The Happiness Hypothesis
The Happiness Hypothesis: Finding Modern Truth in Ancient Wisdom is a 2006 psychology book by Jonathan Haidt written for a general audience. In it, Haidt poses several "Great Ideas" on happiness espoused by thinkers of the past – Plato, Buddha, Jesus and others – and examines them in the light of contemporary psychological research, extracting from them any lessons that still apply to our modern lives. Central to the book are the concepts of virtue, happiness, fulfillment, and meaning.
Summary of chaptersEdit
Ch.0: Introduction: Too much wisdomEdit
The Introduction first explains that the author's goal is to reduce the infinite 'wisdom' accessible to modern people into 10 great ideas, one per chapter. The remainder of the Introduction provides a concise preview of those ten chapters as follows. The first chapter describes how each person has two parts: the primitive part which includes our basic instincts and the highly evolved part which tries to control the instincts. This effort to control our instincts is shown in Chapter Two to tend to cause us too much worry, but various techniques, such as meditation, might be employed to detach the worrier from his worries. The Third Chapter goes to the relationship of the individual to other individuals by beginning with the Golden Rule of doing unto others as you would have them do unto you. That leads in the Fourth Chapter to a description of the tendency that people have of seeing faults in others more readily than in themselves, which by simply realizing we might go to some length to rectify and thus come closer to living by the Golden Rule. By the Fifth Chapter, at the half-way point of the book, Haidt introduces the notion of the Happiness Hypothesis. The Happiness Hypothesis could be that happiness comes from within, as Buddha said, or could be that happiness comes from outside. Haidt argues in Chapter Six that the truth might lie between the two extremes and contends that love depends on more than the self and is crucial to happiness. The Seventh Chapter asks whether adversity is essential to happiness and provides a nuanced answer which is that it depends on your stage in life. Achieving happiness is a complex process which includes acting virtuously, and Haidt claims in Chapter Eight that behaving virtuously means to do as Aristotle said and to develop your strengths and realize your native potential. Chapter Nine extends the idea that a person's happiness benefits from living virtuously by noting that some feeling of divinity helps where divinity comes through a life-long practice of moral actions. Chapter Ten takes this idea of a life-long practice yet further and contends that a happy life is one where you get the relationships right between yourself and others, yourself and your work, and between your work and something larger than yourself—you feel a sense of purpose.
Ch.1: The divided selfEdit
Haidt looks at a number of ways of dividing the self that have existed since ancient times:
- mind vs body
- left brain vs. right brain: (lateralisation of brain function)
- old brain vs. new brain (frontal cortex)
- controlled vs. automatic
Haidt focuses on this last division, between the conscious/reasoned processes and automatic/implicit processes. His metaphor is a rider on the back of an elephant in which the conscious mind is the rider and the unconscious mind is the elephant. The rider is unable to control the elephant by force: this explains many puzzles about our mental life, particularly why we have such trouble with weakness of will. Learning how to train the elephant is the secret of self-improvement.
Ch.2: Changing your mindEdit
The automatic emotional reactions of the "elephant" (affective priming) guide us throughout our lives. People even tend to choose mates, and professions, whose names resemble their own. Though there is a bias towards negativity, some people are optimists and others pessimists. Haidt discusses three ways of changing those automatic reactions: meditation, cognitive therapy, and SSRI medications such as Prozac.
Haidt naturally must make simplifications to present in a 300-page book as much of an overview of biology, psychology, philosophy, sociology, and medicine as he attempts. However, in Chapter 2 he makes a risky oversimplification. For starters, the approaches to reducing negativity are classified as meditation, cognitive behavioral therapy, and Prozac. However, those might better be broadly categorized as behavioral and physical interventions. At that point, one would appreciate that physical interventions go well beyond Prozac or the class of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) of which Prozac is an instance. For example, research has shown that benzodiazepine is a better drug for generalized anxiety disorders than SSRIs. More generally, Haidt gives inadequate attention to adverse effects of pharmacologic treatments. A meta-analytic review of 131 controlled trials done in the 21st century on 25,000 patients said, "SSRIs might have statistically significant effects on depressive symptoms, but all trials were at high risk of bias and the clinical significance seems questionable. SSRIs significantly increase the risk of both serious and non-serious adverse events. The potential small beneficial effects seem to be outweighed by harmful effects."
Ch.3: Reciprocity with a vengeanceEdit
Many species have a social life, but among mammals, only humans in particular are ultra-social – able to live in very large cooperative groups. The Golden Rule, supplemented with gossip, is the secret of our success. Calling on Robert Cialdini's "six weapons of influence", Haidt describes ways in which understanding the deep workings of reciprocity can help to solve problems in our social lives and guard against the many ways that we can be manipulated.
Ch.4: The faults of othersEdit
Part of our ultra-sociality is that we are constantly trying to manipulate others' perceptions of ourselves, without realizing that we are doing so. As Jesus said, we see the faults of others clearly, but are blind to our own. ("Why do you see the speck in your neighbour's eye, but do not notice the log in your own eye?") Haidt looks at what social psychology has to say about this, beginning with the work of Daniel Batson on cheating and self-justification, mentioning Robert Wright's description of our "constitutional ignorance" of hypocrisy in The Moral Animal, and moving on to work by Deanna Kuhn and David Perkins on confirmation bias and Roy Baumeister's work on "The Myth of Pure Evil" Haidt then discusses ways of taking off "the moral glasses" and seeing the world as it really is.
Ch.5: The pursuit of happinessEdit
It is a common idea that happiness comes from within and can't be found in external things. For a while in the 1990s, psychologists agreed with ancient sages (such as Buddha and Epictetus) that external conditions are not what matters. But Haidt argues that we now know that some external circumstances do matter. He identifies ways of improving happiness by altering these, including spending money well, and argues that the Western emphasis on action and striving is not without merit.
