Lovász number

In graph theory, the Lovász number of a graph is a real number that is an upper bound on the Shannon capacity of the graph. It is also known as Lovász theta function and is commonly denoted by $\vartheta (G)$, using a script form of the Greek letter theta to contrast with the upright theta used for Shannon capacity. This quantity was first introduced by László Lovász in his 1979 paper On the Shannon Capacity of a Graph.

Accurate numerical approximations to this number can be computed in polynomial time by semidefinite programming and the ellipsoid method. The Lovász number of the complement of any graph is sandwiched between the chromatic number and clique number of the graph, and can be used to compute these numbers on graphs for which they are equal, including perfect graphs.

Definition

Let $G=(V,E)$ be a graph on $n$ vertices. An ordered set of $n$ unit vectors $U=(u_{i}\mid i\in V)\subset \mathbb {R} ^{N}$ is called an orthonormal representation of $G$ in $\mathbb {R} ^{N}$, if $u_{i}$ and $u_{j}$ are orthogonal whenever vertices $i$ and $j$ are not adjacent in $G$: $$u_{i}^{\mathrm {T} }u_{j}={\begin{cases}1,&{\text{if }}i=j,\\0,&{\text{if }}ij\notin E.\end{cases}}$$ Clearly, every graph admits an orthonormal representation with $N=n$: just represent vertices by distinct vectors from the standard basis of $\mathbb {R} ^{N}$. Depending on the graph it might be possible to take $N$ considerably smaller than the number of vertices $n$.

The Lovász number $\vartheta$ of graph $G$ is defined as follows: $$\vartheta (G)=\min _{c,U}\max _{i\in V}{\frac {1}{(c^{\mathrm {T} }u_{i})^{2}}},$$ where $c$ is a unit vector in $\mathbb {R} ^{N}$ and $U$ is an orthonormal representation of $G$ in $\mathbb {R} ^{N}$. Here minimization implicitly is performed also over the dimension $N$, however without loss of generality it suffices to consider $N=n$. Intuitively, this corresponds to minimizing the half-angle of a rotational cone containing all representing vectors of an orthonormal representation of $G$. If the optimal angle is $\phi$, then $\vartheta (G)=1/\cos ^{2}\phi$ and $c$ corresponds to the symmetry axis of the cone.

Equivalent expressions

Let $G=(V,E)$ be a graph on $n$ vertices. Let $A$ range over all $n\times n$ symmetric matrices such that $a_{ij}=1$ whenever $i=j$ or vertices $i$ and $j$ are not adjacent, and let $\lambda _{\max }(A)$ denote the largest eigenvalue of $A$. Then an alternative way of computing the Lovász number of $G$ is as follows: $$\vartheta (G)=\min _{A}\lambda _{\max }(A).$$

The following method is dual to the previous one. Let $B$ range over all $n\times n$ symmetric positive semidefinite matrices such that $b_{ij}=0$ whenever vertices $i$ and $j$ are adjacent, and such that the trace (sum of diagonal entries) of $B$ is $\operatorname {Tr} (B)=1$. Let $J$ be the $n\times n$ matrix of ones. Then $$\vartheta (G)=\max _{B}\operatorname {Tr} (BJ).$$ Here, $\operatorname {Tr} (BJ)$ is just the sum of all entries of $B$.

The Lovász number can be computed also in terms of the complement graph ${\bar {G}}$. Let $d$ be a unit vector and $U=(u_{i}\mid i\in V)$ be an orthonormal representation of ${\bar {G}}$. Then $$\vartheta (G)=\max _{d,U}\sum _{i\in V}(d^{\mathrm {T} }u_{i})^{2}.$$

Value for well-known graphs

The Lovász number has been computed for the following graphs:

Graph	Lovász number
Complete graph	$\vartheta (K_{n})=1$
Empty graph	$\vartheta ({\bar {K}}_{n})=n$
Pentagon graph	$\vartheta (C_{5})={\sqrt {5}}$
Cycle graphs	$\vartheta (C_{n})={\begin{cases}{\frac {n\cos(\pi /n)}{1+\cos(\pi /n)}}&{\text{for odd }}n,\\{\frac {n}{2}}&{\text{for even }}n\end{cases}}$
Petersen graph	$\vartheta (KG_{5,2})=4$
Kneser graphs	$\vartheta (KG_{n,k})={\binom {n-1}{k-1}}$
Complete multipartite graphs	$\vartheta (K_{n_{1},\dots ,n_{k}})=\max _{1\leq i\leq k}n_{i}$

Properties

If $G\boxtimes H$ denotes the strong graph product of graphs $G$ and $H$, then $$\vartheta (G\boxtimes H)=\vartheta (G)\vartheta (H).$$

If ${\bar {G}}$ is the complement of $G$, then $$\vartheta (G)\vartheta ({\bar {G}})\geq n,$$ with equality if $G$ is vertex-transitive.

Lovász "sandwich theorem"

The Lovász "sandwich theorem" states that the Lovász number always lies between two other numbers that are NP-complete to compute. More precisely, $$\omega (G)\leq \vartheta ({\bar {G}})\leq \chi (G),$$ where $\omega (G)$ is the clique number of $G$ (the size of the largest clique) and $\chi (G)$ is the chromatic number of $G$ (the smallest number of colors needed to color the vertices of $G$ so that no two adjacent vertices receive the same color).

The value of $\vartheta (G)$ can be formulated as a semidefinite program and numerically approximated by the ellipsoid method in time bounded by a polynomial in the number of vertices of G. For perfect graphs, the chromatic number and clique number are equal, and therefore are both equal to $\vartheta ({\bar {G}})$. By computing an approximation of $\vartheta ({\bar {G}})$ and then rounding to the nearest integer value, the chromatic number and clique number of these graphs can be computed in polynomial time.

