Isaac Doolittle

Isaac Doolittle (August 3, 1721 – February 13, 1800) was an early American inventor, engineer, manufacturer, militia officer, entrepreneur, printer, politician, and brass, iron, and silver artisan. Doolittle was a watchmaker and clockmaker, known for making and selling at his shop in New Haven, Connecticut one of the first brass wheel hall clocks in America,[1] where he also crafted and sold scientific instruments, and is regarded as "the first native practitioner" of silversmithing in the Connecticut Colony.[2] He was also an engraver and printer of both legal forms and currency, and became the first American to design, manufacture, and sell a printing press in 1769.[3] Somewhat late in life, he became a successful self-educated bell-foundryman, learning the difficult craft of casting large metal bells.

Isaac Doolittle
Isacc Doolittle engraved signature from brass clockface.jpg
Signature medallion from brass clock face of an Isaac Doolittle hall clock, c. 1770
Born(1721-08-03)August 3, 1721
DiedFebruary 13, 1800(1800-02-13) (aged 78)
New Haven, Connecticut, United States
OccupationEngineer
Spouse(s)Sarah Todd
Children9
Parent(s)Joseph and Sarah Doolittle

An important figure in the religious life of Connecticut as an Episcopal Churchwarden and co-founder of Trinity Church on the Green in New Haven, Doolittle was also an active Patriot during the American Revolution. Perhaps his most notable contribution is his having designed and crafted in 1775 the moving and brass parts for David Bushnell's submersible vessel Turtle, the first submarine used in combat. In crafting the watch work triggering mechanism for Bushnell's explosive underwater magazine, Doolittle created the first mechanical time bomb, while his two-blade propeller was the first practical and applied use of a propeller in watercraft.[4][5]

Doolittle was well known in his time as an "ingenious mechanic", or what would be called an engineer today.[6] His legacy is widespread in numerous forms of American industry and craftsmanship, and his many pioneering innovations are often associated with the popular notion of Yankee ingenuity.

Early lifeEdit

Isaac Doolittle was born in Wallingford, Connecticut, the son of Joseph and Elizabeth (Holt) Doolittle.[7] At an early age he apprenticed under the clockmaker Macock Ward in Wallingford, but moved to New Haven about the time he married Sarah Todd of Wallingford on November 10, 1743. He opened a shop across from Yale College on Chapel Street,[8] where he repaired, made, and sold not only clocks and watches, but "compasses, sea and land surveyors scales and protractors, gauging rods, walking sticks, silver plated buttons turned upon a horn, and a variety of other work".[9]

First Warden of Trinity ChurchEdit

After opening his clock, instrument, and silversmith shop in New Haven, Doolittle became quite wealthy. Around 1749, he was appointed along with Enos Alling by the Anglican missionary priest and educator the Reverend Samuel Johnson, D.D., as one of two church wardens of Trinity Church on the Green, the first Church of England parish in Puritan-dominated New Haven, where the Congregationalist Church was the established state religion of the colony and Yale College in the town was seen as "The School of the Prophets" and the bastion of Puritan orthodoxy. Against strong and determined Puritan opposition, in 1752, he and fellow warden Alling obtained a deed for a plot from innkeeper Samuel Mix, Jr., and oversaw the construction of the first Trinity Church in 1752–1753, with Doolittle contributing more money to its construction than any of its other founding members.[10] He continued on in the role of warden, guiding the parish for much of the next 35 years, from 1750 to 1765, from 1770 to 1777, and again from 1783 to 1785.[11]

French and Indian WarEdit

 
Isaac Doolittle brass hall clock face, c. 1770s

At the height of the French and Indian War the General Court of Connecticut appointed Doolittle Armourer (or Armorer) of the Connecticut Militia: in 1755, he served on the General Staff under General William Johnson from June 9 to August 6 and from September 10 to December 6, supporting Connecticut's war effort.[12] He was again appointed Armorer in 1758, this time for Connecticut's Fourth Regiment under Colonel David Wooster.[13] As armorer "he gained some experience in gunpowder production", which would prove vitally important to the Patriot war effort during the American Revolutionary War twenty years later.[14] He also gained firsthand knowledge of British leadership incompetence in the disastrous expedition against Fort Carillon as well as their naval capabilities in the successful Siege of Louisbourg of 1758.[15]

Video of Isaac Doolittle hall clock striking the hour

Pre-Revolution business activitiesEdit

By 1760, he had returned wholly to civilian endeavors. He was selling imported silver watches, and advertising his own manufactured clocks, bar iron, "screws for clothiers"[16] and surveyor's instruments and mariner's compasses in his Chapel Street shop. As the British Parliament's Iron Act of 1750 prohibited iron and steel manufacturing, Doolittle was already exhibiting a resistance to the British he had so recently joined to fight the French.

