Talk:Christophorus Castanis

Latest comment: 3 years ago by Hoary in topic "some sources"

"some sources" edit

According to some sources, around forty Greek orphans emigrated to the United States in similar circumstances during this period.

Citing 'Extensions of Remarks', GPO, 29 March 1971, p. 8480, within this hundred-page PDF.

This reference seems meaningless. The hon. Roman C Pucinski goes on for what occupies several densely laid-out pages (which I confess I haven't read), and within this, on page 8480, merely cites Castanis as having said this. (It's in the paragraph starting "In the book", in the left-hand column.) Or do I misunderstand?

(Pinging Yiannic2020!) -- Hoary (talk) 07:53, 26 April 2021 (UTC)Reply

Fixed edit

Hi Hoary,

You do not misunderstand, this was a vague reference. I have fixed this up and expanded on the point by citing scholars who have worked on this. Hopefully this is clearer.

Best, Yiannic2020

(Pinging Hoary) -- Yiannic2020 (talk)


Vagueness edit

I have also fixed the vagueness of the references.

(Pinging Hoary) -- Yiannic2020 (talk) 27 April 2021, 2:56 pm (UTC)