Thomas Crofton Croker
Thomas Crofton Croker (15 January 1798 – 8 August 1854) was an Irish antiquary, best known for his Fairy Legends and Traditions of the South of Ireland (1825–1828), and who also showed considerable interest in Irish song and music.
Although Fairy Legends purported to be an anthology of tales Croker had collected on his field trips, he had lost his manuscript notes and the work had to be reconstructed with the help of friends. He did not acknowledge his debt satisfactorily in the estimation of Thomas Keightley, who voiced his complaint publicly, and soon published his own rival work. The other collaborators generally allowed Croker to take credit, notably William Maginn, though after his death his kinsmen insisted Maginn had written four or more of the tales. Croker retracted ten tales in his third edition of (1834), and after his death, a fourth edition (1859) appeared which was prefaced with a memoir written by his son.
William Butler Yeats, who appropriated a number of tales for his anthology, characterised Croker as belonging to the class of the Anglo-Irish ascendancy, and criticised him for comic distortions of the Irish tradition, an assessment echoed by other Irish critics. Bridget G. MacCarthy wrote a biographical paper that scrutinises Croker's habit of publishing writings by others under his own name. Defenders of Croker include Justin McCarthy and Neil C. Hultin.
Life and worksEdit
Croker was born in the city of Cork. At age 15, he apprenticed in business. During the years 1812 to 1815 he travelled the south of Ireland and began collecting legends and songs. Croker took one Irish coronach (keening) that he collected in Cork in 1813, and translated it into English prose, which was published in the Morning Post in 1815 and caught the attention of the poet George Crabbe in 1817, through the intermediary of the antiquary Richard Sainthill.
After his father's death on 22 March 1818, the estate was managed by his distant relative (or of no relation), John Wilson Croker who was then Secretary of the Admiralty, and who procured him a position as clerk there, a position he would retain for thirty years until his retirement in 1850.
He was a man of short stature, measuring 4 feet 10½ inches tall,[a] and described by Sir Walter Scott as "Little as a dwarf, keen eyed as a hawk and of very prepossessing manners—something like Tom Moore".[b]
Researches in the South of IrelandEdit
Croker's first book, Researches in the South of Ireland (1824), was well-received by fellow-antiquaries. According to Croker in his preface, the book was illustrated with pencil drawings by Miss Nicholson and Alfred Nicholson (1788–1833) (his future wife and brother-in-law) who accompanied him on the field trip gathering material.
Researches was followed by Fairy Legends and Traditions of the South of Ireland (1825–1828), which enjoyed immense popular success. This would be Croker's most important work. Walter Scott praised the book in a letter, and commended it in his own works.[c]
The first part was published in 1825; and was translated into German by the Brothers Grimm (Irische Elfenmärchen, 1826). Parts two and three followed in 1828. Part three consisted of the long Grimm essay on fairies (prefaced to the Elfenmärchen) Croker translated, coupled with a section on Welsh fairy tales written by an unidentified female correspondent.
The first edition of Fairy Legends was illustrated with woodcuts by W. H. Brooke; while the second edition was supplied with original drawings by Cork's Daniel Maclise, though undergoing stylistic modifications by the engraver, Brooke. The third edition, three volumes in one was published in 1834. The work went through a total of six editions during the 19th century.
It was instrumental in attracting a wider audience to traditional Irish tales, not just within the English-speaking world, but farther abroad. However, Croker modified the tales according to his own inclinations, and has been criticised for adding too literary a style, and contrived humour to the tales.
Because Croker had lost the manuscript after collecting it from the field, he had to reconstruct the anthology through help from other writers, such as William Maginn, David Richard Pigot, his friend Joseph Humphreys, Thomas Keightley, and R. Adolphus Lynch of Killarney. The first 1825 edition of Fairy Legends and Traditions did not even bear Croker's name, owing to this being a collaborative effort. Humphreys, a Quaker, was a companion during Croker's excursions into the south 1812–1815.[d] Samuel Carter Hall named himself as the contributor of two tales, and Charles Dod of Parliamentary Companion as another collaborator.
In Fairy Legends, the credit for the first piece "The Legend of Knocksheogowna" and three others were claimed by Maginn, including the prominent "Daniel O'Rourke".[e] But according to Croker, the manuscript of "Daniel O'Rourke" was in the handwriting of Humphreys, touched up by Maginn, and further altered by Croker before going into print.[f] Though such production that entails modification at multiple stages may be poorly countenanced by the modern folklorist, it is pointed out that such methodology is not so distant from the one practiced by the Grimms at the time.
