Wikipedia:WikiProject United States Public Policy/Assessment/EdJohnston

EdJohnston's PPI Assessment Page

EdJohnston - Wikipedia expert

Assessment 1, part 1

The purpose of this evaluation in not to gauge variability in article quality, but to look at the metric itself. How consistent is this assessment tool? and Is there a difference in scores between subject area expert assessment and Wikipedian article assessment?

Permanent residence (United States) (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness 6/10
• Sourcing 4/6
• Neutrality 3/3
• Readability 2/3
• Illustrations 2/2
• Formatting 2/2
• Total 19/26

Left some review comments at Talk:Permanent residence (United States)#My assessment

Great Society (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness = 6/10
• Sourcing = 4/6
• Neutrality =1/3
• Readability = 3/3
• Illustrations = 1/2
• Formatting = 2/2
• Total = 17/26

Left detailed comments at Talk:Great Society#Review comments.

Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness = 5/10
• Sourcing = 3/6
• Neutrality = 2/3
• Readability =2/3
• Illustrations =1/2
• Formatting =2/2

Total = 15/26

Drug policy of the United States (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness = 3/10
• Sourcing = 2/6
• Neutrality = 2/3
• Readability = 1/3
• Illustrations = 0/2
• Formatting =2/2
• Total = 10/26

Missouri Plan (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness = 6/10
• Sourcing = 4/6
• Neutrality = 2/3
• Readability = 2/3
• Illustrations = 0/2
• Formatting = 2/2
• Total = 16/26

State school (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness = 7/10
• Sourcing = 4/6
• Neutrality = 2/3
• Readability = 2/3
• Illustrations = 0/2
• Formatting = 1/2
• Total = 16/26

Assessment 1, Part 2

Assessment request 2, please use article version from 1 October 2010. There are a couple of rereviews, hopefully those will go fast for you. This set will tie up the first assessment, which tests the quantitative metric and compares Wikipedian assessment to expert assessment.

Monetary policy of the United States link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

Homeland Security Act link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

Asylum in the United States link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

National Partnership for Reinventing Government link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

Operation Green Sweep link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

Great Society link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

Missouri Plan link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total