Ryazan miracle

The Ryazan miracle (or Ryazan affair; Russian: рязанское чудо, lit.'Ryazan miracle', or Russian: рязанский эксперимент, lit.'Ryazan experiment', Рязанская авантюра "Ryazan venture") is a scandal which happened in 1959 and 1960 in provincial region of Ryazan Oblast, Soviet Union that resulted from a propaganda campaign made in support of its planned economy by Alexei Larionov [ru], chief of the Communist Party Committee of Ryazan Oblast, on the verge of newly highly ambitious plans put forward by Nikita Khrushchev to "surpass America". Larionov promised increases in meat and milk production plans that were widely and boldly advertised in Soviet propaganda until widespread lies and falsification were uncovered.[1][2][3] These proved to be disastrous to Ryazan Oblast economy and became a major blow to Khrushchev's political image.[3]


On May 22, 1957, Nikita Khrushchev, the Soviet leader at that time, made a speech at a regional meeting of Soviet agroindustry representatives, in which he aired his famous slogan "Catch up and overtake America" (Russian: Догнать и перегнать Америку). In this speech Khrushchev promised to surpass the United States in economic growth and to complete building of communism by 1980. In his speech he stated a goal in tripling rates of meat production within next three years, the implementation of which though remained far from feasible. A year after the promise the production had not grown and the USSR was still experiencing food shortages.[4] Khrushchev expressed discontent and, towards the end of 1958, the Central Committee of CPSU issued a circular (decree) to obkoms, regional party committees at the oblast (administrative subject) level, to take "decisive action" to ensure improvements in meat production in 1959.[5]

"Catch up and overtake" (Russian: Кто кого? Догнать и перегнать). A 1929 Soviet propaganda poster based on 1917 paraphrase from Lenin, praising the economic superiority of Marxist economy.


Following Khruschev ambitious plans, Larionov (first secretary or head of the Ryazan Obkom), took on the campaign and declared a goal to triple amount of meat produced within the next year. The promise, despite being practically infeasible, was approved at the regional party conference. On October 12, 1958, Larionov delivered the promise to Khrushchev in person, who became excited by the initiative.[6] On January 9, 1959, the promise was published in Pravda, the official party newspaper at the time. The publication was rushed by Khrushchev in spite of objections from the Agricultural Department of the Central Committee. The challenge was met by several other regions including Stavropol and Krasnodar. Even before starting its ambitious plan, the Ryazan region received several awards. In February 1959, the region was awarded with the Order of Lenin.[5]

Livestock slaughterEdit

In order to meet the promise, the region had to slaughter all the bovine herd of 1959, as well as a considerable part of its dairy stock. In addition, all cattle reared by kolkhoz farmers in their private households was appropriated "temporarily". As the collected amount was still not enough to meet the target, obkom had to buy meat from neighbor regions by reallocating funds from other sources, such as the purchase of agricultural tools and construction. On December 16, 1959, Ryazan obkom reported that the region delivered 150,000 tons of meat to the state, which was three times the amount delivered the previous year. On top of this, the regional authorities promised to deliver 180,000 in the next year.[7]

On December 27, 1959, the success was announced by Khrushchev himself at the CPSU Plenum "On further development of agricultural production" (О дальнейшем развитии сельскохозяйственного производства). Also in December, Larionov was awarded the title of Hero of Socialist Labour.[6]


However, in 1960 production of meat in Ryazan oblast plummeted to 30,000 tons, since mass slaughter had reduced the number of cattle by 65% in comparison to the level of 1958. To make matters worse, collective farm (kolkhoz) workers whose private cattle were "temporarily" appropriated the year earlier refused to process collective farm land. This halved the amount of grain produced in Ryazan oblast. By the fall of 1960, it became impossible to hide all disastrous consequences. In September 1960, Larionov was dismissed from his post. On October 10, 1960, he committed suicide. Even post-mortem he was not stripped of his title of Hero of Labour.[8]


Similar events happening on a smaller scale in other regions of the Soviet Union resulted in a statewide drop in agricultural production. Around the same time Khrushchev was obsessed with growing maize and forced its widespread planting. Some party leaders in North-West Russia and Baltic were also eager to report their aspirations in following party line, even though maize does not grow well in northern regions.

All these events gave a blow to Khrushchev's image in the Soviet Union.[3] His slogan "Catch up and overtake America" was widely mocked in jokes. The events contributed to his final fall from power in 1964.[3]

See alsoEdit

  • "Maize fever" (Russian Кукурузная кампания) — a countrywide campaign to switch USSR farming to maize, which resulted in one quarter of all arable lands being occupied by maize and eventually failed as central planners ignored soil and climate differences between regions of USSR
  • Great Leap Forward — China policy that have resulted in Great Chinese Famine of 1959–1960, which stemmed from similar practices of agricultural planning.


  1. ^ Jeremy Smith, Melanie Ilic (2011). Khrushchev in the Kremlin: Policy and Government in the Soviet Union, 1953–64. Routledge. p. 173. ISBN 9781136831829.
  2. ^ Ilya Zemtsov (1988). Chernenko: The Last Bolshevik : The Soviet Union on the Eve of Perestroika. Transaction Publishers. p. 44. ISBN 9781412819459.
  3. ^ a b c d Gorlizki, Yoram (2013). "Scandal in Riazan: Networks of Trust and the Social Dynamics of Deception". Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History. 14 (2): 243–278. doi:10.1353/kri.2013.0023. ISSN 1538-5000.
  4. ^ Peter Kenez (2006). A History of the Soviet Union from the Beginning to the End. Cambridge University Press. p. 199. ISBN 9781139451024.
  5. ^ a b Соколов А.К., Тяжельников В.С. КУРС СОВЕТСКОЙ ИСТОРИИ 1941-1991 Archived 2008-09-27 at the Wayback Machine
  6. ^ a b Вестник архива президента РФ, Журнал "Источник". Archived 2011-07-17 at the Wayback Machine
  7. ^ Энциклопедия » История » 11 класс » Урок 51 Archived 2008-09-21 at the Wayback Machine
  8. ^ Tenure of RSFSR provincial party first secretaries. Russian archive from University of Manchester