Croker eventually took sole credit, and kept all of the proceeds from the book's financial success, but of these collaborators, only Keightley publicly voiced protest,[g] and Keightley went on to publish his own Fairy Mythology in 1828. In the wake of it, Croker published the 1834 third edition that eliminated portions of competing claims, reducing the number of tales from 50 down to 40, and purged of "most of the copious notes", of which the comparative notes Keightley claimed to have supplied. Literary scholar Bridget G. MacCarthy gave a modern-day view criticism of Croker's dodging his way out of attributing the effort of collaborators.
Daniel O'Rourke on stageEdit
Croker adapted the tale "Daniel O'Rourke" into a Christmas Pantomime under the title "Harlequin and the Eagle", and performed in 1826 at the Adelphi Theatre, for the sake of actor Daniel Terry. The actor had obtained ownership of the theatre, with considerable financial backing from Walter Scott, who was the friend of the actor's. Scott lavished praises on the pantomime at a meeting with Croker. Though it has been told anecdotally that it was Scott's idea to turn this into a play, Croker had this notion earlier, as evidenced in his notes to Fairy Legends. The play was published as Daniel O'Rourke, or Rhymes of a Pantomime, with a second edition appearing in 1828.
In 1828, Croker participated in an excavation of the Roman site Noviomagus in Kent, and together with some members of the Society of Antiquaries, formed a club named "Noviomagian Society", for which Croker was voted president.
Legends of the LakesEdit
Croker's third book, Legends of the Lakes; or, Sayings and Doings at Killarney (1829) was both a critical and commercial disappointment. It was written in the form of a guided tour through the landscapes of at Killarney, interspersed with legends told in the dialect of the peasantry. He also featured discussions of the music of his friend the Irish piper James Gandsey, of some interest to bagpipe or uilleann pipe musicology.
He edited The Keen of the South of Ireland (1844) for the Percy Society. The first item in this collection (in the preface) was a keen composed in Irish by the mother of Flory Sullivan, collected in Gougane Barra, Co. Cork in 1813. Croker translation of it into English got published in the Morning Post in 1815, as already noted above, and caught notice of poet George Crabbe in 1817. It was an earlier version which was shown to Crabbe in correspondence,[h] but on Crabbe's advice Croker had revised the translation to a more simplified version, more in keeping with the original Irish. B. G. MacCarthy notes that he did not actually translate the keen himself but pass off the labor of native Irish informants such as Mrs. Harrington as his own, and when left to his own devices, Croker "merely revealed ignorance" of the Irish language.
He and his wife's testimonies about funereal customs, particularly the tradition of keening the deceased are among the earliest and most significant contributions to the understanding of the Irish language lament and the accompanying traditions.
Attitude to folkloreEdit
Croker did not present his folklore as he found them, but reinvented them in his own literary style, as pointed out by numerous commentators, even cursory ones. The sort of mixing of folklore and literature was also carried out by contemporaries such as Walter Scott in Scotland. But Croker the antiquarian betrayed a "patronizing" attitude toward his subject, the Irish common folk steeped in tradition.
Croker was an Anglo-Irishman (like Keightley), or as Yeats put it, part of the "harum-scarum Irish gentility" (like Lover). Yeats was not the only one to charge Croker with viewing the lore of the Irish peasantry in a tinted "humorised" light; this gratuitous mockery was also noted, for example, by folklorist Seán Ó Súilleabháin. Yeats repeatedly refers to the class that "imagined [Ireland] as a humorist's Arcadia", and continues "Their work [i.e., of the early folklore collectors] had the dash as well as the shallowness of an ascendant and idle class, and in Croker is touched everywhere with beauty – a gentle Arcadian beauty".[i]
Literary scholar Neil C. Hultin also defended the author. Hultin was well aware that Irish critics bristled at Croker's comic caricatures of the Irish and their brogue, but refrained from himself criticising Croker for insensitivity.[j] Hultin co-wrote with Warren U. Ober the introduction to Croker's reissued Fairy Legends (1993), which also depicted Croker in a sympathetic light, stating that he showed genuine affection for the peasantry, and commiseration for the oppression felt by Ireland. Hultin and Ober have suggested that Croker was trapped between two polar-opposite stereotypes of the Irish: both "intelligent, sensitive" and "headstrong, violent".
