Talk:Canard Pars

First header

Where did this age info come from? I can't imagine that Canard is in his mid 30s. I'd say he's in his 20s at most. Redxiv 23:06, 23 August 2005 (UTC)

Brother of Kira Yamato and Parents - clarification needed

Either Canard Pars and Kira Yamato ARE DEFINITELY brothers; OR Ulen Hibiki and Via Hibiki ARE POSSIBLY parents. You can't have ambiguity with the brothers relationship and then they a definite from the same parents relationship at the same time. By definition, same parents = siblings (half or full or step another topic). If they have the same parents, then they ARE brothers. If that is not confirmed, then it should be changed that they POSSIBLY have the same parents. Therefore, either the parents needs to be changed in the Canard Pars and/or the Kira Yamato entry, or the brother relationship needs to be changed in the Canard Pars and Kira Yamato entry. But I need someone whom have read the Manga and watched the Anime to confirm this to give the appropriate answer. Akosygin 03:54, 26 August 2005 (UTC)

Crossposted from Talk:Kira Yamato

I'm removing Kira as a possible brother. No, not right now, but I'm giving everyone a heads up. The entire speculation about the blood relationship comes from a very ambiguous comment from Via. Now, we know she was a seemingly kind and caring woman, so it wouldn't be too odd if she was referring to the entire batch of lab-rat wombs as "our". But that's also speculation.

Now, for a bit more solid arguments: Uzumi knew everything about Kira's past, enough to secure and hide the twins, but he never even mentions Canard. Via's confrontation with Ulen happens after his decision to use Kira as a test subject, there's no mention of any children of hers used a year ago. There's a picture of Kira and Cagalli, but none of Canard among the Hibiki's possessions. In general, there's never being any solid hint towards there being a direct blood relation between Canard and Kira/Cagalli. It's far-off speculation. And considering Gundam "unconfirmed hints" tend to be pretty much freaking obvious ("Prayer: I was cloned from a certain EAF pilot" [Moebius Zero flies in the background]), I can't see enough reason to consider this any more than fanfiction material.

That's the deal. Comments? Ephyon 04:12, 6 February 2007 (UTC)

ok how about you put he is a clone of kira that is as close as it can be —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 137.140.137.21 (talk • contribs).

• 1)Please watch where you put your replies.
• 2)Where in the hells' name did you get "Clone" from? Ephyon 08:03, 26 March 2007 (UTC)

Failure?

My Question's are:

1. What made Canard a failure exactly?
2. Maybe put in that Kira & Canard may be Related by blood but state that there is no supporting evidence? -- Awar 06:50, 20 April 2007 (UTC).

• 1: What exactly were the problematic irregularities in the artificial wombs of the Ultimate Coorinator failures was never explained. The aspect of him that made him a failure was the same as that of every other coordinator: the genetic modifications on him weren't 100% accurate.
• 2: The thing is, you might then as well go and say anything you want just as long as there is a slight possibility that it could be true. Canard's brotherhood is something the fans came up with, not hinted anywhere by anything. there's more evidence against it than for it (which is zero). There were a lot of babies used in the project, do you think Via Hibiki was the biological mother of ALL of them? Of course not. So why Canard, a guy who is never hinted at having any biological relationship with Kira, would somehow be more likely than the rest of the ratlab fetuses? Ephyon 07:54, 20 April 2007 (UTC)