| Year published | Hymn tune | First line | Words by | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1867 | Formosa | "Love Divine, all love excelling" | Charles Wesley | Tune also known as "Falfield" |
| 1867 | Hymn of the Homeland | "The homeland, the homeland" | H.R. Harweis | |
| 1867 | Mount Zion | "Rock of Ages, cleft for me" | Augustus Montague Toplady | |
| 1867 | St Luke | "God moves in a mysterious way" | William Cowper | Tune also known as "St Nathaniel" |
| 1868 | St Lucien | "Of Thy love some gracious token" | Thomas Kelly | |
| 1868 | Thou God of Love | "Thou God of Love, beneath Thy sheltering wing" | J.E. Browne | |
| 1869 | Heber | "When through the torn sail" | Reginald Heber | Tune also known as "Gennesareth" or "Succour" |
| 1869 | St Ann | "The Son of God goes forth to war"" | Reginald Heber | Tune also ascribed to Dr. W. Croft, 1677-1727 |
| 1869 | The Strain Upraise | "The Strain upraise in joy and praise" | John Mason Neale (tr.) | |
| 1870 | All this Night | "All this night bright angels sing" | W. Austin | |
| 1871 | Lux in Tenebris | "Lead, kindly Light" | John Henry Newman | |
| 1871 | St Gertrude | "Onward Christian soldiers" | Sabine Baring-Gould | |
| 1872 | Angel Voices | "Angel voices, ever singing" | Francis Pott | |
| 1872 | Courage, Brother | "Courage, brother, do not stumble | Norman Macleod | |
| 1872 | Fatherland | "I’m but a stranger here" | T.R. Taylor | Tune also known as "St. Edmund" or "Cœlestis" |
| 1872 | Fortunatus | "Welcome, happy morning!" | Venantius Fortunatus, tr. by John Ellerton | |
| 1872 | Lacrymae | "Lord, in this Thy mercy's day" | Isaac Williams | |
| 1872 | The Long Home | "Tender Shepherd, Thou hast still'd" | Catherine Winkworth (tr.) | |
| 1872 | Lux Mundi | "O Jesu, Thou art standing" | William Walsham How | |
| 1872 | Propior Deo | "Nearer, my God, to Thee" | Sarah Flower Adams | Tune also known as "Aspiration" |
| 1872 | Rest | "Art thou weary, art thou languid" | Stephen of Saba, tr. by John Mason Neale | Tune also known as "Venite" |
| 1872 | Safe Home | "Safe home, safe home in port" | Joseph the Hymnographer, tr. by John Mason Neale | |
| 1872 | St Kevin | "Come, ye faithful, raise the strain" | John Mason Neale | |
| 1872 | St Mary Magdalene | "Saviour, when in dust to Thee" | Robert Grant | |
| 1874 | Adoro Te | "Saviour, again to Thy dear name we raise" | John Ellerton | |
| 1874 | Audite audientes me | "I heard the voice of Jesus say" | Horatius Bonar | |
| 1874* | Bethlehem | "While shepherds watched their flocks by night" | Nahum Tate | Adapted by Sullivan from an old tune. Alternative name "Gabriel". |
| 1874 | Christus | "Show me not only Jesus dying" | Josiah Conder | |
| 1874 | Clarence | "Winter reigneth o'er the land" | William Walsham How | Tune from unknown source arranged by Sullivan |
| 1874 | Coena Domini | "Draw nigh, and take the body of the Lord" | John Mason Neale | |
| 1874 | Come Unto Me | "Come unto Me, ye weary" | William Chatterton Dix | Adapted from an original melody by George Frideric Handel |
| 1874 | Constance | "I've found a Friend; oh, such a Friend" | James Grindlay Small | |
| 1874 | Coronae | "Crown Him, with many crowns" | Matthew Bridges | |
| 1874 | Dulce Sonans | "Angel voices, ever singing" | Francis Pott | |
| 1874 | Ecclesia | "The church has waited long" | Horatius Bonar | |