On ancient manuscript recordsEdit
Croker was contemptuous of Irish annals such as the Annals of the Four Masters, and manuscripts such as the Book of Ballymote which contained narratives and poetry, calling them "the monkish chronicles" or "relics", and stating in a cavalier manner that Irish history would not suffer at all at "the total loss of the legendary records of an age of ignorance and superstition".
He claimed to be capable of reading Irish manuscripts, but it is doubtful whether he had any real proficiency in the Irish language.
List of worksEdit
- Researches in the South of Ireland (1824)
- Fairy Legends and Traditions of the South of Ireland, 3 vols. (1825–28)
- Daniel O'Rourke, 2nd ed. (1828)
- Legends of the Lakes, or Sayings and Doings at Killarney (1829)
- Popular Songs of Ireland (1839)
- The Keen of the South of Ireland (1844)
- Popular Songs, Illustrative of the French Invasions of Ireland, Parts I–IV. (1845–1847), repr. (1847)
Additional titles, and notices of the journals he had contributed to, are listed by Croker's son.
- According to William Maginn.
- From Scott's journal entry. The two men met at J. G. Lockhart's breakfast party on this date (20 October 1926).
- Notes to the 1830 edition of his Waverley Novels, and Demonology and Witchcraft.
- Humphreys later headed "the Deaf and Dumb Institution at Claremont, near Dublin".
- The third by Maginn was "The Legend of Bottle Hill", and a fourth was "Fairies or No Fairies" according to the author's brother (Rev. Charles Arthur Maginn, b. 1815, rector of Castletown, Cloyne, Co. Cork since 1840, and rector of Killanully, Cork from 1874 until his death on 2 February 1887 at age 72). But a conflicting claim makes the fourth to be "The Legend Knockgrafton", according to the reckoning by the author's nephew (Rev. Charles Arthur Maginn, b. c.1860?, appointed successor at Killanully, then rector of Clonfert, Cloyne in 1892, later of Sheffield), who selected this piece for an anthology of Maginn's tale published in 1933. Both works (i.e., "Fairies or No Fairies" and "Knockgrafton") may well be Maginn's product, bringing the tally to five.
- Croker was a directly supplying information to the Dublin University Magazine, as MacCarthy points out.
- Though "Other contributors also protested", according to Sean O'Sullivan.
- A letter mediated by Richard Sainthill, esq.
- Yeats here is more selectively quoted by the short bio in the Irish Literature anthology, chiefly edited by Cork native Justin McCarthy.
- Quote: "Irish critics, sensitive to the use of dialect and to comic portrayals of Irish peasantry, have accused Croker of an indifference typical of the 'Ascendancy' who ruled the country".
- Gentleman's Magazine (1854), p. 453. sfnp error: multiple targets (2×): CITEREFGentleman's_Magazine1854 (help)
- Gentleman's Magazine (1854), p. 397. sfnp error: multiple targets (2×): CITEREFGentleman's_Magazine1854 (help)
- Lee, Sidney (1888). "Croker, Thomas Crofton". In Stephen, Leslie (ed.). Dictionary of National Biography. 13. London: Smith, Elder & Co. pp. 132–134.
- Dublin University Magazine (1849), p. 203.
- "Folk Lore: Antiquarian Gleanings", Journal of the Cork Historical and Archaeological Society, 3: 133–134, 1894
- Gavin, Adrienne E. (2007), "Croker, Thomas Crofton (1798–1854)", in Haase, Donald (ed.), The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Folktales and Fairy Tales, 1, Greenwood Publishing Group, pp. 240–241, ISBN 0313049475
- Croker (1859), p. vi.
- Gentleman's Magazine (1854), p. 398. sfnp error: multiple targets (2×): CITEREFGentleman's_Magazine1854 (help)
- Hultin, N. C. (1987), "Belief and Interpretation in T. Crofton Croker's Legends of the Lakes", Folklore, 98 (1): 65–79, doi:10.1080/0015587x.1987.9716397, JSTOR 1259402
- Bates (1891), p. 50.
- Bates (1891), p. 49.
- MacCarthy (1943), p. 540.
- Scott, Walter (2010). "20 October 1826". In Anderson, W.E.K. (ed.). The Journal of Sir Walter Scott. Canongate Books. ISBN 184767495X.
- Cousin, John William, ed. (1910). . A Short Biographical Dictionary of English Literature. London: J. M. Dent & Sons – via Wikisource.
- Dublin University Magazine (1849), p. 204.
- Croker (1859), pp. vi–vii.
- Hennig (1946), pp. 45–46.
- MacCarthy (1943), p. 548.
