Dyke (slang)(Redirected from Dyke (lesbian))
The term dyke or dike is a slang noun meaning lesbian; it is also a slang adjective describing things associated with lesbianism. It originated as a homophobic and misogynistic slur for a masculine, tomboyish, or butch woman; while this pejorative usage still exists, the term dyke has been reappropriated by lesbians to an extent as a word implying assertiveness and toughness, or simply as a neutral synonym for lesbian.
The origin of the term is obscure and many theories have been proposed. The Oxford English Dictionary notes the first attestation as Berrey and Van den Bark's 1942 American Thesaurus of Slang. There, dike was the more common term. From the mid-19th century to the early 20th century, dike had been American slang for a well-dressed man, with "diked out" and "out on a dike" indicating a young man was in his best clothes and ready for a night on the town. The etymology of that term is also obscure, but may have originated as a Virginian variant of deck and decked out.
However, the term bulldyker preceded dyke in print, appearing in Harlem Renaissance novels in the 1920s. Claude McKay's 1928 Home to Harlem includes the passage that lesbians are "what we calls bulldyker in Harlem... I don't understan'... a bulldyking woman." From the context in the novel, the word was considered crude and pejorative at the time. This may be related to the late-19th-century slang use of dike ("ditch") for the vulva. Bull ("male cattle") being used in the sense of "masculine" and "aggressive" (e.g., in bullish), a bulldyke would have implied (with similar levels of offensiveness) a "masculine cunt". Other theories include that bulldyker derived from morphadike, a dialect variant of hermaphrodite, used for homosexuals in the early 20th century; that it was a term for stud bulls and originally applied to sexually successful men; or that it was a dialectical corruption of the name of the rebel Celtic queen Boadicea.
In an investigative study, Julia Stanley theorizes that the source of these varying definitions stems from gender-determined sub-dialects. Homosexuality in America is a “subculture with its own language.” As such, a special vocabulary is developed by its members. Previously, male homosexuals defined dyke as lesbian without derogation. A bull dyke was also defined as a lesbian without further distinction. For female homosexuals of the community, however, a dyke is an extremely masculine, easily identified lesbian, given to indiscretion. Bull dyke is an extension of this term, with the addition of this person described as nasty, obnoxiously aggressive, and overly demonstrative of her hatred of men.
In an alternative investigation, Susan Krantz discusses the etymology of bulldyke, with derivations of the Middle English “falsehood” for bull and dick for dyke (Farmer and Henley 1891). Therefore, a possible origin for a masculine lesbian comes from bulldicker that could specifically mean “fake penis,” denoting a “false man.” Further speculation talks of the synonymous term bulldagger. Here, dagger also alludes to the male genitalia and bull referring to "false" rather than "man". The earliest account of dagger in this context stems from an account in 1348 by Henry Knighton.
In the 1950s, the word dyke was used as a derogatory term used by straight people and lesbians who were most likely to be able to move up in social class. They used this term to identify crude, rough bar lesbians. In the 1970s, a poem called “Edward the Dyke” was published by Women’s Press Collective. This empowered the lesbian community because they had never heard the term dyke used officially, because it was only used as a derogatory term against them. Because of the exposure of the word to the public, the term dyke was officially taken up by the lesbian community in the 1970s.
The meaning of dyke has positively changed over time. Most members of the community have dropped bull from the term to use it as a positive identifier of one who displays toughness, or as a simple, generic term for all lesbians. This abbreviation does not carry the negative connotations of the full phrase as it previously did. Scholar Paula Blank, in an article on lesbian etymology, calls for taking ownership of lesbian and similar words.
In the late 20th and early 21st century, the term dyke was claimed by many lesbians as a term of pride and empowerment. In her article "The Only Dykey One", Lucy Jones argues that consideration of lesbian culture is core to an understanding of lesbian identity construction. Matters came to a head when the United States Patent and Trademark Office denied the lesbian motorcycle group Dykes on Bikes a trademark for its name, on the grounds dyke was offensive, derogatory and disparaging to lesbians. However, the office reversed itself and permitted the group to register its name after lawyers appealed and submitted hundreds of pages to show the slang word does not disparage lesbians in the way it once did. Dykes on Bikes declared victory on December 8, 2005 and slowly gained international recognition for leading the city’s gay parade.
Much of the gay slang that is used today was once seen by the public as self-destructive and demeaning, especially when it was used within the LGBTQ+ community. In 1969, people in the gay community began to march in the streets to demand civil rights. If used, terms such as dyke and faggot were used to identify people as political activists for the gay community. During this time, dyke referred to a woman committed to revolution, the most radical position. A surge of feminism in the lesbian community led to “dyke separatism”, which emphasized that lesbian women should consider themselves to be separate from men and their ideas and movements.
