South China tiger

(Redirected from Maltese tiger)

The South China tiger is a population of the Panthera tigris tigris subspecies that is native to southern China.[2] The population mainly inhabited the Fujian, Guangdong, Hunan and Jiangxi provinces. It has been listed as Critically Endangered on the China's Red List of Vertebrates[3] and is possibly extinct in the wild since no wild individual has been recorded since the late 1980s.[4] In the late 1990s, continued survival was considered unlikely because of low prey density, widespread habitat degradation and fragmentation, and other environmental issues in China.[5] In the fur trade, it used to be called Amoy tiger.[6]

South China tiger
Tiger in the Shanghai Zoo
Tiger in the Shanghai Zoo
Scientific classificationEdit this classification
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Class: Mammalia
Order: Carnivora
Suborder: Feliformia
Family: Felidae
Subfamily: Pantherinae
Genus: Panthera
Species: P. tigris
Subspecies: P. t. tigris
Population: South China tiger
Distribution of the South China tiger
Distribution of the South China tiger

Panthera tigris subsp. amoyensis (Hilzheimer, 1905)

Taxonomy edit

The scientific name Felis tigris var. amoyensis was proposed by Max Hilzheimer in 1905 who described five tiger skulls from Hankou in southern China that differed slightly in shape from Bengal tiger skulls.[6] Analysis of South China tiger skulls showed that they differ in shape from tiger skulls of other regions. Because of this phenomenon the South China tiger is considered a relict population of the "stem" tiger.[7] Results of a phylogeographic study indicate that southern China or northern Indochina was likely the center of Pleistocene tiger radiation.[8]

In 2017, the Cat Classification Taskforce of the Cat Specialist Group subsumed all mainland Asian tiger populations to P. t. tigris.[2] However, a genetic study published in 2018 supported six monophyletic clades, with the South Chinese tiger being distinct from other mainland Asian populations, thus supporting the traditional concept of six subspecies.[9]

Characteristics edit

In 1905, Hilzheimer first described the South China tiger as similar in height to the Bengal tiger but differing in skull and coat characteristics. Its carnassials and molars are shorter than in the Bengal tiger samples; the cranial region is shorter with orbits set closer together, postorbital processes are larger. Their coat is lighter and more yellowish and the paws, face, and stomach appear more white; the stripes are narrower, more numerous and more sharp-edged.[6]

The South China tiger is the smallest tiger in mainland Asia but bigger than the Sumatran tiger. Males measure from 230 to 265 cm (91 to 104 in), and weigh 130 to 175 kg (287 to 386 lb). Females are smaller and measure 220 to 240 cm (87 to 94 in), and weigh 100 to 115 kg (220 to 254 lb). The length of the tail does not usually exceed one half of the head-and-body length. Hair length varies geographically. Greatest documented length of skull in males is 318 to 343 mm (12.5 to 13.5 in) and in females 273 to 301 mm (10.7 to 11.9 in).[10]

A sighting in around 1910 of an unusual blue-coloured or "Maltese" tiger outside Fuzhou in the Fujian Province was reported by Harry Caldwell and Roy Chapman Andrews.[11][12]

Distribution and habitat edit

The skulls described by Hilzheimer originated in Hankou.[6] The historical range of the South China tiger stretched over a vast landscape of 2,000 km (1,200 mi) from east to west and 1,500 km (930 mi) from north to south in China. From the east it ranged from Jiangxi and Zhejiang provinces at about 120°E westward through Guizhou and Sichuan provinces at about 100°E. The most northerly extension was in the Qinling Mountain and Yellow River area at approximately 35°N to its southern extension in Guangdong, Guangxi and Yunnan provinces at 21°N.[13] The South China tiger population was likely connected to the Siberian tiger population through corridors in the Yellow River basin throughout the Late Pleistocene and Holocene, before humans interrupted gene flow.[14]

