Talk:Si Tú Supieras/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Carbrera (talk · contribs) 03:24, 26 January 2017 (UTC)

Initial comments

• In the infobox, please capitalize the first 'p' in 'pop ballad' in the "Genre" parameter
• In the infobox, you should include an "Alt" parameter for the single cover image
• Text using "small" font sizes are generally discouraged in the infobox
• Please include the release year of Me Estoy Enamorando in parentheses after its mention
• I'm not so sure "(US)" needs to be included after "United States"
• Can I make notice of how well written the lead is? Great work!
• I would consider changing the section title from "Background" to "Background and composition"
• In the audio sample, please add an extra space between "song." and "Knight"
• The Billboard source you use in "is a bolero-pop ballad song with ranchera influences." makes no mention of it being a "bolero" song
• Is there any information available about who directed/produced/edited the music video?
• Generally, the "Music video" section belongs below the "Reception" section
• "United States (US)" → Same here as above
• "In November 1999, "Si Tú Supieras" was labeled as the "hottest tracks"" → Did you mean "was labeled as one of the..."?
• "Fernández performs them" → Remove "them"
• "Mijares was awarded with a platinum album certification in Mexico for this album.[26]" → I don't believe this belongs in the article; it doesn't really involve the song and is just a tad bit too trivial

ON HOLD – Great work; I will allow as long as you need to respond to my concerns. Thank you very much. Carbrera (talk) 02:45, 27 January 2017 (UTC)

@Carbrera: Hey Carbrera! I believed I've fixed all the issues you've brought. I can't find any information for any of the music videos for the singles from Me Estoy Enamorando unfortunately except for the directors (which I admit I found in a user-submitted music video database). For the Billboard source, I changed it to the Billboard review that says the album is full of boleros/pop/ranchera sounds. And thanks for the compliment on the lead. :) Erick (talk) 15:34, 27 January 2017 (UTC)

@Magiciandude: Thanks for addressing everything; the article is all set to be passed. Just an FYI if you are interested: I have recently nominated an article to go through the FAC process. You are welcome to glance at it, but it is by no means necessary. Regards and thanks, Carbrera (talk) 01:48, 28 January 2017 (UTC).