Wikipedia:WikiProject Biography/Peer review/Serranus Clinton Hastings

Serranus Clinton Hastings edit

I think it would be interesting to have an article on an Iowa representative get GA status. I've worked fairly hard on this, but I know this would not come close to satisfying criterion 1a. If I was going for FA that is. Whether it can get GA status or not I'd just like to see the article improved from the peer review. References are a problem on this one since the ones I have are basically the only ones there are. --Psych less 04:26, 19 June 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Review by karanacs edit

~~Overall, I think almost every sentence is well-written, but you need to work on your transitions between facts.~~

Lead should be expanded a bit.

When did Iowa become a territory (for those of us not from the state)

I'm confused about the 1838 election -- were his two terms consecutive or concurrent and was he elected to both of them at the same time (or was one of them in 1839)?

Last four sentences of the first paragraph of career seem to be kind of thrown in there -- don't flow at all with each other or the paragraph before.

When did Iowa become a state?

Why was his first term in the federal legislature so short?

~~Need to transition more smoothly between march 3, 1847 and Gov. Ansel Briss appointed him...~~
Any information on why he decided to move to California?

*Is it important that he converted to Catholicism? If you can't find any information on his reasons or whether it affected his life, this is trivia and could be removed. Likewise, the information on his personal appearance could be considered trivia unless you can find a better way to work it into the article. Done Good luck! Karanacs 02:03, 20 June 2007 (UTC)[reply]

I don't know why he moved to California, and can't find any source that tells why he did. I've removed the personal life section and incorporated the marraige and children bit into the career section of the article. Catholicism is just listed as his religion in the infobox now. I've tried to expand the lead as best I can. Any further comments on the article would be appreciated. Psych less 23:11, 20 June 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Your changes look good. Here are some additional suggestions

suggestion: "When Iowa became a territory in 1838, he got involved in the territory's politics. In 1838, he was elected as a member of the House of the First Legislative Assembly." -> "When Iowa became a territory in 1838, he became involved in politics, winning election to be a member of the House of the First Lesiglative Assembly."
You might be able to expand the article a bit by talking a little about the "Blue Book" of Iowa laws. What did it encompass and what is its importance? You could also mention some of the early laws that were passed by the assemblies in which he served.
The two sentences on the border conflict with Missouri should be rewritten. Possibly expand.
You mention in the lead that the law school he founded is now the Law Department at UC. This should also be mentioned in the body of the article.

Karanacs 17:39, 21 June 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Done-ish. It's now a good article candidate. If anyone has any more suggestions feel free to leave them. --Psych less 18:21, 22 June 2007 (UTC)[reply]