Population decline edit

In the early 1950s, the South China tiger population was reported to number more than 4,000 individuals in the wild when it became the target of large-scale government 'anti-pest' campaigns promulgated by Mao Zedong's Great Leap Forward. The effects of uncontrolled hunting were compounded by extensive deforestation and probable reduction in available prey, large-scale relocations of urban populations to rural locations leading to fragmentation of tiger populations and increased vulnerability to local extinction from stochastic events. By 1982, an estimated 150–200 South China tigers remained in the wild.[13] By 1987, the remnant South China tiger population was estimated at 30–40 individuals in the wild, so that danger of extinction was imminent.[15] During a survey in 1990, South China tiger signs were found in 11 reserves in the mountains of Sichuan, Guangdong, Hunan, Jiangxi and Fujian provinces, but these data were insufficient to estimate population size. No tigers were directly observed; evidence was limited to sightings of tracks, scrapings and reported sightings by local people.[16]

In 2001, field studies were carried out in eight protected areas encompassing 2,214 km2 (855 sq mi) in five provinces of south-central China using camera traps, GPS technology, and extensive sign surveys, but no evidence of tigers was found. No scats observed by the field team could be positively verified as being from tigers. Evidence for possible tiger prey species was found in five locations.[17] At the turn of the 21st century, there may still have been some South China tigers in the wild; local people had reported tracks and sightings in Qizimei Mountains Nature Reserve in Hubei province and in Yihuang County of Jiangxi Province.[4] In May 2007, the government of China reported to the CITES secretariat that there is no confirmed presence and declared the goal to reintroduce South China tigers to the wild.[18] In September 2007, a body of an Asian black bear was found in Zhenping County that had possibly been killed and eaten by a South China tiger. In October 2007, a supposed South China tiger attacked a cow in the same county.[19]

Behavior and ecology edit

A tiger of the Save China's Tigers project with his kill

The tiger is an obligate carnivore. It prefers hunting large ungulates, frequently kills wild boar, and occasionally hog deer, muntjac and gray langur. Small prey species such as porcupines, hares and peafowl form a very small part in its diet. Domestic livestock is preyed upon in areas of human encroachment.[20][21] In the former range of the South China tiger additional tiger prey species may have included serow, tufted deer and sambar.[17] In most cases, tigers approach prey from the side or behind from as close a distance as possible and grasp the prey's throat to kill it. Then they drag the carcass into cover, occasionally over several hundred meters, to consume it. The nature of the tiger's hunting method and prey availability results in a "feast or famine" feeding style: they often consume 18–40 kg (40–88 lb) of meat at one time.[10]

Tigers mate at any time of the year but breeding is most common from the end of November to the first half of April. Males are ready to begin mating at 5 years old and females at 4 years old. Offspring is born 103 days after mating.[10] Three to six young are born in a den. They are born blind and weigh between 780 and 1,600 g (28 and 56 oz). They are suckled at least for the first 8 weeks. The mother teaches them to hunt when they are 6 months old. At the age of 18 to 24 months, the cubs separate from their mother.[5]

Man-eating tiger attacks on humans in South China increased dramatically in the Ming and Qing dynasties with vast human population growth and the consequent encroachment into tiger habitats. About 500 attacks took place during this period, with the average frequency being nearly once per year. According to historical records, all these attacks resulted in deaths numbering from several to over 1,000.[22] In 1957, a tiger allegedly attacked and killed 32 people in Hunan province.[23]

Conservation edit

In 1973, the South China tiger was classified as protected by controlled hunting. In 1977, it was classified as protected, and hunting was prohibited.[13] All tiger subspecies are included on CITES Appendix I, banning international trade. All tiger range states and countries with consumer markets have banned domestic trade as well.[24] At the 14th Conference of the Parties to CITES in 2007, an end to tiger farming and stopping domestic trade in farmed tiger products in China were called for.[25]

The South China tiger is listed as critically endangered on China's Red List of Vertebrates (as Panthera tigris amoyensis).[3]

The non-governmental organisation Save China's Tigers, with support of China's State Forestry Administration, has developed a plan to reintroduce captive-born South China tigers into large enclosures in southern China. The main concerns regarding the reintroduction are the availability of suitable habitat and adequate prey, and the fitness of the captive population. Landscape-level conservation of wilderness habitat and recovery of wild herbivore populations as prey base for the tiger will be required. A suggested eventual goal was to establish at least three populations, with each population consisting of a minimum of about 15–20 tigers living in a minimum of 1,000 km2 (390 sq mi) of natural habitat. Cooperative field surveys and workshops have been carried out to identify suitable recovery areas.[26]