In 1764, he was appointed tax collector in New Haven for "Proprietors of the Township of Ludlow, in the Province of New Hampshire.[17] He was also a sealer of weights and measures for town of New Haven, and printed Connecticut currency in his shop as well as government forms.

In 1769, after successfully duplicating the iron screw used in printing presses, he expanded his business to manufacture and sell the first printing press made in America, which he sold to William Goddard of Philadelphia. The Massachusetts Gazette and Boston Weekly News-Letter of September 7, 1768 described it as a "Mahogany Printing-Press on the most approved construction, which by some good judges in the Printing Way, is allowed to be the neatest ever made in America and equal, if not superior to any imported from Great-Britain".[18][19] He and his son Isaac Jr. produced about a dozen presses over the next 20 years, each taking 5 weeks to build and priced at 16 pounds sterling, half the price of a press imported from England.[20]

In August 1774, Doolittle advertised in the New Haven newspapers that he had erected a bell-foundry, and was selling bells made to order. He would continue to cast bells almost until his death in 1800.

 
Advertisement for Isaac Doolittle's bell foundry in New Haven Connecticut Journal, September 29, 1784

American Revolutionary WarEdit

Doolittle was a member of the New Haven Committee of Correspondence.[21][22] When the war started in 1774, Doolittle, with his partners Jeremiah Atwater and Elijah Thompson, erected a gun powder mill in the nearby village of Westville, three miles north-west of New Haven, which turned out large quantities of gunpowder during the war to supply the patriot army and militias.[23] He was also a paymaster for the militia.[24]

He was a New Haven selectman and served on a committee to procure guns for the town's defense.[25] In 1775, he was appointed a commissioner in charge of erecting a beacon to be used to give an alarm if the British attacked New Haven,[26] and was in charge of New Haven's port ship inspections to ensure the boycott of British imports was followed.[27][28] He was also appointed that year to a Connecticut government committee to prospect for lead mines in the colony.[29] In 1776, he was a member of the New Haven Committee of Safety,[30] where he organized a September 17, 1776 memorial warning against the activities of notorious Loyalists such as his fellow churchwarden Abiathar Camp,[31] who five years later in 1781 indeed procured pilots and boats to guide the British fleet into New London harbor.[32]

There is a tradition that Doolittle, though "the most important man among its founders",[33] was forced out of the position Warden at Trinity Church, then part of the Church of England, "because he had aided the king's enemies by making powder" and that it was not until "the conclusion of peace Mr. Doolittle was reinstated in the hearts of his countrymen and in the vestry he became one of the wardens".[34][35] As only two of the 100 heads of households of the church Doolittle helped found were Loyalists, a large number of its members were Patriot privateers or soldiers, and even the neutralists members of his church turned Patriot after the destructive British raid when its rector the Rev. Dr. Bela Hubbard substituted General George Washington's name for King George III in its prayer services,[36] it was more likely that his many war-time activities left him too busy to fulfill the warden's duties until after the war.

The TurtleEdit

According to Benjamin Gale, a doctor who taught at Yale, the many brass and mechanical (moving) parts of the Turtle submarine, the first submarine to engage in warfare, were built by Doolittle.[37] Though David Bushnell is frequently given the overall design credit for the idea of the Turtle by Gale and others, Doolittle is often credited if at all as only a hired "mechanic". However, the relationship was actually asymmetric in the other direction. In 1775, Bushnell was a poor 35 year old Yale bachelor student and a former farmer in rural Connecticut who had sold his half-share of his Westbrook, Connecticut farm to his brother to fund his education as a medical doctor. Doolittle was a very wealthy and highly respected 55 year old head of a family of seven, a successful shop owner with a thriving business, the long time Warden and founder of Trinity Church in New Haven, and a pillar of the city, where he was an armorer, tax collector, selectman, port inspector, lead prospector, and gunpowder miller; he was experienced in large metal design and manufacturing of screws and bells, as well as the more delicate design and construction of pumps, navigation instruments, and clockwork devices, with his own foundry and team of apprentices at hand, and with access to gunpowder and lead, the two most scarce materials needed for the submarine. In the context of the time, an "ingenious mechanic" in Gale's wording[38] was what today would be called an engineer and inventor, a designer and not just a craftsman.

