User talk:Kilroy.15/sandbox

Latest comment: 9 years ago by 164.107.47.208 in topic Illustrated

Instructor Comments

edit

Well-written

edit
  • History section needs expansion and work.
  • Watch for Neutrality.

Verifiable with no original research

edit
  • Would like to see a little more diversity of sources if possible.

Broad in its coverage

edit
  • Good here.

Neutral

edit
  • Watch out for non-neutral words.

Stable

edit
  • No comments yet.

Illustrated

edit
  • Good - but get place an Infobox in.

164.107.47.208 (talk) 17:09, 9 December 2014 (UTC)Reply

Great Start, but I see some issues:

  • The City of Forest Park is in Cincinnati, NOT Columbus. Be careful about this - Most of your article is about the one in Cincinnati.
  • Neutrality: This is the biggest issue so far. I'm sure this is a great place to live, but it sounds like your selling it. Don't do that. For example: Forest Park is an excellent example of a planned community INSTEAD it should read: Forest Park is a planned community located in Columbus, Ohio.
  • There is already A LOT on Forest Park (HINT: It already has a Wikipedia Page)
  • Lead Section: Check out the Lead Section guidelines to help you with this.
  • Use Double-Brackets to link to outside articles (like I did above).
  • Is 1961 after WWII? The traditional Baby-Boom suburbs where in the 1950's.
  • Education: Name the schools; Enrollments; Location (all of this is Public Information).
  • On Civic Assn: Be careful about Neutrality.
  • Move Geography Up in the Sandbox

Kenitzer.1 (talk) 16:02, 18 November 2014 (UTC)Reply

2nd draft

edit

Notes from the class editor: I would possibly add a section on demographics who lives there, median age, etc., also keep in mind Zach's comments above about neutrality. Overall, a good base. Kowalski.118 (talk) 12:57, 9 December 2014 (UTC)Reply