In captivity edit

Captive tiger

As of March 1986, 17 Chinese zoos kept 40 pure-bred South China tigers in their collections, including 23 males and 14 females, none of which were wild-born. All were third or fourth generation descendants of one wild tigress from Fujian and five tigers from Guizhou. Notable problems included uneven sex ratio and improper pairing.[27] In 2005, the captive population of South China tigers consisted of 57 individuals that showed signs of inbreeding, including reduced genetic diversity and a low rate of successful breeding.[5] In 2007, the global captive population consisted of 72 individuals; there are few captive South China tigers outside China.[28] Few seem to be "pure" South China tigers as there is genetic evidence of cross-breeding with other subspecies.[29] In 2019 there were an estimated 150 South China tigers in captivity within China. 144 of these were part of the breeding and management program maintained by the Chinese Association of Zoological Gardens since 1994, five were in Guizhou province, and one was in Fujian province.[30]

One cub was born in a private reserve known as Laohu Valley Reserve in South Africa in November 2007, the first to be born outside China. Since then, a number of cubs have been produced. As of 2016, the Laohu Valley Reserve had 19 individuals.[31]

China's captive South China tigers have been entered onto a centrally registered studbook. Before the studbook was established it was thought that this captive population was too small and lacking in genetic diversity for any re-population program to be successful, but since the start of the central register more and more South China tigers have been identified in zoos across China.

Rewilding edit

Origin edit

The word "rewilding" was coined by conservationist and ex-carnivore manager of Pilanesberg National Park, Gus Van Dyk in 2003. Van Dyk, who in an effort to find the most appropriate translation of the Chinese term "Yě-huà" (Chinese: 野化), chose to adopt the term "rewilding" to describe Save China's Tigers rewilding project of the South China tiger.[32] Since then, the term "rewilding" has been widely used by wildlife organisations worldwide.

Rewilding project in South Africa edit

A male tiger of the Save China's Tigers Project scent-marking his territory

The organisation Save China's Tigers, working with the Wildlife Research Center of the State Forestry Administration of China and the Chinese Tigers South Africa Trust, secured an agreement on the reintroduction of Chinese tigers into the wild. The agreement, which was signed in Beijing on 26 November 2002, calls for the establishment of a Chinese tiger conservation model through the creation of a pilot reserve in China where indigenous wildlife, including the South China tiger, will be reintroduced. Save China's Tigers aims to rewild the critically endangered South China tiger by bringing a few captive-bred individuals to a private reserve in the Free State province of South Africa for rehabilitation training so that they can regain their hunting instincts. At the same time, a pilot reserve is being set up in China. Once it is ready, the offspring of the trained tigers will be released there, while the original animals will stay in South Africa to continue breeding.[33]

The reason South Africa was chosen is because it is able to provide expertise and resources, land and prey for the South China tigers. The South China tigers of the project have since been successfully rewilded and are fully capable of hunting and surviving on their own.[33] This project has also been very successful in the breeding of these rewilded South China tigers and 14 cubs have been born in the project, of which 11 survived. These second generation cubs would be able to learn their survival skills from their successfully rewilded mothers directly.[34] It was hoped that in 2012 the second-generation tigers born at Laohu Valley Reserve could be released into the wild.[35]

Reaction to the project edit

Mainstream conservationists have expressed reservations about the project. The WWF says that the money is being spent in the wrong place, and that the Siberian tiger has a better chance of survival.[36] Scientists confirmed the role of rewilding captive populations to save the South China tiger. A workshop was conducted in October 2010 in Laohu Valley Reserve in South Africa to assess the progress of the rewilding and reintroduction program of Save China's Tigers. The experts present included Dr. Peter Crawshaw of Centro Nacional de Pesquisa e Conservacão de Mamiferos Carnivoros, Cenap/ICMBIO, Dr. Gary Koehler, Dr. Laurie Marker of the Cheetah Conservation Fund, Dr. Jim Sanderson of Small Wild Cat Conservation Foundation, Dr. Nobuyuki Yamaguchi of Department of Biological and Environmental Sciences of Qatar University, and Dr. J. L. David Smith of the University of Minnesota, Chinese government scientists as well as representatives of Save China's Tigers.

