Old Weather is an online weather data project that currently invites members of the public to assist in digitising weather observations recorded in US log books dating from the mid-19th century onwards. It is an example of citizen science that enlists members of the public to help in scientific research. It contributes to the Atmospheric Circulation Reconstructions over the Earth initiative. Data collected by Old Weather has been used by at least five different climate reanalysis projects, including HURDAT, SODA and ECMWF. In February 2013, the project was awarded the Royal Meteorological Society IBM Award for Meteorological Innovation that Matters.
Type of site
|Volunteer Scientific Project|
|Launched||12 October 2010|
Old Weather is a Zooniverse project and is a collaboration between researchers at many institutions, including the University of Oxford, Oxford Martin School, ACRE (International Atmospheric Circulation Reconstructions over the Earth), Naval-History.Net of Penarth, Jisc which encourages UK colleges and universities in the innovative use of digital technologies, the National Maritime Museum at Maritime Greenwich, London, and the UK National Archives, Kew, London.
Importance of volunteersEdit
In the past, computer programs have proved unable to read handwriting reliably. However, it may be worth exploring the current status of automatic and computer-assisted transcription and probabilistic indexing technologies for handwritten text images—also called Handwriting Text Recognition (HTR), Computer Assisted Transcription of Text Images (CATTI) and Keyword Spotting (KWS), respectively).
In any case, the task is much better performed by the human brain and the results transferred to a digital form. In the site's tutorial, would-be volunteers are shown how to digitise a weather record. Further instructions on how to transcribe the logs are available on the associated Old Weather forum. It is intended that the pages of the logs are digitised by at least three people. The results will be used to make climate model projections and an improved database of weather extremes.
USRC, USCG and USS log booksEdit
Currently, the log books of 2 US vessels are available, each of which have been scanned page by page, and the logs of another 21 vessels have been completed. More log books will be added at intervals. The transcriber notes the following from the log books: date, location (or voyage) and weather records, usually consisting of wind direction and strength, weather conditions, cloud type and/or amount of clear sky, barometric pressure and temperature readings. Other log entries, such as refueling figures and sightings of sea-ice, ships, people, landmarks or animals may also be recorded, as well as interesting events.
Phases I & IIEdit
Phase I was launched in October 2010 and all the available Royal Navy logs from that phase and from Phase II have now been completed. By July 23, 2012, officially, 16,400 volunteers had transcribed the weather data from 1,090,745 pages of the log books of 302 ships. These phases of the project have generated 1.6 million weather observations.
Currently, the scope of the project is being extended to include Arctic voyages and expeditions. Satellite imagery of this region goes back only to the 1950s, but it was explored for 100 years before that (for example the Franklin Expedition).
Initial results of Phase I will be published after data collection is complete and conclusions can be made.
Indeed, the readings are still being assessed at a very broad level. But the distribution of temperature by latitude and wind force by latitude have been plotted for 120,000 results for which three readings have been taken.
Security and political considerationsEdit
Because climate change is a very political issue, interested parties could try to corrupt the data by, say, entering temperature figures that are too high or too low. Because three sets of records for each data point will be entered, any set from a digitiser showing a marked deviation from the other records should be easily checkable and eliminated. Large-scale fraud is unlikely because the data is entered one log page at a time, and so is immune to a spam type of attack. Collaborative projects such as Linux and Wikipedia have for the most part been able to rely on the transparent honesty of those taking part.
Accidental errors, such as reading '4's for '7's are possible, but often context will sort this out. A temperature of 40 °F is unlikely to be correct for a latitude in the tropics and may safely be assumed to be 70 °F.
- Philip Brohan (1 March 2013). "People using our results". Oldweather.org. Retrieved 20 March 2013.
- "2012 Award Winners". Royal Meteorological Society. 2013. Retrieved 20 February 2013.
- "Himanis - Chancery Indexing and Search".
- "TSO/BNE/PROLOPE/PRHLT - Indexing and Search".
- "PRHLT Indexing and Search".
- Rachel Saslow (2010-10-18). "British scientists seek help extracting weather data from WW1 naval records". The Washington Post. Retrieved 2011-11-12.
- BBC staff (2010-10-13). "WW1 ships to chart past climate". BBC News. Retrieved 2011-11-12.
- Philip Brohan (2012). "Theres a green one and a pink one and a blue one and a yellow one". Oldweather.org. Retrieved 5 November 2012.
- Philip Brohan (2012). "One million six hundred thousand new observations". Oldweather.org. Retrieved 5 November 2012.
- Ian Simpson (Reuters) (2012). "US Looks to Old Arctic Ship Logs for Climate Change Clues". ScientificAmerican.com. Retrieved 2011-11-12.
- Justin Gillis (2012-10-24). "Retrieving the weather of the past". New York Times. Retrieved 5 November 2012.
- Philip Brohan (3 February 2011). "Stanley to Archangel, and all points in between". Oldweather.org. Retrieved 15 February 2011.
- "Climate change". Met Office. 2008-11-19. Archived from the original on 2010-11-27. Retrieved 2010-11-11.
- The Zooniverse (2010-10-27). "First fruits:Weather records from HMS Acacia". Oldweather.org. Retrieved 2011-11-12.
- Lauren Morello (ClimateWire) (2010-11-05). "Historic Sea Voyages Buoy Climate Science". NYTimes.com. Retrieved 2010-11-11.
- Marissa Cevallos (2010-09-09). "Mining The Maritime Past For Clues To Climate's Future". Science News. Retrieved 2010-11-11.