Talk:Fourth and Long Gone

Latest comment: 5 years ago by 2600:1004:B14D:4951:5A8:B554:2D0F:BE36 in topic Herschel Walker

Citation

edit

Do we really need a citation for the fact that this novel actually exists, and was written by Pepper Rodgers? The picture proves that much. I can accept the fact that there should be a citation to a reliable source for the fact that it is a roman à clef based on actual true stories, but not for the fact that the novel's actual existence and authorship must include a citation to another source other than the book itself. 2600:1004:B14D:4951:5A8:B554:2D0F:BE36 (talk) 02:47, 8 April 2019 (UTC)Reply

Herschel Walker

edit

Okay, even if "Eaarnel Simpson" is a fictionalized Herschel Walker, do we really need the details of the real Walker's subsequent professional career, which has nothing whatever to do with the plot of the book? 2600:1004:B14D:4951:5A8:B554:2D0F:BE36 (talk) 03:00, 8 April 2019 (UTC)Reply