 
The Turtle submarine

"Much of the equipment Bushnell needed to produce for his submarine was beyond the skills of a blacksmith" and were "sophisticated designs requiring precision manufacturing"; they required artisans with years of skill as apprentices, and the ability "to visualize mechanical concepts and interactions between gears and levers" as well as the tools and machinery to make the parts.[39] Given his mechanical engineering expertise and previous experience in design and manufacturing brass bells, clocks, screws, and marine instruments, it seems likely Doolittle designed the brass and the moving parts of the Turtle.[40] Given his wealth and public position, he also likely funded the Turtle's development, supplied the scarce commodities of gunpowder and lead, and obtained the colonial government's cooperation for the first tests. Of the four major innovations of the first submarine, Bushnell figured out how ignite gunpowder underwater while he was a student at Yale,[41] while brass caster, watchmaker, and scientific instrument maker Doolittle designed the propeller and its drive systems, the first working underwater depth gauge,[42] and the mine attachment and clockwork timed detonator. Doolittle's propeller, described as a "a pair of oars fixed like the two opposite arms of a windmill",[43] had "no precedent" in design and was the first known use of a bladed propeller in a watercraft.[44] His clockwork detonator attached to the underwater mine was the first known mechanically detonated time bomb. Other parts of the Turtle, its hand crank, the food-driven treadle, and the flywheel for propulsion,[45] brass and iron emergency ballast drop,[46] brass forcing or bilge pumps for water ballast,[47] brass circular hinged hatch[48] with three round glass ventilation doors,[49] two brass snorkel pipes and ventilator bellows, [50] compass marked with bio-luminescent foxfire,[51] and the rudder along with its iron bar steering mechanisms were based on preexisting designs and were likely jointly designed by Bushnell, Doolittle and his team, then built by Doolittle in his shop and brass factory.

Recently, Doolittle's involvement in the Turtle was part of an important ruling in the field of copyright law over the ownership rights of the "original analysis" identifying Doolittle as the engineer of the brass hatch for the Turtle submarine. On July 15, 2015, US District Judge Jeffrey Alker Meyer ruled in the lawsuit of Leary v. Manstan, in the District of Connecticut that copyright law for nonfiction works does not cover "original historical theories nor use of typical storytelling techniques so long as they do not appropriate the particular expression used by another author."[52]

Marriage and childrenEdit

Isaac Doolittle married Sarah Todd on November 10, 1743. Sarah Todd Doolittle was born on January 30, 1725, in New Haven, and died on March 10, 1814 in New Haven. Together they had nine children, five of whom died before Isaac's death in 1800 and a sixth before Sarah's:[53][54][55][56][57] Thankful Doolittle (b. January 21, 1745, bapt. January 27, d. May 17, 1751, in Wallingford, aged 6); Sarah Doolittle (b. June 29, 1747, bapt. July 16 in Stafford, d. July 21, 1832 in New Haven, aged 85); Abigail Doolittle (b. October 3, 1749, bapt. November 1749, d. October 24, 1794 in New Haven, aged 45); Mary Doolittle (b. March 12, 1752, bapt. April 8, d. August 6, 1760 in New Haven, aged 8)[a]; Thankful Doolittle (b. January 21, 1754, d. February 16, 1827 in New Haven, aged 73); John Todd Doolittle (b. May 20, 1756, d. 1773 in New Haven, aged 17); Isaac Doolittle Jr. (b. February 13, 1759, d. September 15, 1821 in Cheshire, aged 62)[b]; William Frederick Doolittle (b. April 14, 1761, death date unknown, suggesting infant mortality); and Elizabeth Mary Doolittle (b. March 16, 1765, d. April 5, 1811 in Guilford, aged 46).