The tigers in question were born in captive conditions, in concrete cages, and their parents are all captive animals who are unable to sustain themselves naturally in the wild. The cubs were sent to South Africa as part of the Save China's Tigers project for rewilding and to ensure that they would regain the necessary skills needed for a predator to survive in the wild. Results of the workshop confirmed the important role of the South China Tiger Rewilding Project in tiger conservation. "Having seen the tigers hunting in an open environment at Laohu Valley Reserve, I believe that these rewilded tigers have the skill to hunt in any environment," Dr. David Smith remarked. Furthermore, Save China's Tigers recovered natural habitat both in China and in South Africa during their attempt to reintroduce South China tigers into the wild.[37] The goal of preparing captive born tigers for introduction into wild habitat in the former range seems to be possible in the near future.[38] A 2015 study concluded that the project has potential for the reintroduction of South Chinese tigers to their native habitat. It found that the captive-born tigers were capable of stalking and killing several free-ranging prey items, which is important if they are to survive in the wild.[39]

Claims of photographs edit

In 2007, a villager from China's Shaanxi province claimed to have taken 40 digital and 31 film photographs of a wild South China Tiger.[40]: 93  The Shaanxi Provincial Forestry Department backed up this claim in a press conference.[41][42] The photographs aroused suspicion, with many expressing doubts about their authenticity.[43] In November 2007, the Shaanxi Province Forestry Department still "firmly believed" that wild South China tigers exist in the province.[44]

On November 16, 2007, online activists found and published the source of the photos, a New Year's picture published by a small company in Zhejiang Province.[40]: 94 

However, in February 2008, the Shaanxi Forestry Department released an apology, qualifying their earlier statements but without repudiating the pictures' authenticity, writing "We curtly released the discovery of the South China tiger without substantial proof, which reflects our blundering manner and lax discipline."[45]

On June 29, 2008, the Shaanxi Forestry Department announced that its investigation had concluded that the photographs were fake.[40]: 95  The originator of the fake photographs was arrested and ultimately sentenced to a 2.5 year prison sentence for fraud and 13 government officials were disciplined (with seven of them removed from office).[40]: 95 