| 1874 | Ellers | "Saviour, again to Thy dear name we raise" | John Ellerton | Believed to be a harmonization by Sullivan of a tune by E.J. Hopkins. The tune is otherwise known as "Benediction" |
| 1874 | Evelyn | "In the hour of my distress" | Robert Herrick | |
| 1874 | Ever Faithful | "Let us with a gladsome mind" | John Milton | |
| 1874 | Golden Sheaves | "To Thee, O Lord, our hearts we raise" | William Chatterton Dix | |
| 1874 | Hanford | "Jesu, my Saviour, look on me" | Charlotte Elliott | |
| 1874* | Holy City | "Sing Alleluia forth in duteous praise" | John Ellerton (tr.) | |
| 1874 | Hushed was the Evening Hymn | "Hushed was the Evening Hymn" | James Drummond Burns | |
| 1874 | Light | "Holy Spirit! Come in might!" | Edward Caswall | Arrangement by Sullivan from tune of unknown source |
| 1874 | Lux eoi | "All is bright and cheerful round us" | ||
| 1874 | Marlborough | "O Strength and Stay, upholding all creation" | John Ellerton (tr.) | Harmonisation by Sullivan |
| 1874* | Nearer Home | "For ever with the Lord!" | James Montgomery | Harmonized by Sullivan from a tune by Isaac B. Woodbury |
| 1874* | Noel | "It came upon the midnight clear" | Edmund Sears | Adapted by Sullivan from a traditional tune |
| 1874 | Old 137th | "Great King of nations, hear our prayer" | J. Hampden Gurney | Harmonisation by Sullivan |
| 1874 | Paradise | "Oh Paradise! Oh Paradise!" | Frederick William Faber | |
| 1874 | Parting | "With the sweet word of peace" | George Watson | Adapted by Sullivan from an old melody |
| 1874 | Pilgrimage | "From Egypt's bondage come" | Thomas Kelly | |
| 1874 | Promissio Patris | "Our blest Redeemer, ere He breathed" | Harriet Auber | |
| 1874 | Resurrexit | "Christ is risen! Christ is risen!" | A.T. Gurney | |
| 1874 | St Francis | "Father of heaven, who hast created all" | Catherine Winkworth (tr.) | |
| 1874 | St Millicent | "Let no tears to-day be shed" | R. F. Littledale (tr.) | |
| 1874 | St Patrick | "He is gone - a cloud of light" | Arthur Penrhyn Stanley | |
| 1874 | St Theresa | "Brightly gleams our banner" | Thomas Joseph Potter | |
| 1874 | Saints of God | "The Saints of God, their conflict past" | William Dalrymple Maclagen | |
| 1874 | Springtime | "For all Thy love and goodness" | William Walsham How | Arrangement by Sullivan of an original tune |
| 1874 | Ultor Omnipotens | "God the all terrible! King who ordainest" | Henry Chorley | |
| 1874 | Valete | "Sweet Saviour, bless us 'ere we go" | Frederick William Faber | |
| 1874 | Veni Creator | "Come Holy Ghost, our souls inspire" | John Cosin (tr.) | |
| 1875 | Carrow | "My God, I thank Thee Who has made" | Adelaide Anne Procter | |
| 1875 | Litany No. 1 | "Jesu, life of those who die" | Thomas Benson Pollock | |
| 1875 | Litany No. 2 | "Jesu, we are far away" | Thomas Benson Pollock | |
| 1880 | Dominion Hymn | "God bless our wide dominion" | Marquess of Lorne | |
| 1881 | Leominster | "A few more years shall roll" | Horatius Bonar | Harmonised by Sullivan from a tune by G.W. Walker |
| 1897 | Bishopgarth | "O King of Kings, Whose reign of old" | William Walsham How | Composed for Queen Victoria's diamond jubilee celebrations |
| 1902 | Bolwell | "Thou to whom the sick and dying" | Godfrey Thring | |
| 1902 | Chapel Royal | "O love that wilt not let me go" | George Matheson | |
| 1902 | The Roseate Hues | "The roseate hues of early dawn" | Cecil Frances Alexander | Composed 1872, but not published until 1902 |
| 1902 | Victoria | "To mourn our dead we gather here" | Mary Bradford Whiting |
