if there is similarity between hungarian music and the music in neighboring regions to hungarian speakng ones or in other parts of central europe.

the roma have played an important part in the history/development of many countries' musical traditions and have added important elements--certain inspiration, ornamentations, innovations--not to mention the role they have played in many central and eastern european countries in keeping alive and preserving these musics through the ages, and in the wake of the nazi deluge. . .and one should also take note of the role the roma have played, along with jews--but also along with other non-roma and non-gypsy musicians of various nationalities that wandered and taught or taught other wanderers their music--in carrying musical styles and innovations across borders.

and within each of these traditions, there are specific tunes and melodies that are known to be or thought to be specifically roma or gypsy--but it remains incorrect to regard the whole of each of these traditions as specifically "gypsy."

Gypsy folksongsEdit

On the basis of the above mentined reasons, I have placed the following sentences here. More concrete data are needed in this subject in a separate section.

To some extent, the music of ethnic Hungarian people and the music of the Roma in Hungary have been conflated, though the exact degree to which this has occurred is debated. A variation of the Hungarian style of traditional music is Magyarországi Cigány Népdalok, Hungarian Gypsy Folksongs.

I have also put here the following sentence about Jeff Mangum, as he was inspired by Bulgarian folk music, not Hungarian.

Neutral Milk Hotel singer Jeff Mangum is known for being heavily influenced by Hungarian folk music and in 2001 released Orange Twin Field Works: Volume I, a collection field recordings recorded at a festival. --Hunadam (talk) 18:04, 4 August 2008 (UTC)

gypsy folk music removedEdit

Ando Drom and Notar Mary were removed. They are hungarians and folk musicans, but they play purely gypsy folk music not hungarian folk music. This can be misleading.

In fact, Notar Mary's music is not folk at all (pop/dance/latin maybe with some gypsy folk elements), for example: They are a lot more famous and more folkish gypsy singers in Hungary, Notar Mary is not notably. (Bódi Guszti, Fekete vonat, LL Junior and so on... but not hungarian-folk musicans.)

Palya Bea is also gypsy, but her music is more like hungarian folk music with gypsy elements. I let her name in the list. -- (talk) 20:20, 27 February 2015 (UTC)

Return to "Hungarian folk music" page.