Talk:Daniele Ledonne

Redirect

I've redirected this article to Super Columbine Massacre RPG!. I don't see a sufficient claim to notability for this subject to merit a Wikipedia article — while the game created some minor controversy, its own article covers that well enough. A mention on IMDB isn't particularly noteworthy either, and the subject's movies don't assert anything really significant. Tijuana Brass 05:23, 24 December 2006 (UTC)

...and now I've restored it. After reading through a lot of material on the subject and his game, this is a decision which would be better decided by consensus, assuming this article ever gets enough traffic to spark a discussion. He's not notable as a filmmaker, but there was enough media coverage of the game to give Ledonne his fifteen minutes. If it ever comes to a vote — one that I personally won't be around for, since my involvement on Wikipedia is minimal — put me down for a merge. Tijuana Brass 06:57, 24 December 2006 (UTC)

I have a feeling some of this article was written by Daniele Ledonne himself, e.g. the part listing all the films he made that are not especially notable. I looked at the history and a user named "Tolka" made much of that addition, and in the original version it even said one of his films was available for purchase at the national film network. Is he advertising here? I agree this article isn't noteworthy enough (and doesn't have any citations really) to stand on it's own and should be merged with Super Columbine Massacre RPG! article. --Jim Raynor (talk) 22:25, 29 April 2008 (UTC)

I vote that this article should be removed entirely. The game itself was a bit of a controversy and I understand it having a page. Nonetheless, the individual who made the game isn't well-known enough to merit their own page. Anyway, it does seem as if this guy made this page himself, automatically ruining its credibility. (UTC) —Preceding unsigned comment added by IAmJacksAppendix (talk • contribs)