Ch.6: Love and attachmentsEdit
There are many kinds of love, but, Haidt asserts, they all begin to make sense when you see where love comes from, and what it does. To do this he examines John Bowlby's World Health Organization-sponsored study and report, "Maternal Care and Mental Health" in 1950, and the subsequent work with monkeys by Harry Harlow. Understanding the different kinds of love, he writes, can help explain why people make so many mistakes with love, and why philosophers hate love and give us bad advice about it.
Ch.7: The uses of adversityEdit
Nietzsche wrote, "What doesn't kill me makes me stronger", but this is not true for everyone; adversity may result in post-traumatic stress disorder. Haidt discusses how and why some people grow from their suffering, along with ways of improving one's chances of finding post-traumatic growth. Adversity at the right time in life, as Robert Sternberg's research on wisdom shows, can make people more compassionate and better able to balance the needs of self and others.
Ch.8: The felicity of virtueEdit
Taking Benjamin Franklin as an example, Haidt looks at how success can follow virtue, in the broad sense of virtue that goes back to the Ancient Greek arete, excellence. The ancients, according to Haidt, had a sophisticated psychological understanding of virtue, using maxims, fables and role-models to train "the elephant", the automatic responses of the individual. Though the beginnings of Western virtue lie in Homer, Aesop and the Old Testament, the modern understanding of it has much to do with the arguments of Kant (the categorical imperative) and Bentham (utilitarianism). With these came a shift from character ethics to quandary ethics, from moral education to moral reasoning.
Ch.9: Divinity with or without GodEdit
Using the metaphor of Flatland, Haidt argues that the perception of sacredness and divinity are two basic features of the human mind; the emotions of disgust, moral elevation, and awe tell us about this dimension, but not everybody listens. The "religious right" can only be understood by acknowledging this dimension, which most liberals and secular thinkers ignore or misunderstand. The work of William James and of Abraham Maslow (on "peak experiences") shows ways in which this dimension is also relevant to the non-religious.
Ch.10: Happiness comes from betweenEdit
Haidt discusses "the meaning of life", making the distinction between a purpose for life and a purpose within life. Love and work give a sense of meaning to life. A study by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, Howard Gardner and William Damon established the concept of "vital engagement" which characterises work with the most sense of purpose. "Cross-level coherence" within one's self and life is also vital, coherence between the physical, psychological and socio-cultural levels. Religion is an evolved mechanism for creating this coherence.
Ch.11: On balanceEdit
Haidt concludes by arguing that the ancient idea of Yin and Yang turns out to be the wisest idea of all. We need, he writes, the perspectives of ancient religion and modern science; of east and west; even of liberal and conservative. "Words of wisdom really do flood over us, but only by drawing from many sources can we become wise."
The Happiness Hypothesis received positive reviews. Daniel Nettle, reviewing the book in Nature, accepted its central premise of a "striking similarity between the advice of the ancients on how to live, and the thoughts of modern psychologists on how to have a healthy mind". He was impressed by the breadth of Haidt's grasp of modern behavioural science, and found the book "by some margin the most intellectually substantial book to arise from the 'positive psychology' movement". James Flint concluded his review of the book in The Guardian saying, "I don't think I've ever read a book that laid out the contemporary understanding of the human condition with such simple clarity and sense." Christopher Hart writing in The Times described the book as "humane, witty and comforting... brilliantly synthesising ancient cultural insights with modern psychology".
- Gomez, Angelina; Barthel, Abigail; Hofmann, Stefan (2018). "Comparing the Efficacy of Benzodiazepines and Serotonergic Anti-Depressants for Adults with Generalized Anxiety Disorder: A meta-analytic review". Expert Opin Pharmacother. 19 (8): 89–104.
- Jakobsen, J; Katakam, K; Schou, A; Hellmuth, S; Stallknech, S; Leth-Moller, K; Iversen, M; Banke, M; Iggiannguaq, J; Klingenberg, S; Krogh, J; Ebert, Sebastian; Timm, A; Lindschou, J; Gluud, C (2017). "Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors versus placebo in patients with major depressive disorder. A systematic review with meta-analysis and Trial Sequential Analysis". BMC Psychiatry. 17 (58): 1–28.
- Batson, D; Kobrynowicz D; Dinnerstein JL; Kampf HC; Wilson AD (June 1997). "In a very different voice: unmasking moral hypocrisy". J Pers Soc Psychol. 72 (6): 1335–48. doi:10.1037/0022-35220.127.116.115. PMID 9177020.
- Baumeister, Roy F. (1999). Evil: Inside Human Violence and Cruelty. Henry Holt & Company Inc. p. 448. ISBN 978-0-8050-7165-8.
- Peterson, Christopher; Seligman, Martin E. P. Character strengths and virtues: A handbook and classification. Oxford. ISBN 0-19-516701-5.
- See also: Haidt, Jonathan. "the moral roots of liberals and conservatives". TED. Retrieved 28 May 2010.
- Gardner, H., Csikszentmihalyi, M., and Damon, W. (2001) Good Work: When excellence and ethics meet. New York: Basic Books
- Nettle, Daniel (4 May 2006). "A search for meaning" (PDF). Nature. 441 (7089): 29–30. doi:10.1038/441029a. Retrieved 29 May 2010.
- Flint, James (22 July 2006). "Don't worry, be happy". The Guardian. Retrieved 29 May 2010.
- Hart, Christopher (6 August 2006). "The bright side of life". The Times. Retrieved 29 May 2010.