User:The High Fin Sperm Whale/RfA expectations

Home

Talk

Contributions

Email

Userboxes

Sandbox

Commons page

Edit count

These are my expectations that I think RfA candidates should have. If they do not meet these standards, I will vote oppose or neutral. Do note that in the "Participation in admin areas" section, I will only look at the contributions in the areas the candidate says he will be working in, so if he says he will work in one area, I will not review his edits to other areas. Also, every person is different, so these are just rules of thumb - they are not meant to be followed to the letter. There will be exceptions. If you think that these standards are not fair, please do not modify them, but post comments here.

RfAs

Criteria	Likely to vote support	Likely to vote neutral	Likely to vote oppose
Experience and edit count
Account created	1 year ago or more	3 months-1 year	less than three months
Edit count (non-automated, I will not count edits made with automated tools)	2,000 +	1,750-2,000	1,000 -
Participation in admin areas
AfDs and XfDs	75 +	50-75	50 -
CSDs	200 + deleted contributions	200-100 deleted contributions	100- deleted contributions
AIV, RFP, AN, AN/EW, AN/I, UAA, SPI, etc.	100 +	75-100	75 -
Behavior
Block log	6 + months ago	6-3 months ago	3 - months ago
Edit warring	No EWs in the last 9 months ago	EWs 9-6 months ago	EWs 6 - months ago
Usage of Edit Summaries	90%+	90-75%	75%-
Behavior on his RfA
Responses to opposes	Responds in a civil and calm manner	Responds in a somewhat civil manner	Makes personal attacks and behaves immaturely
Responses to questions	Tells the truth and answers the question	Tries to avoid the question	Tells a blatant lie

RfBs

Criteria	Likely to vote support	Likely to vote neutral	Likely to vote oppose
CHU, CHU/SUL, and CHU/U	150 + edits	150-100 edits	100- edits
RfAs and RfBs	100 +	100-75	75-
BTR	150 +	150-100	100-