Talk:Savages (1974 film)

Latest comment: 14 years ago by Arthur Rubin in topic Problems

Problems

edit

Due to the fact that I reverted Burmiester (talk · contribs) while he was editing, I reverted 3 times last night PST. Hence, I need to list the problems that I've seen in the article recently:

  1. The images, although apparently public domain, do not aid understanding of the film.
  2. At one point, a clip of questionable providence was listed in the External links section.
  3. The plot section, at least, is severely overlinked.
  4. The plot section is excessive, per WP:NOT#PLOT.
  5. The plot section may be a copyvio, or may be copied from the (also excessive) plot section of the novel, Deathwatch. (For instance, a source for the specific model of the gun would be required. It was (probably) specified in the novel, but it's unlikely it was specified in the movie.)
  6. IMDB (the only present reference) is not a reliable source.

Tags I cannot restore include:

  1. {{unsourced}}

Arthur Rubin (talk) 16:18, 24 June 2010 (UTC)Reply

Amazon.com is not a reliable source, either. — Arthur Rubin (talk) 19:08, 24 June 2010 (UTC)Reply