DeathEdit

Doolittle's health failed in 1785 and he suspended business activity for several years, but in January 1788 he announced in a newspaper advertisement his return to health and business in his reopened shop.[58] There is a humorous anecdote by the well-known New Haven physician Eneas Munson, a man known not only as a scientific doctor but for his droll comments at the expense even of his intimate friends, that may illuminate something of Doolittle's irascible character in this period. According to the account of Henry Bronson:

He gave an emetic to a troublesome neighbor, Isaac Doolittle, who in a fit of intoxication had taken an ounce of laudanum. The next day, finding his patient sober, he admonished him in the most solemn manner of the error of his ways, saying he had rescued him from a horrible death. “I do not thank you for what you have done,” Doolittle replied. “Well, I am sure the neighbors won't,” responded the doctor.[59]

Doolittle continued to make clocks and cast bells until 1797, when his health failed again and he largely retired from business. He died on February 13, 1800 at age 78, according to his obituary, "after a long and distressing illness of several years", honored as "a very worthy and respectable character".[60] He was buried on the Green in New Haven near the State House;[61] there is an empty space apparently reserved for his stone at Grove Street Cemetery next to his co-warden Enos Alling, but his stone was either lost, broken, or not transferred when the other stones from people buried on the Green were moved to Grove Street Cemetery in 1821 – though his daughter Mary's stone can be found along the west wall there. His wife Sarah, born on January 30, 1725, in New Haven, Connecticut, died on March 10, 1814 in New Haven and is buried in Center Street Cemetery, Wallingford, Connecticut.

LegacyEdit

The brass works for a number of Doolittle's clocks survive in private hands, and a circa 1765 "tall clock" is part of the holding of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City.[62] A number of Doolittle's many apprentices continued his work, including his son Isaac Doolittle Jr. (who took over his father's clockmaking shop following the elder Isaac's death), his nephew Enos Doolittle, Hezekiah Hotchkiss, Nathan Howell, Simon Jocelin, his younger cousin Amos Doolittle,[63] and James Cochran, who took over Doolittle's bell-foundry. It has been noted that, "The talent of these local artisans and others ensured New Haven's reputation as a leading hardware and clock-manufacturing city by the middle of the nineteenth century".[64] Doolittle's grandson, Isaac Doolittle III, was also a Patriot in the War of 1812, an inventor who patented devices for steam engines and furnaces, and, like his grandfather, a pioneering printer and artist who illustrated the poem "Old Santeclaus with Much Delight" in an 1821 book[65] that was the first publication to illustrate the modern American legend of Santa Claus. In this and in other illustrated books he is sometimes credited with introducing the United States to lithography.

The Turtle was the first submersible vessel used for combat. Historian of technology Brooke Hindle credited the Turtle as "the greatest of the wartime inventions."[66] Thus it has inspired a number of working and artistic replicas, some of which can be found on display at the Royal Navy Submarine Museum in Gosport, United Kingdom, the Connecticut River Museum in Essex, the Submarine Force Library and Museum in Groton, and the Oceanographic Museum in Monaco. Rick Brown, a co-builder of a 2002 replica, called it "the greatest technological advancement of the American Revolutionary War," and that with it, "Yankee ingenuity was born".[67]

For over half a century, from 1743 until his retirement in 1797, Doolittle was "one of the leading manufacturers and most versatile mechanics"[68] in the American colonies and "a citizen of character and enterprise, whose mark in his generation was that of striking originality",[69] as well as a key historical transition figure in the shift from Puritan to Yankee in New England. Doolittle is often cited as an early example of the famous Yankee ingenuity stereotype of inventiveness, discovering technical solutions to practical problems, self-reliance, and individual enterprise.

NotesEdit

  1. ^ Mary Doolittle was buried on the New Haven Green. Her grave stone was removed from the Green and moved (probably in 1821) to Grove Street Cemetery, New Haven, where it was placed along the West Wall.
  2. ^ Isaac Doolittle Jr. took over his father's shop after the elder Isaac's death in 1800 and continued to repair and make clocks and scientific instruments. He is buried in Grove Street Cemetery, New Haven.