Relation to Shannon capacity

The Shannon capacity of graph $G$ is defined as follows: $$\Theta (G)=\sup _{k}{\sqrt[{k}]{\alpha (G^{k})}}=\lim _{k\rightarrow \infty }{\sqrt[{k}]{\alpha (G^{k})}},$$ where $\alpha (G)$ is the independence number of graph $G$ (the size of a largest independent set of $G$) and $G^{k}$ is the strong graph product of $G$ with itself $k$ times. Clearly, $\Theta (G)\geq \alpha (G)$. However, the Lovász number provides an upper bound on the Shannon capacity of graph, hence $$\alpha (G)\leq \Theta (G)\leq \vartheta (G).$$

Pentagon graph

For example, let the confusability graph of the channel be $C_{5}$, a pentagon. Since the original paper of Shannon (1956) it was an open problem to determine the value of $\Theta (C_{5})$. It was first established by Lovász (1979) that $\Theta (C_{5})={\sqrt {5}}$.

Clearly, $\Theta (C_{5})\geq \alpha (C_{5})=2$. However, $\alpha (C_{5}^{2})\geq 5$, since "11", "23", "35", "54", "42" are five mutually non-confusable messages (forming a five-vertex independent set in the strong square of $C_{5}$), thus $\Theta (C_{5})\geq {\sqrt {5}}$.

To show that this bound is tight, let $U=(u_{1},\dots ,u_{5})$ be the following orthonormal representation of the pentagon: $$u_{k}={\begin{pmatrix}\cos {\theta }\\\sin {\theta }\cos {\varphi _{k}}\\\sin {\theta }\sin {\varphi _{k}}\end{pmatrix}},\quad \cos {\theta }={\frac {1}{\sqrt[{4}]{5}}},\quad \varphi _{k}={\frac {2\pi k}{5}}$$ and let $c=(1,0,0)$. By using this choice in the initial definition of Lovász number, we get $\vartheta (C_{5})\leq {\sqrt {5}}$. Hence, $\Theta (C_{5})={\sqrt {5}}$.

However, there exist graphs for which the Lovász number and Shannon capacity differ, so the Lovász number cannot in general be used to compute exact Shannon capacities.

Quantum physics

The Lovász number has been generalized for "non-commutative graphs" in the context of quantum communication. The Lovasz number also arises in quantum contextuality in an attempt to explain the power of quantum computers.

See also

• Tardos function, a monotone approximation to the Lovász number of the complement graph that can be computed in polynomial time and has been used to prove lower bounds in monotone circuit complexity.

References

• Cabello, Adán; Severini, Simone; Winter, Andreas (January 27, 2014), "Graph-theoretic approach to quantum correlations", Physical Review Letters, 112 (4): 040401, arXiv:1401.7081, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.040401, PMID 24580419, S2CID 34998358
• Duan, Runyao; Severini, Simone; Winter, Andreas (2013), "Zero-error communication via quantum channels, non-commutative graphs and a quantum Lovász ϑ function", IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, 59 (2): 1164–1174, arXiv:1002.2514, doi:10.1109/TIT.2012.2221677, S2CID 4690143
• Grötschel, Martin; Lovász, László; Schrijver, Alexander (1981), "The ellipsoid method and its consequences in combinatorial optimization" (PDF), Combinatorica, 1 (2): 169–197, doi:10.1007/BF02579273, S2CID 43787103, archived from the original (PDF) on 2011-07-18
• Grötschel, Martin; Lovász, László; Schrijver, Alexander (1993), Geometric algorithms and combinatorial optimization, Algorithms and Combinatorics, vol. 2 (2nd ed.), Springer-Verlag, Berlin, doi:10.1007/978-3-642-78240-4, ISBN 978-3-642-78242-8, MR 1261419, page 285
• Haemers, Willem H. (1979), "On Some Problems of Lovász Concerning the Shannon Capacity of a Graph", IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, 25 (2): 231–232, doi:10.1109/tit.1979.1056027, archived from the original on 2012-03-05
• Howard, Mark; Wallman, Joel; Veitch, Victor; Emerson, Joseph (19 June 2014), "Contextuality supplies the 'magic' for quantum computation", Nature, 510 (7505): 351–5, arXiv:1401.4174, Bibcode:2014Natur.510..351H, doi:10.1038/nature13460, PMID 24919152, S2CID 4463585
• Knuth, Donald E. (1994), "The sandwich theorem", Electronic Journal of Combinatorics, 1: A1, arXiv:math/9312214, doi:10.37236/1193
• Lovász, László (1979), "On the Shannon capacity of a graph", IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, IT-25 (1): 1–7, doi:10.1109/tit.1979.1055985
• Lovász, László (1986), "Chapter 3.2: Chromatic number, cliques, and perfect graphs", An Algorithmic Theory of Numbers, Graphs and Convexity, Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics, p. 75, ISBN 978-0-89871-203-2
• Lovász, László (1995–2001), Semidefinite programs and combinatorial optimization (lecture notes)
• Riddle, Marcia Ling (2003), Sandwich Theorem and Calculation of the Theta Function for Several Graphs (M.S. thesis), Brigham Young University, hdl:1877/etd181
• Shannon, Claude (1956), "The zero error capacity of a noisy channel", IRE Transactions on Information Theory, 2 (3): 8–19, doi:10.1109/TIT.1956.1056798
• Todd, Mike; Cheung, Sin-Shuen (February 21, 2012), "Lecture 9: SDP formulations of the Lovász theta function", Lecture Notes for OR6327, Semidefinite Programming (PDF), Cornell University

External links

• Weisstein, Eric W., "Lovász Number" ("Sandwich Theorem") at MathWorld.