See also edit

  • Holocene extinction

References edit

  1. ^ "Panthera tigris amoyensis (Hilzheimer, 1905)". Integrated Taxonomic Information System. Retrieved 6 June 2023.
  2. ^ a b Kitchener, A. C.; Breitenmoser-Würsten, C.; Eizirik, E.; Gentry, A.; Werdelin, L.; Wilting, A.; Yamaguchi, N.; Abramov, A. V.; Christiansen, P.; Driscoll, C.; Duckworth, J. W.; Johnson, W.; Luo, S.-J.; Meijaard, E.; O'Donoghue, P.; Sanderson, J.; Seymour, K.; Bruford, M.; Groves, C.; Hoffmann, M.; Nowell, K.; Timmons, Z. & Tobe, S. (2017). "A revised taxonomy of the Felidae: The final report of the Cat Classification Task Force of the IUCN Cat Specialist Group" (PDF). Cat News (Special Issue 11): 66–68.
  3. ^ a b Jiang, Z.; Jiang, J.; Wang, Y.; Zhang, E. (2016). "Red List of China's Vertebrates". Biodiversity Science. 24 (5): 500–551. doi:10.17520/biods.2016076.
  4. ^ a b Goodrich, J.; Lynam, A.; Miquelle, D.; Wibisono, H.; Kawanishi, K.; Pattanavibool, A.; Htun, S.; Tempa, T.; Karki, J.; Jhala, Y. & Karanth, U. (2015). "Panthera tigris". IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. 2015: e.T15955A50659951.
  5. ^ a b c Tilson, R. L.; Traylor-Holzer, K. & Jiang, Q. M. (1997). "The decline and impending extinction of the South China tiger". Oryx. 31 (4): 243–252. doi:10.1046/j.1365-3008.1997.d01-123.x.
  6. ^ a b c d Hilzheimer, M. (1905). "Über einige Tigerschädel aus der Straßburger zoologischen Sammlung". Zoologischer Anzeiger. 28: 594–599.
  7. ^ Herrington, S. J. (1987). "Subspecies and the Conservation of Panthera tigris: Preserving Genetic Heterogeneity". In Tilson, R. L.; Seal, U. S. (eds.). Tigers of the world: the biology, biopolitics, management and conservation of an endangered species. Park Ridge: Noyes Publications. pp. 51–63. ISBN 978-0-8155-1133-5.
  8. ^ Luo, S. J.; Kim, J. H.; Johnson, W. E.; Van Der Walt, J.; Martenson, J.; Yuhki, N.; Miquelle, D. G.; Uphyrkina, O.; Goodrich, J. M.; Quigley, H.; Tilson, R.; Brady, G.; Martelli, P.; Subramaniam, V.; McDougal, C.; Hean, S.; Huang, S. Q.; Pan, W.; Karanth, U. K.; Sunquist, M.; Smith, J. L. D.; O'Brien, S. J. (2004). "Phylogeography and genetic ancestry of tigers (Panthera tigris)". PLOS Biology. 2 (12): e442. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.0020442. PMC 534810. PMID 15583716.
  9. ^ Li, Y.-C.; Sun, X.; Driscoll, C.; Miquelle, D. G.; Xu, X.; Martelli, P.; Uphyrkina, O.; Smith, J. L. D.; O'Brien, S. J.; Luo, S.-J. (2018). "Genome-wide evolutionary analysis of natural history and adaptation in the world's tigers". Current Biology. 28 (23): 3840–3849.e6. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2018.09.019. PMID 30482605.
  10. ^ a b c Mazák, V. (1981). "Panthera tigris". Mammalian Species (152): 1–8. doi:10.2307/3504004. JSTOR 3504004.
  11. ^ Caldwell, H. R (1924). Blue Tiger. Abingdon Press.
  12. ^ Chapman Andrews, R. (1925). Camps & Trails in China: A Narrative of Exploration, Adventure, and Sport in Little-Known China. Appleton.
  13. ^ a b c Lu, H. & Sheng, H. (1986). "Distribution and status of the Chinese tiger". In Miller, S & Everett, D. (eds.). Cats of the World: Biology, Conservation and Management. Washington, DC: National Wildlife Federation. pp. 51–58. ISBN 0-912186-78-X.
  14. ^ Cooper, D. M.; Dugmore, A. J.; Gittings, B. M.; Scharf, A. K.; Wilting, A. & Kitchener, A. C. (2016). "Predicted Pleistocene–Holocene range shifts of the tiger (Panthera tigris)". Diversity and Distributions. 22 (11): 1199–1211. doi:10.1111/ddi.12484.
  15. ^ Peilon, X., Bangjie, T., Xiangggang, J. (1987). South China Tiger Recovery Program. pp. 323–328 in: Tilson, R. L., Seal, U. S. (eds.) Tigers of the world: the biology, biopolitics, management and conservation of an endangered species. Noyes Publications, Park Ridge, N.J.
  16. ^ Koehler, G.M. (1991). Survey of the remaining population of South China tigers. Unpubl. report, WWF International, Gland, Switzerland.
  17. ^ a b Tilson, R.; Defu, H.; Muntifering, J.; Nyhus, P. J. (2004). "Dramatic decline of wild South China tigers Panthera tigris amoyensis: field survey of priority tiger reserves" (PDF). Oryx. 38 (1): 40–47. doi:10.1017/S0030605304000079.
  18. ^ Global Tiger Forum. (2007). Tiger Update by Global Tiger Forum (GTF) – May 2007 Archived 25 December 2010 at the Wayback Machine. CITES COP14 Inf. 19.
  19. ^ The Wild South China Tiger: The Photographers Account Archived 17 October 2007 at the Wayback Machine. Save China's Tigers.
