2024 edit
Arthur O. Austin by RoySmith • 29 May– • Brief comments.- 2023 Union Square riot by LunaEclipse • 23 May– • Support. Tweaks to lead.
- Outer Wilds by PresN • 20 May– • General review.
- Shovel Knight Showdown by The Night Watch • 9 May– • Short prose review-ish.
- Bäckadräkten by Dugan Murphy • 5 May– • Support. General review. Source review.
On Her Majesty's Secret Service (novel) by SchroCat • 4–23 May (19 days) • Support.- Hotline Miami 2: Wrong Number by NegativeMP1 • 25 April– • General review.
- Dracunculiasis by Ajpolino • 23 April–22 May (29 days) • Support. Three pointers.
- Eternal Blue (album) by MFTP Dan • 22 April– • Asking for more content on music, production and lyrics.
- "I'm God" by Skyshifter • 13 April– • Support. Brief comments.
- "You Belong with Me" by Ippantekina • 16 April– • Support. Brief comments.
- Worlds (Porter Robinson album) by Skyshifter & TechnoSquirrel69 • 10 April–28 May (48 days) • Support. Brief comments.
- Jacques Offenbach by Tim riley • 7 April–15 May (38 days) • Support. Source review.
Castle in the Sky by TechnoSquirrel69 • 8 April–2 May (24 days) • Oppose(struck). Concerns about completeness with respect to Development/Production. Prose comments. • Withdrawn.- Chetana Nagavajara by Eevnnap • 7–8 April (1 day) • Oppose on prose. • Consensus not to promote.
- "Can't Let Go" (Mariah Carey song) by Heartfox • 4 April–30 May (56 days) • Support. Brief general review.
- Mars Society by CactiStaccingCrane • 10 March–24 May (75 days) • Support. Brief prose comments x2. Source spot check. • Nominator AWOL.
- Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie by Otuocha (SafariScribe) • 25–31 March 2024 (6 days) • Demanding a major rewrite. Joining SusunW's recommendation of a withdrawal. • Withdrawn by nominator.
- Mission: Impossible – Fallout by Darkwarriorblake • 25 March– • Support. General review.
- Prostate cancer by Ajpolino • 21 March–22 April (31 days) • Support. Minor suggestions for improved comprehensiveness. Source review.
- Narwhal by Wolverine XI • 20–31 March (11 days) • Support. Minor suggestions on prose including clarity. • Prose not considered up to standard.
2023 edit
- Howard Florey by Hawkeye7 • 23 July–27 August 2023 (25 days) • Support. Minor suggestions on improved comprehensiveness and prose.
2021 edit
- Trisomy X by Vaticidalprophet • 21 June–10 September 2021 (81 days) • Support. Small addition on buffalo and moral support. • Unaddressed criticism.
Repeat nominators edit
- Reviewed twice: Ajpolino, Skyshifter, TechnoSquirrel69