Talk:Conscript Band of the Finnish Defence Forces

Latest comment: 7 years ago by 69.165.196.103 in topic Assessment

Assessment edit

  • B1: Referencing and citations - Not enough   Fails
  • B2: Coverage and accuracy - Goes too much into details about members without giving much information about the organization at large; that whole section should get blanked since it doesn't seem encyclopedic.   Fails
  • B3: Structure - Not much to it since there's not much to the article.   Fails
  • B4: Grammar and style - Some minor wording issues, but those I will correct   Passes
  • B5: Supporting materials - There's none.   Fails


Overall, this article does not really meet any criteria of C Class, and not very much of Start class either, so I rate it as a stub. 69.165.196.103 (talk) 03:24, 2 March 2017 (UTC)Reply