ReferencesEdit

  1. ^ "American Clock Making", Scientific American, Munn & Company, 1896, Volume 74, p. 387
  2. ^ Bohen, Peter, and Hammerslough, Philip, and Eisenbarth, Erin, Early Connecticut Silver, 1700–1840, Wesleyan University Press, 2007, p. xvi
  3. ^ Steiner, Bruce, E., Connecticut Anglicans in the Revolutionary Era: A Study in Communal Tensions, Hartford: American Revolution Bicentennial Commission of Connecticut, 1978, p.23
  4. ^ Stein, Stephen K. The Sea in World History: Exploration, Travel, and Trade [2 volumes], Editor Stephen K. Stein, ABC-CLIO, 2017, Volume 1, p. 600
  5. ^ Manstan, Roy R.; Frese, Frederic J., Turtle: David Bushnell's Revolutionary Vessel, Yardley, Pa: Westholme Publishing. ISBN 978-1-59416-105-6. OCLC 369779489, 2010, pp. xiii, 52, 53
  6. ^ Morgan, William James, and Clark, William Bell, and Crawford, Michael J., Naval documents of the American Revolution, Volume 1, Naval History Division, Dept. of the Navy, 1964, Letter from Benjamin Gale of Yale from Killingsworth to Benjamin Franklin, August 7, 1775, p. 1089
  7. ^ Jarvis, Lucy Cushing, Sketches of Church Life in Colonial Connecticut: Being the Story of the Transplanting of the Church of England Into Forty Two Parishes of Connecticut, with the Assistance of the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel, Tuttle, Morehouse & Taylor Company, 1902, p. 117
  8. ^ Hoopes, Penrose R., Connecticut Clockmakers of the Eighteenth Century, Charles E. Tuttle Company, 1986, p.9
  9. ^ Hoopes, p. 72
  10. ^ Beardsley, Eben Edwards, The History of the Episcopal Church in Connecticut: From the settlement of the colony to the death of Bishop Seabury, Hurd and Houghton, 1874, p. 172
  11. ^ Croswell, Frederick, “A History of Trinity Church, New Haven, by Frederick Croswell, esq., Read March 8, 1868”, Papers of the New Haven Colony Historical Society, New Haven Colony Historical Society, 1865., Appendix A
  12. ^ Bates, Albert, Rolls of Connecticut men in the French and Indian war, 1755-1762, Connecticut Historical Society, 1903, Volume 1, p.3
  13. ^ Hoadly, Charles J, The Public Records of the Colony of Connecticut [1757-1762], Lockwood & Brainard Company, 1880, p. 125
  14. ^ Kuslan, Louis I., Connecticut Science, Technology, and Medicine in the Era of the American Revolution, American Revolution Bicentennial Commission of Connecticut, 1978, p. 38
  15. ^ Nester, William, The Epic Battles of the Ticonderoga, 1758. Albany, New York: State University of New York Press, 2005, ISBN 978-0-7914-7321-4. OCLC 105469157, pp. 162–164
  16. ^ Hoopes, p. 72
  17. ^ Hoopes, p. 71
  18. ^ Massachusetts Gazette and Weekly New Letter, Boston [Mass.] : R. Draper, 1769-1776, September 7, 1768
  19. ^ Hoopes, p. 71
  20. ^ Amory, Hugh, and Hall, David D., A History of the Book in America: Volume 1: The Colonial Book in the Atlantic World, Univ of North Carolina Press, 2009, p. 168
  21. ^ Kellogg, A.H. editor, A National Register of the Society, Sons of the American Revolution by Sons of the American Revolution, Press of A. H. Kellogg, 1902, p. 180
  22. ^ Hinman, Royal, A Historical Collection from Official Records, Files, &c., of the Part Sustained by Connecticut, During the War of the Revolution: With an Appendix, Containing Important Letters, Depositions, &c., Written During the War, E. Gleason, 1842, p. 39
  23. ^ Rockey, John L., History of New Haven County, Connecticut, Volume 1, W. W. Preston, 1892, p.197
  24. ^ Munsell, Frank, American Ancestry: Embracing lineages from the whole of the United States, J. Munsell's sons, 1890, p. 105
  25. ^ The Collector, Volumes 24-29, Walter Benjeman, 1911, p. 90
  26. ^ Towshend, Charles Hervey, Papers of the New Haven Colony Historical Society, Volume 6, The Society, 1900, p. 160