- O'Sullivan, Sean (1999) . Folktales of Ireland. Richard Dorson (foreword). London: University of Chicago Press. p. vi. ISBN 0226639983.
- "reprints are dated 1859, 1862, and 1882".
- MacCarthy (1943), p. 547.
- Dublin University Magazine (1849), pp. 202–203.
- Croker (1844), pp. xviii–xix.
- Hall, S. C. (1879) A Memory of Thomas Moore, cited by Ó Casaide (1940), p. 290
- Bates (1891), p. 51.
- Notices on "John Maginn (brother of the celebrated William Maginn)" and "C. A. Maginn (brother of his predecessor), entered T. C. D. on 4th June, 1832, being then seventeen years old". Brady, W. Maziere (1864). "Castletown". Clerical and parochial records of Cork, Cloyne, and Ross. 2. London: Longman, Green, Longman, Roberts, and Green. pp. 106–107.
- Mackenzie, Robert Shelton, ed. (1999) . The Fraserian Papers of the Late William Maginn, LL. D.: Annotated, with a Life of the Author. Richard Dorson (foreword). New York: Redfield. pp. xxxvii–xxxviii.
- MacCarthy (1943), p. 550.
- Notices on the two "Charles Arthur Maginn"s. Cole, John Harding (1903). "Killanully". Church and Parish Records of the United Diocese of Cork, Cloyne, and Ross, Comprising the Eventful Period in the Church's History of the Forty Years from A.D. 1863, to the Present Time. Cork: Guy and Company. p. 68.
- MacCarthy (1943), pp. 551–552.
- Dublin University Magazine (1849), p. 207.
- Hultin & Ober (1983), p. xxv, "Introduction", p. xxv, cited by Vejvoda (2004), p. 43.
- MacCarthy (1943), pp. 548–549.
- MacCarthy (1943), p. 552.
- MacCarthy (1943), pp. 547–554, e.g. "since the stories were well-known folk-tales, Croker had a loop-hole of escape", p. 551; "very digressive and confusing description", p. 551; "No one knew better the slippery tactics of the Leprechaun", p. 552; " So far from allaying existing doubts this preface renders confusion more confused", p. 553; "busy shrouding authorship in mystery", p. 554.
- Schacker, Jennifer (2018). "2 Fairy-Tale Sociability: Print and Performance in Folklore's Prehistory". Staging Fairyland: Folklore, Children's Entertainment, and Nineteenth-Century Pantomime. Wayne State University Press. ISBN 0814345921.
- Croker (1859), p. vii.
- MacCarthy (1943), p. 549.
- Croker (1859), pp. xi–xii.
- McCarthy, Justin, ed. (1904). "Thomas Crofton Croker". Irish Literature. 2. Maurice Francis Egan, Charles Welsh, Douglas Hyde, Lady Gregory, James Jeffrey Roche (assoc. & manag. edd.). John D. Morris & Company. pp. 680–681.
- Breathnach, Breandán (1996). The Man & His Music: An Anthology of the Writings of Breandán Breathnach. Dublin: Na Píobairí Uilleann. pp. 34–36. ISBN 0226639983.
- Gentleman's Magazine (1854), p. 401. sfnp error: multiple targets (2×): CITEREFGentleman's_Magazine1854 (help)
- Gentleman's Magazine (1854), pp. 398, 453. sfnp error: multiple targets (2×): CITEREFGentleman's_Magazine1854 (help)
- Croker (1844), pp. xxii–xxiv.
- MacCarthy (1943), pp. 544–545.
- Schacker (2015), p. 58.
- Hogan, Robert (2016), "Folklore, Irish", Macmillan Dictionary of Irish Literature, Macmillan International Higher Education, pp. 246–247, ISBN 134907795X
- Yeats (1888), p. xv.
- Hultin (1987), p. 65.
- Hultin & Ober (1993), p. 65.
- Compare MacCarthy (1943), p. 546 who points out that Croker in 1847 was busy "copying [songs] out of the anti-Irish Collection of Constitutional Songs edited by A. Edwards (Cork, 1799)" for his Popular Songs illustrative of the French Invasions of Ireland.
- MacCarthy (1943), p. 546, citing Researches in the South of Ireland: chap. xviii, P. 334
- Croker (1832).
- Croker (1859), p. x.
- Croker (1824).
- Croker (1825), 1st ed., Part 1. Croker (1828), 2nd ed., Parts 1, 2, 3.
- Croker (1828b).
- Croker (1829).
- Croker (1839).
- Croker (1844).