Dyke Marches have become a popular gay pride events nationwide in the United States. They are generally non-commercial, often in sharp contrast to corporate-sponsored pride events, and are usually inclusive of lesbian, bi, and trans women. The Dyke March held in Boston is known for having a spirit of unity and inclusiveness. Its mission is “to provide a dynamic and welcoming space for participants of all sexualities, gender expressions, races, ages, ethnicities, sizes, economic backgrounds, and physical abilities.”
A dyke bar is a term used to describe any bar or club in which lesbians often attend, but can also indicate a "tougher" establishment (in terms of the patrons or environment). As with the stand-alone word dyke, the term is considered not only slang, but a potential slur when used by non-LGBT persons.
- Krantz, Susan E. (1995). "Reconsidering the Etymology of Bulldike". American Speech. 70 (2): 217–221. doi:10.2307/455819. JSTOR 455819.
- Spears, Richard A. (1985). "On the Etymology of Dike". American Speech. Duke University Press. 60 (4): 318–327. doi:10.2307/454909. ISSN 0003-1283. OCLC 913655475. JSTOR.
- Dynes, Wayne R. (1991). The Encyclopedia of Homosexuality. Garland Publishing. pp. 335–336.
- "dyke, n.³", Oxford English Dictionary, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1972.
- "dyke, n.²", Oxford English Dictionary, 2nd ed., Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989 .
- "dyke", Online Etymology Dictionary.
- Herbst, Phillip (2001). Wimmim, Wimps, & Wallflowers: An Encyclopaedic Dictionary of Gender and Sexual Orientation Bias. Intercultural Press. p. 332. ISBN 978-1-877864-80-3..
- Judy Grahn, Another Mother Tongue.
- Stanley, Julia P. (1970). "Homosexual Slang". American Speech. 45 (1/2): 45–59. doi:10.2307/455061. JSTOR 455061.
- Faderman, Lillian; Gross, Larry (2001). Garber, Linda, ed. Identity Poetics. Race, Class, and the Lesbian-Feminist Roots of Queer Theory. Columbia University Press. pp. 31–62. doi:10.7312/garb11032. JSTOR 10.7312/garb11032.6.
- Blank, Paula (2011). "The Proverbial "Lesbian": Queering Etymology in Contemporary Critical Practice". Modern Philology. 109 (1): 108–134. doi:10.1086/661977. JSTOR 10.1086/661977.
- "success stories: trademark".
- Jones, Lucy (2011). "'The only dykey one': constructions of (in)authenticity in a lesbian community of practice". Journal of Homosexuality. 58 (6–7): 719–41. doi:10.1080/00918369.2011.581917. PMID 21740207.
- Anten, Todd (2006), "Self-Disparaging Trademarks and Social Change: Factoring the Reappropriation of Slurs into Section 2(a) of the Lanham Act(currently unavailable as archive only includes records within 3 years of present)" (PDF), Columbia Law Review, 106: 338, archived from the original (PDF) on 2006-04-26, retrieved 2007-07-12
- Stanley, Julia P. (1974). "When We Say "Out of the Closets!"". College English. 36 (3): 385–391. doi:10.2307/374858. JSTOR 374858.
- Seelhoff, Cheryl Lindsey; Leigh, Sue; Rodgers, Melissa; Herold, Steph; Mantilla, Karla (2007). "UNITED STATES: when is a dyke not welcome at a dyke march?". Off Our Backs. 37 (2/3): 6–6. JSTOR 20838797.
- Bates, Gloria (June 6, 2018). "Dyke: A Fracture In the Lesbian Community". Medium.
- Bendix, Trish (June 23, 2017). "Dyke Marches Assert Political Power and Demand Visibility. But They're Under Threat". Outward. Slate.
- Eliason, Michele J. (20 July 2010). "A New Classification System for Lesbians: The Dyke Diagnostic Manual". Journal of Lesbian Studies. Taylor & Francis. 14 (4): 401–414. doi:10.1080/10894161003677133. ISSN 1089-4160. OCLC 795931159.
Special Issue: A History of "Lesbian History," Part 2
- Kleindienst, Kris, ed. (1999). This Is What Lesbian Looks Like: Dyke Activists Take on the 21st Century (1st ed.). Firebrand Books. ISBN 978-1563411175.
- Knadler, Stephen P. (2002). "Sweetback Style: Wallace Thurman and a Queer Harlem Renaissance". MFS Modern Fiction Studies. Johns Hopkins University Press. 48 (4): 899–936. doi:10.1353/mfs.2002.0076. ISSN 0026-7724. OCLC 436657207. Project MUSE.</ref>
- Levy, Ariel (March 2, 2009). "Lesbian Nation". The New Yorker. (article about the Van Dykes collective)
- Morris, Bonnie J. (December 22, 2016). "Dyke Culture and the Disappearing L". Outward. Slate.
- Smith, Kristin (June 21, 2011). "The Lez Look Book". The Bold Italic. Medium.