Fred Rose (politician)
This article includes a list of references, but its sources remain unclear because it has insufficient inline citations. (June 2014) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
Fred Rose (born Fishel Rosenberg; December 7, 1907 – March 16, 1983) was a Canadian politician and trade union organizer. A member of the Communist Party of Canada and Labor-Progressive Party, he is best known as the only member of the Canadian Parliament ever convicted of a charge related to spying for a foreign country.
|Member of the Canadian Parliament|
August 9, 1943 – January 30, 1947
|Preceded by||Peter Bercovitch|
|Succeeded by||Maurice Hartt|
December 7, 1907
Lublin, Russian Empire
March 16, 1983 (aged 75)|
Rose was jailed during the 1930s for sedition, and won the hatred of Quebec Premier Maurice Duplessis for writing about the close connections between the Duplessis government and the fascist governments of Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini. He was a close associate of Norman Bethune, a doctor who had aided anti-fascist and communist fighters first in Spain during the Spanish Civil War and later in China.
Rose was a candidate for the Communist Party of Canada in the working class Montreal-area riding of Cartier in the 1935 federal election, coming in second with 16% of the vote. He ran in the Quebec general election, 1936 in the riding of Montréal–Saint-Louis for the Communist Party of Quebec and came in third with 16.8%.
Election to parliamentEdit
Early in World War II, the Communist Party of Canada was formally banned and many of its leaders interned. After a major public campaign the CPC was legally reorganized as the Labor-Progressive Party. Rose won election to the House of Commons as an LPP candidate from Cartier in a 1943 by-election. He won with 30% of the vote in a tight four-way race, beating among others, David Lewis of the social democratic Co-operative Commonwealth Federation (CCF). Rose was re-elected in the 1945 election with 40% of the vote. Most of the riding's immigrant Jewish population voted for Rose, who benefitted from the perception that the Soviet Union was the main hope for saving Europe's Jews from Hitler; his main rival, Paul Massé, of the anti-war Bloc Populaire, who came second, was supported by the French Canadian population of the constituency.
Fred Rose was caught up in the world political sea change following World War II when the Soviet Union, a major wartime ally, was now perceived as an enemy in the new Cold War reality. Igor Gouzenko, a young cipher clerk in the Soviet embassy in Ottawa, was recalled to his homeland in July 1945. Rather than return home, Gouzenko defected with documents in September 1945 claiming to show evidence of a massive Soviet spy ring operating in Canada and the United States.
Few took Gouzenko's accusations and evidence seriously at first. A Royal Commission of inquiry, the Kellock–Taschereau Commission, was ultimately established by the government of William Lyon Mackenzie King in February 1946 to investigate Gouzenko's evidence. Headed by two Supreme Court justices, Roy Kellock and Robert Taschereau, the commission arrested and sequestered Canadians named in Gouzenko's documents without legal counsel and barred them from all contact with the outside world until summoned before the commission.
Rose was alleged to lead the ring of up to 20 Soviet spies, which were primarily targeting atomic weapon research from the Manhattan Project. Raymond Boyer, an alleged co-conspirator, testified that Rose was involved in the operation. Rose refused to testify before the commission, which he said was designed to "smear honest and patriotic Canadians". Rose was ultimately found guilty of conspiring to turn over information about the explosive RDX to the Soviets, and was sentenced to prison for a term just one day longer than was required to deprive him of his elected seat in the House of Commons.
Mr. Speaker: If the will of the people is to prevail, if justice is to be done, there can be no question of my expulsion from the house. To the contrary, I should be in my seat in the House of Commons and not in the penitentiary. Parliament is the highest of Courts. Through its actions in my case it will decide whether hysteria is to continue or whether reason and justice are to prevail. Respectfully, Fred Rose, M.P.
His letter was returned to him unread, and on January 30, 1947, he was formally expelled from the House of Commons.
Rose was released from prison in 1951 after four and a half years with his health broken. Attempting to find work in Montreal, he was tailed from jobsite to jobsite by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP), who pointed out to employers and workmates that he was a convicted spy.
In 1953 he went to Poland to attempt to set up an import-export business and to obtain health treatment he could not afford in Canada. He worked for many years as English-language editor of Poland, a magazine of Polish culture and civilization designed for sale in the West. While living in Poland, his Canadian citizenship was revoked in 1957, and he was unable to return to Canada to lead the fight to clear his name.
His appeal against revoking his citizenship was denied, although in 1958 Minister of Citizenship and Immigration Ellen Fairclough amended the Citizenship Act with a so-called "Fred Rose amendment" so that such a removal of Canadian citizenship could never happen again. Years later, former federal cabinet minister Allan MacEachen acknowledged the pages of Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King's diary dealing with Rose had gone missing, as had most of the other records dealing with his case.
|Canadian federal election, 1935: Cartier|
|Liberal||Samuel William Jacobs||13,574||65.27|
|Communist||Fred Rosenberg (Rose)||3,385||16.28|
|Independent Liberal||Paul-Emile Goyette||1,531||7.36|
|CartierCanadian federal by-election, August 9, 1943: |
Death of Peter Bercovitch
|Bloc populaire||Paul Masse||5,639||29.63|
|Co-operative Commonwealth||David Lewis||3,313||17.41|
|Total valid votes||19,030||100.00|
|Labor–Progressive gain from Liberal||Swing||+0.40|
|Canadian federal election, 1945: Cartier|
|Liberal||Samuel Edgar Schwisberg||8,935||35.04|
|Bloc populaire||Paul Masse||6,148||24.11|
|Quebec general election, 1936: Montréal–Saint-Louis|
|Union Nationale||Louis-Gédéon Gravel||773||22.47|
|Communist||Fred Rosenberg (Rose)||578||16.80|
|Independent Union Nationale||Éphrem-J. Cuerrier||65||1.88|
- Green, David B. (December 7, 2016). "This Day in Jewish History 1907: A Canadian MP and Russian Spy Is Born". Haaretz. Retrieved August 7, 2017.
- "Evidence - February 15, 2017". Standing Senate Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology. Senate of Canada. February 15, 2017. Retrieved October 14, 2017.
I am sure my colleague from CIJA is aware that the last case of citizenship revocation on grounds of treason was to a Jewish Canadian citizen named Fred Rose, who at that time was seen as breaching what is called the fundamental betrayal of core values of Canada. He was a Communist and was convicted of conspiracy to disclose secrets to the Soviets. He didn't actually do it; he was convicted of conspiracy to do it. He had his citizenship revoked. It was the Conservative government of Prime Minister John Diefenbaker that introduced what was known as the 'Fred Rose amendment,' in 1958 so that it would never happen again.
- Levy, David (2011). Stalin's Man in Canada: Fred Rose and Soviet Espionage. New York: Enigma Books. ISBN 1936274272.
- Sunstrum, Jim (reporter); Weisbord, Merrily (guest) (March 19, 1983). Obituary of Fred Rose, Soviet spy. Saturday Report (Television production). CBC Television. Retrieved August 7, 2017.
- Watson, Patrick (2003). "Fred Rose, the Member for Treason". The Canadians: Biographies of a Nation (Omnibus ed.). Toronto: McArthur & Company. pp. 544–559. ISBN 9781552783900.
- Weisbord, Merrily (1994). "The Fred Rose Case". The Strangest Dream: Canadian Communists, the Spy Trials, and the Cold War (2nd ed.). Montreal: Véhicule Press. ISBN 9781550650532.