User talk:Mattinbgn/Undisambiguated Australian places
Suggestions
edit(all checked for other usages, etc)
WA:
- Port Hedland
- Karratha
- Coolgardie
- Pinjarra
- Kununurra
- Margaret River (complicated issue of where should be what needs to be resolved for this one, but the town IMO should have primary usage)
- Meekatharra (sufficient notoriety)
SA:
- Mount Gambier (issue with volcano?)
- Murray Bridge (issue with bridge which is notable enough for an article)
VIC:
- Mildura
- Shepparton
- Warrnambool
- Echuca
- Wodonga
NSW:
- Goulburn (Goulburn River?)
- Wollongong
- Cooma
- Port Macquarie
- Broken Hill (Kabwe could be an issue)
- Katoomba
- Lithgow
- Batemans Bay
- Byron Bay
QLD:
- Rockhampton (need to argue primary usage for that one)
- Townsville (The Powerpuff Girls, anyone ...)
- Cairns
- Cunnamulla (unusual situation - it's well known from a song)
- Hervey Bay
NT:
- Alice Springs
Other possibilities (mostly narrowly failing the "where the?!" test for people outside their state/region)
- Bairnsdale VIC
- Traralgon VIC
- Colac VIC
- Busselton WA
- Marble Bar WA
- Charters Towers QLD
- Goondiwindi QLD
- Longreach QLD
- Yeppoon QLD
- Kingaroy QLD
- Coober Pedy SA
- Ceduna SA
- Nowra NSW
- Taree NSW (seems PRIME to me)
- Tennant Creek NT
Orderinchaos 20:18, 20 October 2010 (UTC)
- My additions indented for each state. (Of course, I think that every unique or unquestionably prime place should be un-disambiguated)
- I can see a case for "widening the net" from "capital cities" to "places which would implicitly be defined in most observers' minds", but I think it would create the sort of maintenance nightmare we see in other countries if we were to do it for everything, as well as creating unnecessary work for readers. Orderinchaos 06:43, 21 October 2010 (UTC)
- We will have to agree to disagree :) However, I have no plans for a mass renaming of articles - it would only be divisive and disruptive, at this stage. -- Mattinbgn (talk) 07:10, 21 October 2010 (UTC)
- I can see a case for "widening the net" from "capital cities" to "places which would implicitly be defined in most observers' minds", but I think it would create the sort of maintenance nightmare we see in other countries if we were to do it for everything, as well as creating unnecessary work for readers. Orderinchaos 06:43, 21 October 2010 (UTC)
Wangaratta
editCurious to know about these other "Wangaratta"s. There is no disambiguation page for Wangaratta or even a hatnote at "Wangaratta, Victoria". A search for Wangaratta, Queensland finds a rural locality (no urban area) south of Home Hill - but not enough to be realistically threatening Wang in Vic as PRIME. -- Mattinbgn (talk) 07:06, 21 October 2010 (UTC)
- When I was doing the local government articles I hit a Shire of Wangaratta surrounding Bowen, Queensland and an abandoned town there with some interesting history. That among many other things stalled when my LGA project did - I've been doing things in blocks. Orderinchaos 07:58, 21 October 2010 (UTC)
Borroloola
editSeeing as your own earlier moves got no objections, I've moved Borroloola, Northern Territory. Anyone can obviously revert, and I'll be happy to hold a proper RM. Nightw 11:47, 14 February 2011 (UTC)