Wikipedia:Peer review/List of Fulham F.C. players/archive2

List of Fulham F.C. players edit

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch peer review

This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because it previously failed a FL nomination, and has been edited and updated to hopefully now be of a good standard.

Thanks, 03 md 02:38, 5 February 2013 (UTC) Comments[reply]

You've got one disamb link, to Simon Davies.

Done

The images of Edwin van der Sar, Jimmy Hill with Maurice Cook, Danny Murphy, Bobby Moore, and Brede Hangeland all need alt text. The welsh flag could probably literally use alt=Flag of Wales.

Yep I'll sort those

"Fulham Football Club is an English professional football team based in Fulham in the London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham." Can this be reworded to have more to do with the players, and/or can "Fulham Football Club" be bolded?

I'll do that

The whole intro's first paragraph seems like it would be better as a history section than an intro

In most cases I'd agree, but it is modelled off other football featured lists, which have this an intro.

"Figures are mostly taken from Fulham: The Complete Record by Dennis Turner (published in 2007). UEFA Intertoto Cup, UEFA Cup and UEFA Europa League appearance statistics for the 2002–03 and 2009–10 seasons are taken from Soccerbase, along with all other statistics from the 2007–08 season onwards." instead of this, can you include citations in the citations column or is that too much?

Will do.

Sonny Gibbon's flag is missing text, it's just the flag

I'll sort that

Suggestion: This isn't a requirement for featured list or anything, but since my focus on wikipedia is dog related articles, the featured lists I am most familiar with are List of Best in Show winners of Crufts and [[List of Best in Show winners of the Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show] - in these lists, there is a column for pictures of most of the dogs that won. Is it possible to include pictures of the footballers for which we have them available in the table, or is this not practical?

That is a good idea - the dog articles I've seen do it well - but this is not common in football featured lists so I will probably stick to images outside the table.

Criteria 5.a of the featured list criteria states that "a minimal proportion of items are redlinked." Is it possible or practical to stub out some of the player articles?

I will try to do as many as possible.

Can the Soccerbase refs get more complete references or is that a no?

I'll address that

That's all I noticed for now. Other than that it looks pretty good.--TKK ^{bark !} 19:39, 26 February 2013 (UTC)[reply]

Thanks for your review, I will change the things you suggested and then hopefully put it up for Featured List consideration. 03 md 11:20, 1 March 2013 (UTC)[reply]