  20. ^ Bagchi, S.; Goyal, S. P.; Sankar, K. (2003). "Prey abundance and prey selection by tigers (Panthera tigris) in a semi-arid, dry deciduous forest in western India". Journal of Zoology. 260 (3): 285–290. CiteSeerX doi:10.1017/S0952836903003765.
  21. ^ Wegge, P.; Odden, M.; Pokharel, C. Pd.; Storaasc, T. (2009). "Predator–prey relationships and responses of ungulates and their predators to the establishment of protected areas: A case study of tigers, leopards and their prey in Bardia National Park, Nepal". Biological Conservation. 142: 189–202. doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2008.10.020.
  22. ^ Ming Z. D. (2003). "The Tiger Trouble and its Relevant Problems in Ming and Qing Dynasty". Ancient and Modern Agriculture. 16 (1): 17–23.
  23. ^ Mo, Y. (2008). "百虎围村50年前的人虎大战". 法制周报 (in Chinese).
  24. ^ Nowell, K. (2007). Asian big cat conservation and trade control in selected range States: evaluating implementation and effectiveness of CITES Recommendations (PDF) (Report). Cambridge, UK: TRAFFIC International.
  25. ^ Nowell, K.; Bauer, H.; Breitenmoser, U. (2007). "Cats at CITES COP14" (PDF). Cat News (47): 33–34.
  26. ^ Breitenmoser, U.; Tilson, R.; Nyhus, P. (2006). "Reintroduction of the Chinese Tiger" (PDF). Cat News (44): 15.
  27. ^ Bangjie, T. (1987). Status and Problems of Captive Tigers in China. pp. 134–148 in: Tilson, R. L., Seal, U. S. (eds.) Tigers of the world: the biology, biopolitics, management and conservation of an endangered species. Noyes Publications, Park Ridge, N.J.
  28. ^ Luo, S. J.; Johnson, W. E.; Martensen, J.; Antunes, A.; Martelli, P.; Uphyrkina, O.; Traylor-Holzer, K.; Smith, J. L. D.; O'Brien, S. J. (2008). "Subspecies genetic assessments of worldwide captive tigers increase conservation value of captive populations". Current Biology. 18 (8): 592–596. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2008.03.053. PMID 18424146. S2CID 16594083.
  29. ^ Guo, J. (2007). "Tigers in trouble: Year of the tiger". Nature. 449 (7158): 16–18. Bibcode:2007Natur.449...16G. doi:10.1038/449016a. PMID 17805270. S2CID 4332687.
  30. ^ Zhang, Wenping (September 2019). "Sorting Out the Genetic Background of the Last Surviving South China Tigers". Journal of Heredity. 110 (6): 641–651. doi:10.1093/jhered/esz034. PMID 31102441. Retrieved 14 April 2021.
  31. ^ Chellel, K. (2016). "The South China Tiger Is Functionally Extinct. Stuart Bray Has 19 of Them".
  32. ^ Rare South China cubs head for South Africa Archived 28 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine. Save China's Tigers UK (1 September 2003).
  33. ^ a b FAQs Archived 15 February 2011 at the Wayback Machine. Save China's Tigers (25 July 2004). Retrieved on 26 September 2011.
  34. ^ The Baby Tiger That's Beating Extinction | Youtube Channel-SkyNews. (4 December 2007). Retrieved on 26 September 2011.
  35. ^ Clock ticks for South China tigers in symbolic year Archived 16 July 2010 at the Wayback Machine. Reuters News. 12 February 2010. Retrieved on 26 September 2011.
  36. ^ Tiger finance, a banker's effort to fund survival. Reuters. 16 February 2011. Retrieved on 26 September 2011.
  37. ^ Scientists Confirm the Role of Rewilding Captive Populations to Save the South China Tiger Archived 28 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine. Save China's Tigers UK (October 2010)
  38. ^ Warren, J. (2010). Tiger Cubs Saved by Catwoman., 5 October 2010. Retrieved on 26 September 2011.
  39. ^ Fàbregas, M. C.; Fosgate, G. T.; Koehler, G. M. (2015). "Hunting performance of captive-born South China tigers (Panthera tigris amoyensis) on free-ranging prey and implications for their reintroduction". Biological Conservation. 192: 57–64. doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2015.09.007. hdl:2263/50208.
  40. ^ a b c d Shi, Song (2023). China and the Internet: Using New Media for Development and Social Change. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press. ISBN 9781978834736.
  41. ^ World | Asia-Pacific | Rare China tiger seen in the wild. BBC News (12 October 2007). Retrieved on 26 September 2011.
  42. ^ 绝迹24年华南虎重现陕西 村民冒险拍下照片 Archived 13 October 2007 at the Wayback Machine. Retrieved on 26 September 2011.
  43. ^ EastSouthWestNorth: The South China Tiger Photographs. Retrieved on 26 September 2011.
  44. ^ Paw imitations: Those tiger snaps prove fake| 上海日报 – English Window to China News. Shanghai Daily. Retrieved on 26 September 2011.
  45. ^ Wu, Z. (2008). "'Paper tiger' tales shred credibility". Asia Times Online. Archived from the original on 12 May 2008. Retrieved 23 April 2008.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)

External links edit