  27. ^ Hinman, Royal, A Historical Collection from Official Records, Files, &c., of the Part Sustained by Connecticut, During the War of the Revolution: With an Appendix, Containing Important Letters, Depositions, &c., Written During the War, E. Gleason, 1842, p. 516
  28. ^ Barber, John Warner, Connecticut Historical Collections, New Haven: Hamlen, 1836, p. 176
  29. ^ Child, Elias, Genealogy of the Child, Childs and Childe Families, of the Past and Present in the United States and the Canadas, from 1630 to 1881, Utica NY: Curtiss and Childs, 1881, p. 209
  30. ^ Hinman, p. 567
  31. ^ Hinman, p. 566
  32. ^ Foster, Alexander, Ontario Bureau of Archives, Report of the Bureau of Archives for the Province of Ontario, Volume 2, Part 1, L.K. Cameron, 1905, p. 80
  33. ^ Scientific American, p.387
  34. ^ Jarvis, p. 118
  35. ^ Scientific American, p. 387
  36. ^ Olsen, Neil, Two Hundred Years on the Green: Celebrating the 1816 Consecration of Trinity Episcopal Church, New Haven, Connecticut, Trinity Church Publications, 2017, p. 61-76
  37. ^ Diamant, Lincoln, Chaining the Hudson: The Fight for the River in the American Revolution, New York: Fordham University Press, 2004, p. 23
  38. ^ Morgan, William James, and Clark, William Bell, and Crawford, Michael J., Naval documents of the American Revolution, Volume 1, Naval History Division, Dept. of the Navy, 1964, Letter from Benjamin Gale of Yale from Killingsworth to Benjamin Franklin, August 7, 1775, p. 1089
  39. ^ Manstan and Frese, p. 52
  40. ^ Manstan and Frese, p. 52, 52-53, 57, 88, 105, 107, 109, 110, 112, 120-123, 131, 138, 150, 194-198
  41. ^ Tucker, Spencer C. Editor,"Bushnell, David (1740-1824)",American Revolution: The Definitive Encyclopedia and Document Collection, ABC-CLIO, 2018, Volume 1, p. 200
  42. ^ Marstan and Frese, pp. 120-124
  43. ^ Abbot, Henry L., Beginning of Modern Submarine Warfare under Captain Lieutenant David Bushnell, Hamden, CT: Acrhon Books,1966, p. 177
  44. ^ Manstan and Frese, p. 150
  45. ^ Manstan and Frese, p. 94, 95
  46. ^ Manstan and Frese, pp. 103-104
  47. ^ Manstan and Freese, pp. 105-108
  48. ^ Manstan and Frese pp.109-114
  49. ^ Manstan and Frese, pp. 114-115
  50. ^ Manstan and Frese, pp. 116-117
  51. ^ nstan and Frese, p. 120a
  52. ^ Leary v. Manstan, Case 3:13-cv-00639-JAM Document 70 Filed 07/15/15
  53. ^ Jocobus, Donald Lines, Families of Ancient New Haven, Rome, New York, Clarence D. Smith, 1923, p. 547
  54. ^ Doolittle, William Frederick, M.D, The Doolittle Family in America, Vols 1-7, Cleveland, 1901-1908, p. 104
  55. ^ DAR Records, Vol 32. p. 118
  56. ^ Mackenzie, George Norbury & Rhoes, Nelson Osgood, Colonial Families of the USA, 1995, Vol 7, p. 198
  57. ^ Tuttle, George Frederick Tuttle, The Descendants of William & Elizabeth, 1883), p. 598.
  58. ^ Hoopes, p. 72
  59. ^ Bronson, Henry, M.D., "Medical History and Biography", Papers of the New Haven Colony Historical Society, Volume 2, New Haven Colony Historical Society, 1877, p. 272
  60. ^ Connecticut Journal, February 20, 1800; Hoopes, p. 72
  61. ^ Jarvis, p. 118
  62. ^ The Met Fifth Avenue, New York, New York, Bequest of Helena D. Swift, 1943, Accession Number:43.148
  63. ^ Hoopes, p.9
  64. ^ Sletcher, Michael, New Haven: From Puritanism to the Age of Terrorism, Arcadia Publishing, 2004, p.43
  65. ^ Stansbury, Arthur Joseph (1821). The Children's Friend: A New-Year's Present, to the Little Ones from Five to Twelve. Part III. : Containing Eight Coloured Engravings. Broadway, New York: Gilley, William B. III.
  66. ^ Alex Roland, "Bushnell's Submarine: American Original or European Import," Technology and Culture 18 (April 1977), 158.
  67. ^ Tom Gidwitz, "The Turtle Dives Again: Two artists recreate George Washington's wooden sub." Archaeology, 58 (May/June 2005): 36–41
  68. ^ Hoopes, p. 70
  69. ^ Scientific America, p. 387