- Croker (1847).
- Croker (1859), pp. x–xi.
- "Our Portrait Gallery―No. LV: Thomas Crofton Croker, F.S.A., M.R.I.A.", Dublin University Magazine, 34 (55): 202–216, August 1849
- "Thomas Crofton Croker (obituary)". The Gentleman's Magazine. October 1854. pp. 397–401.
- "Sir Walter Scott and Mr. Crofton Croker". The Gentleman's Magazine. November 1854. pp. 452–455.
- Croker, Thomas Crofton (1824). Researches in the South of Ireland: Illustrative of the Scenery, Architectural Remains, and the Manners and Superstitions of the Peasantry. London: John Murray.
- —— (1825). Fairy Legends and Traditions of the South of Ireland. London: John Murray.
- —— (1828). Fairy Legends and Traditions of the South of Ireland. 1–3. London: John Murray.
- —— (1859). Fairy legends and traditions of the south of Ireland [by T.C. Croker]. With a short memoir of the author by his son. Thomas Francis Dillon Croker. London: William Tegg.
- —— (1828b). Daniel O'Rourke; or, Rhymes of a pantomime. Founded on that story (Second ed.). London: Ainsworth.
- —— (1829). Legends of the Lakes: Or, Sayings and Doings at Killarney. 1. London: John Ebers.; vol. 2
- —— (1832). The Adventures of Barney Mahoney. London: Fisher, Son & Jackson.
- —— (1839). The Popular Songs of Ireland. London: Henry Colburn.
- —— (1844). The Keen of the South of Ireland: As Illustrative of Irish Political and Domestic History, Manners, Music, and Superstitions. Early English poetry, ballads, and popular literature of the Middle ages XIII. London: Percy Society.
- —— (1847) . Popular Songs, Illustrative of the French Invasions of Ireland, in Four Parts. Early English poetry, ballads, and popular literature of the Middle ages XXI. Part 1. London: Percy Society. ISBN 9780384102057.; Part 2 (1847) ; Parts III&IV (1847)
- Hennig, John (January 1946), "The Brothers Grimm and T. C. Croker", The Modern Language Review, 41 (1): 44–54, doi:10.2307/3717492, JSTOR 3717492
- Hultin, Neil C.; Ober, Warren U. (1983) , "Introduction", Fairy Legends and Traditions of the South of Ireland by Croker (New ed.), Delmar: Scholars' Facsimiles & Reprints, pp. i–
- Hultin, Neil C.; Ober, Warren U. (1993). "An O'Connellite in Whitehall: Thomas Crofton Croker, 1798-1854". Éire: A Journal of Irish Studies. 28 (3): 61–86.
- Bates, William (1891) . "Thomas Crofton Croker". The Maclise Portrait-gallery of "illustrious Literary Characters". Daniel Maclise (illustr.) (New ed.). London: Chatto & Windus. pp. 49–53.
- MacCarthy, B. G. (December 1943), "Thomas Crofton Croker 1798-1854", Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review, 32 (128): 539–556, JSTOR 30099490
- Ó Casaide, Séamus (June–December 1940), "Crofton Croker's Irish Fairy", Béaloideas, 10 (1/2): 289–291, JSTOR 20642543 [extract of DNB, and other sources]
- Schacker, Jennifer (2015). "3 Everything Is in the Telling:T. Crofton Croker's Fairy Legends and Traditions of the South of Ireland". National Dreams: The Remaking of Fairy Tales in Nineteenth-Century England. University of Pennsylvania Press. pp. 58–. ISBN 0812204166.
- Vejvoda, Kathleen (2004), ""Too Much Knowledge of the Other World": Women and Nineteenth-Century Irish", Victorian Literature and Culture, 32 (1): 41–61, doi:10.1017/S106015030400035X, JSTOR 25058651, S2CID 162138066
- Yeats, William Butler (1888), "The Legend of Knockgrafton", Fairy and Folk Tales of the Irish Peasantry, W. Scott
- "Archival material relating to Thomas Crofton Croker". UK National Archives.
- Works by T. Crofton Crocker at Project Gutenberg
- Works by T. Crofton Croker at Faded Page (Canada)
- Works by Thomas Crofton Croker at Project Gutenberg
- Works by or about Thomas Crofton Croker at Internet Archive
- Works by Thomas Crofton Croker at LibriVox (public domain audiobooks)
- Works by Thomas Crofton Croker at Open Library
- Thomas Crofton Croker at Library of Congress Authorities, with 41 catalogue records