Elmer Edward Solly

Elmer Edward Solly (September 5, 1945 – November 30, 2007) was convicted of manslaughter in 1970 for the death of two-year-old Christopher Welsh. Solly escaped from custody in 1974 and spent the next 27 years living under numerous pseudonyms. At the time of his arrest in May 2001, he was living in Florida as Daniel "Danny C" Catalano, a supposed former member of the American rock 'n' roll group Sha Na Na; in fact, he never had any ties to Sha Na Na.[2][3]

Elmer Edward Solly
2001 mugshot of Elmer Edward Solly
Born(1945-09-05)September 5, 1945
DiedNovember 30, 2007(2007-11-30) (aged 62)
NationalityAmerican
Other namesDaniel "Danny C" Catalano
Criminal chargeManslaughter
Time at large
27 years
EscapedJune 1974
Escape endMay 10, 2001

Manslaughter conviction and escapeEdit

On the evening of July 25, 1969, Solly, in a drunken rage, severely beat his girlfriend's two-year-old son, Christopher Welsh, who died of his injuries. Solly turned himself in to local police a few days later. He was convicted of manslaughter on April 16, 1970, and incarcerated at Trenton State Prison. While Solly was in Trenton State Prison, his mother and grandmother began a letter-writing campaign alleging mistreatment on the part of prison guards.[4]

As a result of the campaign, Solly was transferred to medium-security Leesburg State Prison in 1974. There, he befriended a prison psychologist, who convinced officials to allow Solly to visit his mother. During the third visit, in June 1974, Solly was accompanied only by the psychologist. Solly asked to be allowed to visit his girlfriend, and he used the opportunity to escape.[2][5] His escape was not reported to police for six hours, giving Solly sufficient time to disappear.[6]

As a fugitiveEdit

Immediately after his escape, Solly began using a series of assumed identities to evade capture. In 1975, he was arrested in Philadelphia for receiving stolen goods, but because he used a fake name, police did not realize who he was. Similarly, he provided a fake name when he was stopped for a traffic violation in 1979 and avoided detainment.[3] Detectives had few leads in the case, and received no cooperation from Solly's family, particularly his mother, Edna Bolt, who consistently denied knowing her son's whereabouts. Eventually, Solly's escape was considered a cold case.[4]

Solly eventually made his way to Florida, where he assumed the identity of Vinnie Taylor, lead guitarist of the rock 'n' roll revival group Sha Na Na. The real Taylor died of a heroin overdose in 1974, but using forged documents, including a Social Security card, a birth certificate, and a baptism certificate, Solly successfully passed himself off as Taylor.[3][5] Solly, posing as Taylor, claimed that Taylor's death had been staged and so he took on the new stage name of Daniel "Danny C" Catalano, and began performing and recording under that name.[2] Sha Na Na discovered the fraud and demanded that Solly cease performing as Danny C. When Solly refused, the group considered filing a lawsuit, but decided not to do so in order to deny Solly the free publicity the case would generate.[2]

Investigation and captureEdit

In 1999, New Jersey State Police, Louis Kinkle, and Cumberland County Sheriff's Office investigators reopened the Solly case. They enlisted the aid of forensic artist Frank Bender, who used 25-year-old photographs of Solly to create an image of what he would look like currently. In March 2000, Edna Bolt died, after which other members of Solly's family began cooperating with investigators. Bolt's husband Harry told police that Solly was living in Florida as a singer using the name Danny C. A web search revealed a website for Danny C, billing himself as the "Bad Boy" of Sha Na Na. The site featured a picture of Danny C that closely resembled the image produced by Bender.[5][6]

Based on this information, authorities traveled first to Orlando and then to St. Pete Beach.[2] They discovered Solly fishing on a pier near his apartment complex. U.S. Marshals arrested Solly on May 10, 2001, and he was returned to New Jersey on May 18. He was convicted on October 5 for his 1974 escape and was incarcerated at Riverfront State Prison in Camden to serve that sentence and the remainder of his manslaughter sentence. Solly was granted parole in August 2003 for good behavior and time served. He was last reported to be living in a welfare motel in New Jersey.[5] Solly died on November 30, 2007, in Gloucester City, New Jersey.[1]

External linksEdit

Notes and referencesEdit

  1. ^ a b "Edward E. Solly Obituary". Legacy.com. December 5, 2007. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
  2. ^ a b c d e Tisch, Chris; Graham Brink (2001-05-21). "27 years on lam, felon's gig is up". St. Petersburg Times. Retrieved 2007-08-11.
  3. ^ a b c Moran, Robert (2001-05-24). "Sha Na Na impostor lived a lie for years". Philadelphia Inquirer. Retrieved 2007-08-11.[dead link]
  4. ^ a b "After 27 years, escaped murderer apprehended, returned to New Jersey". Archived from the original on 2007-08-10. Retrieved 2007-08-11.
  5. ^ a b c d "The Great Pretender: Fugitive Steals Identity Of Doo-Wop Group's Lead Singer". CBS News. July 8, 2004. Retrieved 2020-08-31.
  6. ^ a b "Head Cases". The Investigators. 2007-08-11. Court TV. Archived from the original on 2006-02-05.