Wikipedia:Picture peer review/DopplerRedshift

Doppler Redshift edit

Doppler effect, yellow ball appears greenish (blueshift) approaching observer, turns orange (redshift) as it passes, and returns to yellow when motion stops.

I think this image has great encyclopedic value. It is a very good depiction of the doppler redshift and fits in well with its article. I thought it could be considered for nomination if others think it's good enough.

Nominated by: Pkenans (talk) 13:00, 27 June 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Comments

I like the idea that it illustrates redshift and blueshift, but it's just not eye-catching enough to be a featured picture. It's good enough to go on a high school science website, but it lacks the intrigue of a typical FP. If there were included elements off to the side, detailing the speed of the object, its relative position to the observer, and the change in the wavelength of the light, then I might reconsider my position. Palladmial (talk) 15:59, 15 July 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Seconder