Lord Robertson of Port Ellen

edit

Why have you removed the section on the libel action from the article? You did not give an edit summary, so there is no explanation of why you removed a big chunk of text. Please could you explain. The section is not libellous, so there is no excuse for removing it without discussion. It is actually a significant case as it considered whether online publishers or service providers can be held responsible for what their users write - very relevant to Wikipedia.

If you don't give any reason for that edit, I'll reinstate the section (which included a reference) and if it is then removed again, I'll consider the removal vandalism. JRawle (Talk) 00:13, 6 June 2008 (UTC)Reply

I am one of Lord Robertson's sons and I attended a boys club in Dunblane, led by the man who murdered these children in my old primary school. The libel story cause a great deal of hurt and for that reason, I removed it from my father's page. It is not vandalism. I just have a different perspective to others.—Preceding unsigned comment added by Nationalist67 (talkcontribs) 20:01, 16 June 2008

I have reverted your most recent edit to the Lord Robertson article as removing the link to the Dunblane massacre article serves no apparent purpose. I have also reverted your unexplained edits of the Dunblane massacre article on the grounds that your claimed relationship could constitute a potential conflict of interest. If you wish your edits of the Dunblane article to be restored, please read Wikipedia's policy on handling conflicts of interest and then provide an explanation for your edits on the article talk page. Regards. Road Wizard (talk) 21:29, 17 June 2008 (UTC)Reply

You do whatever you like. I will go on editing from time to time, as I please, and I'm sure you'll get your rule book out and "revert". Of course I have an interest, but it is not a conflict. People like you have little regard for the feelings of the people who lived through this terrible event. The gunman, who I will never name, did what he did partly to live long in people's memories. Pages like this, complete with photographs, help him achieve that objective and I do what I do to help bury the memory of an awful man.