Wikipedia:Article assessment/Hugo Award-winning works/A Canticle for Leibowitz

Assessment

Hugo Award-winning works

Undergoing assessment 4 June 2006 – 25 June 2006

Assessments

A Canticle for Leibowitz A Case of Conscience A Deepness in the Sky Doomsday Book Dune (novel) Ender's Game Forever Peace Gateway (novel) Neuromancer Rendezvous with Rama Ringworld Speaker for the Dead Stranger in a Strange Land The Diamond Age The Demolished Man The Forever War The Left Hand of Darkness The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress To Say Nothing of the Dog Where Late the Sweet Birds Sang

Assessment of an article under the topic Hugo Award-winning works.

Article: A Canticle for Leibowitz

Details of the assessment method can be found at the main page. Feel free to add comments when you assess an article, or use the talk page for discussion.

Review by Geo.plrd

• Coverage and factuality: 9
• Writing style: 7
• Structure: 7
• Aesthetics: 8
• Overall: 7

Geo.plrd 23:47, 8 June 2006 (UTC)

Review by [User:JimDunning]

• Coverage and factuality: 5
• Writing style: 6
• Structure: 2
• Aesthetics: 3
• Overall: 3

Parts of this article are well-written, but have few or no sources and appear to be original research (Literary significance). It is unorganized and the plot summary is far too detailed and long (per Project guidelines). Although some of the individual parts are good in themselves, overall the article requires a complete revamp.

Review by [User:]

• Coverage and factuality:
• Writing style:
• Structure:
• Aesthetics:
• Overall: