Danish opt-outs from the European Union
Denmark holds opt-outs from European Union policies in relation to security and defence, citizenship, police and justice, and the adoption of the euro. They were secured under the Edinburgh Agreement in 1992 after a referendum for the ratification of the Maastricht Treaty was rejected by Danish voters, as a package of measure to assuage concerns raised during that referendum.
The Danish governments has held two referendums on modifying its opt-outs. The first in 2000 rejected the adoption of the euro by 53.2% to 46.8% on a turnout of 87.6%. The second in 2015 rejected converting Denmark's current full opt-out on home and justice matters into a case-by-case opt-out similar to that currently held by Ireland and the United Kingdom by 53.1% to 46.9%.
Denmark obtained four opt-outs from the Maastricht Treaty following the treaty's initial rejection in a 1992 referendum. The opt-outs are outlined in the Edinburgh Agreement and concern the Economic and monetary union (EMU), the Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP), Justice and Home Affairs (then JHA, now PJCC) and the citizenship of the European Union. With these opt-outs the Danish people accepted the treaty in a second referendum held in 1993.
The EMU opt-out means that Denmark is not obliged to participate in the third phase of the European Exchange Rate Mechanism, that is, to replace the Danish krone with the euro. The abolition of the euro opt-out was put to a referendum in 2000 and was rejected. The CSDP opt-out originally meant Denmark would not be obliged to join the Western European Union (which originally handled the defence tasks of the EU). Now it means that Denmark does not participate in the European Union's foreign policy where defence is concerned. Hence it does not take part in decisions, does not act in that area and does not contribute troops to missions conducted under the auspices of the European Union. The JHA opt-out exempts Denmark from certain areas of home affairs. Significant parts of these areas were transferred from the third European Union pillar to the first under the Amsterdam Treaty; Denmark's opt-outs from these areas were kept valid through additional protocols. Acts made under those powers are not binding on Denmark except for those relating to the Schengen Agreement, which are instead conducted on an intergovernmental basis with Denmark. The citizenship opt-out stated that European citizenship did not replace national citizenship; this opt-out was rendered meaningless when the Amsterdam Treaty adopted the same wording for all members. Under the Treaty of Lisbon, Denmark can change its opt-out from a complete opt-out to the case-by-case opt-in version applying to Ireland and the United Kingdom whenever they wish. The protocol governing this provision stipulates that if Denmark exercises this option, then it will be bound by the Schengen acquis under EU law rather than on an intergovernmental basis.
Proposals to abolish the opt-outsEdit
Anders Fogh Rasmussen governmentEdit
One or more referendums on abolishing one or more the opt-outs were announced by Prime Minister Anders Fogh Rasmussen in his speech on 22 November 2007 after he won the 2007 parliamentary election. It was not announced whether the referendum would only offer a full repeal of all opt-outs, or a case-by-case choice, and no date was announced, except that it would be before the 2011 Danish parliamentary election. The V/K (Liberal-Conservative) government had been planning to hold a referendum on abolishing the opt-outs (or at least the euro opt-out) since at least 2004, following a favourable change in public opinion, but the discussions and controversy regarding the Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe and the Treaty of Lisbon had delayed this.
The referendum was originally expected to be held in the autumn of 2008 but following Ireland's rejection of the Treaty of Lisbon, Fogh Rasmussen stated that this would not happen. In early 2009, it was announced that Fogh Rasmussen expected to hold a referendum on Denmark joining the Eurozone in 2010, as he believed it was possible to meet the demands of the Euro-sceptic Socialist People's Party.
Lars Løkke Rasmussen governmentEdit
Following the appointment of Anders Fogh Rasmussen as Secretary General of NATO in 2009, his successor, Lars Løkke Rasmussen, announced that the opt-outs would be put to a referendum "when the time is right", which was seen as an indication that he did not necessarily intend to proceed with a referendum.
A month later, in May 2009, Løkke Rasmussen stated that he hoped at least a referendum on the common currency would take place before the parliamentary elections in 2011 so that Denmark could become "a full member of the European Union", and to give him a popular mandate in the negotiations over the Competitiveness Pact in the Summer of that year. The Prime Minister's suggestion was criticised by Jens Ladefoged Mortensen, a political scientist, who claimed that the time for a referendum was ill-chosen, pointing out that Denmark was set to hold general elections later that year.
In November 2009 the leaders of the three largest opposition parties Helle Thorning-Schmidt, Villy Søvndal and Margrethe Vestager suggested that a referendum on abolishing the opt-outs concerning the Common Security and Defence Policy and the Justice and Home Affairs be held on 23 March 2010.
Ultimately, no referendum was held and Løkke Rasmussen's coalition lost the election in the autumn of 2011.
Helle Thorning-Schmidt governmentEdit
After the victory of the left-wing coalition under Thorning-Schmidt in the September 2011 elections, the new government announced that it planned to hold referendums on abolishing the defence opt-out and on either abolishing the justice opt-out or modifying it to a flexible opt-in like that of the United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland to allow Denmark to participate in measures which it chooses. However, in June 2012 Thorning-Schmidt announced that she didn't anticipate holding a referendum before a certain amount of stability and order returned to the situation in Europe, possibly not before the end of the government's term, citing the "anxiety and uncertainty" surrounding the European project at the time.
In August 2013, Lars Løkke Rasmussen, the leader of the opposition Venstre party proposed that a referendum on the opt-outs from EU defence and justice co-operation, as well as on the Unified Patent Court, leaving opt-outs from European citizenship and the euro, be held on the same date as the 2014 European election. The proposal was rejected by the Minister for European affairs, Nick Hækkerup, who argued that the timing was not right.
In October 2014 Thorning-Schmidt announced plans to hold a referendum on converting the inflexible opt-out on home and justice matters into a flexible opt-out following the next Danish general election due by September 2015, due to concerns that the opt-out would force Denmark to leave Europol. Several parties, including the two largest in parliament, the Social Democrats and Liberals, reached an agreement in December 2014 to hold the referendum following the upcoming election, but before the end of the first quarter of 2016, if they secured enough seats in the election. This was supplemented by an agreement in March 2015 amongst the parties that if the referendum is approved, Denmark would join 22 EU regulations it is currently not able to participate in, including the Rome Regulation. To join additional Regulations, the agreement requires either consensus amounts the parties to the agreement, or that the proposal is made public as part of the party's platform prior to a subsequent election.
Second Lars Løkke Rasmussen governmentEdit
Following the election in June 2015, Venstre formed government with Lars Løkke Rasmussen again becoming Prime Minister. He committed to holding the referendum on converting the justice opt-out into an opt-in by Christmas 2015. On August 21, 2015, the Danish government announced that the referendum would be held on December 3, 2015. The government has also said it is planning on holding a referendum on abolishing its opt-out from the EU defence policy following the justice opt-out referendum. Danes rejected the proposal by a margin of 53.1% to 46.9%. In May 2019 Rasmussen again proposed a referendum on abolishing its defence opt-out during the following parliamentary term, though his party lost the general election the following month.
A poll from early June 2008 saw a clear majority in favour of repealing the defence and judicial issues opt-outs, a very close race regarding the euro and a clear majority against repealing the citizenship opt-outs. Following an increase in support for abolishing the opt-outs, support dropped in mid-May 2009; in January 2009, 49.8% were in favour of having the Euro as Danish currency, dropping to 45.2% against and 43.7% in favour in May 2009. Support for abolishing opt-outs on legal and defence cooperation has also dwindled to equal numbers pro and against.
Afterwards support for abolishing the opt-outs increased again. In October 2009, there was a majority in favour of abolishing each of the four opt-outs, the only difference being in the size of majority:
- Absolute majorities were in favour of adopting the euro (50% in favour, 43% opposed, 7% no opinion) and participating in a Common European Defence policy (66% in favour, 21% opposed, 13% no opinion).
- There were relative majorities in favour of judicial cooperation (47% in favour, 35% opposed, 18% no opinion) and EU citizenship (40% in favour, 30% opposed, 30% no opinion).
- When asked, how they would vote when they had to decide about all four opt-outs in a package, a relative majority of 42% would vote in favour of abolishing the opt-outs, 37% would vote in favour of keeping the opt-outs and 21% expressed no opinion.
Following the European sovereign debt crisis, particularly the financial market turmoil of 2011, support for the euro dropped dramatically with a poll showing 61% of respondents opposing adoption of the euro, with 37% in favour.
- "Denmark to vote on Justice and Home Affairs opt-in model on 3 December". Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark. 21 August 2015. Retrieved 21 August 2015.
- Motivations and consequences of the Danish CSDP opt-out (Revue Stratégique n. 91–92): http://www.stratisc.org/Strategique_91-92_TDM.htm
- Europolitics (7 November 2007). "Treaty of Lisbon – Here is what changes!" (PDF). Europolitics № 3407. Archived from the original (PDF) on 27 November 2007. Retrieved 2007-11-22.
- Olsen, Jan M. (22 November 2007). "Denmark to Hold New Referendum on Euro". Associated Press. Archived from the original on 3 December 2007. Retrieved 22 November 2007.
- Charter, David (30 October 2008). "Denmark currency crisis prompts euro re-think – Times Online". London: Business.timesonline.co.uk. Retrieved 22 January 2009.
- Parker, George; Eaglesham, Jean; Benoit, Betrand (1 January 2003). "Danes face second referendum on joining euro". Financial Times. Retrieved 17 October 2007.
- Danish PM says possible autumn referendum on EU opt-outs — EUbusiness.com – business, legal and economic news and information from the European Union Archived 28 April 2008 at the Wayback Machine
- "Europa – Nachrichten – Kopenhagen strebt in die Euro-Zone". FTD.de. 17 March 2008. Retrieved 17 December 2010.
- Lisbeth Kirk. "EUobserver.com". EUobserver.com. Retrieved 17 December 2010.
- "Besked om EU-afstemning efter sommer" (in Danish). Politiken. 11 June 2008. Retrieved 11 June 2008.
- "Fogh aflyser EU-afstemninger" (in Danish). Politiken. 7 August 2008. Archived from the original on 8 August 2008. Retrieved 7 August 2008.
- "Fogh klar til eurovalg næste år" (in Danish). Politiken. 22 January 2009. Archived from the original on 25 January 2009. Retrieved 22 January 2009.
- "S og R raser over Løkkes EU-nøl" (in Danish). DR. 14 April 2009. Retrieved 15 April 2009.
- "Løkke R.: Euro-vote this term?". Politiken. 13 May 2009. Retrieved 19 May 2009.
- "Løkke: Vi skal stemme om euroen" (in Danish). Politiken. 13 May 2009. Archived from the original on 16 May 2009. Retrieved 24 May 2009.
- "Denmark eyeing referendum on euro". euobserver.com. 3 March 2011. Retrieved 28 March 2015.
- "Ekspert: Løkkes varslede EU-afstemning er dårlig timing". Politiken. 3 March 2011. Archived from the original on 24 January 2013. Retrieved 28 March 2015.
- "Oppositionen vil stemme om EU-forbehold" (in Danish). Politiken. 24 November 2009. Archived from the original on 7 June 2011. Retrieved 25 November 2009.
- Pop, Valentina (4 October 2011). "New Danish government rolls back border controls". EUObserver.com. Retrieved 18 October 2011.
- Brand, Constant (13 October 2011). "Denmark scraps border-control plans". European Voice. Retrieved 18 October 2011.
- "Danish prime minister skips referendum commitments". EU Observer. 26 June 2012. Retrieved 26 June 2012.
- Lauritzen, Thomas; Jens Bostrup (26 June 2012). "Thorning udskyder afstemning om EU-forbehold". Politiken (in Danish). Archived from the original on 27 June 2012. Retrieved 26 June 2012.
- "Danish opposition agrees to quick EU referendum". 12 August 2013. Retrieved 26 September 2013.
- "PM rejects opposition call for swift EU referendum". Copenhagen Post. 13 August 2013. Retrieved 26 September 2013.
- Steensbeck, Bjarne (7 October 2014). "Regeringen gør klar til opgør med retsforbeholdet". DR. Retrieved 8 October 2014.
- "Danish PM postpones EU referendum". EurActive. 8 October 2014. Retrieved 8 October 2014.
- "Aftale om Danmark i Europol". Archived from the original on 2 April 2015. Retrieved 2015-01-26.
- "Legislative files Denmark will opt-into if referendum is positive" (PDF). Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark. Retrieved 21 August 2015.
- "One step closer to a referendum on the JHA opt-out – modalities have now been decided". Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark. 17 March 2015. Retrieved 21 August 2015.
- "Aftale om tilvalg af retsakter på området for retlige og indre anliggender" (PDF). Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark. Retrieved 21 August 2015.
- "Regeringsgrundlag juni 2015: Sammen for Fremtiden (Government manifest June 2015: Together for the Future)" (PDF) (in Danish). Venstre. 27 June 2015. Archived from the original (PDF) on 1 July 2015.
- "New Danish government to hold EU referendum by Christmas". 28 June 2015.
- "Danish government plans referendum on EU defence opt-out". Reuters. 5 August 2015. Retrieved 21 August 2015.
- "Rasmussen wants Danish referendum over EU defence relationship". 15 May 2019. Retrieved 14 July 2019.
- "Danes Assess Reversion of EU Exemptions: Angus Reid Global Monitor". Archived from the original on 3 June 2009. Retrieved 2008-08-07.
- "Poll: Danes say no to euro". Politiken. 19 May 2009. Retrieved 19 May 2009.
- "Opinion Poll" (PDF). borsen.dk (in Danish). Greens Analyseinstitut. October 2009. Retrieved 28 March 2015.
- Wienberg, Christian (27 September 2011). "Debt Crisis Pushes Danish Euro Opposition to Record, Poll Shows". Bloomberg. Retrieved 18 October 2011.
- Howarth, David (1994). "The Compromise on Denmark and the Treaty on European Union: A Legal and Political Analysis". Common Market Law Review. 34 (1): 765–805.
- Butler, Graham (2020). "The European Defence Union and Denmark's Defence Opt-out: A Legal Appraisal". European Foreign Affairs Review. 25 (1): 117–150.