Talk:List of National Historic Landmarks in Delaware

Latest comment: 14 years ago by Smallbones in topic Jacob Broom House

Quality rating of this list-table article for WP:NRHP edit

Per discussion at Talk page of WP:NRHP of what should warrant Stub/Start/B/FL class rating for a list-table, I think this article merits "Start" rating within WP:NRHP, because:

  1. It is a "useful" list in the sense required in WP:WIAFL
  2. It is factually accurate as far as it goes. Support for all facts about NHLs within are supported by the corresponding articles, I think.
  3. It is comprehensive, listing all the NHLs in DE.
  4. There should not be controversy about its scope, it is a factual matter what sites are NHLs and which are not.
  5. It displays photos of some of its items
  6. There is an article of at least Stub class for every item on the list.
  7. Reference supporting completeness (first External link) is provided.

It's still a low rating, so I am going ahead and rating it myself, although I am one of the main authors. doncram 15:44, 8 November 2007 (UTC)Reply

Jacob Broom House edit

I'd guess the coords are off on the Jacob Broom House, which is the last here not to have a photo. Google Mapd DOES mark a Jacob Broom House near the coord given, but it is not that close to Montecharian and it is not close to the Brandywine, but rather sort of near the Red Clay Creek. I'd think this is another Jacob Broom house - maybe even owned by a relative. Smallbones (talk) 16:19, 1 April 2010 (UTC)Reply