- Terrence O'Donnell, associate justice of the Ohio Supreme Court
- William J. O'Donnell, associate justice of the Maryland Court of Appeals
{{disambiguation|tndis}}
- Elisha Payne, chief justice of the Vermont Supreme Court
- H. Vern Payne, associate justice of the New Mexico Supreme Court
-==See also==
{{disambiguation|tndis}}
- William H. Pemberton, associate justice of the Washington Supreme Court
- William Y. Pemberton, associate justice of the Montana Supreme Court
- Miles Nelson Pike, associate justice of the Supreme Court of Nevada
- Robert G. Pike, associate justice of the New Hampshire Supreme Court
- Epaphroditus Ransom, associate justice of the Supreme Court of Michigan
- Richard E. Ransom, associate justice of the New Mexico Supreme Court
- Perez Richmond, associate justice of the Rhode Island Supreme Court
- William Richmond (Rhode Island), associate justice of the Rhode Island Supreme Court
- Abraham M. Rudman, associate justice of the Maine Supreme Judicial Court
- Paul L. Rudman, associate justice of the Maine Supreme Judicial Court