Talk:Abdullah ibn Khatal

Create Different Topic: Those sentenced to death at Conquest of Mecca

As it is, the topic is not really of any significance -- jillions of similar characters of no importance. However, it acquired significance within the context of people who were condemned at the conquest of Mecca

Here is a quote from: https://islam.stackexchange.com/questions/38977/who-were-sentenced-to-death-during-the-conquest-of-mecca This is of importance/relevance because of contemporary debates, indeed burning debates, within Pakistan especially and to a lesser extent throughout the Islamic world, about the extent of tolerance towards non-Muslims. In general, Islamic principles are very generous but there are limits, and these limits are very much subject of contemporary debate. This incident is one of the KEY incidents uses as source for setting these boundaries: (many other references are also cited in the article.

Shedding blood of nine arch-criminals was declared lawful even under the curtains of Al-Ka'bah. Nevertheless, only four of them were killed while the others were pardoned for different reasons. As for those who were killed, mention could be made of 'Abdul 'Uzza bin Khatal who had become a Muslim and then deputed to collect alms-tax in the company of a Helper. They had also a slave with them. 'Abdullah, in a fit of rage, killed the Helper's slave on account of a mere trifling dispute, and joined the pagan Arabs as an apostate. He was never repentant at this heinous crime but rather employed two women singers and incited them to sing satirically about the Prophet peace be upon him. The other man who was put to death was Miqyas bin Sababa. He was a Muslim. A Helper accidently killed his brother Hisham. The Prophet peace be upon him had arranged the payment of blood money to him, which he had accepted. His revengeful nature, however, was never appeased, so he killed the Helper and went to Makkah as an apostate.

Similarly, Huwairith and one woman singer went to death.

On the other hand, every attempt was made to grant pardon to the people. 'Ikrimah bin Abu Jahl, who had attacked Khalid's detachment at the time of the entry into Makkah, was forgiven. To Wahshi, the murderer of Hamzah, the Prophet's uncle, and to Hind, who had chewed his liver, was also extended his generous clemency. The same generous treatment was accorded to Habar who had attacked the Prophet's daughter with a spear, while on her way from Makkah to Madinah, so grievously that she ultimately died of the fatal injuries.

In the same context of magnanimity peculiar to Muhammad peace be upon him, two chiefs of Quraish were pardoned once they had embraced Islam. They were Safwan bin Omaiyah and Fudalah bin 'Umair. The latter had attempted to assassinate the Prophet peace be upon him while circumambulating in the Holy Sanctuary. The Prophet's matchless tolerance and broad-mindedness instigated by his mission as 'A mercy to all people', converted a terrible hypocrite into a faithful devout believer.

Asaduzaman (talk) 06:30, 16 August 2019 (UTC)